/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>15680205
>Maybe she saw in Rudolf the same ruthlessness she had and was attracted to that.
You're thinking rationally and not with emotion.
>oh maybe she just loved his ruthlessness
Really? Waiting years for him just because she loved how direct he was? Not the obvious that he's a playboy and she fell in love because she's a worthless woman?

>Perhaps coming from a crime family would make her lack empathy and become more ruthless.
Perhaps perhaps perhaps. Si si si. Et avec des si on mettrai paris en bouteille.
Coming from a crime family does not make one automatically apathetic.

You ignore the obvious fact that is right in front of you.

Knox 6th
>It is forbidden for accident or intuition to be employed as a detective technique.
Coming from a crime of family is based on intuition, not evidence.

>>15680259
>I see you are still a child.
Ad hominem. Not an argument.

>It isn't guess work. It is using information we have to form a list.
Probability defintiion: the extent to which something is probable; the likelihood of something happening or being the case.
synonym: likelihood, prospect, expectation, *chance*, chances, odds

Probability is not a direct proof of cause and effect but a generalization and chance.
Chance is not evidence. The chances of someone being born from a family from a family of crime is not evidence that they will commit a crime.

Knox 6th
>It is forbidden for accident or intuition to be employed as a detective technique.

>Actually it does work like that you moron.
No it doesn't you moron. Holy shit. You present EVIDENCE.
not
>oh come on guys, this gangbanger was born in a poor neighborhood, so OF COURSE he's the killer!
The fingerprints we found on the knife, X happened and blood was found on his shirt, he was seen at the scene of the crime, etc.

Probability has nothing to do with it. Chance has nothing to do with it. The place of upbringing has nothing to do with motive.

You don't know anything.

>What if I told you that if you want to reach the truth of Umineko you need to discard meaningless terms like mystery and fantasy?
What if I told you that's exactly what the goats did in ep 8 and you're a goat who knows nothing?