[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique


View post   

File: 892 KB, 1800x1200, haloa.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6899765 No.6899765 [Reply] [Original]

Previous thread: >>6881138

Do Art Daily:
>Link: https://dad.gallery
>Discord: You must have a DAD streak of at least 14 to join. Ask Vastian#0988 for an invite.
>Found an issue with the site? Lost your streak and want to appeal? Please message the contact link at the bottom of the site instead of posting in the thread.

Rules:
>Draw every day (or your preferred frequency)
>Submit your work by 23:59:59 GMT
>Spend at least 30 minutes on each submission
>No loli or shota porn
>Miss a day and you'll be alright, just keep going!
>Maintain your streak and you too can become the LAST ARTIST STANDING!!
>Have fun!

Go and comment on each other's artwork; dads love attention!

FAQ:

What is the goal?
>To form a habit of drawing. The gains you make are dependent on you.

I am /beg/gar and not know draw, can I join?
>Yes x99. Stop asking and start submitting art, chum. Make something!

How long does it take until my account is approved?
>Between two to three weeks, usually when you reach level 3. Even unapproved submissions count toward your streak!

A brief history:
>Last Artist Standing (LAS): The original site, created by Lava (presumed dead, rest in peace). It has changed and ruined the lives of many lassies.
>Draw Every Day (DED): A short-lived site between LAS and DAD, run and abruptly cancelled by w.
>Do Art Daily (DAD): The current site, by the dadmin and developer banana.

Community links:
>DADcast: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCfCw_buGoBDPQC1bbcukmnQ
>LAS discord (alternative to DAD discord): https://discord.gg/5777rZnqW9
>Crit Dashboard: https://dad-crit.vercel.app/

>> No.6899856
File: 151 KB, 765x695, E_hXz_3VQAACse2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6899856

please cheer up dads

>> No.6899861

Can somebody reupload that folder of LAS artists' drawings?

>> No.6900078

dad non tourney tierlist when?

>> No.6900094
File: 6 KB, 222x227, shurrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrg.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900094

Gotta agree with sekx here even though they're a sperg fresh account that should stfu

>> No.6900144

>>6900094
its a pretty legendary meltdown to be sure

>> No.6900149

>>6900144
where did it happen?

>> No.6900157

>>6900149
sekx's third tournament entry

>> No.6900174

>>6900157
Seeing that someone actually used my "yeti in a snowstorm" idea made me so happy :)

>> No.6900186

>>6900094
Can't shake the feeling that he knew he wasn't going to finish in time and used the judge as an excuse to leave the tourney without feeling guilty. I still get that he is mad even thought it's excessive.

>> No.6900198

>>6899520
>composition
>I think you only learn it by making finished pieces
Yes, making quick illustrations will make you improve, but it's a bit more complex than that if you want to improve at a decent rate. This video is relevant to this discussion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OI_3bQ-EWSI

>> No.6900273
File: 646 KB, 1500x1000, random531.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900273

Wageslave™ the board game!

Try now the Human Experience!
The game designed by our illustrious Prince of Nightmare in collaboration with infamous eldritch beings from beyond the stars!

Summon your cryptid friends and fellow urban legends to play this cursed game...
Pay taxes! Work overtime! Struggle to make ends meet! Savour the the suffering!
(Based on true human madness and despair)

>> No.6900275

>>6900273
SOOOOOUL

>> No.6900294

coin's already carving me a new hole for my subpar composition...
maybe I'll make a try

>> No.6900339
File: 595 KB, 1642x1048, random531b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900339

alright, this should be a little better

>> No.6900603

It's almost over DADs I love you all even the tone deaf ones. Happy drawing and some awesome art in this tourney. Don't get distracted by the gossip. Keep walking your path. Draw avery Day. Remmeber to draw at least one penis for cocktober.

>> No.6900668

>>6900603
>even the tone deaf ones
NAMES

>> No.6900684
File: 3.33 MB, 1642x1048, dsdfs.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900684

>>6900339
i think the flow of this arm looks weird coming out so horizontally from the side of the page

>> No.6900690

>>6900339
I'd tone down that blue in bg a bit, it's too saturated for me

>> No.6900766 [DELETED] 

>>6900684
>>6900690
Alright. Last version.
I even added extra shitty effects so it feels 20% more premium.

No more... I'm on the ground bleeding. Stop beating me.

>> No.6900770
File: 621 KB, 1643x1048, random531c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900770

>>6900684
>>6900690
Alright. Last version.
I even added extra shitty effects so it feels 20% more premium.

No more... I'm on the ground bleeding. Stop beating me.

>> No.6900807
File: 215 KB, 1306x837, animutourney.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900807

>>6900770
HAHA JUST KIDDING.
HERE'S THE REAL FINAL ENTRY

>> No.6900849

>>6900174
Wait he didn’t even come up with the idea himself?

That’s 0/10 creativity for art theft.

>> No.6900952
File: 136 KB, 581x873, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6900952

I plan on drawing every day, once my B-day hits, in 21-ish days. Gonna be 22 y/o and more or less wanna see how I progress more, on a day by day basis. Also should ask, but are 3d/blender pictures okay to post? Wanna get into blender sculpting for the 3d to 2d work flow.

>> No.6900962

>>6900952
You can post whatever you want as long as it takes you at least 30 minutes. There's a small handful of 3d people on the site already.

>> No.6900969

>>6900962
>30 minutes.
Will keep that in mind. Good thing I will allocate 4 hrs/per day to both!
>Got a 4hr/day part time job in the afternoon to evening.

>> No.6900998

>>6900770
I absolutely love it dude. Such a cool piece

>> No.6901002

>>6900603
Thank you brother. I promise to get better with colors (and everything else too) and try my best to push myself harder, no matter what

>> No.6901021

>>6900094
Who the fuck are they even talking about? who was writing crits for who? schizo meltodown/10

>> No.6901022

Pour one out for Paganini

>> No.6901098
File: 33 KB, 583x472, 1679155146125359.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6901098

You know what? I'm gonna say it.
I fucking love drawing.

>> No.6901120

>>6901098
BURN HIM

>> No.6901187

Everyone complaining about judges… in 2021 Chooby was literally the ONLY judge for prompts 2 and 3. And we were happy.

>> No.6901189

>>6901098
heretic

>> No.6901196

>>6901098
You will hate it soon enough

>> No.6901200

>>6901187
Chooby is the hero we need, but not the one we deserve.

>> No.6901207

>>6901187
Chooby can go suck a fat one imo but I still love him

>> No.6901267

>>6900952
Why are you waiting for after your birthday? What are you, 5?

>> No.6901418

Now that the tourney is over.
Best contestant overall?
favorite prompt?
favorite entry?
honorable mention?

>> No.6901420

>>6901418
>Best contestant overall?
me!

>> No.6901484

>>6901418
Faves:
>Ariel
> Yoshi
> Urazi
Honorable:
>Wuschel
Worst:
>Sekx
For being such a bitch boy
Best overall:
>Me!

>> No.6901494

>>6901418
Well done to everyone that participated!

Faves:
> Tableguy
> Haloa
> Yoshi
> Ainarika

Honorable:
> WuschelMiniTyp
> Tori

Worst
> WinarDaBernd

Best overall:
> Yoshi
Went absolutly crazy with the giant scene and characters.

- Urazi

>> No.6901505

Tableguy posted his crit, score and tierlist in the tourney challenge if you want to check it out.

>> No.6901514

>tableguy giving himself the highest score
Kek. We all know letting a judge participate and judge their own work was bound to be a horrible idea.

>> No.6901518

>>6901514
You can dislike his tastes and subject but you can't denied that he is good and has creative idea.

>> No.6901521

>>6901418
>best
me
>worst
you
DNFs

>> No.6901525

TG managed to make the entire tourney about him kek. Are we going to see more or less DADs participate next year? But I guess every year has something scuffed about it.

>> No.6901530

>>6901525
This entire community is about stroking his massive ego these days.

>> No.6901532
File: 25 KB, 739x415, STT2023.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6901532

>>6901518
Okay tableguy

>> No.6901534

>>6901530
all 5 judges should give him all 10's to piss him off

>> No.6901622
File: 59 KB, 646x875, I'm going to say it.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6901622

>>6901098
>>6901120
>>6901189
>>6901196

>> No.6901691

NO CRYPTO CRYPTIDS WHAT THE FUUUCKk

>> No.6901696

We need to get Tableguy thrown out as a judge. I'm sorry but it just has to be done so we can all move on.

>> No.6901725

can somebody explain the whole tableguy/dingle thing? table was a judge? i'm confused

>> No.6901737

>>6901725
Dingle got a comic gig 2 weeks ago and had no more time to write critics so he copy paste the ones Table did.

>> No.6901867

>>6901737
>Dingle got a comic gig 2 weeks ago
Wait, what? Dingle got an actual art related job?
wtf, i thought you guys are losers just like me ;_;

>> No.6901928
File: 2.32 MB, 3754x3500, Bleeding-WIP.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6901928

>>6901267
Got my schedule set up for the following weeks, and following months to not slog around, and get to drawing drafts up. and avoid doing past mistakes with having a job. Wanting to do something with art for a long time, whilst having my current irl job. If I had known now at 18, the last three years would have been spent less with bouncing from retail job to dead end warehouse jobs, spending on credit with money that should have been budgeted.

Not in a desperate situation, just a 21 y/o living with parents, while paying off debt. Figured with the stripped spending, I can definitely pay of the 3k of credit debt within 2 months, save at least 15% of my current pay, and handle the 20k student loan from a college semester in 2019-2020.
>The loan is set at 140/month. But I wanna pay if off asap.

Got an at home workout routine and diet regimen to cut the last 88lbs off, supplements for health, and generally want to make more out of myself, as opposed to just living for a 9-5. Or rather a 4pm-8pm with the current hours. Job aint bad, far from it. But outside of that, I made myself a 3-4 year plan to move out, have a good amount of savings, not spend like a manic. Started the last part with cutting my credit cards, Guess its sort of my own New Year's resolution, just reevaluating where I want to be, and what I want to do in a year from now. Might as well plan ahead with some drafts.

>> No.6901979

>>6901928
none of these excuses actually stop you from drawing every day
I bet you have like 4 hours of youtube or netflix or gaming you can trim out 30 mins with.

>> No.6901988

>>6901979
You are right. I got 9am-12 for the drawing studies and drafts set up. Hadn't gamed since july.

>> No.6902042

>>6901928
Holy shit go blog somewhere else

>> No.6902051

>>6901928
Holy shit go blog in your submission descriptions like the rest of us

>> No.6902059

>>6901928
Any updates on how your day is going?

>> No.6902081

>>6901928
Holy shit, post more blogs, I actually like them :D

>> No.6902104
File: 172 KB, 582x614, 1620341641402.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902104

I actually like blogposters
its more interesting than an empty thread, sitting on page 8

>> No.6902137

>>6902104
>I actually like blogposters
>its more interesting than an empty thread, sitting on page 8
What about drama posters and bullies?
(i posted a sub 30 minutes submission recently btw)

>> No.6902142
File: 675 KB, 1080x1331, 1681235821882412.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902142

>>6901928
I asked.

>> No.6902149

>>6902137
nah dramaposting and bullying sucks
its a very short term thing, just harass or bully someone and then they leave and then thread is silent for another couple of weeks

>> No.6902329
File: 16 KB, 663x553, obbaogga.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902329

>>6901418
>favorite entry?
Hanameru's
>Best contestant overall?
Haloa. Would've been echo if his first submission wasn't dogshit.
>favorite prompt?
hard to say...
Harvest because it's the one I had most fun doing.
Costume party because I found the judge's reactions funny
Urban legends because I didn't do anything
>honorable mention?
sekx for having a funny idea

.3 things i've learned
1. Learning fundamentals is.. good..
2.
3.

>> No.6902337
File: 214 KB, 320x240, ce2b93fa959897d91d835b5d5dd8af0b8735e2bc99c5dbd824640135a78d971e.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902337

>>6902104
I'd like to imagene thats a police sketch artist

>> No.6902352

idc about any of this drama. you're all dumb and gay. just add mp4 support already

>> No.6902387

>>6902352
do this

>> No.6902429

>>6901737
why are people blaming banana then?

>> No.6902432

>>6902149
>just harass or bully someone and then they leave
dads are like kleenex
remove one, another one shows up

>> No.6902439

>>6902429
Because he's organizing this whole shindig. For banana haters it's easy to just point fingers at him whenever anything goes wrong and to take a working 24/7, completely free, ads free site that hosts thousands of dads and hundreds of thousands of files that also works as a spam-free forum for granted.

>> No.6902467

why are so many high streak dads dying recently

>> No.6902530
File: 365 KB, 1500x1000, ch102_onepunch.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902530

>>6902467
So I can stay on page1 despite having switched to every other day to give some love to my neglected trash isekai novel (pic related).

>> No.6902613

>>6902530
is that guy going to be ok?

>> No.6902625
File: 484 B, 72x76, no.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6902625

>>6902613

>> No.6903012

>>6902329
>echo if his first submission wasn't dogshit
this is the skill level of the average guy calling your work dogshit. literal toddler tier. remember that

>> No.6903099

The tier tourney really brought out the reasons why the dad community stinks, but it's so good for storing files and tracking. Hopefully the ingrates don't make it implode.

>> No.6903233

NEW SCORES ARE UP FOR PROMPT 3!!! GET THEM WHILE THEY ARE HOT

>> No.6903263

>>6903099
>The tier tourney really brought out the reasons why the dad community stinks
What reasons exactly?
Because people care about those challenges enough to get emotional? Because average dad is deviant-art tier?

Maybe I'm autistic, but I'm really not sure what EXACTLY do you mean Anon.

>> No.6903267

>>6902329
echo is a woman

>> No.6903273

>>6903099
If you know of a better community where:
- there are many actual professionals and high level artists
- that's focused on building positive drawing habits
- where majority actually draws instead of being just social
- where you can easily browse everyone's work, including admin and mods
- where there are regular fun challenges to engage in
- that isn't overly prudish about NSFW stuff
then I'd love to hear about them.

My point is that sure, dad has some flaws, but there are literally no better alternatives.

>> No.6903276

>>6903267
Echo draws like a man. Are they a tranny?

>> No.6903291

>>6903012
>you need to be a great cook to recognize a badly made dish

>> No.6903294

>>6903099
I CANT FUCKING TAKE IT ANYMORE

>> No.6903303
File: 16 KB, 137x137, smug.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6903303

>>6903291
There's no good art, only decresing levels of dogshit

>> No.6903307

>>6903273
>- that isn't overly prudish about NSFW stuff
They make me censor my work with their QUESTIONABLE labeling. I dont even draw porn.

>> No.6903378

>>6903307
>I dont even draw porn
Then how come, I keep masturbating to your work?
Checkmate.

>> No.6903469

>>6903012
I said he was in second place so you can relax lol.
>literal toddler tier
We all start somewhere
>>6903267
I don't care

>> No.6903646

>>6903307
tableguy detected

>> No.6903651

>>6903273
>dad has some flaws
Just kick Tableguy out, problem solved.

>> No.6903740

>>6903651
No thanks. rather kick you out WinarDaBernd. getting mad over softball critique is just sad

>> No.6903800

>>6903651
While I enjoy whining about his creativity scores and I see how him writing critiques for another judge could be bothersome, that's taking it a bit far.
Table is alright for a sex-having normie. His kind of weird makes dad more interesting, you know?

>> No.6903811

When's the Ramionn episode dropping?

>> No.6904007

>>6903800
Dad would have less drama if some of the users had sex and weren’t so socially underdeveloped but seeing the biggest spergs on the board throw public fits occasionally is very funny

>> No.6904031

>>6904007
>if some of the users had sex and weren’t so socially underdeveloped
You're asking for a lot from 4chan users

>> No.6904034

I wish some dad would just post his morning routine for the day like yesterday.
I'm tired of the Tableguy drama and Tableguy himself.

>> No.6904057

>>6903740
NTA
I remember some dad posting a drawing of some sign for work and an apology that she couldn't draw more because of tiredness. In her comment you posted that you report her for that. I think it's obvious that you critique people here behind their backs while they have open comments, considering that you whine about furries 24/7 while drawing even more disgusting fetishitic shit yourself

You're legit the most obnoxious and grumpy dad (or even artist) that I know

>> No.6904078

>>6904007
>where do you think we are?

>> No.6904131

>>6904057
if you're talking about tg and konsui they are buds and constantly give eachother shit for fun. Don't take it too seriously

>> No.6904151
File: 7 KB, 222x227, plankton.jpeg.jfif.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6904151

>>6904034
>i wake up
>shower/brush teeth/feed my cats
>either go wage or stay home depending on day

>> No.6904153

Anyway I wish you'd all stop drawing the same thing but it can't be helped. *pats your head*

>> No.6904173

>>6904151
same but dogs

>> No.6904199

>>6904034
You will participate in the spring tableguy tourney. You will look at tableguy art. You will agree with judges giving tableguy high scores. You will accept tableguy judging and ignore all others. You will post about tableguy on the thread. The sooner you accept this the faster you will reach enlightenment

>> No.6904227
File: 680 KB, 720x540, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6904227

>>6903740
>rather kick you out WinarDaBernd.
not me tho.
>getting mad over softball critique is just sad
You did not critique me LOL and i'm not mad. If you think retarded critique is enough for me to start a witch hunt after someone I wouldn't be using the internet.

>> No.6904321

>>6904173
You brush your dogs instead of your teeth? Radical.

>> No.6904586
File: 109 KB, 533x208, gotgud.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6904586

no way

>> No.6904589

>>6904586
Holy shit

>> No.6904590

>>6904586
>waits till that last minute to post everyday.
It was bound to happen. He'll just make an appeal and be reinstated.

>> No.6904601

>>6904590
god damnit ur probably right

>> No.6904623

>>6904586
what the fuck, is this real, whizzard is the new king??

>> No.6904663

>>6904586
Damnnnnnn bro, that is actually fucking crazy. No more flawless streaks. We are entering into a new /dad/ era
>>6904623
git gud definitely “won” dad by being the last flawless imo but yeah. The king is dead, long live the king

>> No.6904760

>>6904586
the final flawless has fallen

>> No.6904767

>>6904586
I trust it was an internet thing. The score really should be reset. The spirit of the streak is wouldn't be tarnished considering the circumstance.

>> No.6904768
File: 866 KB, 1438x955, Screenshot_20231024_184522.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6904768

my power grows stronger. soon i will be number 1

>> No.6904770

Man, seeing how many streaks have fallen recently I really should have kept mine up....

>> No.6904797

>>6904770
come back!

>> No.6904854

It's way cooler to drop a big streak then just keep going like nothing happened

>> No.6904883
File: 159 KB, 500x375, 1694492518903808.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6904883

>>6904586
Page 1 chads
They got one of us.

>> No.6904899

the hex worked, finally

>> No.6904921

>>6904586
KWAB

>> No.6905205

Scores are finally up, took fucking long enough. Big surprise who they picked as first. Don’t even bother looking.

>> No.6905378

>>6905205
>Big surprise who they picked as first
Was it Echo?? I love that guy :D

>> No.6905408

>>6904586
>his internet went down in the last 10 minutes
my worst fear.. but im not gonna stop posting at last minute either

>> No.6905412

Are anonymous judges a good thing or not?
Vote pls: https://strawpoll.com/xVg7jqDOznr

I mean, some of them put in a lot of effort and thought into this project. Others did not. The problem is that next year, when I'll be voting for a judge, I won't know who has a history of good critiques and who didn't took it seriously.

>> No.6905449

>>6905412
For every complaint about perceived effort from a judge, there have been 200 complaints because judges didn't share the person's values of what fills the rubric. I can't imagine the shit storm when these 3 complainers can cherry pick a judge's pictures to discredit a score they disagreed with.

But it's not too hard to figure out who is who

>> No.6905485
File: 309 KB, 800x678, 3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905485

>>6905205
gave everyone barely even one sentence critiques except for like, two /dad/cord users

this site is so dead aha

>> No.6905495

>>6905449
>But it's not too hard to figure out who is who
Not everyone spends as much time socializing with dads as you do, Anon.

>> No.6905500
File: 24 KB, 545x362, B7f2_OECEAAyijj.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905500

>>6905412
>next year

>> No.6905511

>>6905485
This happens because there's no rubric with images of what a 0, 5, or 10 look like so every score is up to how the judge is feeling at that moment.

>> No.6905521

>>6905449
Just tell me who did this: >>6905485

>> No.6905522

did all the other judges also give up on the tourney lol

>> No.6905523

>>6905412
>>6905449
If a score can be completely discredited by an anonymous 4chan user, then it wasn't a good score in the first place.

I want tier tourneys to be better each year. If having a thread or two filled with shitposts is what it costs, that's fine.

>> No.6905544

>>6904586
fuckj nooo please I don't want to get even higher

>> No.6905549 [DELETED] 

Judge "Critique"
> I hate anime girls looking at camera art, but this one is pretty good. I just wish it was more of a scene than just character design.
kek. Very helpful.

>> No.6905578
File: 2.11 MB, 5000x3500, sketches.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905578

hi, what are you guys working on??

>> No.6905581

>>6905578
not that

>> No.6905582

>>6905522
Depending on job/ school expect judges to take a few days to a week or so. Don't fret if they're giving it the time it deserves.

>> No.6905597

>>6905485
Explain to me what this image is trying to convey

>> No.6905608

>>6905485
This score is fair. Top one feels like a monster that you stumbled on at night and is going to jump at you.
Bottom displays skill, but it doesn't make you feel like you're in that world.
Art should be about feeling not just displaying skill.
I 100% agree with this judge.

>> No.6905620

>>6905608
are you high

>> No.6905646
File: 458 KB, 256x256, 85c.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905646

>>6905608

>> No.6905661

>>6905620
Yes. I have high class taste and appreciate good content. If you prefer superficial looks over content, fine, but you're the sort of guy that buys a beautiful car that brakes down every mile and then complain why you have to give your local hobo a blow job to help you push your worthless junk to the repair shop every 10 minutes. You must be some retarded inbred fuck to give such a mentally dumbfuck take.

>> No.6905679

>>6905661
>>6905608
wow you're such a contrarian, i never realized how smart one man could be, please suck on my tits and have sex with me right now boy genius

>> No.6905684

>>6905608
Are you retarded?

>> No.6905703

>>6905679
>>6905684
No. The whole point of art is that you want to materialize a feeling. The top work has feeling, the bottom one does not. Therefore the top one is better than the lower one.
But that's fine. You guys like bland, unimpressive and generic things, that's cool, I'm sure your arts reflect that. If that's what makes you happy, the joy of retarded children is the most pure and wholesome of all.

>> No.6905704

>>6905608
This anon is right, and the fact that not a single person has yet to bring forth any counterarguements to his statement is proof of that.

>> No.6905707

>>6905412
>>6905449
>>6905485
>>6905521
>>6905582
>>6905522
So do you miss tablejudge now??

>> No.6905709

>>6905608
This anon is right, I agree with this guy >>6905704

>> No.6905713

God just shut up. The ratings are completely arbitrary and don't mean anything.

>> No.6905720

>>6905511
This kind of thing always happens when commercial illustrators, fine artists, and hobbyists come together. These groups all have different values when asked the question "what is art?", but they always get lumped together as "artists".

>> No.6905733
File: 33 KB, 640x604, demo_alcove_candles.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905733

>>6905578
Backgrounds and animations for a demo

>> No.6905741

>>6905703
Sorry, it seems that i have forgotten the "feelings" score next to "creativity and originality". I'm not feeling that piece or your post, 1/10.

>> No.6905823

>>6905608
actually mostly agree, except I think bottom deserves a 9 in technical (one point docked because the highlights make the image more washed out rather than punchier).

>> No.6905825

>>6905661
You're completely correct. I wear beautiful shoes that ruin my feet and my favorite car is known to break down every 5 minutes. I am committed to beauty and craftsmanship to the point where I'll pay whatever price. We are not the same. You can keep defending your and other peoples 13 views, 1 like fridge drawings from within my shadow where you belong.

>> No.6905830
File: 22 KB, 261x247, importedImageeb12877d-db8b-45b1-bfed-d20a263b93cf.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905830

>>6905495
You can mostly infer from the following
> coin - meme reviews, hates anime girls staring at camera, hates painting on grey, gives lots of 10s or 0s
> apricot - nicest judge. gives lots of high scores
> dingle - toughest judge. gives low scores (or none at all, kek). signs his name
> ocos and hunchen I haven't figured out how to distinguish them yet

>> No.6905839

>>6905830
>> dingle - toughest judge. gives low scores (or none at all, kek). signs his name
Lol sometimes he signs his ghost writers name who crits even more harshly

>> No.6905845

>>6905733
Sounds pretty cool. It reminds me of Skyrim dungeons a little bit.
Stay focused, brother.

>> No.6905854
File: 120 KB, 2481x585, space.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6905854

>>6905578
Continuing my little space adventure.

>> No.6905929

>>6905707
If he actually volunteered to be a judge and followed the rules that come with that, then I'd be happy to vote for him.
Table scores are alright, the problem was with how it was handled.

>> No.6905939

>>6905830
so coin is the first judge? that explains why the composition scores are so off. well, everything's off really.

>> No.6905946

>>6905707
no, tablejudge was easily the worst part of this all

>> No.6905948

>>6905929
> the problem was with how it was handled
didn't banana take care of the situation

>> No.6905968

>>6905608
>>6905709
>>6905704
Y'all either have brain damage or are trolling.
But since some of lurkers probably really ARE that retarded, here are your "counterarguments" you asked for:
>COMPOSITION AND DESIGN
Upper image is the most boring, central composition imaginable. Design is a girl in a white dress with altered features to make it more creepy. 7/10
Bottom image is central as well but with elements intentionally framing focal points and leading to it (like how sword is leading the eye to the face of anime girl, how the elastic cat circles, frames that face to emphasize it more). Artist clearly took the effort to do some research on medieval clothing and attire and altered it to appeal to more modern tastes, but without losing medieval feeling. Design was very elaborate. 4/10, much worse than the upper one according to the judge.
>APPLICATION OF FUNDAMENTALS
Upper picture shows no knowledge of anatomy, no sense of lighting, environment looks like something a child would draw from imagination: 7/10
Bottom one shows variety of textures and materials, artist uses light and shadow in a consistent matter, lineart is clean and crisp, anatomy and proportions pleasant. Both human and animal features are appealing. Maybe I would emphasize ambient occlusion and reflect lights more for a more realistic feeling and redo cat's paw, but other than that it's very nicely done. 8/10, slightly better than above pic.

I can kinda agree with the other scores but not with these ones.
I hope someone will identify who's that judge so I won't vote on them accidentally, or that they simply won't volunteer for it next year. Yes, they put in some effort into those (like with a paintover for torture), but their scores aren't consistent and they don't reflect what a normal person understands by "fundamentals" and "composition and design".

>> No.6905984

>>6905948
>>>6905929 (You)
>> the problem was with how it was handled
>didn't banana take care of the situation
I meant how it happened in the first place, how dingle handled fact that he couldn't write his scores. Him apologizing in those threads later and banana sorting the issue out was a good way of taking care of the situation.
People bitching about tablejudge probably are autistic, not handling this sudden change well. I'm just pointing out this drama could be avoided in the first place.

>>6905608
>Art should be about feeling not just displaying skill.
Tier tourney with scores like "fundamentals", "composition" and "technique" is about skills, not about how much you personally like it you retard. If you don't like it, then make your own tourney, where the only score is how much you liked it at the moment.

>> No.6906001

>>6905984
>People bitching about tablejudge probably are autistic not handling this sudden change well
This is part of it but I think it's more that tg bypassed the entire system that was put in place to select judges. It is annoying when one guy gets to circumvent all the rules while the rest of us have to adhere to them. I would have loved to be a judge but I chose to compete. Im sure some of the judges would have loved to compete but they could only judge this time.
I like table's scoring and the way he did it on his own is great (my only suggestion is that he wait for the official scores to be released instead of beating them to the punch).

>> No.6906018

I think the judge rule is unnecessary anyway. Sure conflict of interest might be a concern, but with a community of this size, it's sort of unavoidable. And I think it's a shame to bar 4 or 5 of the most active community members from participating.

>> No.6906028

>>6906018
yeah I agree. If the rule didn't exist it wouldn't be an issue. Something to think about for next year maybe

>> No.6906056
File: 157 KB, 887x758, Screenshot from 2023-10-25 14-32-42.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6906056

>>6905578
drawing furry porn.

>> No.6906165

>>6906018
>>6906028
The rule exists because tableguy was a judge last year and participated last year and won last year.

This year he was not allowed to be a judge so that he couldn’t inflate his own scores to fake “win” the tournament.

>> No.6906174

>>6906165
Yeah, the judges obviously shouldn't be able to rate themselves. Whoever came up with that is a big dummy.

>> No.6906184

Do you think banana will learn from all of this and design a better tourney next year?

>> No.6906231

>>6906174
But that is exactly the problem. Because I nerfed all the scores including my own, but when they made me drop my self crit, everyone got the Tableguy nerf except for me, Tableguy, and thats how i won.

It’s better to just not include the scores all together. Or make 2 separate tiers of results. One with the judges included and one with participants only.

In either case, i found the judging this year to be incredibly homogeneous. I felt all 5 judges rated very closely to each other and have similar values. I was kind of happy to make my own set of scores. Because my 20% contribution to the weighting of the official panel scores would not have been enough to make any noticeable difference in the results. I also like that you know it came from me. And you can see what I valued in the submissions. It felt more personal.

I almost feel like part of participating should be that everyone has to crit all the drawings. Maybe there are still officially 5 judges that we choose who we trust, but then we could have like a “peoples choice” tier list and a “official” tier list.

I think it’s important that everybody look at everyone’s drawings for more than 30s and we spend a nonzero amount of time to say something about each drawing, even if it’s a shitpost or empty praise.

>> No.6906266

>>6901207
Why the Chooby slander?

>> No.6906309

>>6906184
What did banana fuck up? What does he need to fix?

>> No.6906327 [DELETED] 
File: 59 KB, 1200x495, fight.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6906327

i really need to do some more just random dynamic sketching
it's been quite a long time since i've done any

>> No.6906367

>>6906309
yarly. banana did everything right this was just peeps going over his head. people just hating on nana for no reason

>> No.6906371

Literally just hire Banksy to rate everyone and then everyone can stop complaining. If everyone chips in 10 bucks we can make it happen.

>> No.6906378

>>6906367
Don't mean to talk shit about banana but it wasn't perfect considering the tourney was supposed to be 6 months ago...and then out of all the months he chose the same month as inktober. I bet there were at least a few users who didin't enter because of inktober.

>> No.6906387

>>6906309
Nothing, really. I wasn't talking about Banana "fixing" stuff, but about improving. Everything ended up alright, but he could always improve how he organizes this tourney, for example:
- rethink the idea of barring judges from participating. We had very few judges to pick from and this rule makes it worse.
- rethink idea of judges being anonymous. Some judges are much worse than the others and with this rule in place we can't really weed them out. Voting was very close to a tie (>>6905412)
- it started few months too late
- decide if the new weekly format works better than the weekend one and/or consider other options
- be more clear about judging criteria (since just "fundamentals" or "creativity" can be interpreted in very different ways by different judges and that results in a mess)
And so on. The idea that every participant should crit/score/comment on every other submissions is worth talking over as well.

I'm just worried that next year nothing will really change. Banana doesn't participate in those threads nor in his tourney so he doesn't see the effect his rules and decisions have.

>> No.6906402

>>6906231
I see. I suggested that everyone votes earlier in the thread too. It would make things a lot more complicated in some ways though. If everyone had to vote the way it is now, I think it would turn off too many members.
The most realistic idea I could imagine would be to strip the categories down to a simple 1-10 from everybody, public with name attached and require to give a short justification. Maybe 3 pros and 3 cons or something like that. As for the official judges, I don't want to be a dick, but there are barely any dads who are qualified to be tournament judges anyway.

>> No.6906405

make a thread on DAD.gallery and let it be a discussion there, I think the guys that 4chan are more bitter than the general pop of DAD anyway

>> No.6906476

haha so ungrateful

>> No.6906515
File: 66 KB, 640x480, 1669816920474572.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6906515

Doesn't matter.
I won in spirit and SOUL.

>> No.6906544

you should fear the sword yourselves; for wrath will bring punishment by the sword, and then you will know that there is judgment.

>> No.6906645

okay tier raging over

underrated dads, go

>> No.6906672

>>6906645
pelvis no jutsu - awesome environments
masmo - comfy inkwork
dtierdaddy - should update his name

>> No.6906707

>>6906476
>ask someone for critique to improve
>get a meaningless comment they've spend ~10 seconds on
>"why are you so ungrateful?"
Take a guess. And don't volunteer to be a judge next year if you can't figure it out.

>> No.6906744

>>6902329
>.3 things i've learned
>1. Learning fundamentals is.. good..
>2.
>3.
To be fair you really should learn them, it will make your art better.

>> No.6906797

>>6906405
>make a thread on DAD.gallery and let it be a discussion there
Good point! I made the new discussion thread here: https://dad.gallery/forums/threads/502

>> No.6906805

>>6906645
mgop

>> No.6906813

I won't post in that thread because banana can see ips behind anonymous posts and probably shares everything with his dadcord buddies.

>> No.6906819

How to fix next year's tournament - with only 1 change:

Judges have to be /int/ and upwards. Increase judge pool so there's an option to disqualify lazy/bad judges. Judges can also participate in the tourney.

>> No.6906830

>>6906819
why is it such a big deal that judges can't officially participate? It didn't stop other judges participating this year, they just didn't sperg over a badge.

>> No.6906835

>>6906830
the sole reason is that tableguy is annoying

>> No.6906836

>>6906813
To fix tourney, we have to convince people responsible for it.
Who do you think banana is more likely to listen to? A completely anonymous poster on 4chan, who's probably just trolling? Or someone he's sure is an actual dad?
>and probably shares everything with his dadcord buddies
Banana isn't on discord.

>> No.6906840

>>6906819
>Judges have to be /int/ and upwards
Coin is at least /int/ tier and his takes (>>6905485) are pure feces. The only way to separate the wheat from the chaff is to have non-anonymous judges.

>> No.6906843

>>6906819
>How to fix next year's tournament - with only 1 change:
>names 3 changes
Kek. It's no wonder you were embarrassed of posting your takes on official dad forum.

>> No.6906905

>>6905485
top image looks cute

>> No.6907078

>>6906905
ur cute

>> No.6907180

judge let an AI judge next year. solved

>> No.6907209

>>6907180
Ooh run the ai judge over the entries this year would you

>> No.6907269

>>6907180
How would you even do that?

>> No.6907273

>>6897179
>Give them a rubrick to score on then. That's how grading works on a professional level, so if you want objectively scoring you should use those as a standard.
Do you guys have some more info on those pro level grading rubrics? Specifics are needed if we want to fix the tourney, Banana isn't good enough to make one on his own

>> No.6907290

>>6907269
the technology will be there by 2024

>> No.6907305
File: 20 KB, 480x270, 1223141b8512f7c507a71f63e179562c6ba2bbbd_hq.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6907305

Despite the controversy, I am grateful to the judges who wanted to give back to their community and offered their valuable time. Thank you. ( I didn't participate btw)

>> No.6907316
File: 79 KB, 660x800, pepe from google.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6907316

Due to the controversy I hope some judges (you know who you are) will be too ashamed to volunteer again next year. Spending 30 seconds to write half of a sentence when dads were looking forward to helpful critiques for illustrations they've spend hours on is like farting in their faces. Kys. ( I didn't participate either btw)

>> No.6907331

>>6907316
Hey some people pay good money for face farts

>> No.6907337

>>6907331
kek

>> No.6907353

>>6900186
This desu. I show up to the tourney just to hold myself accountable and have fun and get some attention and critiques. I personally like tableguy being a judge because it means I get an extra crit, and some extra attention which I love

>> No.6907421

i have it on good authority that banana is going to kill himself because of this tourney and name a successor

>> No.6907425

>>6906836
>Banana isn't on discord.
Wow, you don't have his discord? He must not like you enough to share it with you.

>> No.6907473

its funny watching all the crybabies and drama dads who made it miserable for everyone else now saying stuff like "huh its just for fun why is everyone taking it so seriously"

>> No.6907476

>>6907473
Names.

>> No.6907477

>>6907476
i can't name names because I was one of them

>> No.6907485

>>6907477
based shit stirrer

>> No.6907612

the gossip was the most fun part of the entire tournament. having 9 people drop out due to butthurt is way better and way funnier than getting to see their submissions.

>> No.6907754

>>6907612
you are a fool if you think the majority of them dropped out due to (expected) drama

>> No.6907762

> tier tourney judges in a nutshell
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovezV6b1J6E

>> No.6907779

>>6907754
one of them dropped due to the war in the middle east which is like the ultimate drama if you really think about it

>> No.6907800

>>6907612
>9 people drop out due to butthurt

It'd be a good meme if this were true, but I'd bet only one, MAYBEEE 2 if I wanted to be generous, did.

>> No.6907816
File: 2.28 MB, 3192x3059, marky3.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6907816

Hi, /dad/s.
What are you guys doing?

>> No.6907821

I didn't post on DAD for a while.
Can I just put it all in one submission? Am I allowed to do it?

>> No.6907838

>>6907816
okay now make her pretty

>> No.6907861

>>6907821
it won't add a bunch of numbers to your streak if that's what you're asking anon, draw daily, post daily

>> No.6907869

critme should be integrated into the site or there should be a critme checkbox on your submission. This seems so obvious

>> No.6907876
File: 17 KB, 800x1100, 1677663436426039.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6907876

>>6907180
No one found out all my submissions were AI generated.

>> No.6907877

>>6907861
But is it against the rules?

>> No.6907908
File: 53 KB, 600x611, 10262051_10202271916658945_1058480794194592846_n.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6907908

>>6906645
me...

>> No.6907944

>>6907877
yeah its against the rules. you should only post work from this particular submission cycle. So from today if daily or from this week if weekly

>> No.6907961

God help you if we find evidence otherwise

>> No.6908015

>>6907876
What prompts did you use? "Beginner" and "amateurish"?

>> No.6908020
File: 2.39 MB, 3192x3059, marky5.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6908020

>>6907838
Better?

>> No.6908059
File: 32 KB, 335x303, 1678312981398304.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6908059

>>6908015
FUCK

>> No.6908062

>>6908020
Learn how to values and use refs. You're wasting your time with this.

>> No.6908067

>>6908020
now give her an education

>> No.6908120

>>6908020
It's better.

>> No.6908151

>>6906819
>Judges have to be /int/ and upwards
>disqualify lazy/bad judges
Bro, we didn't even get to vote for judges because there were so few applicants. You're expecting too much from people who volunteered out of good will.

>> No.6908154

>>6908151
Seeing how active this year's tourney was, I'd wager there would be way more applicants next year.

>> No.6908161

>>6908151
https://dad.gallery/forums/threads/493
We voted. And you know who won? Tableguy. Then he wasn’t chosen as a judge because he was ineligible, but then he hacked dingle into publishing his crits anyways. But then they were rescinded. And now Tableguy is the only one to finish all the crits for everyone’s submission and make a completed tierlist that nobody asked for. And you know who won? Tableguy.

What is this tournament!?

>> No.6908171

>>6908161
volunteer to be a judge next year and take part in the "how to fix tourney" discussion on dad
be the change you want to see
That's what I'm doing and you can do it too.

>> No.6908351

How to convince more dads to volunteer to be judges next year? Any ideas?

>> No.6908392

>>6908351
How many dads are even qualified to judge other's artwork though

>> No.6908394

>>6908351
putting them on blast and making them accountable/ named for takes you disagree with and giving them a 5 page rubrick to follow is a good idea

>> No.6908466

>>6908351
Everyone will forget the drama by next year

>> No.6908558

>>6908351
its a pretty thankless task desu and anyone who does it gets harassed/gossiped about in the threads

>> No.6908616

>>6908558
>if i become a judge people will talk about me
well i guess im signing up next year!

>> No.6908641

>>6908558
>anyone who does it gets harassed/gossiped about in the threads
That’s part of the appeal!

>> No.6908671
File: 295 KB, 1600x1065, 1697131107039517.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6908671

>>6908062
>Learn how to values and use refs

I am going to watch Sinix videos.
Can you tell me how, exactly, I use reference? If you have any tips, I'd be glad to hear them.

>> No.6908735

>>6908671
Oh wow, I really love that study!

>> No.6908821

>>6908735
Thank you. I'm trying to improve!

>> No.6908868

If your only skill is drawing women I will never respect you

>> No.6908918

>>6908868
I haven't drawn women. ever. Do you respect me?

>> No.6909033

Is it against the rules to have multiple DAD accounts if I post different stuff on each?

>> No.6909036

>>6909033
what's the point of that?

>> No.6909041

>>6908868
You'll have some manly looking women when you do.

>> No.6909059

>>6909036
i link my regular DAD profile to friends from time to time. I want to practice drawing some smut and id rather keep that stuff away from their normie eyes. I could just not post it anywhere, obviously, but having a streak to worry about has been a tremendous motivator for me

>> No.6909075

>>6909059
That sounds fine desu
I think a smut hider wouldn't even ask and there could be dozens of them already

>> No.6909190

third judge is just trolling at this point

>> No.6909192

>dad keeps purging their twitter
n please stop

>> No.6909250

i have infinite respect for gottagitgud for not trying to reclaim his streak and starting from scratch

>> No.6909258
File: 2.55 MB, 3019x3567, my_cute_wife2.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909258

Hi, /dad/s.
What are you guys working on?

>> No.6909263

>>6909258
trying to lose weight

>> No.6909275 [DELETED] 
File: 258 KB, 1920x1080, bridgman 01.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909275

>>6909263
Good luck then.
Let's draw. It distracts your mind and helps you stick to your diet. Your brain goes to a kind of "busy mode" and you don't have time to think about food.

>> No.6909278
File: 258 KB, 1920x1080, bridgman.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909278

>>6909263
Good luck then.
Let's draw. It distracts your mind and helps you stick to your diet. Your brain goes into a kind of "busy mode" and you don't have time to think about food.

>> No.6909290

>>6909250
gottagitgud has a very feminine art style i always thought....

>> No.6909300
File: 264 KB, 1510x1784, 1698455457503632.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909300

>>6909258
Zoom out and use a larger brush, lil bro.

>> No.6909307

>>6909300
Thanks for doing it too.
:3

>> No.6909331
File: 2.56 MB, 3019x3567, my_cute_wife7.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909331

>>6909300
Oh, the chin looks a bit strange in my painting.
Thanks for showing this.

>> No.6909572
File: 3.36 MB, 4032x3024, image.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909572

I find having one of those little date stamp tools is a good motivation for drawing in my sketchbook daily.

>> No.6909595
File: 328 KB, 840x859, 45eg1g.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909595

>to get a good tierlist you need a tier tourney
>to get a good tier tourney you need good judges
>to figure out who'll be a good judge you need a tierlist

>> No.6909668

>>6908671
Get actual refs shot for artists. Don't study twitter artists/anime/instagram girls.

>Sinix
Avoid that terminal NGMI. Download a good video course from the torrent thread and study it.

>> No.6909704

>>6909668
What's wrong with Sinix? I think he's helpful when rendering

>> No.6909720

>>6909668
What is your definition of making it lol

>> No.6909734
File: 3 KB, 239x304, 1681046255495732.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6909734

>>6909258
if new drawing tablet comes in (last one broke) then ill draw with that. If not then I'll animate :)
>>6906744
Yea, but I'm not trying to improve so I'll pass on studying them... regularly. I'll have my fun and accept that in 3 years I still won't be as good as (you) :)

>> No.6909775

>>6909258
flipping burgers for obese people

and studying hands

>> No.6909858

>>6909704
>What's wrong with Sinix?

>>6909837

>> No.6909909

>>6909858
>sinix is bad because i got filtered by his videos

>> No.6909929

>>6909668
>terminal NGMI
He teaches at LCAD. He's made it

>> No.6910617
File: 36 KB, 300x619, 2023.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6910617

Final results are here.

>> No.6910628
File: 38 KB, 1066x805, be44794eacf52d0194160c3c64ebaab8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6910628

>>6910617
I knew he could do it

>> No.6910647

>>6910617
rigged

>> No.6910660
File: 94 KB, 1125x1111, EWnKipoXkAA1ZiB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6910660

>>6910617
guess who's last

>> No.6910783
File: 42 KB, 335x356, 1696222164847802.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6910783

>>6910660
Not me.
I did it, bros.

>> No.6911052

>"noo, you won't get any points for creativity, because someone helped you a bit!!1! I don't care if final result looks really creative!"
Ridiculous.
Imagine if judges approached other scores in the same way:
>wait, you asked for a redline on your anatomy? Sorry bucko, but that means you get 0/10 for fundamentals, even if it looks good
>Nice composition! Sadly I've seen you talking about it in discord and getting great tips from other dads. That's automatic 0/10
>wait, wait, wait! You used a youtube tutorial for figuring out how to use your medium, didn't you?! How outrageous. 0/10 for medium mastery.

I demand justice for sekx. This idea wasn't stolen, it was freely offered (by me) and they deserve at least some creativity points.

>> No.6911064

>>6911052
This. Judges were supposed to judge the ARTWORK, not the ARTIST.

>> No.6911091
File: 50 KB, 700x525, Anna’s Light – $105.7 Million.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911091

I'll just post this 0/10, worthless painting here.

>> No.6911192

>>6911052
>>6911064
Nah. I'd rather not see the next tourney be filled with "art" like these >>6911091

>> No.6911206

>>6911052
>>6911064
The judges judged the artist because there was nothing else to judge, the submission was a shit tier "participation award" idea. You know it, I know it, everybody knows it

>> No.6911213

>>6911052
yeti in a snowstorm is a minor deviation of polar bear in a blizzard which is a tired cliche. stop patting yourself on the back for this idea. I would have been impressed if you suggested chupacabra fucking mothman in a cave at midnight of the winter solstice or something

>> No.6911261

>>6911206
>>6911192
Look, if idea was interesting and creative, they deserve at least some points in creativity score. As simple as that.
Sure, give them 0/10 for fundies and everything else, but if you say "there was nothing to judge", you're just shitposting.

That you personally don't like how pro artists (>>6911091) paint and that you don't like looking at this kind of art is meaningless. It's not a valid argument for giving sekx 0/10 in creativity.

>> No.6911270

>>6911192
>I'd rather not see the next tourney be filled with "art" like these
Even if we'll get more objective judges next year who'd give 8/10 in creativity for blank canvases, dad's doing that would still get only 2 points in total.

Unless you're F tier you have no reason to be worried about your position in tierlist or to do that.

>> No.6911271

>>6899765
Considering starting this (/beg/-tier). Wish me luck, lads.

>> No.6911280

>>6911271
Good luck, Anon! Dad helped me out a lot in the past and I think you're making a right choice here. As long as you don't spend more time shitposting and worrying about banter in those threads than actually drawing, you'll do fine.

>> No.6911284

>>6911280
Yeah. There's just too much I want to improve on for me to put off grinding reps. I'll make you proud, DADs.

>> No.6911301

How do you get more people to participate in things like tier tourneys?

>> No.6911319

>>6911301
not have them 4 times a year is good

>> No.6911330

I'll never understand why anyone would ever defend some DNF fag who submits a blank canvas just so they can get a badge that they clearly did not earn. I would've had more respect for sekx if he submitted his actual unfinished tourney entry instead of pussying out and then making the judges the scapegoat for his inability to finish.

>> No.6911345 [DELETED] 
File: 785 KB, 1209x1209, 1688753723219611.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911345

>>6909734
Okay the tablet came in. Not in the mood for drawing so this is all im gonna do today :p. bye fags

>> No.6911347

>>6911330
Nah sekx did the right thing. Judges were disrepectful. no reason to take it seriously at all

>> No.6911405

>>6911347
i wonder who is behind this post...

>> No.6911438

>>6911330
>I'll never understand why anyone would ever defend some DNF fag who submits a blank canvas
What part of "if idea was interesting and creative, they deserve at least some points in creativity score" you don't understand?

>> No.6911468

>>6911330
>I would've had more respect for sekx if he submitted his actual unfinished tourney entry instead of pussying out and then making the judges the scapegoat for his inability to finish.
Understandable. I don't have any problem at all with you disliking sekx. I have problem with judges who punished sekx with their scores for engaging with drama, instead of giving honest and objective scores like they promised to.

>> No.6911469
File: 30 KB, 720x293, c23b55fa5f9f3d129deca673a02f7b7a.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911469

>>6911438
Even if you wanted to argue for creativity for submitting a blank canvas, "polar bear in a snowstorm" is literally one of the most common art jokes in the book. Even fucking normies know about that one.

>> No.6911472

>>6911052
>>6911469
Still more creative than taking the prompt literally or painting yet another pinup girl.
I'm not saying that sekx deserves 10/10. I'm saying he doesn't deserve 0/10.

>> No.6911473

>>6911468
he didn't actually submit anything though, it was more of a vessel to espouse how annoyed he was with the judges. btw, it was one judge, who apologized and didn't mean any malice with it. His submission was just ungrateful to spit in the other judges' faces who actually gave him time of day. So yeah. Fuck em.

>> No.6911474
File: 20 KB, 482x424, 5621ca8c4068806ed6b2a224dd0e392c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911474

>>6911472
alright, sekx, you can have a 1/10 in creativity
congratulations
i hope that makes you happy
everyone is very proud of you

>> No.6911478

>>6911472
>submits literally nothing
>he doesn't deserve 0/10
nta but you are completely fucking retarded

>> No.6911479
File: 6 KB, 307x340, a.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911479

>>6911473
>he didn't actually submit anything though
Clean your screen.
>it was more of a vessel to espouse how annoyed he was with the judges
That's irrelevant for scoring his artwork.
>His submission was just ungrateful to spit in the other judges' faces who actually gave him time of day. So yeah. Fuck em.
Should anyone complaining about judges get an automatic 0/10? Because that's how retarded your "argument" sounds.

>> No.6911488

>>6911478
Are you? Actually don't answer this one, you're probably oblivious to it.
But see >>6911091 and unless you can earn that much with all your paintings, than you shove your shitty opinion up yours.

>> No.6911492

>>6911479
why didn't you stand up for buckley? Or Illilis? Shut the fuck up.

>> No.6911498

>>6911492
I didn't go through all tourney submissions. If you feel judges slighted them as well, then by all means, post their work here and explain how scores they got weren't fair.

>> No.6911499

>>6911474
>everyone is very proud of you
this, but unironically

>> No.6911501

>>6911498
are you sekx?

>> No.6911532

>>6911492
>>6911501
No, I'm Anonymous. Who am I is irrelevant to this topic, just as those other dads were irrelevant to this particular case of sekx. Scoring art should be a fairly straightforward process and it should be discussed as such. It's ridiculous that you feel the need to bring out who I am. Stop trying to start drama with those tangents, idiot.

>> No.6911535
File: 169 KB, 585x827, clothing.study-2023-10-29.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911535

>>6909258
Finally studying some clothing and its folds.
I like your portraits anon, good job.

>> No.6911566

>>6911492
buckley's drawing was horseshit and literally had nothing to do with the theme, why would anybody stand up for him?

>> No.6911585

>>6911492
>>6911566
What do you guys think about changing "Creativity/Originality" to "Creativity, Originality and Effort"? It would solve problems with submissions like sekx, but also be a way of motivating newbies like buckley or illilis for their hard work.

>> No.6911605

>>6911585
It is obscenely hard to judge actual effort, particularly with regard to beginners AND highly competent artists.

>> No.6911607
File: 38 KB, 349x642, WW2e3J-dW87-or5BbqFNdafTs4W-neK_qILujq7fUkw (1).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6911607

>>6911052

>> No.6911611

>>6911607
>no arguments
>only insults
As expected from a 4channer.

>> No.6911613

How has it been a year and I'm still shit. AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.

>> No.6911643

>>6911611
>upset judges didn't waste effort on their shitpost of an entry

>> No.6911719

>>6911643
Better! That's an actual argument, I'm proud of you anon, I was worried you're illiterate (that you can't read or write)

>> No.6911722

>>6911643
>>upset judges didn't waste effort on shitpost
Still gay move though after they bragged about handling criticism well and how objective they'll be in the Judge Applications thread.

>> No.6911729

>>6911719
why can't you just act like a normal human being

>> No.6911759

>>6911643
Other people are posting laughing at you, not just me lol. Take your meds and go lay down.

>> No.6911761

>>6911759
I fucking (You)'d my own post, but you know who it was for >>6911719
lmao I'm too old for this shit

>> No.6911779

>>6911729
why can't judges just be objective
>>6911759
>>6911761
Go touch grass, grandpa.

>> No.6911908

I am the best. I am the greatest

>> No.6911922

Tierlist of judges when?

>> No.6911989

>658
what is happening right now

>> No.6911994

>>6911989
Maybe Courtier finally gave up on dad.

>> No.6912022

>>6911994
You think so huh https://dad.gallery/submissions/219156

>> No.6912139

>>6911989
WE'RE MOVIN UP PAGES BOYS

>> No.6912223

>purging of last minute posters
Heh, you'll reap what you saw

>> No.6912225

>>6912223
echo is next

>> No.6912227

>>6912225
no me

>> No.6912396

DNF fag: "Waaaah judges are bad! I'm not gonna take this tourney seriously now. Here, have a shitpost!"
Judges: "Okay, were not gonna take your entry seriously then..."
DNF fag: >:(

>> No.6912439

>>6911472
I don't understand some of you guys' hatred of pinups. Are you salty that people actually like to look at those or what's the problem?

>> No.6912442

>>6912439
it's just lazy comfort-zoning. that's all there is to it, really.

>> No.6912453

>>6912439
I enjoy pinups a lot too but I also think that it holds back the artist from making interesting images. I was pleasantly surprised with Wuschel's entries this tourney because of how well he pulled off the differing scenes for each piece. If he made his entries just a vertical portrait of a girl staring at the camera in 3/4 view and coat it in a particular skin to match the prompt, then it would get samey and boring real fast.

>> No.6912464

>>6912453
> If he made his entries just a vertical portrait of a girl staring at the camera in 3/4 view and coat it in a particular skin to match the prompt, then it would get samey and boring real fast.
Kek, what are you on about? Ainarikia got way higher marks than Wusch
https://dad.zone/results?year=2023

>> No.6912490

>>6912464
NTA but Wuschel scored higher in creativity, what are you on about?

>> No.6912836

>>6912439
3 of the judges were women and the other 2 were faggots

>> No.6912887

why is everyone still raging about the tier judges, it was fun making everyone mald when it was going but now im starting to think people were actually upset about it this whole time

>> No.6912989

>>6912887
nah i think people are still just fucking around

>> No.6913046

Dreaming of free time then wasting what I have. Being human is a meme.

>> No.6913152

>>6912453
What's the difference between an interesting pinup and an interesting landscape? I just love pinups and think they're perfect. All the drawings in my inspiration folder are pinups without exception. It's like telling a passionate portrait photographer to start shooting trees in landscape to reach their 'true potential'. I don't get it. It just sounds like you're trying to force your taste on others.

>> No.6913395

>>6911989
Oh god no. I don't even wanna be on page 1, even more so in the higher rows. Please page 1 dads don't lose streaks

>> No.6913410

>>6913152
>What's the difference between an interesting pinup and an interesting landscape?

Interesting landscapes make million dollar movies and books.
Interesting pinups make cheap calendars and posters because they don't really scale to anything greater. That's how it is.

>> No.6913508

>>6913410
kek I hope you'll tell me how many multi million dollar movies you've inspired one day. I'm satisfied with people using my drawings as their phone background and making them smile a little.

>> No.6913516

>>6913508
this guy drawing cute anime girls when all we really want to see is retarded kids looking at washing machines baka

>> No.6913543

Threads about to die but now that I'm scrolling through the scores finally, yeah, the judge's evalutions aren't great. Urazi's had some of the most sovl, though. Drawing your cowboy oc for all of them is based and I hope they had fun, I like their pieces best of the tourney

>> No.6913922

>>6913516
Yes, what's the deal with that entry anyways. Where's the "costume" element in it? People got zeros for not following the prompt.

>> No.6913955

>>6913922
>he doesn't get it
Kek. The costumes inside the washing machine are having a party, anon.

>> No.6913964

>>6913152
Can you name a tourney participant who submitted an interesting pinup"?

>> No.6913965

>>6913964
banana

>> No.6913967

>>6913964
paganini’s harvest and cgraphite’s costume party were both pinups with storytelling elements

>> No.6914017

I miss my niggas (D)ull, leech and izoomi

>> No.6914043

The only Judge that matters is Me.