[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique


View post   

File: 2.45 MB, 3024x4032, 667722B9-5DCD-4DB0-8E3E-57816B498A4C.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897021 No.4897021 [Reply] [Original]

[NO HARSH AND OFFENSIVE REPLIES]

>> No.4897067

Try to use 3d forms instead of 2D shapes,you'll get better results.

>> No.4897069
File: 15 KB, 190x266, 6A880C22-436E-44C1-8B0D-22ABCADD95DC.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897069

>>4897021
> [NO HARSH AND OFFENSIVE REPLIES]

inb4 harsh and offensive replies

>> No.4897085

>>4897067
this

Looking up Morgana's official art you can clearly see his head is more spherical than what you drew. 3d is important even in cartoons and anime where it might "seem" flat

>> No.4897087

>>4897021
Cute, you should post this in /beg and I'll give you a critique there

>> No.4897089

>>4897087
But I'm not a beginner?

>> No.4897091

>>4897021
Cute, but please post in /beg/ like everyone else instead of making individual threads from now on.

>> No.4897094

>>4897089
if this is your best after drawing for several years or whatever you are still in practice a beginner. delete this thread so you can get better crit in /beg/

>> No.4897095

>>4897089
Ok you're right my bad. I mistook your stylistic choices for mistakes. You might want to work on your line quality and proportions but other then that you did a great job my friend. I look forward to seeing more work from you

>> No.4897096
File: 43 KB, 700x503, 1578011460428.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897096

>>4897021
>NO HARSH AND OFFENSIVE REPLIES
>posts on 4chan

>> No.4897097

>>4897095
Thank you!

>> No.4897099

>>4897089
>>4897095

This is awful bait, stop samefagging

>> No.4897100

>>4897096
>>4897069
This is the most supportive board on the site. Nobody will make fun of him if he's trying his best to improve

>> No.4897102
File: 159 KB, 346x360, 1588381183786.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897102

>>4897089
The Dunning Kruger effect is strong with this one

>> No.4897104
File: 520 KB, 2748x1662, Screen Shot 2020-09-27 at 12.14.55 PM.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897104

>>4897099
Im not samefagging...

>> No.4897106

>>4897104
If this is serious you should give up. Fuck off to beg and don’t come out for 7 years

>> No.4897107

>>4897104
How long have you been drawing, OP?

>> No.4897109

>>4897021
Say not bad! all you have to improve is Lineart, perspective, form, colors, composition.. oh

>> No.4897110

>>4897104
>If this is serious you should give up. Fuck off to beg and don’t come out for 7 years
If this is serious you should give up. Fuck off to beg and don’t come out for 7 years

>> No.4897112

>>4897107
All my life xD

>> No.4897113
File: 299 KB, 732x464, 1601090222992.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897113

AHHHHHHHHHH my 8 year old son is better than you nigger!

>> No.4897118

>>4897112
how old are you?

>> No.4897119
File: 15 KB, 512x194, darules.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897119

>>4897096
To be fair...

>> No.4897120

>>4897106
>How long have you been drawing, OP?
Not Op, you actually have absolutely no reading comprehension skills if you couldnt figure that out by looking at the picture attached

>> No.4897122

>>4897120
Oops meant to respond to >>4897107

>> No.4897124

>>4897120
there's definitely people who stagnant from focusing on stylization for literal years and don't draw from reference or practice weaknesses. its very pervasive in anime and cartoon fanartists like OP

>> No.4897125

>>4897119
There’s also a global “no racism outside of /b/‘ rule

>> No.4897129

>>4897125
It's not racist to call a nigger a nigger
>>4897124
Yeah and Op clearly has no interest in getting better

>> No.4897132
File: 47 KB, 694x678, image0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897132

I've been here for years, and I forgot that existed. Mostly I give really sound advice, but flat out claiming you're not a beginner? naaaah, just because you've drawn all your life doesnt mean you did it right. Go read Perspective Made Easy, or take Eric Olson's course, see you in half a year

>> No.4897133

>>4897122
What are you talking about, you fucking retard?

>> No.4897134

>>4897021
Not bad. The linework is a bit scratchy. Could use more shading too. The shapes feel like they lean too much. Practice ellipses and stable linework.

>> No.4897135

>>4897129
>Yeah and Op clearly has no interest in getting better
i wouldn't say that exactly, just that communities that surround fanart are very hugbox-y. i think him posting here at least is a step in the right direction provided he actually take what little actual criticism he got into consideration

>> No.4897142
File: 13 KB, 193x258, ECD53217-E40B-4C51-9005-60A31511AD2A.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897142

>>4897134
>>4897109
>>4897095
>>4897091

>NOT BAD OP KEEP UP DER GOOD WERK time to eat my own shit with my bare hands

>> No.4897143

>>4897133
Oh right, I tagged the wrong post.
Good thing my post asked "OP" and not the anon I replied to then.

>> No.4897144
File: 827 KB, 1099x678, unknown.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897144

>>4897134
Don't you lie to him..

>> No.4897146

>>4897133
>fucking retard
This is coming from the person falsely accusing others of samefagging. Go be a nigger somewhere else

>> No.4897149

>>4897142
jealous ngmi retarded crab

>> No.4897154

>>4897146
You are literally never gonna make it, I urge you to continue trying so I can prove it. Waste your life bro

>> No.4897155
File: 101 KB, 1080x507, IMG_20200927_183027.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897155

>>4897146
I didn't accuse anyone of samefagging, mongoloid.

>> No.4897157
File: 23 KB, 224x224, 99DE30BB-1034-4B99-91E8-E6668790E8FB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4897157

>>4897149
>jealous

>> No.4897168

How exactly do I post on /beg/?

>> No.4897171

>>4897168
>boards.4chan.org/ic/catalog > ctrl+F "/beg/"
>open thread
>???
>profit

>> No.4897174

>>4897168
Search ‘beg/, post on it

>> No.4899479

>>4897021
here's a tip for you
stop trying to make artists your audience

>> No.4899481

>>4899479
nice bump, faggot

>> No.4899517

>>4899479
Nigga nobody wants this shite

>> No.4899519

>>4897089
Of course you're not.

>> No.4899605

>>4897142
did you not even read what you were replying to?

>> No.4899609

>>4899605
Nice bump, faggot

>> No.4899618

This is just bad I'm sorry, go learn the fundamentals like basic forms/shapes, volume, perspective, just everything. This isn't about being harsh, I don't know how old you are but it looks like a small child drew this and if you are young well it shows and that's fine but if you're older you simply are skipping every single step necessary to make a good drawing even for cartooning. There is nothing wrong with going back to the basics.

>> No.4901130
File: 652 KB, 643x595, ORAL.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4901130

>>4897021
I don't like the appeal of the design; the inconsistency in form (mostly the face) just looks off-putting. The tail looks like it's growing out of the left leg, and not from where it's typically expected. There's no depth, no shading, and the character is leaning way too far to the left-- which wouldn't be as much of a problem, but thanks to the lack of depth, it's more unusual than stylistic for a pose choice.

>> No.4901151
File: 96 KB, 640x619, 1541590570843.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4901151

>>4897021
>[NO HARSH AND OFFENSIVE REPLIES]

>> No.4901251

>>4901130
>taking this piece seriously enough to actually critique it

Why bother?

>> No.4901263
File: 567 KB, 633x605, HONGREE.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4901263

>>4901251
I sometimes got nothing else going on
It's also fun to share images like this

>> No.4902540

>>4897021
form and proportions, maybe some perspective.Dyb