/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>39110760
Geh. Castling, are we? It's certainly true that it's much harder to assault the position if one puts aside the assumption that it was a relationship between two people of the same age-group...
How about this? The fact that Erika had the freedom of movement necessary to stalk that man and collect evidence on him suggest she was beyond the age of compulsory education! Her largely equal standing in their relationship argument points to this being a relationship between peers! The Erika in that relationship was an adult, of college-age at least.

>>39110795
Debating the details of characters one dismisses as wholly unreal and amorphous is meaningless and impossible. Thus, in order to discuss Erica, we suspend the fictional nature of her character both within and without the canon universe of Umineko in order to have a dialogue. That's the nature of discussing fiction, and the fact that Erika is fiction within fiction doesn't change it.

>>35683207
Regardless of the strength of your emotion, what you are feeling is not true love.