/diy/ - Do It Yourself

Hey /diy/ I have an old Craftsman garage door opener that works fine when I press the button on the wall to open or close it but when I attempt to close it using pic related, or the keypad on the exterior of the garage, it will not close.
The weird thing is, it opens fine using the clicker or the keypad. I have made sure the sensors are not blocked by anything. I have googled the hell out of this and the only thing I found was some forum where a woman said her LED light bulb in the opener was causing the signal to fuck up?? I switched to a non-led and I am still getting the same problem.
Any ideas?