/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>17888375
>To be fair, the manga ruined the fun of uncoverubg the whole thing by ourselves.

You can't uncover anything without confirmation. How would you know? Pic related.

It's not like ep 7-8 don't tell your Kyrie killed everyone and Shkanon was a thing. You are not some kind of genius for figuring Umineko. The novel tells you.

>>15640474
>I don't understand. I'm saying that it's through the fantasy scenes that the motive becomes more clear. Those scenes are tied to the motive for a mass murder, because they give hints to it.

The fantasy scene gives context for Yasu dilemma and internal fights. Leaving aside how much of these scenes people dismissed people they had problems accepting Kanon=Shannon, they didn't understand how to tie these scenes (Yasu identity dilemma) tied to MASS MURDER.

People failed to connect it with a reason to massacre the family and the cousins (whom she's in love with) previous to episode VII.

VII gives you a reason, her "roulette" and leaving things to fate, but even then people found it weak.

Yes, a lot of things are hinted in fantasy scenes, but without a way to check if your answers are correct, you have no way to understand whatever Kinzo "roulette" in Ep 1-4 is actually 100% fantasy, about OLD Kinzo, or Yasu (who is, again, mostly in fantasy scenes, so no way to actually CHECK if you are correct or not).

The manga does a better job because it shows how much unstable she became and her thought process.

>>15631282
>>90% of fanbase: omg wtf it didn't explain anything wtf was this shit, where is muh truth????

>>12341338
What a shame that such an about-face happened.