/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>16037878
>Honestly, the CD sounds better to me.
Well, to each their own. Ultimately the point I wanted to convey is that versions differ, not necessarily in good or bad, just different, and I like to have them all. I think it's interesting that people have different opinions over this.

I re-listened to the gekkabijin version and the instruments just sound off to me. Battery is weird. During the emotional part at 3min the guitar doesn't have any punch either. Miku's singing(? don't know how to call it) at the start and end of the song also have much more emotion in the original PV version.
Now while I'm being "harsh" I still think it's an interesting version and I'm actually glad he went on changing it, better have two instead of one after all.

In case people care about what we've been talking about :
http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm19180162
http://mikudb.moe/album/gekkabijin/

Just listened to the "POPsTAR the VOCALOID Season2" version and... it's pretty much the same as the original PV version, but slightly better I would say after only listening to it once. So considering you said...
>The arrangement is the same so I wouldn't go out of my way to download this one.
it looks like there perhaps was a misunderstanding.
http://mikudb.moe/album/pop%e2%98%85star-vocaloid-season2/

If you're interested, I just learned about a 3rd version here (completely new arrange; a collab it seems) :
http://mikudb.moe/album/traveler/
Pretty nice.