[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

View post   
File: 34 KB, 173x175, 1580012208208.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4801697 No.4801697 [Reply] [Original]

>see someone crit industry pros and other incredibly skilled artists at the highest level
>their work is completely beginner and they've just started drawing

>> No.4801711
File: 85 KB, 850x510, __kasumi_kantai_collection_drawn_by_ijima_yuu__sample-f2c90c406fb0121dd449be8d4db810a7.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4801711

>>4801697
no person in the sports are free from criticisms of the public, art should be no different

>> No.4801879

I want bernkastel to suck on my dick

>> No.4801890
File: 604 KB, 1125x1133, 038A661B-FB40-4893-BA7A-159C19568BC8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4801890

>>4801711
Even if the criticism/feedback is completely wrong?

>> No.4801913

>>4801879
same holy shit

>> No.4801943

Da Vinci commented that a layman is perfectly qualified to criticize a master painter when his work is shit. Dont feel like digging up the quote.

>> No.4801946

>>4801711
>>4801943
Yes, and other laymen can also go ahead and criticize the guy who first criticized if they don’t agree with his criticism.

>> No.4801954

dunning kruger

>> No.4801963

>>4801954
>>4801697
No that's just flattery. Who cares. Fuck you OP

>HOW DARE THEY TALK TO MY FAV ARTIST

>> No.4801989
File: 76 KB, 700x668, 1572706843602.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4801989

>>4801697
The more work i find myself having to bust my ass to improve, the less I feel the need to criticise other people's art for making mistakes, lets be real, the only part that easy about this shit is fucking it up.

>> No.4801994

>>4801711
Fpbp

>> No.4802083

>>4801989
I feel you, Anon. I've just grown to appreciate people's work.

>> No.4802551

>>4801711

either what they said are right or wrong. their arts skill has nothing to do with this.

>> No.4803328

>>4801879
>>4801913
Based Bernchads

>> No.4803392

>>4801711
>Anime shitter
>hypocrite logic
What a surprise. People should be proficient in their craft before they criticize. Only dunning krugers that know nothing about art think otherwise

>> No.4803403

>>4801711
Why should dunning krugers have that kind of power? They say retarded shit like this >>4801890 all the time and we should take them seriously?

>> No.4803407

Good criticism is about having an analytical mind and good taste rather than being skilled. The former's connected to the latter but they are not the same. Well and being eloquent. The question is does the criticism hold up or is it just petty crab shit?

>> No.4803415

>>4803392
Hey, taste my turd pizza. oh, you didn't like it? That's because you don't understand the taste of turds and you probably hasn't cooked for a living either so you have no right to criticize my recipe.

>> No.4803423
File: 164 KB, 514x640, CF8AC449-A8FB-45BB-A436-FC514BDD0B44.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4803423

>>4803415
Yes

>> No.4803430

>>4803403
What power? To say things? To make observations?
The criticism (because it’s not critique) is either valid or not, it has nothing to do with who made it.
If a pro and a non-artist point out the same issue, is one of the wrong or undeserving of speaking to you? Don’t be retarded.

>> No.4803439

>>4803423
found the /int/ who can't take criticisms

>> No.4803552

It’s embarrassing when begs crit because they don’t know what the fuck they’re talking about 99% of the time. They literally make shit worse because they’re suffering from dunning Kruger so badly they actually think they have the necessary knowledge to properly provide solutions. Any dickhole can analyze a piece, very few can give actual advanced solutions. Regards can’t figure that bit out though and think they can give proper crit.

>> No.4803585

>>4803552
do as i say, not as i do