/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Alright, I want to discuss something different.

As we are already spoiled to hell with EP6, I'm almost sure you all already know that EP1-2 are the original "EPs" and that EP3-6 are Touya's "fanfictions", made with the truth. I'll completely disregard magic for now, so nothing about "witch that watches fragments".

If EP1 and EP2 were found in the same "fragment", and EP3-6 were written in the same "fragment" as well.. And if in said "fragment" Eva survived the "Rokkenjima Mass murders", then there's something awkward there.

In EP1, Eva dies in a closed room on the bed, along with Hideyoshi in the bathtub. Was she dead? I don't recall Nanjo doing a quick autopsy of her body, but whatever.
In EP2, Eva dies with a vertical cut on her stomach, filled with candies and other things. It must have been fatal.

According to a witch hunter (EP4) who claimed to have read the original letter(s), he saw "Beatrice's handwriting" as "Maria". It's either EP1 or EP2, and in both EPs, Eva died.

Then how did Eva survive? Was she really dead?

Also, in Touya's first fiction, EP3, Eva survived. EP4, she apparently died, but that was a complete magic scene. EP5, Eva didn't die (guessing, game board ended before we could see further). EP6, Eva died. For some reason I want to completely ignore Chiru, as it looks like a complete magic board with no trusted POV.

What are your thoughts on this?

Alright, I want to propose something different.

As we are already spoiled to hell with EP6, I'm almost sure you all already know that EP1-2 are the original "EPs" and that EP3-6 are Touya's "fanfictions", made with the truth. I'll completely disregard magic for now, so nothing about "witch that watches fragments".

If EP1 and EP2 were found in the same "fragment", and EP3-6 were written in the same "fragment" as well.. And if in said "fragment" Eva survived the "Rokkenjima Mass murders", then there's something awkward there.

In EP1, Eva dies in a closed room on the bed, along with Hideyoshi in the bathtub. Was she dead? I don't recall Nanjo doing a quick autopsy of her body, but whatever.
In EP2, Eva dies with a vertical cut on her stomach, filled with candies and other things. It must have been fatal.

According to a witch hunter (EP4) who claimed to have read the original letter(s), he saw "Beatrice's handwriting" as "Maria". It's either EP1 or EP2, and in both EPs, Eva died.

Then how did Eva survive? Was she really dead?

Also, in Touya's first fiction, EP3, Eva survived. EP4, she apparently died, but that was a complete magic scene. EP5, Eva didn't die (guessing, game board ended before we could see further). EP6, Eva died. For some reason I want to completely ignore Chiru, as it looks like a complete magic board with no trusted POV.

What are your thoughts on this?