/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>7494068
Yes she could have at any time. But Homura and sometimes other people prevented her from making a wish. By the end of the series with all the extra knowledge she had of how everything worked and with everyone else dead and Homura almost becoming a witch she finally did make her wish that changed the whole universe.

Nothing you've said contradicts anything. If you need more evidence, keep in mind that only Homura and Madoka know anything of the original universe. Even when Homura tells QB about the previous witch system, he says that it's never worked that way