[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]

2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

File: 87 KB, 864x483, golbinedit1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Thu Feb 14 21:55:34 2019 No.3810732 [Reply] [Original]

hello ic
i was playing with photoshop today and just wanted to share

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 21:55:57 2019 No.3810733 File: 45 KB, 620x785, tubedit1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 21:56:41 2019 No.3810734 File: 897 KB, 800x811, suckedit1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 21:57:19 2019 No.3810735 File: 188 KB, 935x1392, oceanedit1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 22:26:54 2019 No.3810770 >>3810732 this shit is not art

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 22:56:54 2019 No.3810804 >>3810770 says you, i think it's fun why dont you post your art

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:01:21 2019 No.3810811 File: 176 KB, 1200x671, sidebyside.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] heres a side by side to show the changes

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:04:15 2019 No.3810816 Dom't you have any actual drawings? We can't really give criticism on these shitty photo edits.

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:05:26 2019 No.3810817 >>3810816 brainlet post, if you can give criticism on a drawing you can give criticism on an edit. why not start with this one >>3810811

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:09:56 2019 No.3810822 >>3810817 Okay they're shit

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:11:34 2019 No.3810824 >>3810817 I asked you a question, have you drawn anything or haven't you?

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:12:40 2019 No.3810827 >>3810822 not really a criticism more of a lazy opinion >>3810824 yes but what does that have to do with anything

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:15:34 2019 No.3810830 >>3810827 >yes but what does that have to do with anything Mind posting it then? This IS an art board.

Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:22:41 2019 No.3810843

>>3810827
>not really a criticism more of a lazy opinion
Not as lazy as your editing attempts.
Do you actually think these look good? I can tell you're young, do yourself a favor and don't waste your time on this shit or at least watch tutorials first if image manipulation is something you're genuinely interested in. This just looks low effort and unappealing.

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:26:09 2019 No.3810848 >>3810830 >>3810843 you know its okay to not like something without being a massive cunt about it. post your art

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:35:45 2019 No.3810855 >>3810732 >>3810733 >>3810734 >>3810735 fuck off with this trash, it's not art and it sure as hell isn't good

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:37:01 2019 No.3810857 >>3810848 Sure I'll gladly post some art after you do

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:43:35 2019 No.3810863 >>3810732 >>3810848 Hey OP, please delete this thread :) Thank you for your time

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:46:58 2019 No.3810866 >hey can i get some crit >REEEEEE REEEEE FUCK YOU OP REEE some things never change

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:51:01 2019 No.3810869 >>3810857 because you want to see if im good first so you can bitch out if im better than you besides, ive already posted 4 things ive made in this thread

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:52:01 2019 No.3810871 >>3810866 go ahead and crit him random /ic/ poster, you're not OP at all

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:53:06 2019 No.3810873 >>3810871 it was me actually, how come youre so incapable of just giving some simple tips? if its more effort to help someone than insult them, isnt it more effort to insult them than say nothing at all? you just get off on being rude?

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:55:42 2019 No.3810874 >>3810873 it takes 5 seconds to tell you to fuck off cunt than it would to critique something that isn't even art and would be more of a photoshop critique than anything. fuck off cunt

>>	Anonymous Thu Feb 14 23:57:44 2019 No.3810876 >>3810874 i mean, it is art and instead of calling me a cunt you can just keep your 30 IQ mouth shut. you just dont like it and want to make me feel bad

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:00:36 2019 No.3810881 >>3810876 >it's art because I say it's art don't care, 99% of this board doesn't care because this board is about drawing and painting, not photoshoping porn

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:03:01 2019 No.3810882

>>3810881
>its not art because i say its not
i added details with an overpainting to be fair
and theres nowhere else to post something like this. If people can get crits on clay sculptures and photobashed concept art...

i dont see why youre so desperately fighting me on this when i just want some simple criticism, why does it hurt you so much?

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:03:42 2019 No.3810885

>>3810873
I actually gave you some tips >>3810843, I told you to watch some tutorials and not waste your time on this low effort shit, I was being genuine about this. I've fucked around in photoshop too, I know how much effort this takes and you could actually do better. Watch some tutorials, try harder and fuck off.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:06:54 2019 No.3810886 >>3810885 you fuck off whatever man.

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:09:37 2019 No.3810887

>>3810882
You have a horrible attitude about your art, and you'll struggle to improve with your current. You want critique? fine here: your edits aren't good at looking like what you're trying to represent, they are blurry and stretched and the key point here - they aren't appealing.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:09:51 2019 No.3810888 >>3810886 Thanks for the drama, newfag.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:11:40 2019 No.3810891 >>3810887 >theyre blurry, stretched, and unappealing wow! thank you! not too happy my thread had to be nuked with autism for those three little things but thanks regardless. dont suppose you want to post your work before i go do you?

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:12:14 2019 No.3810892

>>3810732
Look Im going to pretend you are serious and give you some advice on how to use this board. This stuff isnt just bad photo editing, its not worth anyone's time to help. You are learning to use Photoshop tools and that is good in this hobby. Nothing you have 'made' is worth a critique. You are learning photoshop mechanically, you are not making art. If you had questions about photoshop and used these edits as a reference, fine, but as a piece of art, it isn't worth a glance. You learned nothing about art from this, study the fundamentals or don't ask for critiques.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:13:55 2019 No.3810894 These look absolutely, atrociously disgusting.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:16:08 2019 No.3810896 >>3810891 He said nothing constructive. He didnt tell you how to correct anything. He told you its shit in nicer words.

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:20:03 2019 No.3810902

>>3810896
thoses three things are literally the only feedback beyond I HATE IT FUCK YOU in like 20 posts so i was trying to cut my losses.

dont worry guys next time ill post some anime in the style of Bouguereau as not to offend your delicate sensibilities

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:28:14 2019 No.3810911 >>3810902 I mean at least that's an attempt at creating art, >>3810892 this guy is spot on. Try be a little self aware and listen to him if you want to actually improve. Btw you might actually be retarded.

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:32:51 2019 No.3810915

>>3810911
>btw youre retarded

not fucking necessary jesus christ, i disagree with him but that doesnt mean im completely closed off to input or anything. i think it has a bit of artistic merit, the goblin one at least.
not in a Louvre sense but its not like the anime chickenscratch smut you see here has any more

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:37:27 2019 No.3810922 >>3810915 Sorry you delusional retard, there's no artistic merit to sloppily painting over bad porn.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:43:20 2019 No.3810925 >>3810915 lmao how are people like this actually real

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:45:49 2019 No.3810929

>>3810922
i mean this >>3810811
is more than a "sloppy paintover", at least worthy of feedback.

try this thought exercise, pretend that i drew everything on the left by hand dot by dot, and then give it a lil critique. (if you need to jump through some mental hoops to be a normal person)

if you just want to argue and say retard a lot, you cant do that on your own in Wordpad

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 00:46:52 2019 No.3810930 >>3810925 like what? what am i saying thats irrational? youre just overreacting to nothing

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 01:22:39 2019 No.3810954 >>3810929 >>3810930 this has got to be a troll, no one is actually this derpy

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 01:34:10 2019 No.3810963 >>3810954 >derpy like what do you actually mean by this? im just not being an asshole, its probably a culture shock to this board

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 01:51:49 2019 No.3810982 >>3810732 nice 'art' dipshit, next time post in the cringe thread

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 02:04:06 2019 No.3810989
File: 363 KB, 1920x1080, 802847.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>3810734
wtf hahahaha what were you thinking when you were doing this OP, did you look at this afterwards and think, hmmm.. looks good, time to call it a day XD.

Hey ic like my edits >>3810732

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 02:16:17 2019 No.3810998 >>3810989 nah i thought it looked funny. thank you for pointing out the uneven eye, you couldve pointed it out without the desperate attempt at cunty "humor"

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 02:17:20 2019 No.3811000 >>3810982 post your art

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 02:24:52 2019 No.3811003 >>3810998 so if you can tell something looks off why don't you do something about it?

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 07:12:36 2019 No.3811204
File: 571 KB, 916x1100, 1429328008421.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

>>3810848
>you know its okay to not like something without being a massive cunt about it
Do you lack basic reading comprehension? All I asked you to do was post ART and you can't even do that. But since you want me to post my art so badly, here you go.
Pic related was made in a week. Now it's your turn.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 07:18:42 2019 No.3811207 >>3810734 Wide nut-sack is wide.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 08:45:12 2019 No.3811251 >>3811204 Is this pic some kind of meme?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 15 09:16:34 2019 No.3811265 >>3811251 Nope, drew that all by myself. Here's my blog. http://andrewsonea.com

Anonymous Fri Feb 15 18:03:53 2019 No.3811767

>>3810915
I bet you cant draw a figure. I bet that these shitty photoshops are the extent of your ability. Tracing is theft and teaches nothing. In the real world, tracing will get you a lot of controversy. What you are doing is worse than tracing. You put in less than the minimum effort. Like ai said, its good that you are learning photoshop but it isnt art. If you have some actual art you drew you can post it and maybe it will be worth a critique. Until then, go to /beg/ or dont come here at all. This board isnt for you, you would get better responses on /b/.

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]