[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

View post   
File: 30 KB, 339x337, e1461ed5625d630c6cffe1ff9a83fcb5c129f42941c78da682d6638b2dce8d2b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4028197 No.4028197 [Reply] [Original]

Who is the weakest "professional" artist you have ever seen? The one that makes you wonder how he/she got a job on the industry.

>> No.4028199
File: 81 KB, 780x577, kek_punch_man.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4028199

>>4028197
Although desu, this is also proof that with story and emotions, you can make it even if your art is shit.

>> No.4028200

>>4028197
I think Loish gets way too much credit for doing sameface bighead portraits, she got a job on Horizon Zero Dawn

>> No.4028210

>>4028200
I agree on the sameface thing, though her work on horizon was good imo, her problem is really easy to fix, but probably she doesnt care, and thats what pisses me.

>> No.4028212

>>4028197
The only true answer is Robert Liefeld. >>4028199 ONE somehow feels like he mastered the fundamentals of manga itself so I don't consider him weak. He's good at everything besides anatomy. Literally the only thing he lacks, because even the figures and gestures are good enough to convey fights better than most manga.

>> No.4028974

>>4028212
Dude..what?

>> No.4028990

>>4028197
There are people in capeshit that are just atrocious and it was before the PC shitstorm so I have no idea how they got in. It isn't possible that they were chosen among other professionals.
See Rob Liefeld, Frank Miller, etc.
>>4028200
I'm sure Loish is a more complete artist than she looks. All these people are probably better than they look. I've seen people I thought were 100% sameface one trick ponies deliver good art and get 1/10 the likes.

>> No.4029008

>>4028197
Sakimichan draws the most boring and safe bullshit on the planet yet probably makes 10s of thousands of dollars on Patreon

>> No.4029021

I was kind of surprised at how shitty some MTG artists are. Made me hopeful that can make it.

>> No.4029023
File: 260 KB, 710x1094, dark-knight-returns.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4029023

>>4028990
>Frank Miller

Subtle.

>> No.4029028

>>4029021
Networking can really make up for a lot

>> No.4029052

>>4028197
Everyone who works on Steven universe

>> No.4029072

>>4028199
most mangakas

>> No.4029107

>>4028212
He does not just lack anatomy, he can't draw at all. Idk why people defend ONE's trash scribbles just because they like his stories and writing That only makes him a good writer. His stuff is better in the hands of competent artists.

>> No.4029116

>>4029107
ONE is bad on a technical level but incredibly skilled on a storytelling level. Comics aren't just about the quality of the art inside the panels, but the way the panels and pages are composed and ONE is very talented at that

>> No.4029138

>>4029116
That's fair, he's a great writer and maybe let's say visual communicator. I like his work, I just don't like looking at it. When he lends his storytelling and compositional skills to artists that's when the real magic happens.

>> No.4029184

>>4028990
>I've seen people I thought were 100% sameface one trick ponies deliver good art and get 1/10 the likes.


thats really sad and could explain a lot of samefacer with high quality work, money ruins it all.

>> No.4029186

>>4028212
>The only true answer is Robert Liefeld.
facts

>> No.4029204
File: 685 KB, 1200x953, 1560391432200.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4029204

>>4029184
Andrew K Mar draws almost exclusively the same fantasy thot over and over, it's tasteful art but it's always the same. Occasionally he draws some really cool shit and he's clearly way more imaginative that it looks from his instagram.

>> No.4029215

>>4028197
-Marc Brunet
-Trent Kaniuga
-Ruan Jia
-Anthony Jones

>> No.4029218

>>4029023
This looks like shit.

>> No.4029249

Dave.xp all his art is pretty much the same thing over and over ahai

>> No.4029255

>>4029215
>Marc Brunet

samefaces, decent technique

>Trent Kariuga

game aimed art, generic but not bad technically, just infinitely boring.

>ruan jia

dont know they

>anthony Jones

not bad, just repetitive as fuck

it seems you judge under the fact they recycle themselves over and over, I can agree on that, but its hard not to when you are working for (((the industry)))

>> No.4029259

>>4028197
most mangakas now days

>> No.4029501

>>4029218
Subtle.