[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique


View post   

File: 51 KB, 669x839, Asian Style Cape Shit ASCS.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6687168 No.6687168 [Reply] [Original]

Why is it that Japanese cape shit has soul but western cape shit lacks any soul? Does anyone the secret sauce for their superiority?

>> No.6687172

>>6687168
Soul is a meme word used by people that can't properly express why they like a certain artwork.
You simply prefer the anime aesthetic.

Stop opening dumb threads, retard.

>> No.6687178

>>6687172
I feel sorry that you lack soul to feel souls emanating from art

>> No.6687195

>>6687168
good writing

>> No.6687204

What exactly counts as japanese capeshit? The only ones who fully fit the bill are toku shows and My Hero Academia and the latter is directly based on western capeshit. Are Saint Seiya and Dragon Ball capeshit? What about magical girls anime like Sailor Moon? Do Doremi and Precure count as well?

>> No.6687212

asian genes

>> No.6687427

>>6687168
Great, another east vs west thread.

>> No.6687433

>>6687172
Couldn't agree more. Buzzwords like this just indicate someone who can't express what they like about a piece. It's the exact same as just saying "I like this better" which is irrelevant.

>> No.6687438
File: 180 KB, 605x512, mojojojo.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6687438

stop lying the PPG anime sucked massive ass compared to the original.

>> No.6687451
File: 307 KB, 696x498, OjamajoDoremi.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6687451

Ok /ic/, is this capeshit?

>> No.6687452

>>6687451
uoh

>> No.6687466
File: 820 KB, 900x886, idontunderstand.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6687466

imagine what this board could do if 50% of it wasn't east vs west shit on repeat forever

but also it's because you like cute shit and moe stuff of girls meant for an adult male audience. the true essence and truth of moe is not fully realized in english speaking artist circles.

>> No.6687561

>>6687168
AI shit

>> No.6687566

>>6687561
Rent free.

>> No.6687634

>>6687566
I saw it on pleddit

>> No.6687637

>>6687168
>Japanese cape shit has soul
Pic not related?

>> No.6687647
File: 679 KB, 1125x656, 1684824461223256.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6687647

>>6687168
Soul flied away from "capes" at the end of the 80s, when kids stopped reading them, the moment where the genre should had just fucking die instead of being kept standing on with sticks
The whole (fake, but that's another topic) ideology behind American super heroes simply doesn't exist anymore, and they just repurposed its glamorous exterior to serve as infinitely exploitable husk that can be filled with anything.
Shit like my hero gay ass sure takes visual inspiration from America, but everything inside is extremely Japanese super heroes, something that have common roots with the USA ones, but are ultimately a different breed.
You could say that for their intrinsic viscerality and distance from the aforementioned American ideology, Japanese super heroes have more noticeable amount of "soul", but in the end they both are extremely tired horses, and both, even if in different amounts, have limped very far from their cultural roots whipped by their greedy owners.
There is nothing more removed from the all permitting, morally relative, haunted behind every digital corner by horrors beyond every kind of ethical social construct modern day than the archetype of the super hero.
One could argue, that's exactly why it's so fitting. But aren't the false idols of today already enough?
Is a laic saviour figure any different from the ones religion offers when they've been showed time and time again we'll less than sacred as they proclaim to be?

>> No.6689372

>>6687438
The only good thing to come out of it was the music and transformation sequence.

>> No.6689416
File: 1.97 MB, 327x251, 226B9660-5367-4395-99A0-FF9E8ED96419.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6689416

>>6687168
Cybersix counts as capeshit and it has soul. It's Argentinian. So by that logic it's just american capeshit that sucks ass

>> No.6689443
File: 50 KB, 602x339, main-qimg-40f018ea653ee6f3ca045a2a8eaca6a7-lq.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6689443

You're not allowed to draw giant sexy women in american comics anymore

>> No.6689448

>>6689416
That was animated by TMS and produced by some canucks. Most people who know this only remember it for the animated series which was heavily sanitized to the point of fanfiction.

>> No.6689482

>>6689448
Still more soul than amerislop

>> No.6689524
File: 93 KB, 340x388, 1683066664721216.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6689524

>>6687168
>Ah Sweet
>Another east vs west thread

>> No.6689525

>>6687438
Well, it was fun in it's own right, but a massive downgrade action wise. Designs are just as good as the original, except for miss bellum.

>> No.6689579

>>6687168
it makes muh dik hard

>> No.6690262

>>6687451
Yes, but better

>> No.6693445

>>6687168
Chuck Dixon said it best. You can tell the people working on manga actually enjoy it and want to do it.
Meanwhile..
Everyone in the west is only making comics in hopes they get turned into adaptations. And when then they drop the series the moment they realize that won't happen.

>> No.6694789

>>6687168
The comics you've read were targeted at 12 year old or younger children and 30 year old or older adults.
You are a horny 17 year old adult wannabe.