[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

File: 1.73 MB, 320x180, Naruto-quality-3.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:34:31 2020 No.4419649 [Reply] [Original]

Was this bad animation ?

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:36:12 2020 No.4419654 No

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:37:50 2020 No.4419655 Yes

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:41:00 2020 No.4419660 >>4419649 It's good creative animation but it didn't fit the tone of the show and the serious climactic feeling of the fight.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:50:44 2020 No.4419676 >>4419649 It’s stylish, but I >>4419660 has a point

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 15:55:42 2020 No.4419687 >>4419660 this, very good point, from an aniation standpoint is not bad, but its very fucking strange

Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:09:56 2020 No.4419717 [DELETED]

>>4419649
I personally think so. But on a non technical note, I feel like there is a lot to be said about how well known and memorable it is. There are certainly thousands upon thousands of instances of “better” animation that most people don’t know about or even care to know about, but this particular battle is cemented into so many people’s memory.

Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:17:32 2020 No.4419736

>>4419649
I personally like it. But on a non-technical note, I feel like there is a lot to be said about how well known and memorable it is. There are certainly thousands upon thousands of instances of “better” animation that most people don’t know about or even care to know about, but this particular battle is cemented into so many people’s memory whether they like it or not, which I feel makes it an artistic success.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:19:57 2020 No.4419741 >>4419649 I like it, but something as insipid as Naruto doesn't mix well with this.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:30:01 2020 No.4419764 >>4419649 Is that suppose air resistance or inertia deforming his face? He don't seems to be moving that fast for it either.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:36:15 2020 No.4419772 >>4419649 When you fail at Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann action scene.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:39:05 2020 No.4419780 File: 12 KB, 236x261, B72D578B-1F3A-45CF-B1FB-0AD31FFA85E6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>4419649 U retarded? It was fantastic animation

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:56:07 2020 No.4419809 File: 22 KB, 480x360, hqdefault (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>4419736 By your logic then pic related is also an artistic success.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:59:06 2020 No.4419815 >>4419809 unironically is

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 16:59:34 2020 No.4419817 >>4419809 To be faiiirrrr, the woman got to cash in.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 17:04:15 2020 No.4419825 >>4419809 it's great art if you take account it's meta-narrative.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 17:48:01 2020 No.4419888 >>4419649 No, it's one of the better animated fights of the series just the artstyle was really out of place.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 23:12:03 2020 No.4420399 >>4419649 Stretches like that work for an inbetween frame but having that many frames in a row is NOT the way you so motion

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 23:21:35 2020 No.4420406 >>4419649 No.

>>	Anonymous Wed Mar 11 23:29:37 2020 No.4420413 >>4419660 This. It's like ifyou were watching a Dragon Ball Z episode and suddenly https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EKTw50Uf8M Pretty cool, pretty funny but that's not what was expected.

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 00:09:43 2020 No.4420468 >>4420413 except that would be fucking epic dude

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 00:26:24 2020 No.4420492 >>4420468 Can't deny that.

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 00:37:48 2020 No.4420509 >>4419809 What's it's look like before?

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 03:49:55 2020 No.4420701 >>4419649 yes

Anonymous Thu Mar 12 07:52:50 2020 No.4420921

>>4419809
it is because you remembered it and made people talk about it again

the old one was a good looking jesus painting but this ones memorable for how terrible it is
its like certain deviantart pictures that are stuck in the minds of thousands of people

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 08:20:34 2020 No.4420938 >>4419649 Yes, definitely. That deformation adds absolutely nothing to the dynamicity of the scene. No-thing. It just makes it look weird af.

>>	Anonymous Thu Mar 12 11:07:43 2020 No.4421152 File: 223 KB, 700x1072, Elias_Garcia_Martinez_-_Ecce_Homo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>4420509

>>	Anonymous Fri Mar 13 06:21:56 2020 No.4423030 >>4419660 This anon gets it. Fantastic animation but didn't fit the already well established style that naruto had. Also the choreography was pretty bad at some points.

>>	Anonymous Fri Mar 13 13:32:08 2020 No.4423475 >>4419736 >it became an epic maymay thats why i like it

Anonymous Sat Mar 14 17:57:53 2020 No.4426084

>>4419764
To be able to transfer that much energy into the ground with only his muscles and the weight of his body he would have had to have moved at a speed faster than the threshold to combust from atmospheric friction. rather than speed up the animation they should have given more visual cues for how fast he was actually moving

Anonymous Sun Mar 15 20:56:00 2020 No.4428192

>>4419649
I'd argue no. it's creative and kinda funny that it just shows up, but I never really thought that it was ever particularly well animated
the way it's animated makes him look like his face is made outta rubber. sure, it's pretty damned fluid, but the character's model shouldn't be to this degree

on top of that, this is supposed to be a fairly serious scene. just throwing this in takes away from the tension

>>	Anonymous Sun Mar 15 22:35:56 2020 No.4428312 >>4419649 A lot of fucked key frames in this. I should know, I struggle with that problem too.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 02:35:21 2020 No.4428615 >>4423475 >implying that's not the reason people like most things It's memorable, so the artists did 'succeed' in regards to having a legacy. More than one can say for the average /beg/.

Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:07:02 2020 No.4429016 [DELETED]

>>4419649
>a cut made to capture the viewer attention captures the viewers attention
THIS IS BAD ANIMATION!
I swear the hardcore otaku are a bunch of worthless retards.
They'll do anything to bitch about production or animation and fight over it for years.

Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:09:33 2020 No.4429021

>>4419649
>a cut made to capture the viewer attention captures the viewers attention
>THIS IS BAD ANIMATION!
I swear the hardcore otaku are a bunch of worthless retards.
They'll do anything to bitch about production or animation and fight over it for years.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:19:57 2020 No.4429032 >>4429021 >>4428615 infamously memorable, prefer to die anonymous than to die with my name signed on a turd for everyone to see

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:37:51 2020 No.4429053 File: 2.19 MB, 854x480, painnaru.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:42:10 2020 No.4429064

>>4429032
99% of people don't even know who worked on that scene and that's a good thing because they would forever link him with that one scene. Same with videogame fags who blame one person for everything wrong about a game.
https://www.sakugabooru.com/post?tags=shingo_yamashita
He worked on all of this and more but of course noone ever mantions those because idiots don't know who actually works on what.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 12:46:59 2020 No.4429070 its good for looney tunes

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 13:32:27 2020 No.4429120 >>4429053 Why he slide on ground, why he fly through forest yet need to flip around it? What is happening?

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 13:39:06 2020 No.4429129 >>4429032 >turd go back to youtube or reddit or wherever you don't belong on an art board if you gonna bring that otaku contrarian bullshit. Use your head or go back to mommy.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 13:46:41 2020 No.4429138 >>4429120 It's an anime with people basicly having super powers. But i guess anything that isn't 100% realistic is shit.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 13:48:17 2020 No.4429142 >>4429138 Sliding on water sure, but if you can fly why do it around branches and trees?

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 17:37:11 2020 No.4429471 >>4429142 I don't think they can fly, I think its just supposed to be movement so fast you don't see them touching the trees/ground at their fastest but its very confused and badly done in that scene.

>>	Anonymous Mon Mar 16 18:52:49 2020 No.4429589 >>4429053 lmao what fucking a piece of trash

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]