/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>35545735
>EVA never denied that a personality could have done it.
Either a human did it, or a non-human did it. The number of humans is accounted for in the reds, and non-humans are denied.

>I also point to the fact that the amount of humans on the island is never defined.
what was Erika's red at the end of episode 6 referring to?

>Shannon and Kanon are never defined as human.
>Therefore saying they are dead has no meaning.
Then the word 'dead' is completely meaningless, and the reds that point to the solution are meaningless as well. And if that's the case, the only way to solve the mystery before episode 7 is by guessing which of the many possible interpretations of the fictional scenes is correct, and twisting the reds to fit your theory. That would make Umineko an unfair mystery and go against the message about trusting the author in episode 5.