/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

>>3894295
>lowqualitybait.jpg

>>3894297
Seething

and?

>>3894295
ngmi

opbp

don't drop such giant truth bombs in /ic/, the crabs will never survive

>>3894395
Cope

>>3894417
I accept your concession

>>3894423
Cope

>>3894295
You cheated not only the beginners but yourself.

You didn't grow.
You didn't improve.
You took a shortcut and gained nothing.

You experienced a hollow victory.
Nothing was risked and nothing was gained.

It's sad that you don't know the difference of what true artist are.

>>3894295
I agree. My phone's camera already made pseudo-realism crabs obsolete lmao
Just take a photo lmao

>>3894295
I would be inclined to agree, but posts like >>3894410 and >>3894440 show that most people just like the most generic and boring anime style possible.

>>3894511
Does this trigger you?

>>3894511
SEETHING loomiscuck

>>3894515
He's right you know.

>>3894514
>>3894515
You only go onto to prove my point. There is interesting and cool anime however you choose to draw dime a dozen “moe”. Which is quite possibly the most boring thing behind human photocopiers.

>>3894511
How ironic your post is.
There are multiple anime/manga styles, you would call them generic, but there is literally only one style of realism, and that's called... realism. It either looks like the real thing, or you missed the mark. In other words, generic.

Sorry that you've been replaced by phone cameras. I'll throw some money your way when I need to commission some pseudo-realism furry art.

>>3894295
>posting on an anime Image sharing website
Brave statement

>>3894525
This is so fucking generic and boring

>>3894524
Yeah? Does that trigger you? You mad about? Gonna start a thread about it? Cry like a little bitch about it?

Hey look at this. Pic related. LMAO I bet you're seething right now. I bet you just threw something across the room. lmao I gotta go, brb

>>3894524
I know, right? The only thing worse than that is those classic oil paintings that all... look the same...

>>3894525
>>3894534
In my original post I say I would be inclined to agree that anime > realism but most anime drawings are just as homogenized.

>>3894537
I know dude. It's almost like... all art from a specific style tend to share the same characteristics, except for the most extreme examples from those styles, which you're just pretending to care about because you're trying to be deep...

>>3894556
Expand your tastes.

>>3894563
Stop getting triggered by peoples' tastes.

>>3894563
This! I'm so fucking deep because I pretend to care about this ugly ass drawing where the dude makes all the eyes look like pointy triangles. Because at least it's different!

You know what, maybe there's a reason when you're drawing realism, you draw eyes to look like eyes and not a fucking penis. Because that's how eyes are supposed to look. I don't give a fuck if you think that's generic. No one thinks you're special.

>>3894570
Where’s the “deep” thing coming from? Can you seriously not appreciate different stylization in art, is that pretentious to you?

>>3894571
I love stylization. You're taking it to an extreme though, because you want me to think you're deep. Sorry, not buying it. You're not special just because you draw penises coming out of a character's eye sockets.

>>3894571
You're not fooling anyone, Mr. Penis Eye Man!

>>3894524
>MOE BAD

>>3894613
kek i think this image would be much funnier if nobody else was eating, but only saber had the rice bowl

>>3894295
>start drawing for anime
>immediately lose interest in anime and want to paint realistic paintings

What is the difference between anime tiddies and realism ones

>>3894527
I hold dear to your autobiography.

>>3894655
Anime artists like Asanagi draw ugly tumors that don't even look like boobs and make the proportions look all retarded

>>3894295
I trained into both and i gotta say
> Realism >>>>>>Anime
Anime looks cool and all , but it's not as satisfying as when you get all that knowledge about the human body and apply it in a realistic drawing.Also you can twist it as much as you want from there.

>>3894686
>get all that knowledge about the human body and apply it in a realistic drawing.Also you can twist it as much as you want from there.
Isn't that the point of half of animu art though?

>>3894698
It is, but can be used for other twists too, just give it a try, you will see it's fun.

>>3894410
>>3894440
>>3894514

>>3894511 is right, pretty genric art style and heavy same face.


>>3894515
This is pretty alright and expressive.

>>3894686
I think it really depends on what do you want out of art. If you want to tell a story, anime is superior. If you want to make something pretty, realism is better.
Just my opinion though, i think super polished anime art is cringy.

>>3894525
There's no point in stylization if all of your faces start looking the same.

>>3894702
Sure, let me just use some of my broad anatomical knowledge...
;_;

... I get you though. Also depends on what you want to achieve.

>>3894706
>heavy same face
How disingenuous. If you're going to be that loose with the term "same face," then you could practically accuse just about anything of "same face."

I can understand wanting something different from the norm, but go too far and you're just asking for something that isn't even anime/manga style.

>>3894710
I can agree with that.
>>3894713
Goodluck fren, don't give up.

>>3894706
>>3894711
sameface

>>3894727
lol
I'm just going to use that whenever I want to shit on something. Just accuse the artist of sameface. You can't argue against it because it's so subjective, apparently.

>>3894722
>>3894727
>>3894729
I consider something sameface when you can basically switch the hairstyles of two different characters and they'd look same. It's weak character design and that's what annoys me about it.

>>3894735
>>3894711
samehair lol

>>3894711
>>3894735
samegloves

>>3894737
I question your eyesight.

>>3894738
Never mind fuck, I concede.

>>3894735
Yeah I get that, but you're being really liberal with the examples. If you took Saber's hair and put it on that tambourine girl, it would look like a totally different character. Maybe you just don't like the over-cartoonization, but don't know how to put it into words?

Western influenced anime look great honestly. I think people dislike anime style mostly because of the subject matter

>>3894754
This has less to do with the subject matter and more to do with Takahashi being really good

>>3894749
I'm not dumb enough to accuse all faces of looking the exact same, but the differences are so minor and insignificant that it all starts to melt into each other. Artists that suffer from a certain degree of sameface have an overreliance on hairstyle, hair color and eyecolor. Sometimes they also make sure their characters all look like they are stuck in one particular emotion they always express to some degree with their face to hide sameface. This dosen't completely kill certain artpieces for me, it just amkes them less memorable than they could be. It's kind of a shame.

>>3894440
> Can’t see well enough to tell difference between photos and life.
> thinks he’s an artist.

Honest opinion on sameface from very popular artist?

>>3894770
lol that's hilarious

>>3894770
On this sameface in particular? I personally don't like the Nasuverse shovelface.
If you're asking in general, it really depends on the artist.

>>3894769
anon, look at the format of that post you're replying to
you should know better than responding seriously to a shitpost

>>3894770
Two of the same-faced characters are twins though

>>3894770
>One angle man

>>3894417
>>3894423
>>3894298
Calm down NGMI dads.

>>3894778
>Shovelface
Holy shit that perfectly describes it

>>3894770
It's uniquely his. Nice to that he managed to evolve past that early 2000s doujin look.

>>3894295
agreed

>>3894295
westernish anime > all

>>3894781
You’re right!
I have not been here regularly for a while:)

The people who say all anime looks the same and the people who say all classic art looks the same are literally two faces of the same coin.
They should get a visual cortex transplant,

>>3895061
I don't think anyone says "all art looks the same" we say "all the faces look the same" because it's hard to draw faces that look cute and not shit

>Not enjoying both generic and non-generic anime styles
This thread is full of disgusting plebs

>>3894295
Semi realism has the benefits of look satisfactory to create while looking highly skilled to the average viewer, It only simplifies by not adding in 100% real time rendering and finer details like pores, skin patches, individual hairs etc.

If an artist can achieve photo realism from scratch without a reference they have basically mastered human anatomy.

stylized art can look interesting but majority of the time it is used by people simply breaking the rules of anatomy instead of mastering them to a point where then can bend the rules, this results in the infamous "my style" excuse when critiqued.

>>3895164
This. Semi realism is incredibly satisfying to draw.

>>3894770
Takeuchi might be one of the only artists where sameface is actually a legit criticism and not just the artist drawing the sameface because they find it pretty while still being able to draw it from other angles. He just can't draw any other face or the saberface from any other angle and even the males have the exact same face, except when they're a gaijin or old man in which case the face has some random wrinkles and geometric nose neither of which could possibly have been stylized from anything that exists in reality. Wada's saber and nero look like completely unrelated people compared to any saberface made by Takeuchi.

>>3894511
What a faggot if you don't like cute girls just shut the fuck up and draw bara men we get it you like sweaty oiled up muscles you made the ricardo meme a thing that's okay just AAAAAAAAAAAAA LEAVE THE CUTE ANIME GIRLS ALONE THEY'RE ALL I HAVE AAAAAAAAAAA REAL GIRLS DON'T EVEN LOOK AT ME

>>3894580
>>3894590
There's npthing wrong with drawing cartoons you autistic samefag.

>>3894531
Do you hear yourself anon?