/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

fuck no, story's pretty good tho

>>6486492
>The story is pretty good
Making Eren a gigantic cuck is not good storytelling

>>6486467
yes, people just don't appreciate sketchy, dynamic drawing

>>6486472
That hand lmao.

>>6486498
S1-3 and some of the parts until the rumbling are good. Rest is trash. My head canon ending is the moment rumbling starts.

Why do you retards insist on only posting garbage speedscans?

>>6486498
Eren was a gigantic cuck from the chapter 1. Anyone claiming otherwise is either in denial or speedread the fucking manga.

>>6486467
No but he's a decent enough to tell the story he wanted.

>>6486467
He told the story he wanted to tell which means he was good enough

Too bad the cuck ending ruined the series retroactively for many people, myself included

>>6486467
He's good enough and it doesn't matter once he's popular anyway.

>>6486492
>story's pretty good tho
no it's not, he just uses suspense and mystery well, once you find out what's actually going on it's retarded.

>>6486467
Does it really matter? He made bank and achieved what everyone on /ic/ could only dream of with less technical prowess and cringey art. He's a successful artist.

>>6487656
>no it's not, he just uses suspense and mystery well
>no he's not, he just [writes] well

Never read SnK. He seems like an effective and creative artist, if not the most technically competent. That makes him better than 95% of /ic/.

>>6486467
Greatest manga artist of the last decade. No other comic author draws detailed scenes from multiple perspectives on his level. Non artists can’t appreciate an action scene drawn from the west in one panel then the same scene drawn from the east in the next panel, then again drawn from an aerial view in the next panel.

>>6486467
the fuck is going on here?

>>6486467
Yes, it's pretty clear he's a good artist and storyteller when you realize that Eren kills Mikasa.

>>6489108
I don't mind Isayama but jesus christ read more manga

>>6487703
not him, but yes
good execution doesn’t mean a good idea
christopher lee could read out the most retarded fucking monologue on the planet and make it sound good, but the monologue is still shit

>>6489587
>good execution doesn’t mean a good idea
No, it doesn't, but a good idea is worthless without execution. It's ALL about the execution. Isayama bungled it in the end but up until that point it was a very compelling run and all your cope can't change that. It's why we're talking about it in the first place, why you faggots can't stop seething about it. A good idea gets you to the serialization, good execution gets you to being serialized for a decade and world-wide fame.
The anon I was replying to posted that he sucked at writing despite praising him for his writing. Suspense and mystery is writing.

>>6490696
I never even read it lol
I’m just saying the writing being good and the story being good are not two different things

>>6486618
Why was eren a cuck? I don't understand. Just watched the anime btw, havent read the manga yet.

>>6487703
Who is this chick? :)

Why the fuck did the main guy go cold feet on killing the (((((Marleyans)))))

>>6486646
hows it end, never really gave enough of a shit to read it or watch it so I dont care about spoilers.

>>6490824
Eren reveals that it was his plan to force his friends stop him after annihilating 70% of the global population, so the world would blame him and not the entirety of Eldians for his sins becoming literally the Hitler of all sins. After that he pulls Armin's consciousness into the Eldian hivemind and starts rambling and cries to him about how being a KHV sucks and how he wanted to have a life with Mikasa but for the common good he had to sacrifice himself then they disconnect from the hivemind to settle their battle for once and for all. Mikasa then kills Eren after getting into his titan's mouth then beheads him. 100 years pass after the incident and the world makes a coalition to retaliate against Eldains carpet boming their entire island into the stone age. The end

he's good enough, which is all you need to worry about if you want to make money pal

>>6490766
you act like the (((eldians))) aren't what's ((( ))) here

All artists should study writing as well. It is debatable to more important element in getting people to enjoy what you make

>>6490835
wow that sounds like it would retroactively piss me off.

>>6486467
Yes, ain`t generic and full of "energy".

>>6487703
>pic
Pls post name or code

>>6486467
Why is he so shit at proportions and forms after all those years when it comes to the human characters?

>>6491276
because he's not studying anatomy.

>>6489462
I’ve read hundreds of manga. Fuck off with your non-argument

>>6489108
>Greatest manga artist of the last decade.
that's not saying much really.

>>6491406
Then how can you possibly think he's anywhere near the top? Brain worms?