/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

>>3098711
>there's some exceptional weeb-tastic anons there for sure

This is a varied board with many styles. Us pointing out that a weeb style is good for pandering to a weeb audience and fits the aesthetic just fine apparently makes us all weebs. Well, whatever helps you to convince yourself to disregard any critique (which is hilarious considering these "edits" were critiques the original creator should take on, according to you guys. The irony.).

This is why you know nothing about design, you can't even come to this conclusion on your own.

You're all speaking from the viewpoint of people who are biased since you don't like yandere simulator. This is why you are so nitpicky and unnecessarily critical for the stupidest things.
We are all unbiased and speaking from the position of artists who have experience and an eye for art/design, we couldn't give 2 fucks about this guy, just the work.

>But hey, everyone has their own tastes and /ic/ is no exception.

Critique is not taste. Your edits removing shit like "antenna" = your taste, which is why people got irritated when you tried to pass off projecting your personal preference as criticism.
Us telling you why your edits are objectively worse and unappealing is fact, not opinion, not taste.

I would say that almost nobody in the thread likes the OG art, it's very amateur and western weeb.
But did your "fixes" improve on it? No way in hell, they all look worse objectively.
Don't act like we are biased and you are not.