[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

View post   
>> No.4306789
File: 32 KB, 367x479, 1428766299271.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4306789

>>4306783
Imagine a movie that copied real life 100%

>> No.4307041
File: 24 KB, 606x406, Jean Renoir 3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307041

>>4306789
Imagine taking a hypothetical situation intended to be a metaphorical commentary on the nature of realism 100% seriously

>> No.4307285
File: 112 KB, 681x1024, Head_of_Boxer_of_Quirinal_(Mys_from_Taranto).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307285

>>4307041
So how many % of seriously do you expect us to take that quote ?

>> No.4307286

>>4307041
Imagine being a faggot like OP

>> No.4307287

>>4306789
Even before the camera was invented, realism painters realized that reality was not really desirable.

>> No.4307290

>>4307287
So perfect realism never happened ?

>> No.4307292

>>4307290
I don't know. Did it?

>> No.4307293

>>4307290
It happened. It just wasn't desirable.

>> No.4307295

>>4306783
I know this is a meme, but you do undestand that an example of what he's talking about is the "photocopiers" who spend 100s of hours copying a photography of an eye, a person, etc. the example you called "souless" is fantasy ,fictional character, and completely original picture that only existed in the artist's mind.

It doesn't fall into what he's describing.

>> No.4307417

>>4307295
STFU faggot, It looks extremelly generic muh sakimichan clone garbage.

muh realistic anime whore.
It's souless trash

>> No.4307423

>>4307417
I didn't say it wasn't shit, I just said that what the "art decadence" picture is describing isn't what op (maybe you) said.

pyw faggot

>> No.4307425

>>4307423
It applies to every art form retard.

look up videogames by example.

>> No.4307431

>>4306783
That looks nothing like Marianne. There's artistic license, and there's this.

>> No.4307433

>>4307425
yes it applies to all art forms, I never said it didn't, that still doesn't mean that what the picture is describing is what you are trying to prove.

This isn't imitating anything in nature https://twitter.com/SilversTweet/status/1216509054115307521 and it also isn't realistic it's complete fantasy and fiction.

pyw

>> No.4307436

>>4307433
It looks souless and bland, like every fucking piece that tries to be realistic.

>but It's not 100% photorealism, is not realistic
kys nigger

>> No.4307449

>>4307436
That's your opinion, but still the "art decadence" isn't talking about that, you are completely misrepresenting what he's talking about to further your own opinions about detailed/realistic paintings because of your own insecurities, that's why I'm guessing you do "stylized" work.

so you aren't going to post your work for me to make fun of you or you won't because you know it's shit?

>> No.4307453
File: 103 KB, 965x827, EOIGwZYX4AA3YV6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307453

>>4307449
kek loser, pic related has more soul than your overpolished fantasy and sakimichan clone or realistic old master trash.

stay mad faggot.

>> No.4307455

>>4307453
That isn't your work, post your real work for me to make fun of you

>> No.4307456

>>4307455
kek, kys loser.

>> No.4307457

>>4307453
Gee I wonder why every time people say soul its a child's drawing. Could you possibly be retarded maybe hmm

>> No.4307459

>>4307456
Just proved my point, you know your art is shit that's why you have to resort to this.

Kys ngmi

>> No.4307462

>>4307457
because children art still have the inocence and pureness of being a small children.

realistic work is bitter cope from retards who are too bitter to enjoy life and need to pay the food of their wife kid and pay taxes for feed niggers.

children don't care about their work being shit, that's why is pure and fun.

>>4307459
stay mad, loser bitch.

>> No.4307468

>>4307462
"loser" real projecting right there. Post your work I really want to see the humiliating shit you call art.

>> No.4307469

>>4307462
Soul is what retards say when they cant draw well enough to understand what makes a drawing appealing from a technical level, the art appraisal equivalent of making a bunch of thick outlines and letting your eyes only follow the most appealing ones

>> No.4307473
File: 69 KB, 850x400, quote-remark-to-herbert-read-while-at-a-children-s-art-exhibition-when-i-was-the-age-of-these-pablo-picasso-309148.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307473

>>4307468
I don't draw.

;)

>>4307469
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XJbmJT5DMyI

explain how this shit has more soul than profesional anime even while being total garbage?

>> No.4307477

>>4307473
pyw

>> No.4307480

>>4307473
(also comparing yourself to Picasso when you don't have a single drop of talent and you can't draw like Raphael and never will) pyw

>> No.4307482

>>4306783
>a less funny ripoff of nyan neko sugar girls
>soul

>> No.4307486
File: 263 KB, 2176x864, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307486

>>4307477
>>4307480
;)

>> No.4307487

>>4307473
Its a magnified parody of an genre taking the lowest common denominator features from that genre and delivering then with in a blunt ham fisted simplistic art style which appeals to people without a sophisticated palette. The art equivalent of a 25 cent hard candy.
Also
>explain how my subjective opinion using this term I won't quantify doesn't compare evenly between this specific video and a massively general and undefined second variable

What a fucking awful post you made there

>> No.4307489

>>4307487
>retard can't understand humour
ok bitch retard.

>> No.4307490

>>4307486
I'm pretty sure I made it clear it was me when I said "also", are you retarded? kek is that your work?

>> No.4307491

>>4307489
>b-bro I was pretending to be retarded
>it was a j-joke

:^)

>> No.4307493

>>4307490
has soul.

>but muh glorified art study of some life still whore
lmao, keep drawing your garbage real life studies retard.

>> No.4307494

>>4307491
>he thinks people watch a parody genre expecting to be serious shit
amazing low IQ.

;)

>> No.4307502
File: 1.88 MB, 1000x1286, Personal 1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307502

>>4307493
I've never drawn a study and have yet to study fundamentals.

>> No.4307503

>>4307502
>post a very generic fantasy painting
lmao, why every realistic piece is souless generic trash.

>> No.4307504

>>4307494
Back pedal more nigger ill bust your fucking teeth out cunt bitch

>> No.4307506

>>4307503
It's my first personal "painting" ever, thank you for your crit, I think I will be doing ok in a few years when I get better, good luck with your "soul" 5 year old drawings anon.

>> No.4307510

>>4307504
post some soulfull realistic piece then.

>>4307506
the issue with realistic pieces is that for being realistic they end up looking like all the other realistic pieces (AKA souless).

>> No.4307519

>>4307510
anon the last person I will take advice from is a retard who can't draw, there's nothing more souless than a colorless , bad copy of an anime girl of someone who clearly doesn't know how to draw.

There's people in here that draw things with "soul" that only use paint black and white pixel art because that's their style and they already know how to draw, but your shit is far from being that.

>> No.4307522

>>4307417
muh muh muh

>> No.4307525
File: 8 KB, 250x247, 1520455231828.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307525

>>4307519
>retard thinks I was serious when I posted a shitty waifu made on paint

>>4307522
STFU faggot realist loser.

enjoy griding the same generic anatomy every realistic piece has.

>but I'll make money
kek, I have a real job to work in something like art, like every art major and graphic design major working at mc donalds.

;)

>> No.4307533
File: 3 KB, 348x69, smile.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4307533

>>4307525
>>retard thinks I was serious when I posted a shitty waifu made on paint
Sure anon pretend that isn't the best you can do maybe that will help you sleep at night.

Also don't worry anon I'm doing just fine for a 20 year old, maybe when you are 30 you'll be able to draw finally :)

>> No.4307536

>>4307533
>oh no, you can't have a real job
>oh no, you need to waste your life trying to make money from drawing
lmao nigger, I make more by just solving IT shit to old boomers with money in some shitty company than whatever garbage you dream of making.

enjoy being poor drawing realistic pieces, whatever, lol.

>> No.4307541

>>4307536
Oh anon you are wrong, the realistic piece is for me P E R S O N A L, I make stylize drawings that I sell in fiverr which take 10 min to make.

Don't worry anon I'm also planning to start making nsfw art, so when I'm as old as you I will be making much more than I am rn :) guess those are the benefits of actually knowing how to draw.

>> No.4307567

>>4307536
>>4307541
If both of you actually respected what you were doing you wouldn't be doing this dumb internet fight. You both look like dumbasses.

>> No.4307594

>>4307567
I just asked him a simple question, that retard is the one who misrepresented the picture " art decadence" and insulted everyone he disagreed with, I just wanted to prove my point that he can't draw therefore his opinion is meaningless.