/jp/ - Otaku Culture

I believe someone just said something ridiculously stupid on an AnimeSuki umineko thread, /jp/.

I said:

>You're using the argument of:
>"Forgers who know of this accident often theorize that she drifted onto Rokkenjima...." - Therefore, she didn't drift onto Rokkenjima.
>This has the form of:
>"Forgers often theorize that [X]" - Therefore, [not X].
Which leads to an abundance of logical absurdities like:
>"Forgers often theorize that people died on Rokkenjima." - Therefore, nobody died on Rokkenjima.

She replied:
>"Forgers theorize X" so X isn't true, does not mean "forgers theorize Y", so Y isn't true.

Bump. Don't let this thread die, fellow Erika slaves!

>>5711824
That's because she's Furudo Erika, Witch of Truth, best character on the show, better than the salami and the bologna combined. She can wear whatever she wants. Besides, who's gonna stop her? The dead Ushiromiya family? Vegetable Battler?

>>5700399

Erika has really so many strikes against her that even though she's a Rika clone, sticking it into her is a repulsive thought. Liar, used goods, and a total bitch.

She's got one thing going for her and that's her "can do" attitude.

>>5677828
I think we came up with a ~sort of~ acceptable solution to the puzzle of how Kanon could rescue Battler from the guest room last night. It was total bullshit, but with all of our BS powers combined, we might have beaten Ryu's closed room without resorting to Shannon.

It's totally absurd, but it goes like thus: Either a) Battler's 'Guest Room' was actually in the guest house and not in the mansion, or b) the 'Cousin's Room' was actually in the mansion.

Then you can solve the mystery with a simple application of the cups and coins puzzle that was mentioned (but not solved) in the beginning of the game: If Battler's room was actually inside the cousin's room, then Kanon could enter it without breaking any of the seals on the cousin's room. He then discarded his name as 'Kanon' becoming Yoshiya. Thus, 'Kanon' does not exist inside Battler's room.

It's important to note that Erika never said she sealed the two rooms at the same time, or that she sealed them from the outside. If she left the 'next room over', killed Rosa etc., and then went into the cousin's room and sealed the door behind her, all the seals will still be valid at the time she checked on them (after the logic error).

What about Erika in child form?

>>4171664
A mystery~
In a good way.

>>4055810
<bad>

>>3581728
>>3581674
>>3581688
cease this faggotry at once