/jp/ - Otaku Culture

which 3 eroge is the best????

The theme of Muramasa is an avant-garde look at good vs. evil and the challenge of universal peace. What theme does FSN have? Does it even have a theme?

Big 3 thread.

The theme of Muramasa is an avant-grade look at good vs. evil and the challenge of universal peace. What theme does FSN have? Does it even have a theme?

Big 3 thread.

>>9442452
what's your favourite eroge? which big 3 the best?

if u culd 4get one eroge in the pic which would it be? if you could wipe your memory of one eroge which would it be?

also which eroge would you fuck
which eroge would you take with you to an uninhabited island

>Muv-Luv Alt: Blockbuster movie
>Baldr Sky: Game
>Muramasa: Long novel

>They all have their own strengths and weakness Alt is an experience akin to seeing a great movie, you watch stuff that they happen on the screen and it manages to amaze you. But it's not like the writing is really great, it's a VN that wouldn't work if you removed the visual. But that's not a bad thing, that's what make it awesome even.

>Baldr Sky in the same way wasn't exceptionally well written and wouldn't work if you removed the visual part/gameplay parts. But again it manages to mix the gameplay and the story so well you never feel bored. And even though it never goes too far in the thematic elements the story is really good. Everything mesh to make a really uplifting experience that goes crescendo in intensity. Think of it like playing a really good game.

>And Muramasa is the only one that would work as a standalone novel. Among Visual Novels there is simply nothing that come even close to having a script that has as much impact, every words are powerful and the themes are explored to a depth that is pretty much unimaginable for a VN. But it's not like it goes for a "deep" experience either, it manages to avoid that pitfall very well unlike say Subahibi (that is really good in its own way though). But Muramasa also very wordy and dark at time so among the three it's probably the one that will get the less popularity here.

how accurate /jp/?

>>8858927
Seems like even moogy agrees that MLA is the worst of these eroge.

Why is MLA such a bad game compared to the other two?

what makes a good eroge?

who narutu here

Which one /jp/?

which game has the best font?

Obviously inspired by the Rewrite thread: Iet's get some nominations for these three mecha eroge that people seem to view as the best the mecha genre has to offer (or possibly the eroge medium?)

Please don't view this thread as some sort of fanboy/troll/flamewar thread. I'm only interested in what people think of these three titles because I enjoyed MLA a lot, which is actually the only game I've played of those three, so essentially all I really want to know is what to expect when they're translated.

Which game has the best story?
Which game has the best characters?
Which game has the best OST?
Which game is the most well-written?

Also I want your opinion on this as I just watched the OPs:

Which game has the best OP?
Which game has the best OP song?

Muramasa: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Le2zxWrD294
MLA: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UENpZitXCCc
Baldr Sky: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zD_ecJalA2s