[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / g / ic / jp / lit / sci / tg / vr ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug ] [ 4plebs / archived.moe / rbt ]

Support us on Patreon!

/diy/ - Do-It-Yourself

View post   

[ Toggle deleted replies ]
File: 38 KB, 700x700, gv12_04.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]
1593315 No.1593315 [Reply] [Original] [archived.moe]

What type of valve is best for daily use? I heard gate valves are NOT good for regular use

>> No.1593318

Gate valves are for on/off operation, fully open or closed.
Globe valves are more suitable for throttling applications.
Ball valves are for on / off operation, but many people still use them for throttling anyways.
There are special ball valves designed for throttling purposes.

>> No.1593321

I don't mean for throttling I mean for turning fully on and off once a day every day

>> No.1593328

The big thing that causes valve failure is lack of use. If you’re going to be using the valve every day, throw in a ball valve, it will be quicker and easier to operate.

>> No.1593343

A ball valve then is the best choice.

>> No.1593346


>> No.1593481

Ball valves are not meant to be turned on and off every day. With a gate, the packing gland material can be replaced
When it starts leaking. Good luck with a ball valve.
A real licensed plumber.

>> No.1593496

>Ball valves are not meant to be turned on and off every day.

Really, mr. licensed plumber? How about once per week? Month? Year? What exactly do you think they are for?

>> No.1593519

He has a point, a gate valve is something you can repair, when a ball valve takes a shit it’s done. However if you’re turning the valve on and off every day, a gate valve will require a new packing much sooner, it wouldn’t surprise me if once a year the packing needed to be replaced on a cheaper import valve. On a ball valve the packing is made out of Teflon instead of rubber, and since it’s only a quarter turn it doesn’t get near the friction that a gate valve does. If you install a quality ball valve it’s going to last you a long time before the packing gives out, probably decades. We’re kind of splitting hairs here, either valve is going to work fine, gate might require a little more maintenance, ball isn’t repairable, but if the guy is smart enough to install a ball valve I’m sure he’ll be smart enough to replace it in 20 years when it shits out on him. I would use a ball valve on my house, personally.

>> No.1593533

after about 4 or 5 years of turning a ball valve on and off once or twice a day i think you could probably write off the cost of about what $5? to replace a ball valve vs the $? to replace the packing gland?
nobody knows because gate valve suck and you haveto spend ages turning them. ball valve fast as fuck

>> No.1593799

Licensed plumber here.
Get a switch and use a washing machine solenoid. Bonus points for pictures.

>> No.1593826

We use ball valves everyday at work and throw them 20ish times an hour sometimes. Sometimes we throttle them. They work fine.

>> No.1593840

real plumber here. gate valves are outdated trash that have no use.
replace the packing? why? a ball valve will fail in 20 years after daily use. oh no, gotta go buy another 20 dollar valve what a shame. with gate, enjoy replacing that shit every few years when you find that small puddle of water under it.

ball or bust you fucking hack fraud buster

>> No.1593858
File: 2.66 MB, 300x169, 1554420139540.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

The question seems to be how long do you intend to be involved with this valve and does its failure imply a major problem? KISS

>> No.1593868

Like everything else, gate valves are useful in some applications. Ball valves work better when used regularly, gate valves have a better chance of working after long periods without use. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve come across a ball valve that is completely seized up after being installed new less than ten years ago. Gate valves get a bad rap, mostly because everyone switched to ball valves 30 years ago, so a majority is ball valves people come across are new, and a majority of gate valves are old. Ball valves need exercise or they seize up, gate valves can go longer without being touched and still operate properly, although the difference seems to be more prevalent in bigger pipe/valve sizes, 1 1/4” and up.

>> No.1593946

What the fuck are you guys doing that requires turning a valve on and off multiple times a day?

>> No.1594084

>nobody knows because gate valve suck
They have their uses like when you get to bigger diameter pipe and higher pressures. Ever tried to open a 3 inch ball valve with 180psi differential on it? You'll fucking break the handle off before you open it. Gate valves give you more mechanical advantage. For example boiler stop valves are gate valves.

>> No.1594087

>Get a switch and use a washing machine solenoid.
Do this if you want to cause water hammer.

>> No.1594088

Since you're a plumber, your playing with low pressure child's play pipe sizes. Gate valves are what real men use once they get above certain pressures and diameter.

>> No.1594377
File: 34 KB, 600x600, zone valve.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Or just get a water sprinkler zone valve.
They are high flow and won't hammer lines like a solenoid valve.
Fully rebuild-able and if you cobble up a 24VAC source they can be switched via a relay.

>> No.1596315
File: 30 KB, 678x593, face.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>ball valves are not meant to be turned on and off every day.

You have never used them apparently.

>> No.1596337

the question is, how damaging is a gate valve failure over a ball valve failure?

>> No.1596350

I work with steam, I had a gate valve fail on a 2"npt line with 150psi steam. The valve stem broke off from the disk. I had no idea it was broken, thought I released the pressure in the line. Pulled the bonnet off and there was the disk sitting there still holding the steam back. From my experience, gate valves tend to leak by over time but usually it's not a bad leak. Ball valves just leak everywhere and when they do fail inside it's the Teflon rings getting lose and wedging into the ball. Then you can't close the ball valves and they leak by like a motherfucker. No valve will give you 100% close for its life. If you're looking for 100% isolation you should get a block and bleed valve. Consists of 3 valves with one in the middle of the three being the bleed to atmosphere or a vessel to hold it.

>> No.1596575

>work in greenhouse
>water and chemical lines everywhere
>get used multiple times a day, every day
>100% ball valves

obvious choice is obvious

>> No.1597451
File: 337 KB, 478x464, disgust.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

>boy these plumbers sure are mad.

>> No.1598260

what is the red spinny part called and how expensive is it
searching gate valve finds what im looking for but theyre expensive as fuck

>> No.1598271

Regular use? Ball valve? What kind of ball vavle?

>> No.1598391
File: 2.10 MB, 4032x3024, CC5E6AA8-53F5-4DBE-88F9-4573883A80B8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]

Ball valves are always the best option

>> No.1598395

>Teflon O-rings
That’s your problem, epdm or viton rings don’t leak

>> No.1598617

Ball valve or butterfly valve for daily on usage. Material of valve is important based on what you're using it for. I work chemical process. If home usage (water lines i presume) use brass, steel (carbon steel will corrode over time though) or 304 SS (316ss preferred but not necessary)

>> No.1600620

Plumber here,
Gate valves aren't particularly good because they are relatively difficult to operate and not easy to tell if they are on or off at a glance. Over time the packing nut will degrade and the valve will cease to work. The easiest valve to operate and understand at a glance is a ball valve, though some models, particularly commercial model brass valves, take up quite a bit of room relative to their counterparts. Ball valves almost never malfunction like gates do.

Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.