/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Because your mom niggerfaggot. Fortnite.

>>3914810
The right is much better.

The composition is better, left is le tits and retarded faces, right actually seems like there was some thought put into it. I guess if the right version was rendered more painterly while retaining its core rules, then it would be even much better.

You should kill yourself if you think left is any good btw.

>>3914810
soul soulless

>>3914814
>"people should kill themselves because my taste is shit"
begs btfo'd

>>3914820
>his taste is shit
>says the person who eats literal shit

>>3914814
>The right is much better.

>>3914814
>pillow shading and shitty hair
>good
funny joke

>>3914810
Because there is still an stigma against anime
That's why live action remakes are still a thing, even though they're always horrible compared to the source

>>3914810
source of left pic?

>>3914823
then brush your teeth shitbreather

>>3914810
Just here to say right is so much better.

Fuck anime, my dude.

>>3914826
>shitty anatomy and shitty form
I don't know, dude...

bc it looks nice. Even if they messed up the horns and I can't tell what the hell that meat blob under her neck is supposed to be

>>3914814
right is literally a photo with a filter, the only painted parts like the horns, hair, and all the background are beg tier. Also anything below the shopped fingers was literally beg-painted to create an arm of sorts.

you really showed us anon.

>>3914810
Shuten Douji is very sexy and cute

>>3914870
How can a girl be both sexy and cute, moron.

>>3914870
>Make porn outfit.
>Say it’s not hentai.
>Profit.

>>3914810
There's something really off-putting about the horns on the right. I think this design doesn't work as well when made semi-realistically.

>>3914876
iirc the fate guys asked a doujin artist to do the design for this character.

>>3914810
right is the definition of souless, the dude couldnt even be bothered to get the eye color for the character correct, he just wanted to make a quick dollar, fucking whore

>>3914810
How can the right one even compare when left one has already reached perfection

>>3914810
because Your style / My styke

>>3914876
everything its hentai, but some hentai has more plot than other

>>3914814
lol right is the photo of that meme girl with the pigeon

>>3914814
>>3914823
>>3914846
>>3914844
Shit taste.

>>3914870
I want to fuck it

>>3914810
Who is the artist?

>>3914810
I'm with you on this.
Right looks like the artist just traced over a photo and slapped some horns and a similar hairstlye.

Honestly, what the fuck is wrong with these realismfags? Most of the art I see is traced from photos. I get it, most artists need a reference, that's okay. But these people are often following the reference so much the result just looks photobashed in the end.

>>3914810
Because normies like seeing what fake characters would look like if they were real.
>>3914814
I agree, the right is better. They're both shit though.

>>3914810
WHO DREW THE LEFT ONE

>>3915130
Yang-Do
This is the guy that made an excellent Mordred doujin iirc

>>3914810
>tfw can't do left or right
Why?

>>3914810
who painted the right one??

>>3915149
Woah can I get a red line on that torso? It looks super long.

>>3915153
reminds me of that artist who made those odd posts in the alt threads. about how movie companies were stealing his ideas and how he's enslaved to produce art by some unknown persons with malignant intent toward him. forgot name and twitter.

>>3915174
I can see what you mean, but Jace's art really doesn't look like that at all. He's got a better aesthetic.

>>3915149
yang-do's a beast

>>3914810
Because it's fun. Stop being so autistic.

>>3915149
why is her torso so loooong!?

>>3915200
>>3915164
clearly there is a second dude under her skirt

>>3915149
me under the skirt

you can still enjoy both! and see that they can be good in different ways

>>3914873
Sounds like you are the moron

>>3915149
oh god himself I see
literally the hottest doujins there is

>>3914873
>look at the face
damn she cute
>look at the body
dick: damn she sexy

done

idk fellas, they both look good to me but for different reasons.

People like seeing different takes on things they enjoy or putting their own spin on things. This is why realistic Pokemon renderings, gender swaps, and modern day Disney princess re-imaginings are popular.

There is nothing wrong with re-imagining character designs anymore than there is anything wrong with remixing a song - it's a matter of if the person executing the revision/redux is shit or not.

Not sure why this is hard to understand.

>>3915914
lel

>>3914810
The form, perspective push, and color selection is much much better on the left. If you can't acknowledge that you're a tastelet who things realistic = technically superior by default.

>>3914814
I don't disagree, because it just looks like right isn't fully finished. Needs more highlights and core shadows. The right also has a sexier gesture, the right is just typical "porn girl gets raped" looking shit.

>>3914857
omg you fucking autistic fucks think any good artist is a filtered photo LMAO

>>3914810
It's just a copy of this photo...

>>3916034
Holy shit, delete this.

>>3916034
bros...

>>3916034
>>3915998
Get absolutely fucked. If it looks like a paint over of a photo, it probably is a paint over of a photo.

>>3916034
OH NO NO NO NO
IT WAS JUST SUPPOSED TO BE A STUDY BROS

>>3914873
Are you fucking retarded?

>>3914810
>>3916034
no fucking wonder her left wrist is so bad

>>3916034
LMFAO

>>3916034
ah, so it's soulless because it's based on an actual women

>>3914810
it's interesting to see how they'd look in real life, why does it need to be more or less than that?

>>3916161
Because it ALWAYS looks like generic girl#123498 traced in some shitty position with a 3/4 profile
>inb4 b-but all anime looks the same too
I'm not denying that anime artists can fall into the same meme, but somehow western patreon whores doing that thing OP points out manage to be thrice as creatively bankrupt. These "realism"fags are the worst, it's as if they had a catalogue of pre-rendered random people and just added whatever features some fotm anime character possesses on top. The girl on the right doesn't look anything like the one on the left, it's as if the artist drew some cosplayer.

>>3916052
I never said it wasn’t a photo copy I said it wasn’t filtered you stupid autistic fuckhead

>>3916034
it's even funnier because the dude fucked up so bad the parts the photo didn't show. what the fuck did he try to do in her back?

>>3915149
legs are fucked up too.

>>3914810
what did he try to do here?

>>3916034
OH NO NO NO HAHAHAHA
>>3916355
>backpedaling

>>3916034
ITS OGRE

>>3916034
At least right has good taste in girls.

>>3915998
LMAO indeed

>>3914810
is that the same guy that did pic related

>>3916666
Cool 3d trace

>>3915998
>>3916034
Look at this fucking kek

>>3916666
No, because your picrel looks like it's done by a half competent artist.

>>3914810
Because it looks better to non-autists.

>>3914810

for attention... also obviously heavily referenced. That's why it looks so "soulless" they just copied of a model photo.

>>3914814
I'm only replying because
>composition
its not, its a straight forward view of a girl. Its less dynamic and has less energy than the left. The left actually has a good composition, and her horns work with the gesture and the background. The right just has horns thrown on cause that's the character.
Plus the borders, the left opens up to allow the girl to rise out of the clothes, even if you cleaned up the right its just splattered all over the bottom and it looks like shit. It doesn't open up or lead into the woman, it covers up and makes her appearance behind a block as opposed to feeling elegant like the left.

Right has shit composition.

>>3914810
are there still retards who still believe like all of his works and arent copied/traced?

>>3916722
To be fair, in every single one of these the copy is better than the original.

>>3916722
That'll be going into my Ilya folder, thank you very much
Also to answer your question, if people don't realize it it's because they have never drawn themselves and don't get the process. That's why normalfags don't give a shit.

>>3916722
1. this isn't close to being traced
2. referencing is not a big deal, which this is referencing
3. fuck off and draw

>>3916739
>f-fuck off and draw
Don't forget to renew your patreon subscription, Kuvshinov needs it to keep producing 3/4 anime girl profiles! Keep that chromatic aberration high!

>>3916722
While the first two are the usual sasuga Ilya-tier, the third one is acceptable in my eyes. I mean the only similar things there are glasses and a pose.
>>3916739
Even if some of these are not traced or heavily referenced, the level of creativity is close to zero. I mean look at Kuvshinov's stuff. He didn't just want to draw characters and people "in his style", he often took some official art or a photo and just drew the exact same thing.

I liked him more when he was drawing fanart of Houkago Play. It had a soul. And it didn't have chromatic aberration.

I like both.

>>3914810
>some dude with a drawing program copies the work of an actual artist by taking a photo of some random girl and painting over it
>why do they do this
Money.
And since normies can't tell the difference between water and oil, it works.

>>3915998
>>3916034
lmao

>>3915124
Realism and digital art don't mix. It's almost always a trace or a photobash.

>>3914814
Wrong. The contrast on the left helps differentiate it from the background as opposed to the right which composition wise is worse and just blends together value wise.

Likely a shit post but if not NGMI.

>>3914810
who drew the one on the right?

what's the point of learning art if you're not going to fap to your own drawings?

>>3914810
Drawing an ugly cunt and calling it realism is not realism.

>>3916034
OH NON NOMONLOnpiojdspvfwe

>>3915998
>>3916034
HHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA

>>3915149
fucking triggered

>>3920175
>Complaining about fat thigh
fucking faggot

>>3920178

>>3920175
>>3920186
man /ic/ can be so embarassing sometimes

>>3920212
what do you mean sometimes?
its all the time anon. 24-7. embrace that shit.

>>3920175
soulless

>>3920175
the small hands thing is kinda dumb tho, it's obviously intentional to suit her character. looks fine, really.

i've seen some small fuckin hands in my life dude, and they weren't on small girls, either lol

>>3920444
eh, matter of opinon.

>>3920444
well, to be fair, everything he pointed is retarded, and he draws like one too, so...

Purely for fapping purposes. /thread

>>3920444
I am a grown ass man and I have had people grab my hands in shock and admire how small and delicate they are. It doesn't make me happy at all you dummies

>>3920625
at least you can masturbate pretending your hand is a cute girls's hand.

>>3920175
>>3920186
>>3920585
>This is the kind of faggot that give advice
lmao what an embarrassment

>>3920175
>>3920186
>>3920585
Delete your posts. Leave for a week and think about what you've done. Never namefag again.

>>3920585
kek

>>3914810
>why do they do this
Narcissism.

>>3914810
I hate it when I have to fix other lazy people's dang pictures. Still soulless but I tried.

>>3916034
>>3920175
Christ, what a fucking embarrassment.

>>3920585
KAWAIIII DESU

>>3921425
Don't worry anon, at least you tried.

>>3921425
her pinky still looks like a thumb

It's funny how you faggots manage to always be more embarrassing than bait OPs.

>>3917844
This. I don't think I've ever seen a "muh realistic" piece from a digital artist that wasn't a trace, "reference", or flat out filtered/painted photo.

>>3921867
>I don't think I've ever seen a "muh realistic" piece from a digital artist that wasn't a trace, "reference", or flat out filtered/painted photo.
>"reference"
But Anon, people have been using references to do art since dawn of time. There is nothing wrong about that.

>>3920957
>>>
why, am I making you uncomfortable?

>>3914810
i'm fucking tore. the other has good rendering but the other has more dynamism...

>>3914810
It looks bretty nice desu, love the eye candy colors

>>3914814

Everybody that replied is a retarded and merely coping. The right is far superior and you're wrong if you think otherwise.

>>3914810
>artist gives an obvious photo the "art" treatment
why do they do this

>>3924809
Only if you have shit taste, imagine liking such an obvious, stiff photobash
Just look at her fucking horns lmao

>>3916034
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>>3914814
i wish you were dead