[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

View post   
File: 91 KB, 1280x720, yoshinari-kou.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4727839 No.4727839 [Reply] [Original]

Is this good animation or bad animation? And why?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3uvuffWLDU

>> No.4727894

>>4727839
remove the music then you might get a reply

>> No.4727899

>>4727894
Or you could click "mute", but I guess that's asking too much from a brainlet like yourself.

>> No.4727901

>>4727899
yeah ask me to watch then make me do more work. you should just get it right the first time and start creating for others instead of yourself.

>> No.4727916

>>4727901
No, you're a brainlet. Enough said.

>> No.4727918

>>4727901
>make me do more work
replying this takes longer than just clicking the mute button, retard

hby just stfu if you have nothing of value to say

>> No.4728168

>>4727899
video doesn't start muted, the auditory damage that the first few seconds cause is going to convince everyone to not reply to this shitty thread

>> No.4728483

>>4727839
Compared to what?

>> No.4728548

Its okay. Most of it is clear and I can tell whats going on. The tentacles and robot being stripped apart was really cool. The hand scene was too choppy. The part at the end with the robot parts ejecting the jet needed more easing.

>> No.4728965

>>4727839
Yes.

>> No.4730014

>>4728483
??

>> No.4730185

>>4730014
What are you comparing it to?

>> No.4730282 [DELETED] 

>>4727839

>> No.4730569 [DELETED] 

>>4727839

>> No.4730771

>>4727839
Is Muv-Luv worth playing/reading?

>> No.4730834

its fine, better than what i can do. i don’t like the way it’s colored, too soft and glowy and sterile for my tastes.

>> No.4730869

>>4730185
The entirety of all animations producted by the human race until now.

>> No.4730928

>>4730834
Are you sure?

>> No.4730963
File: 389 KB, 1280x1024, 49796350_p0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4730963

>>4730771
Not Op, but yes, MLA is a masterpiece. Make sure to read muv-luv before reading MLA.

Meiya is best gril

>> No.4730965

>>4730963
>I love cannibal cookouts too

>> No.4730968

Consider killing yourself you defensive, confrontational faggot. Maybe exhibit some independent thought before you make a pointless thread asking other people to think for you.

>> No.4730987

>>4727839
pars of it are good, but there are parts that are bad or really bad, like the shaking hands parts wtf. none of it is particularly exceptional though.

>> No.4731042
File: 1.44 MB, 1020x590, Muvluv Alternative - Yoshinari Kou.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4731042

>>4730987
>none of it is particularly exceptional though
this is.

>> No.4731052

>>4727839
What does /ic/ think of Yoshinari Kou's animation in general?

https://youtu.be/Wkw7WClIt_A

>> No.4731076

>>4727839
so it looks nice. it's flashy. all that stuff. But as an animation, it looks stiff and very claustrophobic. there really aren't any establishing shots. I'd compare this to a fight scene in Alien vs Predator. Everything is 2 inches away from the camera. It feels very rigid too.

>> No.4731221

>>4731052
Holy shit

>> No.4731227

>>4731042
That’s pretty good especially if this is just tv animation

>> No.4731241
File: 838 KB, 800x600, DmVw50k.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4731241

>>4731227
It's visual novel animation. It's actually rare for them to get animation at all, usually they're just 100% static character CGs against static backgrounds (see pic).

Muv-Luv Alternative is one of the biggest, most ambitious VNs ever made, and they managed to get Yoshinari Kou (who's a legendary animator in the anime industry) to do some of the cutscenes and parts of the OPs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9r4vaBr806E

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkXuCESlWsY

>> No.4731242

>>4731241
>>4731052
There’s a reason his little brother is more famous.

>> No.4731244

>>4731242
Yes, because he worked with Gainax and Trigger, which has a larger, and exponentially more retarded fandom.

Kou is objectively the better artist and animator though. See >>4731052

>> No.4731368

>>4731042
nice

>> No.4731419

>>4727839
looks like dogshit

>> No.4731461

>>4730869
Then it's an astonishing piece of animation easily in the top 0.01%

>> No.4731524

>>4731419
retard

>> No.4731586

>>4727839
of course

>> No.4731636

>>4727839
this is fucking awesome

>> No.4731639

>>4731419
fuck off

>> No.4731702 [DELETED] 

>>4727839

>> No.4731793 [DELETED] 

>>4727839

>> No.4731856

>>4730771
Seconding this question.

>> No.4732510

>>4727839
>kou

awkward overanimated stilted bullshit. everything he makes is the animated equivalent of grasping jello with chopsticks.

>> No.4732548

>>4727839
Pros:
-good amount of detail
-some bits and pieces of dramatic action like the sepuku sword having bits and pieces of viscera sliding along the blade
Cons:
-looks like rotoscoped action figures most of the time
-a LOT of repeating animation
-a lot of nothing happening
-no dramatic narrative shown therefore no reason to care
-very muddy(could be the video quality itself, maybe the original looked better)
-the action choreography is bland as shit

2.5/10

>> No.4732703

>>4727839
I've seen worse.

>> No.4733314

>>4727894
the music is based

>> No.4733321

>>4727839
that shading is so muddy it's difficult to see what the fuck is going on
when you animate mecha you either go cell shading or don't do shading at all

>> No.4733325

>>4727839
why didnt they just shoot the big blaster from the start why the purple mech have to die

>> No.4733352

>>4733325
Because it was charging up. Purple was basically acting as a decoy.

There's a lot more to it, but not worth explaining. You either play the VN or you don't.

>> No.4733371

>>4731042
absolute shit tier animation, why are people pretending it's good?

>> No.4733403

>>4727839
Not particularly impressive. Jittery and reuses shots, no fluidity or interesting direction to make up for it

>> No.4733448

>>4732548
>a LOT of repeating animation
>no dramatic narrative shown therefore no reason to care
Because the shots aren't shown back-to-back like that in the game. They're spread out over half an hour or so.

>> No.4733479

>>4727839
There is barely any animation in there. Probably 20 seconds out of 2 minutes. I like the artstyle tho.

>> No.4733506

>>4733479
>There is barely any animation in there
wat

>> No.4734521

>>4727839
Not like anyone on /ic/ could do better.

>> No.4735936 [DELETED] 

>>4734521
this.

>> No.4739507

>>4734521
Really?

>> No.4739719

>>4727839
Kou is incredibly talented but the coloring/postprocessing on his Muv Luv work (anf often in his other stuff too) makes it look kinda weird.

>> No.4740375
File: 111 KB, 723x833, c09oze_vqaair0c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4740375

>yoshinari kou

>> No.4742216

>>4740375
That doesn't look like anime...

>> No.4745737

>>4727839
It's good.

>> No.4747276

Thoughts on Muv Luv?

>> No.4747310

>>4747276
Why do you keep bumping the fucking thread every time it hits page 10?

>> No.4747311

>>4747310
Why are you mad?

>> No.4748416

>>4727839
Yes

>> No.4748442

>>4740375
Is this a good picture?

>> No.4749577

>>4740375
Nice.

>> No.4751450
File: 1.25 MB, 3000x3000, b9a913e61c1fa61a2ff3b0cb719f60eb470b245092ff940f3078b05b14feb038.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4751450

>>4740375
>yoshinari kou

>> No.4754151
File: 1.25 MB, 1000x1000, f0e1de77e9b421f57073ce84532a5fe68ad35dcd0cc119c9d0df90c03deb7361.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4754151

>>4740375
>yoshinari kou

>> No.4757490
File: 1.91 MB, 640x480, e9e56f444fb1a6d299db53205e740244.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4757490

>>4740375
>yoshinari kou

>> No.4759922

Yoshinari Kou

>> No.4762088

>>4757490
is this sasuga?

>> No.4762264

>>4727839
Why is Mecha animation so hard?

>> No.4763571

>>4751450
i'm so horny

>> No.4766315

>>4727839
Why indeed.