/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Shut up Shiki you only killed data servants.

That's like being able to kill someone in an MMO.

I have a theory, and it actually showed just how *not* hopeless HF actually was and how utterly needless Mind of Steel was:

Ilya is able to move souls, so it is a viable option had more relaxed minds thought of it. Ilya herself would have known what to do as well, and she was practically the most neutral party there. Ilya had several ways to end this without killing Sakura and making sure there were no more victims. Remember that dead end? She has exhibited powers that enable her to have some control over souls, since she was able to keep Shirou alive with just a head like in the first bad end. Rin performs freaking neurosurgery on Shinji while under duress in UBW. There was just flagrant irresponsibility here on the part of the people with superior abilities, so I do not blame Shirou for being hesitant to just off her. Mind you, this is not talking about her using the same Third as she did on Shirou in HF True. My "doll plan" only required her to be able to move souls, and she can do that easily.

It could have ended with Shirou having his true dream of cooking in the kitchen with Ilya, Rin, and Sakura. Hell I think Ilya was cognizant of the Shadow's identity even before Saber was killed, and knew Shirou liked her(remember the one you get for lack of Ilya points and she meets him at home, crushing Saber, and soul drains him to use him against Sakura). Basically, Ilya screwed 'herself and everyone else' out of the ultimate happy end.

There you go. *walks out*