Shit Anatomy Thread

[Anonymous No.3476414]

I will start

[Anonymous No.3476417]

>>3476414
kys

[Anonymous No.3476418]

id like to see ic explain how op's image has shit anatomy

[Anonymous No.3476429]

>>3476414
I can tell you're not a successful artist.
Stop this fuckery and go draw something

[Anonymous No.3476430]

>>3476414
redline pls

[Anonymous No.3476439]

beg here
Is this really badly proportioned or just stylised?, I'd say the later but I figured I'm better asking

[NoseBro No.3476444]

>>3476439
there are issues at the pelvis, her shoulder, the origination point of her right arm, but beyond that, op is just baiting. It could also be argued she has a long torso.

[Anonymous No.3476450]

>>3476444
I'm gonna go ahead and unironically ask you for a redline. The only thing imo that can't be attributed to stylization is her right arm being slightly longer than the left, but that's it.

[Anonymous No.3476458]

>Crabs defending shit animu art
knees lmao

[Anonymous No.3476462]

>>3476458
SOURCE

[Anonymous No.3476471]

>>3476439
It's stylized. There's nothing wrong here. I'm gonna bet that the artist behind OP's image never did hard anatomy and classical like training, but they made up for it in stylizing the fuck out of it. She/he will be doomed to make mediocre profile shots for the rest of their lives, but for what we have right now, there's nothing meaningful to nitpick

>>3476458
If it looks good, it looks good. Nothing to it than that. No undercanvas watercolor scoring, Centennial poke-dot backgammon judge calls, or Indian Ocean server specific lacrosse rules apply.

[NoseBro No.3476472]

>>3476450

[Anonymous No.3476474]

My cock will bulge that neck like nobodies business

[Anonymous No.3476476]

>>3476472
literally stylistic choices. original is proportional just has a smaller head compared to your redline.

in other words, fuck off

[Anonymous No.3476478]

>>3476462

Took two seconds, try harder.

[Anonymous No.3476479]

>>3476472
You absolute retarded as fuck, mong. You are wrong. Look at where the belly-button and waist are, you fucking pants on head retard. APPLY YOURSELF

LLLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMISSSSSSSSSSS

[Anonymous No.3476480]

>>3476478
post link

[NoseBro No.3476482]

>>3476476
what isnt a stylistic choice is the angle of her pelvis which ive changed to full front, as well as the elbow being realistically locked.

[Anonymous No.3476485]

>>3476482
are you retarded? you changed the angle of something that was anatomically consistent

[Anonymous No.3476486]

>>3476482
>realistically

you fucked up....just drop the tripfag and fuck off

[NoseBro No.3476487]

>>3476479
im glad you picked the literal only thing you could be proven objectively wrong about. Google belly button, youll see most of them start a few cm below where the hips begin.

[Anonymous No.3476489]

nosebro is best artist

[NoseBro No.3476490]

>>3476486
ok, show me how the elbow and arm interlock if youre so confident. Youll realize they dont.
>>3476485
except if you look the original drawing implies this:

[Anonymous No.3476491]

>>3476439
>>3476444
Literally just a stylistic choice, Nosebro doesn't know what the fuck he's talking about.

Look at Dexter's Lab, look at Ed, Edd, and Eddy, look at Johnny Bravo. Cartoons are cartoons. You can do whatever the fuck you want so long as its appealing.

[Anonymous No.3476494]

>>3476487

[NoseBro No.3476495]

>>3476489
though left side is a bit old, i appreciate your sentiment!

[Anonymous No.3476497]

>>3476490
oh you just don't know how females look nvm

study more

[Anonymous No.3476498]

>>3476495
Well, you've improved. But if anyone needs to desperately work on Stylization, it's you.

[NoseBro No.3476499]

>>3476494
Do you know what most means? Also, his drawing also has the belly button below the hip start point.

[Anonymous No.3476500]

look at this garbage

[Anonymous No.3476502]

>>3476500
Looks ok to me.

[NoseBro No.3476503]

>>3476497
Let your defeat fuel our next bout kohai!~
>>3476498
eh. im aware. im aiming for something new.

[Anonymous No.3476509]

>d-don't worry, it's a stylistic choice haha..

[Anonymous No.3476510]

can someone post link where Noseretard shitting on old masters. This thread was golden

[Anonymous No.3476512]

>>3476490
youre a dumbass

[Anonymous No.3476513]

>>3476510
This
>https://boards.fireden.net/ic/thread/3109988/#3111041

[Anonymous No.3476514]

>>3476499
>B-bro, you know he did it too after I tried to redline someone else
You fucking retarded mong

[Anonymous No.3476518]

>>3476514
>>3476512
Just filter it and report.

[Anonymous No.3476520]

Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet? Are these threads reportable yet?

[NoseBro No.3476522]

>>3476512
>fixed underwear,
>breaks thigh,
>doesnt draw hand or the connection or the shoulder because that invalidates your point

[NoseBro No.3476524]

>>3476514
you said my belly button is too low, i showed its accurate to reality and is not even a variation of the original.

[Anonymous No.3476527]

>>3476458
It's not shit if I can fap to it

[Anonymous No.3476530]

>>3476520
>>3476518
>*resets IP*
Useless. Bans not working. Only ISP ban works. But good luck. Even /qa/ thread will not help you. Mods rarely use ISP bans. The last one I seen was in /m/

[NoseBro No.3476532]

>>3476512
to be more precise about the hand thing, you literally drew a line cutting 15% of the hands mass to read your objective. You also went slightly over the fabric for the elbow, youre ignoring foreshortning or the connecting between tit and triceps. You have to be aware, theres no way you aren't. You have the skill to draw a decent arm.

[Anonymous No.3476534]

>>3476512
I'm glad you did this because it was fucking with me, however, the OP still looks fucked up to me around her pelvis/legs

[Anonymous No.3476535]

>>3476522
legit kill yourself you will never make it

[Anonymous No.3476538]

>>3476414
She would be decapitated at the drop of a hat

[NoseBro No.3476541]

>>3476535
ok and you think this elbow connection is accurate and okay? Completely form breaking.

[Anonymous No.3476543]

[Anonymous No.3476545]

>>3476543
little neck problem

[Anonymous No.3476548]

moar shit art

[Anonymous No.3476553]

>>3476535
lmao

[Anonymous No.3476555]

>>3476541
the fuck do you mean form breaking? the connection isn't shown it has nothing to do with the form in the piece, its just the construction of it.

[Anonymous No.3476557]

>>3476548
post more shit art

[Anonymous No.3476559]

defend this

[Anonymous No.3476560]

>>3476557

[Anonymous No.3476561]

>>3476559
ok: the palette and style make me feel comfy

[NoseBro No.3476563]

>>3476555
Add me on Discord, ill go over what I mean while screensharing in private chat. The short of it is that many pieces occupy the same space and this flattens the image. Look at mine for comparison.
I'm going grocery shopping, ill continue in an hour if youre still interested in discussing it

[NoseBro No.3476564]

>>3476563

[Anonymous No.3476565]

ITT: Boxfags and constructards don't know what stylization is

[Anonymous No.3476567]

>>3476559
It looks nice

[Anonymous No.3476569]

>>3476563
no you fuckin weirdo, you have no idea what youre talking about you're just using words you think sound artsy
gtfo

[Anonymous No.3476571]

>>3476565
>nosetard don't know what stylization is
ftfy

[NoseBro No.3476572]

>>3476569
Thats fine, I'll remember the fact that the weirdo is the one reaching out for constructive dialogue, and you are normal in fearing verbal interaction.

Have a nice day!

[Anonymous No.3476582]

>>3476572
cant tell if troll or auto-fellating neet

[NoseBro No.3476589]

>>3476582
wouldnt have to fellate myself if you accepted my cybersex session invitation

[Anonymous No.3476605]

>>3476559
sauce

[Anonymous No.3476616]

>>3476500

Garbage opinion.

[Anonymous No.3476653]

Ask mods in /qa/ to range ban NoseBro.
All proofs of shitposting, discord posting, bans, ban evading in archives. I will support you.

[Anonymous No.3476662]

>>3476414
>>3476500
These are fantastic.

[Anonymous No.3476669]

>>3476414
OP is just mad no one likes his shitty art.

[NoseBro No.3476771]

>>3476653
the mods love me too much to do so!

[Anonymous No.3476781]

>>3476653
If I make the thread will you all back me?

[Anonymous No.3476784]

>>3476771
We're range banning you for your own good. So you can get good. Because we all secretly love you and hate you at the same time.

[Anonymous No.3476803]

>>3476414
blog? love the style

[Anonymous No.3476808]

[Anonymous No.3476821]

>>3476808
those hands look like shit and the faces lack the charm of op

[Anonymous No.3476832]

>>3476565
doesnt seem like you do either since you couldnt bother to post a redline :thonk:

[Anonymous No.3476856]

>>3476490
I don't get it? the hips doesn't have to be tilted that crazily for it to form that kind of cross contour. And hips do naturally tilt in that angle in neutral positions. Plus our eye level is higher than the panties, making the ellipse more pronounced.

[Anonymous No.3476859]

>>3476856
More random examples

[Anonymous No.3476862]

>>3476859

[Anonymous No.3476864]

>>3476862

[Anonymous No.3476866]

>>3476864

[Anonymous No.3476884]

>>3476856
nosetard has never seen a human female until now that's literally all there is to get, he doesn't know what hes talking about

[NoseBro No.3476885]

>>3476864
this one is tilted forward
>>3476862
this one is nearly flat
>>3476859
this one is tilted forward and has differential height due to ass, is not same view

>>3476856
this one isnt as extreme and is also a photoshop i believe

[Anonymous No.3476888]

>>3476541
I'm guessing you're talking about how the forearm looks too short, thus breaking construction? I'd say the artist was foreshortening the forearm, seeing how we're seeing the fingers from the top angle, though I suppose the artist left it ambiguous

[NoseBro No.3476894]

>>3476885

[Anonymous No.3476904]

>>3476894
if that was remotely correct why does her right thigh look like that
youre legit retarded stop posting lmfao

[Anonymous No.3476905]

>>3476856
I know it's not, but I'm gonna pretend this is one of the femanons that posts here, and fap to it.

[Anonymous No.3476918]

>>3476414
Gonna need the sauce for that

[Anonymous No.3476922]

>>3476856
Pic was based on photo. あみあん likes to stylize photos. Sadly ref for this particular pic is dead http://honkawa.tumblr.com/post/135497537076
Would be funny to see nosetard's damage control.

[Anonymous No.3476926]

>>3476781
Yeah. Underage degenerate should be gassed.

[Anonymous No.3476929]

>>3476894
How exaggerated the ellipse is up to interpretation I guess, but I think you pushed it a bit too far. And no, I didn't retroactively correct it to fit the ref

[Anonymous No.3476933]

>>3476929
Ok, I just noticed I fucked up the hip placement there, but it shouldn't change the orientation of the panties cross-contour which is the point of it

[Anonymous No.3476938]

>no Loomis

[Anonymous No.3476945]

>>3476559
heeey thats pretty good

[Anonymous No.3476949]

>>3476653
Isn't Nosebro a mod himself...?
They aren't going to turn on one of their own unless he does something illegal.

[Anonymous No.3476957]

>>3476949
>Nosebro a mod himself.
lmao

[Anonymous No.3476961]

>>3476957

[NoseBro No.3476966]

>>3476933
fix it then ill fight it.

[Anonymous No.3476989]

>>3476966

[NoseBro No.3477006]

>>3476989
it has that shape because youre looking from above. Youve obfuscated this by cropping everything out.

the ilt is further showcased by vagina being a bit further, demonstrated by the line on the lower end which my version changes. The issue is the whole things perspective is off, which is why my redline feels more grounded.

[NoseBro No.3477009]

>>3477006
the pantie doesnt go far enough to grab onto the pelvis either, which means it has to be the level kind of panty too.

[Anonymous No.3477010]

>>3477006
theres a natural tilt to the pelvis and spine you monkey stop talking out of your ass

[NoseBro No.3477014]

>>3477010
yes, and that tilt is too large on the original image. Can you even tell me what is eye level on the original? Fucking impossible because its 0p'd to hell and contradicting.

[Anonymous No.3477028]

>>3476414
ITT jellyfags nitpick things to death

[Anonymous No.3477029]

>>3477014
youre basing your inaccurate critique on your inaccurate redline so this is like talking to a wall.

go study stop shitposting

[Anonymous No.3477030]

>>3477028
you mean nosetard attempts to nitpick something nonexistent to death

[Anonymous No.3477034]

>>3477006
I can see what you mean by the vagina being off, and I also see how it's mismatching the way the thighs are constructed

But I still can't really see how the elliptical panty line is off. Her hips is tilted forward in the natural pos. + our eye level being higher than the panty can easily explain it. Just like the photo I was referring to.

Also the crop is because if I make it any bigger, it breaks the 4MB limit

[Anonymous No.3477038]

>>3476478
Why do you people have to be such dicks? The google search doesn't turn up shit more often than it actually works. Especially on certain devices.
>>3476480
https://twitter.com/grimgrim0730/status/850326374220836864?lang=en
Here anon, enjoy tapping to yor new bunny waifu

[Anonymous No.3477044]

>>3477038
That's why you use IQDB

[Anonymous No.3477099]

>>3476653
>>3476781
>>3476926
threadly reminder to filter him as well

[Anonymous No.3477141]

>>3477038
>spoonfeeding
>phoneposters
>4chan 2018
we reddit now

[Anonymous No.3477149]

>>3477038
At least he's tracing good stuff

[Anonymous No.3477150]

>Spent time calling other artist shit
>Instead of trying to improve your arts
Stop sketching and draw a real picture for once Nosefag, jesus christ this is embarrassing.

[Anonymous No.3477153]

>>3477141
WE WUZ REDDIT AND SHEEEIT

[Anonymous No.3477157]

>>3477149
UGHHHHH PUFFY LOLI PUSSY

[Anonymous No.3477169]

>>3477157
SHUTEN IS LOLIBABA

[NoseBro No.3477170]

>>3477150
nice rdl

[Anonymous No.3477285]

If anyone is wondering, this is the artist http://amiami.sakura.ne.jp/

[Anonymous No.3477308]

The amount of autism in this thread is enough to give you an ulcer.

[Anonymous No.3477322]

basically my whole gallery is a festival of shitty anatomy

[Anonymous No.3477324]

>>3477308
suck my dick ika musume

[Anonymous No.3477465]

>>3476414

[Anonymous No.3477469]

>>3477465
nice hooves

[Anonymous No.3477479]

>>3477465
Figure is too western.

[Anonymous No.3477484]

>>3477465
the too-rendered torso combined with the simplistic face and hands makes me discomfortable destroy it

[Anonymous No.3477521]

>>3476559
Maybe it's not anatomically accurate, but the pose is believable:
- she's holding an heavy object so the nearest leg is straight, causing it to be higher
- the other leg bends, only needs to rest on one point because the other foot has both heel and sole touching the ground
- whole body is bending to balance the thing she's holding

There's a few issues with hips and shoulders but otherwise it's fine

[Anonymous No.3477534]

>>3477465
i like the hair lines you do for the changes in form on the knees and belly.

[Anonymous No.3477537]

>>3477465
looks good anon

work on your feet

[Anonymous No.3477544]

>>3476458
This isn't horrible but I think would be more successful if it was further stylized and had simpler coloring. I think the artist also overdid it on drawing how her right buttock is visible from in front, it just looks like a lump, and too many skin folds beneath her armpit also making her look lump. But overall not horrible.

>>3476866
I know this is a photograph but her hips still look weird.

[Anonymous No.3477582]

>>3477537
>>3477469

I was using a thick brush so I didn't detail the feet since they're so smol.
Here's some feet I sketched up. I spent about a total of 5 minutes drawing this.

>>3477479
>>3477484
I thought the point was to make it more anatomically correct. I kept the style of the face with the exception of making a few tweaks about it such as resizing the head, raising the ears, and adjusting crooked features. I was looking to make the body more attractive since I think the style itself is already cute despite it's flaws.

[Anonymous No.3477585]

>>3477582
why did you draw these feet? to prove you could? weird. drawing feet by themselves is different from drawing them connected to a figure anyway.

the over-rendered torso and legs clashes with the simple style of the face and head.....you missed the mark.
>despite its flaws
just because something is stylized doesn't mean it is flawed.

[Anonymous No.3477586]

>>3476414

[Anonymous No.3477588]

>>3477582
feet dont look/work like that

[Anonymous No.3477589]

>>3477585
I can smell you from here.

[Anonymous No.3477591]

>>3477589
you can smell me but not the monkey who felt the need to prove his feet drawing abilities? okay

[Anonymous No.3477813]

>>3477591
>>3477588
>>3477585
>>3477537
What's up with the crabbing? Or are you boys just angry that someone is better than you at drawing?

[Anonymous No.3477819]

>>3477813
this whole thread is hilarious.
a bunch of shitty artist wannabes crapping on people better than them.

[Anonymous No.3477843]

>>3477813
>>3477819
>my skill's fine, anyone shitting on it must be a crab
i do agree that those anons are giving that guy crap for no reason, but you sound pretty dumb too

[Anonymous No.3477893]

>>3477813
>What's up with the crabbing?
just another day on /ic/

[Anonymous No.3477910]

>>3476414
still amazed how willing are you all to choke and gag with low-grade bait. trying to correct stylized art and even redline it, come on. the artist never aimed for anatomical correctness, like pic related and many of amiami work it's properly labeled with the original source of reference (most from tumblr and many dead pages sadly) most likely a study as tagged あみあん日記 in tumblr upload. either way at the end OP its a faggot

[Anonymous No.3478109]

>>3477465
nice

[Anonymous No.3478112]

>>3477465
Is there anyway to make her nose cuter?

[Anonymous No.3478121]

Nobody actually gives a shit about muh perfect anatomy as long as it looks good. Nice crab thread.

[Anonymous No.3478246]

>>3477843
why exactly do I sound dumb?
because I think 99% of these posts are an autistic nitpick fest?

[Anonymous No.3478364]

>>3476495
that was a joke

[Anonymous No.3478442]

>>3476490
god you're a fucktard

[Anonymous No.3478448]

>>3476472
There's absolutely nothing wrong with the OP image, however I do like your version better.

[Anonymous No.3478480]

>>3476472
Fix your nose, my dude.

[Anonymous No.3478484]

I can't take ic seriously anymore

[Anonymous No.3478508]

Worst thread on /ic/

[Anonymous No.3478511]

>>3478484
>Ever taking /ic/ seriously

[Anonymous No.3478525]

the knees scare me

[Anonymous No.3478578]

>>3478525
they seems to low, other than that I can't see how they can be scary

still saved tho because I like the texture and cat ears are one of my weaknesses

[Anonymous No.3478584]

This fucking thread.

[Anonymous No.3478594]

>>3478578
I don't know it's not that shocking, just imagine she has small feet and huge sneakers

the pose however is atrocious

[Anonymous No.3478604]

>>3478594
>the pose however is atrocious
good think my monitor is not big enough to view it all at the same time

>just imagine she has small feet and huge sneakers
if I force myself I can see that, but I still have to continue forcing myself or it doesn't work so, to me, they are still proportionally work

[Anonymous No.3478622]

>>3476414
there's nothing on /ic/ quite as amusing as posture grinders acting like they don't find anime cuties appealing

[Anonymous No.3478677]

>>3476938
But momodora rulez

[NoseBro No.3478881]

>>3477465
you killed the perspective though

[Anonymous No.3478883]

>>3478881
what? the perspective is almost identical to op

[Anonymous No.3478889]

>>3478622
ikr i thought that despite its bad anatomy it is super cute.

[Anonymous No.3478924]

>>3476474
top 10 anime deaths

[Anonymous No.3479189]

>>3476414
Yo whos the artist that shit looks hella cute i like it

[Anonymous No.3479208]

This whole thread. /ic/ is hopeless.

[Anonymous No.3479295]

>>3476472
none of theses shapes are appealing and you completely ruined the silhouette
good job

[Anonymous No.3479318]

>>3477479
>anon defines how the shapes work on the body
>it gets called western

[Anonymous No.3479357]

>>3476559
this is from Splatoon and it fits the theme and proportions of the game just fine. Splatoon itself is extremely stylized or unique, and this drawing actually looks alright with that in mind. Give this drawing a pass, aside from her missing arm and sleeve. Figure you'd at least be able to see the shoulder in that pose.

[Anonymous No.3479374]

Checked out the artist OP posted because I like her style. She has a lot of cute stuff but I hate this piece.

[NoseBro No.3479377]

>>3478883
literally just look at the head.

[Anonymous No.3479665]

>>3479374
Okay now this is something i can hate, all other stuff the artist does is good.

[Anonymous No.3479672]

>>3479208
The worst part is that these threads could be funny and useful if we all posted our failed art.

[Anonymous No.3479854]

>>3476414
found this on my twitter tl.

the left arm is just too weird, at least imo.

[Anonymous No.3481457]

>>3476500
You people are delusional.

[Anonymous No.3482239]

this thread is actually very reassuring in a way
the next time people on /ic/ shit on my art i'll keep in mind that some of them are just imbeciles with shit taste

[Anonymous No.3482248]

>>3479854
shoulder is not in the right spot and the arm is too long to make up for it. Try the pose for yourself and you'll see it.

[Anonymous No.3482249]

>>3479208
>/ic/ is hopeless
sorry bud but I see you helping just as much as any crab. the LAS/DAD threads are pretty comfy

[Anonymous No.3482285]

>>3476821
>hand autist
Your opinion belongs in the same place as your sperm: the trash

[Anonymous No.3482306]

>>3482285
why are you projecting your inability to draw hands onto me? Go practice more you weirdo

[Anonymous No.3482394]

what the actual fuck is this thread. like is this the absolute state of ic or what bc this is fucking embarrassing. holy fucking shit it's a fucking cartoon the proportions aren't going to be realistic holy shit

op is a genius troll senpai yall played yourselves

[Anonymous No.3485371]

>>3482394
Are you new? This shits been happening for years. Take what you see on these boards with a grain of salt.

[Anonymous No.3485388]

As long as it's not spaghetti tier and actually visually appealing it does not matter. This is literally crabs: the thread

[Anonymous No.3485394]

>>3485388
>>3482394
none of yall actually read the thread or youd see it was literally only nosebro being autistic about anatomy

[Anonymous No.3485702]

>>3476559
...squids don't need to have human anatomy? (that actually might be a kid tho can't really tell)

[Anonymous No.3487154]

>>3477893
I think we should change the board name to /icrab/
:(

[Anonymous No.3487517]

>>3477028
/thread

[Anonymous No.3487522]

>>3487154
kek

[Anonymous No.3487603]

I actually found a lot of art I like because of this thread.
Thanks for being a gigantic autistic faggot, NoseBro.

[Anonymous No.3487703]

[Anonymous No.3489210]

>>3476414

[Anonymous No.3489248]

>>3489210
wrong thread retard

[Anonymous No.3490596]

>>3476559
inkling anatomy is different from human anatomy you dolt

[Anonymous No.3490602]

one of these threads huh

[Anonymous No.3490610]

[Anonymous No.3490611]

[Anonymous No.3490614]

[Anonymous No.3490621]

>why is everything here only non-western art

[Anonymous No.3491266]

>>3490610
>>3490611
those made me physically cringe ngl

[Anonymous No.3491271]

>>3476559
It's cute, cartoony and expressive.I like it a lot and want to see more of this artist's work.

Is that all you wanted?

[Anonymous No.3491290]

>>3479374
what's the name of the artist?

[Anonymous No.3491542]

>>3476559
id say my only problem is the arm is maybe a bit too short or the perspective is off with her forearm. but thats me nitpicking because you told me to defend it, it looks fine to me considering how stylized splatoon is. what was your problem with it?

[Anonymous No.3491800]

>>3476548
>>3476559
its a cartoon retard

[Anonymous No.3491878]

>>3491290
Amiami https://www.pixiv.net/member.php?id=4249