[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ic/ - Artwork/Critique


View post   

File: 187 KB, 1024x1024, IMG_20190730_220507.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043760 No.4043760 [Reply] [Original]

thoughts on this?

>> No.4043761
File: 1.23 MB, 1492x2656, lol (6).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043761

>thoughts
what, you think /ic/ is capable of something so complex?

>> No.4043764

>>4043760
And?
What about it?

>> No.4043766

>>4043760
holy shit the bottom right
imagine the smell of the landwhale that came up with that

>> No.4043785

>>4043760
Why did bottom right gain traction?
It comes from a literal who.

>> No.4043787

>yet another east vs west thread
what's the point

>> No.4043791

>>4043760
Top are both bad, Captain Marvel can look fuckin kino sexy by western artists, and I'm sure eastern artists can do a way better job than that soulless, forgettable, generic husk in the OP. As for the bottom, the one on the right is obviously pandering to a very specific demographic. A tasteless, misandrist non-video game playing demographic, but their audience nonetheless. It's probably therefore successful in its goal to please these people, and upsetting those they dislike.

>> No.4043792

everything in and about that image is bad

>> No.4043794
File: 43 KB, 960x960, 1563610592644.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043794

>>4043760
>Japs good west bad
Ok thank you for the info

>> No.4043796
File: 603 KB, 1280x1968, 672995._SX1280_QL80_TTD_[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043796

>>4043785
No one was really talking about it except for weebs like the OP using it as a prop to "prove" that anime is superior to western art. Also the top right looks bland af, the top left isn't that great either but come on.

>> No.4043849

>>4043796
what is up with her leg

>> No.4043854

>>4043796
Shading looks good but her design leaves a lot to be desired.

>> No.4043856

>>4043760
I don't get it.

>> No.4043874
File: 200 KB, 696x991, 427400fb3b23a2d44f8833c83a4a9e2019ac537f0df118cecbecfb9318b493f0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043874

I've said this before but
west is good for wholesome shit
east is good for sexy

both can do either, but if, both sides tries to do wholesome then west wins (vice versa with east doing sexy shit). the problem is that the west doesn't take advantage of its strengths.

like pic related's story is crap (its some sjw shit where Sups beats up KKK people) but I think the artwork is nice though. But when you go against anime which have both good story and art, west loses in this. Just make a story that's universal/human that anyone can understand, and maybe they can finally sell their comics instead of being force-fed political bullshit that no one cares about.

>> No.4043889

>>4043760
>>4043766
>>4043791
>>4043874
Hey.

Retards.

Bottom left was dranw by a spaniard.

Stop eating bait.

>> No.4043891

>>4043760
Shit bait
Top left looks womanly, so does bottom left. Both right looks like shit.

>> No.4043896

>>4043760
The capeshit girl in the top is 10 times worse than the original, and that drawing is fucking /beg/ tier.

>> No.4043899

>>4043874
>Just make a story that's universal/human
That's hard to do when you're not human.

>> No.4043900

>>4043889
Spain is western europe.

>> No.4043902
File: 4 KB, 211x239, images.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043902

>>4043889
Literal brainlet

>> No.4043905

>>4043760
How is it ruining if the original design still exists. Also I think all of the pictures are cool even if the punk aesthetic assblasts /pol/

>> No.4043910
File: 1.06 MB, 1337x941, moeb.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4043910

>>4043874
T.

>> No.4043933

>>4043889
>le /plebbit/ spacing detected
go back to your safe space, faggot

>> No.4043963

>>4043889
literally the west end of western europe lmao

>> No.4043998

>>4043900
>>4043902
>>4043963
yes
bottom left is western
not japanese, you fucking idiot

>> No.4044010

>>4043889
samus is still a japanese design, brainlet

>> No.4044030
File: 80 KB, 500x501, bait fishing pole.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044030

>>4043760

>> No.4044031

>>4044010
Except the OP destroyed their own point by using a Western design of Samus as example of being good, genius

>> No.4044042

>>4043760
I don't get the hate for the bottom right one, there's so many out-of-character oversexualized fanart, how is this any different

>> No.4044116

>>4043874
superman's face looks too babyish, it looks wierd

>> No.4044149

>>4043760
They’re both shit, now get back to drawing or you’ll be NGMI.

>> No.4044455

>>4043900
>>4043902
>>4043933
>>4043963
>>4044010

>Japanese design vs. Western design
>Except the "Japanese design" is fucking spanish which is WESTERN

You people are fucking retarded holy shit.

>> No.4044457
File: 835 KB, 877x752, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044457

>>4043900
>>4043902
>>4043933
>>4043963
>>4044010
THIS ONE.
THIS IS THE SPANISH ONE.

>> No.4044458
File: 53 KB, 375x488, 1563670165048.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044458

>>4043796
Glad do see Toy Story's spider doll grew to be a strong a woman.

>> No.4044459
File: 133 KB, 951x451, 1512448958612.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044459

>>4043900
>>4043902
>>4043933
>>4043963
>>4044010

>> No.4044512

>>4044459
>>4044457
>>4044455
you guys are actually retarded

>> No.4044525

>>4043760
who tf actually did that samus

>> No.4044531

>>4044457
Spain is literally western europe, brainlet.

>> No.4044553

>>4043933
reddit is literally 2006 4chan

>> No.4044559

>>4043849
Nothing, but the foot would have look better slightly tilted forward imo.
>>4043854
How come? The desing looks really good to me.
>>4044458
Retarded

>> No.4044566
File: 127 KB, 1727x174, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044566

>>4044512
>>4044531
Are yo two fucking retarded?

OP was presenting the one on the left as a Japanese design so as to present the one on the right as being western and ruining an eastern design.

ITS FUCKING SPANISH.

THE ONE THE OP IS SAYING IS JAPANESE IS A FUCKING SPANISH DESIGN. WHICH IS WESTERN.

>> No.4044571

>>4044559
I'm sorry we don't like your female power fantasy, better luck next time.

>> No.4044574

posting in an epic thread

>> No.4044575
File: 55 KB, 500x333, 1544891892085.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044575

>>4044566
Brazilian here. Are you telling me if I copy Super Mario Bros. I can claim it for my country and make us a gaming superpower?

>> No.4044576

>>4044566
>ITS FUCKING SPANISH.
Spanish as in from spain, which is western europe you /pol/tard.

>> No.4044580

>>4044571
I was talking about skills, go with your retarded war somewhere else, I don't give two shits about it, I was just replying to you who think know better and do the most retarded crits ever based only on personal subjectivity and taste, is fucking disgusting.

>> No.4044581

>>4044575
Okay listen you dumb portugese speaking retard.

The OP was first off being disingenous becuase it was trying to present the spanish design as both eastern and eastern art compared to a fanart redesign.

SECOND. Its NOT the fucking same zero suit as other games, it is a different fucking design. Similar sure but it isnt the same design.

>>4044576
YES.

ITS WESTERN.

BOTH IMAGES ON THE BOTTOM IN OPs PIC IS WESTERN WHICH DEFEATS HIS POINT YOU ILLITERATE FUCKING RETARD.

>> No.4044588

>>4044581
>ITS WESTERN.
Then what the fuck is your point, retard.
They're both western and ruining a japanese design

>> No.4044589

>>4044588
First, that clearly wasnt OPs intention.

Second, no, the one on the left isnt. I'd love to see you try to explain this instead of just admitting you were a fucking idiot.

>> No.4044594
File: 41 KB, 507x512, 1882fe008f7a57e5f2f2d51e3255f4fe219b5c2534a46b507a46690f003708af.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044594

This place always reminds me how obnoxious weebs are, arrogant cunts with less brain than a meth addict.

>> No.4044596

>>4044589
The problem is that you can't read. The Japanese design is being ruined by two different westashit "artists".

>> No.4044599

>>4044596
That literally isnt what the OP image is saying and you can clearly tell because of the fucking top half of the image.

Also again you've yet to say whats bad about the one on the left.

Why cant you just admit to being a dumb fucking retard? Digging a deeper hole isnt doing you any favors, dipshit.

>> No.4044610

>>4044599
You're just not smart enough to get it lol.
One more time for the sake of your lonely neuron
>top half is one example of a Japanese draftsman btfoing the westashit lesbian power fantasy doddler's work
>bottom half shows two examples of westashit hacks butchering a great Nihon design

>> No.4044613

>>4043760
I like flat chested adult women and these people manage to draw them in a way I find abhorrent. You can really tell that they just went flat because they wanted every bit of femininity removed. Bait OP aside I think this is what sets apart weebshit from this tumblr garbage, despite both being trash, weebshit is drawn with positivity in mind, "this is good", Western stuff is drawn with negativity in mind, "this is bad", it's the first time in history that artists have reasoned like this.

>> No.4044614

>>4044610
That, again, isnt whats happening.

And once more i'll ask whats wrong with the Samus on the left.

>> No.4044615

>>4044613
I'm also confused by her lack of ass. Its a skintight suit, even in somewhat thick material someones ass usually shows through on material if you have even a bit of muscle mass.

Is she wearing a fucking diaper?

>> No.4044617

>>4044589
>First, that clearly wasnt OPs intention.
>>>/x/
for you mindreaders

>> No.4044618

>>4044617
WHAT.

IS.

THE.

PROBLEM.

WITH.

THE SAMUS.

ON THE LEFT.

Answer my fucking question.

>> No.4044624

>>4044618
stop redditspacing, redditor.
>what's wrong
The fact that it's ruining a great and iconic design.

>> No.4044626

>>4044624
>"LE EBIN REDDIT XD SPACING XD"
>not answering the question

Fuck off retard.

>> No.4044630

>>4044626
I explicitly answered your question, redditor.

>> No.4044631

>>4044630
No, you didnt.

>> No.4044634

>>4043760
weebs ruined this board.

>> No.4044635

>>4044634
the autist to janitor ratio is too high

>> No.4044636

This shit is par for the course for the SJW rat den who works at Marvel they can't design attractive women in comics because it reminds them of their disgusting overweight bodies.

>> No.4044637
File: 178 KB, 840x781, 1508223846394.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044637

>>4044631
>Nu-uh

>> No.4044639

>>4044637
Nigga i asked you to explain how and what is the problem with the design and all you said is "it ruined it".

Explain your fucking shit, retard.

>> No.4044641

>>4044636
The Carol on the left was drawn be a cheesecake pinup guy who mostly draws sexy women.

The Samus on the left is from a Spaniard.

Stop eating bait you dumb fucking idiot.

>> No.4044645

>>4043760
Samus looks like a basedboy.

>> No.4044650
File: 118 KB, 405x456, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044650

>>4043760
>>4043766
>>4043791
>>4043794
>>4043874
>>4043900
>>4043902
>>4043933
>>4043963
>>4044010
>>4044512
>>4044531
>>4044575
>>4044576
>>4044588
>>4044596
>>4044610
>>4044617
>>4044624
>>4044630
>>4044637
>>4044645
>>4044636

>> No.4044655
File: 60 KB, 500x706, 1564256364874.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044655

>>4044639
*SNAP*
Yeah this goes straight into my cringe compilation

>> No.4044657
File: 172 KB, 337x334, [palpable disgust].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044657

>>4044655

>> No.4044664

>>4044581
>it is a different fucking design. Similar sure but it isnt the same design.
Ok, then I take away my argument.

Also good luck trying to untangle this mess these dyslexic fucks started, you have a lot of patience. Makes me wonder just how much information is completely deformed on a daily basis on this board and how much people actually communicate with success in here. Scary shit.

>>4044580
Skills mean nothing if it looks like shit.

>> No.4044669
File: 39 KB, 474x639, 148772376418.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044669

>>4044657
*SNAPS*
Thank you senpaii!! :3
Now my cringe folder is bigger than ever :ç
And all thanks to you :O You really are speciaru desudesu (h)

>> No.4044671

>>4044664
>Japs better, western bad

Stop this madness, you braindead zealots

>> No.4044680
File: 196 KB, 960x960, 1562442895963.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4044680

>>4044664
>a slightly different design is all it takes for your country to own the design
DaleDaleDaleDaleDaleOOO

>> No.4044709

>>4044680
You do understand that either way, OPs point was retarded because both images of Samus are western yet operating as if the one on the left, by spanish people, is Japanese when it isnt, correct?

>> No.4044717

>>4044709
Well, BR-kun here. >>4044680 has a point, the "Spanish version" pretty much keeps all the design in place, so it's more like a fanart or slight modification, while the right bit seems like a complete makeover, showing the artists "own vision" of how Samus should look like.

>> No.4044737

>>4044650
>>4043889
>two retards replying to >>4043766
cope landwhales, nothing said about east vs east in this post, only that the right could only be made by a cringe sjw

>> No.4044755

>>4044669
>>4044655
pls dont bea real person, pls dont be a real person.

>> No.4044764

>>4044626
Stop taking the bait you fucking autistic piece of shit.

>> No.4044794

>>4043760
Top right is shit though

>> No.4044800

>>4044755
please dont be from reddit, please dont be from reddit

>> No.4045409

>>4043874
>west is good for wholesome shit
>some big blue alien fag imposing his morals on everyone

>> No.4045478

>>4043889
You a subhuman or something? I didn't even mention a single thing about the bottom left picture. Neck yourself.

>> No.4045479

>>4045478
You bought into OPs bait, retard

>> No.4045481

>>4045479
Literally didn't even read what I posted, retard. You're just flailing in every direction like a moron knocking over furniture and claiming superiority when someone gets hit during your bout of tard rage. Finish your English class and reread the replies before you post, otherwise you just out yourself as the biggest mongoloid in this thread.

>> No.4045483

>>4044669
im gonna save these anime girls and stuff them in my fap folder so i can fap to them sometime later today.

>> No.4045484

>>4043760
those are some pretty shit examples of different cultural philosophies for character art, but at least the bottom left seems most faithful to the source material?
>>4045479
>>4045481
>1 line of retarded dialogue gets an essay of 3rd degree scalding reality
this place is alright sometimes, between the symbol drawers and the shitposters

>> No.4045489
File: 70 KB, 823x823, Absolute Kek.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4045489

>>4045481
Touched a nerve, did i?

>> No.4045500
File: 493 KB, 1017x1500, 1564458263405.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4045500

this is now a thread for sharing your favorite western arts of eastern characters and vice versa

>> No.4045506
File: 247 KB, 750x479, 5E6FDB54-CF7B-4985-8BD7-348365AD253D.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4045506

Personally, I like the bottom right. Maybe it’s cause I’ve seen it on twitter tho and I just like that style overall.

>> No.4046278
File: 33 KB, 471x315, 550x367_9DB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4046278

argentina skills

>> No.4046328
File: 128 KB, 1078x1080, 1563625623902.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4046328

>>4043760
Western lefties are against the beauty itself, because the beauty is an natural inequality.
The very fact that some people are born better than other goes against their narrative
>everybody is beautiful, especially if the fat disgusting fucks
>everybody is capable it's just evil white men stole everything
>everything is normal the fucking straight people monopolyzed reproduction because they are evil
and the other retarded suppositions which are if you look of them nothing but coping mechanisms of the inferior people.

>> No.4047717

>>4046328
>Western lefties are against the beauty itself, because the beauty is an natural inequality.
This, thats why the hate traps and dfc (delicious flat chest)

>> No.4047829
File: 55 KB, 652x320, wellhowaboutthat.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4047829

>>4043760

>> No.4047844

Stop licking the nip cock so bad

>> No.4047863

>>4043760
it baffles me that people think the bottom right looks good, it doesn't even look like samus anymore. not just because of the shitty dyke cut or man body, but not even the fucking face looks remotely like her. honest to god i don't understand why these twitter "redesign" faggots think so highly of themselves and how people eat it right up. it just looks like shit and you can tell no fucking effort or thought was put in other than they wanted "woke" points

>> No.4047975
File: 927 KB, 480x270, giphy.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4047975

>this whole thread

>> No.4048279
File: 440 KB, 280x304, tumblr_ox54awwCQ61tbq54wo1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4048279

>>4047975
>looking at all the guys trying to take the highground by typing increasingly agressive and faux cringy things

>> No.4048291

>>4043874
>west is good for wholesome shit
Nah, west used to be good for trad art.
Western cartooning remain universally shit and have been since capeshit and modern animation took over.

>> No.4049094
File: 399 KB, 483x495, cayup.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4049094

>>4043760
man that trash ass, how-to-anime lookin Captain marvel.

cease.

>> No.4049120

>>4043760
>top right
>improved
NGMI, kill you are self

>> No.4049609

I thought I was on /v/.

>> No.4049842

>>4043760
>Top Left
Terrible 1st year comic artist trying to copy Jim Lee and failing terribly
>Top Right
Basic weeb shit, nothing special like all anime
>Bottom Left
Okay senpai art. Looks like Samus Zero suit. Otherwise plain
>Bottom Right
It's a concept for Samus and it should stay a concept. BUT would look badass in the Warframe universe as an Operator suit and I'd pay platinum for it

>> No.4050795

Pyw