/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

>>6899670

>>6812455

>>4226216
>Because its dull its wrong.
Do you not see composition as a fundamental aspect of art that can be criticized and improved?

>That is an actual fix to the original piece you fucking idiot.
Yes, that is what the redline did. Actually fixing it.

>>4226212
You both have a very myopic vision of what a redline can do. Why does a redliner have to limit themselves to whatever arbitrary set of aspects that you decide on?
I personally have learned a lot from these type of high effort redlines, and I don't see why other people can't. If anything, it is you who is underestimating how well people can learn.

With such a pussyfooting attitude against redlining, people like teal would've existed and I learned a hell lot from his stuff.

>>3969717
We had it real good with Teal, you can't reiterate this enough he was a treasure trove of redlines and personalized critiques. But then just like right now some buttmonkey who sperged out each and everytime Teal posted we would have a shitstorm very much like this one.

>>3969719
Yes exactly.

>>2222278

why not start a thread about japanese artists drawing lolis.