/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>19845686

Guys, I haven't read Umineko in 3 years, I don't remember anything. How does it hold up on a reread?

>>18954583
>vsbattles
Now go ahead and read Batora.

At what point did you realize the truth?

>Ep 6 last red made me understand the whole thing.

>>16213954
I just don't find it possible.
Imagine yourself. Pushing 99 years old, only thing thats confirmed is your craze for Beatrice, huge interest in occult and alcohol to drown you from your suffering.
Do you think HE would find mundane things such as grandkids a joy?
He probably doesn't even think of anything but of his own world since he is locked in his room all the day and doesn't want to interact with outside world.
1985 Rokkenjima red truth shows it.
He definitely wouldn't change in a year.

>>15596095
>>15596018
Wait no, there's a rule saying the Culprit cannot die, and that the culprit is a shown character. So that narrows it down to the survivors at the end, Battler, George and Maria. George and Maria try to rule each other out through Purple, but that could be lying if they are both culprits.

Maybe this time it's Battlers time to go nuts?

>The Maria theory
Now this one is a little far thatched. Basically, Maria + X is Beatrice. Whoever carried out the murders, they need to have a superficial knowledge of the occult. Magic isn’t real, but you don’t just learn how to write down Hebrew on the fly. Someone masquerading as Beatrice has duped Maria into aiding them kill everyone. But this requires Maria’s help, so whoever has been pretending to be Beatrice has been buttering Maria up at the family conference for years. I’ve only recently thought of this one, so it’s going to need some more development.

And there we have it, my initial theories. I’ll repeat that I haven’t put them to the grindstone yet of proving each of the cases and defeating each of the Closed rooms using this theory. But I have an idea of where I am going, so hopefully with a re-read I can comeback with a definitive theory with proof up the ass.
I will acknowledge that I’m basically not suspecting any of the grand-children here (expect tangentially Maria), but I basically can’t envision a scenario in which they are the killers. The rest seem fair game though (apart from Kumasawa, she’s too old to do any of this shit).

I still don’t know what happens that kills Battler at 24:00 at October 5th, Or what Battler did in 1980 that Beatrice is so ass hurt over. I’m going to need to figure these out to come to any satisfactory answer about who Beatrice is.

>>15441634