/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

>>4543844
pyw see how yours compare

Michelangelo is the greatest artist ever.

>>4543904
why?

>>4543936

>>4544262
desu David is one of those "it's awesome because he did it first"-types of artpieces. If you did something similar today, it would be considered boring. That applies to many of the classics of course but not all of them -- there's something magical about the Mona Lisa for example, which surpasses the "he did it first"-ism.
>>4543904
meh. His work is iconic and well recognized today but since when was art a popularity contest?

>>4544284
/ic/ newfriend here. Is this type of retarded faggot subhumanoid common in this board?

>>4544284
>That applies to many of the classics of course but not all of them -- there's something magical about the Mona Lisa for example, which surpasses the "he did it first"-ism.
Fucking kill yourself fucking pathetic fucking artfag. The Mona Lisa is fucking ASS. Stop being a pretentious faggot. Nobody cares about your opinion on what "good" art is, because it's wrong.
Mona Lisa ASS-ism.

>>4544284
>David is one of those "it's awesome because he did it first"
By "did it", you mean achieved perfection?
>there's something magical about the Mona Lisa
By "something", you mean the fact it's been shoved down your uneducated normalfag throat?

>>4544317
based and sanepilled

>>4544284
>>4544311
>>4544317
Mona Lisa is literally only popular because of the "he did it first" ism. If someone sculpted david in front of you today you'd be fucking shitting bricks. The Mona Lisa looks like some /beg/ tier deviantart type shit. Nobody would give a flying fuck about the painting if it wasn't for the history and hype behind it.

>>4544323
The Mona Lisa is the template for all portraiture afterwards. Liking it depends on your interest in portraiture I guess. That’s like saying Citizen Kane is a bad movie. Like it kind of is, but also anything before Citizen Kane is unwatchable

My man roberto ferri is trully a modern master

>>4544284
>>4544311
>>4544317
>>4544323
>>4544437
Literally nothing wrong with the Mona Lisa. It's a perfect painting, especialy when it comes to her hands.

>>4544444
>horizon is on different levels on the two sides of the woman
>nothing wrong

>>4544509
It’s ON PURPOSE! Muh Leotardo made his masterpiece BAD ON PURPOSE! It’s part of a SECRET MESSAGE FOR BASED PEOPLE ONLY! HE CAN DRAW A STRAIGHT HORIZON IF HE WANTS TO!!!!

>>4544518
Dude... This board is so trash. If other boards knew /ic/ was talking shit about Leonardo da Vinci they’d close this board. Not to mention all the actual good artists fill up requests threads in random boards and not ic. Ic is where people who don’t draw go to say shit like this

Michelangelo's work is divine and perfect
The Mona Lisa has the stare of an evil soul
Leonardo was demonic

>>4544555
are they old enough to be posted here?

>>4544518
Funny that the queer couldn’t even get his horizon straight.

>>4544311
>>4544323
I concede that sculptures in general are awesome. Now if David was made by some guy today and he told you that this sculpture depicts the biblical David, about to face off with the giant Goliath, would you keep shitting bricks? He's supposed to be afraid. Does he look like anything other than low key pissed off? It took researchers to look at the sculpture from unnatural angles and analyze its anatomical details in order to detect the emotions of fear and excitement. Of course the caveat is that Italians at the time had just invented "cool" and this feeling is exuded by both David and Mona Lisa. But I'm just saying -- David doesn't look like David. He doesn't look like a guy who's about to face off a giant in a battle to death. Sure, it looks cool, it's a nice sculpture. But it's boring. David isn't supposed to be cool, he's supposed to be ready for battle. This sculpture would be met with a round of yawns today.

>>4544441
based post

>>4544738
make a trip so I can filter you

>>4544761
>boohoo leave Michaleangelo alone
Nice defence.

>>4544738
Or maybe it depicts the moment after the battle.

Nice blog post though.

>>4543854
Okay faggot

>>4544845
But it literally depicts the moment before the battle.

>>4544509
If perfect realism is in your set of criterias, then you have to deal with David's missing muscle. At least one can argue that Da Vinci bent the rules to achieve a perfect composition. Michaelangelo just made a mistake.
https://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2004/10/18/1222193.htm

>>4544866
>horizon is a set of stairs
>perfect realism
>it’s bad on purpose

>>4544437
>like saying Citizen Kane is a bad movie. Like it kind of is
Are you shitting me?
>anything before Citizen Kane is unwatchable
Jesus fucking Christ, delete your post.

>>4544653
Why is the child so buff

>>4543844
>OH NO NO NO NOOOOOO, HOW THEY DARE TO MAKE SUCH AWFUL NON ANIMUH PAINTINGS???? WE ARE SO MUCH BETTER NOW !!!!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IuakWhptWlk

The Mona Lisa is the most beautiful piece of art ever created.

>>4545475
>The Mona Lisa is the most beautiful piece of art ever created.