/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>5740667
Sorry, but if you want to argue that, you'll need to count 'Beatrice' as a person. No more than 17 people exist. All dead people are included in the 'X people' count, including personalities apparently. Beatrice is a personality? Then the count should reach 18. It does not.

If you're going to try to claim that Beatrice isn't a 'person' and therefore doesn't count in this count somehow... how about you explain who killed Kanon/Shannon, who were killed by another person? If Beatrice doesn't count as a person, she can't kill them. Shannon and Kanon cannot kill each other at the same time. One personality has to be dominant after all; one is always sleeping, right? They can't both be awake at the same time and kill each other simultaneously, right? Or is the argument now 'They can exist together at the same time provided it's in a situation that pokes a hole in this theory'?

Oh, but that point doesn't matter at all in the slightest. Why?

Because, it's impossible for Kanon or Shannon or Beatrice to have entered the chapel 'completing' the closed rooms because the chapel key was found in the boiler room. The door was locked. How did they enter the chapel and still have it meet Beatrice's closed room definition? Master keys cannot open the chapel. So it won't work to say he opened and locked it with a master key.

Oh, and finally.

'Furthermore, all of the doors and windows in the 6 rooms are normal.'
'No device exists which can lock them without a key, such as an auto-lock.'

So you can't even argue that Shkanontrice locked the chapel door from the inside without the chapel key which he did not have.