/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>16095164
Can you prove that?

>>14988143
Truth brings a greater understanding of the world around us. The explanation of causality, although messy, has a greater benefit than accepting nihilism or denying cause and effect correlation. The journey to finding the truth being more important than the destination itself, but never accepting that the destination itself is meaningless?
Just because humans are flawed in their pursuit of the truth and their view of the truth does not make the pursuit invalid in of itself. To me, it just means that humans are flawed idiots.

I'm always reminded of that proverb where a bunch of people look into a vase through a small holes under different angle. All of them see something different but neither is wrong. And everyone claims that their view is accurate and that everyone else's is wrong. That, to me, is the core understanding of human nature. Different interpretation of the same source we call life, arguing over the same damn thing, killing each other and arguing endlessly over it.
Heh, now that I think about it, I guess that's what Umineko is about. Except we're reading what people wrote when they saw through the small hole of the vase.

Is that quote from Umineko or did you make it up?

>>14988158
Yes, and your interpretation that the manga is more accurate than my interpretation is perfectly valid. Sorry if I misunderstood you, I assumed I couldn't have personal interpretation, as you didn't care for it. Or maybe I stupidly correlated not caring with not being allowed to have an interpretation.

I still think that it's a plot hole, unless it was George or Kyrie that killed Nanjo not Yasu. But that's my interpretation. Yours is that the manga tells the truth completely without fault. Without red herrings or falsehoods.
Or perhaps, you're missing a small piece of a puzzle, that you think that small fragment of a page, that Nanjo was killed by Yasu to be the only part where the manga lies. As you say, if it's all truth, why would there be one small lie? A chessboard switching could provide answer perhaps, who knows.

>I trust the manga more than I trust you, since it's written by Ryukishi.
Also, bla bla bla, death to the author, not that it means anything since >>14988009,
>it's possible to show a different truth by using a different interpretation. Appeal to authority doesn't and should discern interpretation.

I say it's a plot hole, you say that the manga is truth and that there is no plot hole.