/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>40533808
Tell me something anon, if your job is to adapt a large sprawling ensemble story like Heavens feel and the majority of people's take away or memorable scenes are Salter vs Berserker and Salter vs Medusa both of which are very inconsequential storywise, would you consider HF well done? The theme of the route? The pain and chekhov gun nature of archers arm? Shirous pleas of anguish to live? Etc
It's like saying any of the manga adaptions are the definitive adaptions of the Stay night routes when they're supplementary to what a fan. However, since these are probably going to remain the only anime adaptions of HF don't you think the route was owed more than an adaption that treats the important material as secondary?