[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 36 KB, 650x366, 827687-aussie-meat-pie-and-sauce.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412659 No.6412659 [Reply] [Original]

When you hear the word 'Pie' do you think sweet or savory?

Which is more prominent in your country?

>> No.6412661

I'm from New York so all I can think of is pizza.

>> No.6412663

sweet, of course. just as any red blooded american would

>> No.6412664

>>6412661
question- is pizza pie:
a) just a different word for pizza
b) a deep dish pizza
or neither of the above

>> No.6412665

>>6412663
do americans have savory pies? in my head you having those gross chicken and vegetable pies we have here in australia but nothing else.

>> No.6412666

I'm from England so savory

>> No.6412667

>>6412659

asufag. I think of beef pie first, so savoury. savoury or meat pies are definitely more prominent, although fruit pies aren't at all hard to find.

I miss eating fruit pies, the sulphites fuck me up.

>> No.6412668

>>6412659
>australia shitposting
>>6412663
>euro shitposting
>>6412664
>meme pizza bait

I want you all to die in a fire

>> No.6412670
File: 49 KB, 630x300, Steak-and-ale-pie-630x300.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412670

>>6412659
>ketchup on savoury pie

Why do you have to ruin perfectly good pies, Australia? You might as well be being some bastardized sweet pie.

>> No.6412672
File: 11 KB, 320x276, veggie-pot-pie[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412672

I'm American and I think sweet when I hear the word pie. I'm not sure why we don't have a more prominent savory pie culture; it seems like something we'd be into considering all the other foodstuffs out here. I know there are places where you can get them, and I know some parts have some variant of pasty if that counts as a pie, but they're either very regional or uncommon. The only common savory pie in the US is probably potpie.

>> No.6412675
File: 57 KB, 620x387, pork-pie_2180207b.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412675

>>6412666
fuck me i miss these things

>>6412668
oh man, someone had a bad day :(

>> No.6412774

I think of a delicious Macleods meat pie.

>> No.6412782

>>6412670
Tomato sauce actually

>> No.6412784

>>6412668
Sounnds like you have a case of the mondays

>> No.6412786

>>6412665
>>6412672
What this guy said. Pot pie is the, aka pie filled with meat, veggies, and gravy is pretty much the only "American" savory pie that anyone eats. I personally think it's delicious and make it from scratch to use up leftover meat. Mostly it's eaten as a frozen food though. The Marie Callender brand of frozen pot pies is pretty much ubiquitous to the same level as Heinz is with ketchup, I'd say.

Americans know of savory pies, but we think of them in a sort of ye olde Britishe way if you know what I mean. They're the kind of thing you get at international cultural fairs and the sort.

>> No.6412789

>>6412675
>mfw im gping to be in the uk in a few days and my wifes nan is making me some to try. Cant. Fucking. Wait

>> No.6412828
File: 107 KB, 1600x1067, eelpie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412828

>> No.6412831

>>6412659

pie makes me think of pussy first, sweet pies later

>> No.6412844
File: 494 KB, 1440x1080, 3.1415926535897932.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412844

>> No.6412847

pussy, then sweet pies. then chicken pies, then i long for the taste of meat pies.

>> No.6412858
File: 119 KB, 500x375, pie-floater.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412858

meat pie floater master rave coming through

>> No.6412860

>>6412858
Is that ketchup?

>> No.6412861

Savoury, can't beat a good steak and ale.

>>6412844
>filename

>> No.6412889

>>6412860
tomato sauce, ausbro sauce isn't as sweet as catsup

>> No.6412927

>>6412659
Sweet. I've had many savory pies, but I will always take sweet. Maybe it is an american thing, but warm blueberry pie is the best pie.

>> No.6412950

Savoury. Love a nice homemade steak pie.

>> No.6412958

>>6412889
you sure? heinz tomato is similar to masterfoods. whats the main ketchup brand in usa?

>>6412664
can someone answer this

>> No.6412963

>>6412958
Isn't it just a literal name? Like beef pie is a pie based on beef, pizza pie is a pie based on pizza.

>> No.6412972
File: 63 KB, 451x482, savoury slicesml.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412972

>>6412786
man that sucks those pies are so weak

in this small town in south aus they make these things they call 'savory slices' - they're pizza on top and then a thin layer of pastry and then meat pie filling and then another layer. shits so fucking dope pic related

>> No.6412974

>>6412958

Heinz is the best-selling brand in the US.

>>pizza pie
A. It's just a different word for pizza. It doesn't mean anything special, it's just a different manner of speech.

>> No.6412980
File: 41 KB, 855x571, pizza-pie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6412980

>>6412963
as in a meat pie but with pizza filling in it? nah. thats a thing in australia though - http://www2.woolworthsonline.com.au/shop/ProductDetails?Stockcode=353678&name=balfours-pizza-pie-premium

>>6412974
right, thats what i thought. kind of annoying.

>> No.6412985

>>6412927
>Maybe it is an american thing, but warm blueberry pie is the best pie.

Probably. Because there's nothing quite as comfy as relaxing in the evening with a homemade steak and ale pie. It's a feeling sweet pies will never quite suit.

>> No.6412994

So in conclusion, Americans have only sweet pies and the rest of the world enjoys both delicacies.

>> No.6412997

>>6412980
Oh Australia. Is there anything you won't pie?

>> No.6412998

>>6412994
most of the time, yes. meat pies are for scraps, where americans have enough money to purchase good cuts of meat instead of eating cow lips and assholes.

>> No.6413002

>>6412985
If I want a similar type of cozy I do a nice pasty.

>> No.6413003
File: 15 KB, 254x264, 1368645501905.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413003

>>6412998
sucks you don't have the good kind of meat pie then i guess

>> No.6413007

>>6412998
Americans HAD enough money. Then all that money got condensed into the hands of like 20 people, and most Americans are now poor. But they never learned how to make lips and assholes taste good, so they go into debt buying filet mignon and overcooking it.

>> No.6413012

>>6413007
>what is soul food

>> No.6413016

>>6413012
Fair point well made.

>> No.6413031
File: 75 KB, 600x450, aussiepiewarmer.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413031

I'm in bed and this thread is killing me, 12 hours from now I'm going to destroy some bakery for lunch.

>> No.6413037
File: 118 KB, 400x230, 184.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413037

>>6413031
thats the most beautiful sight. not complete without these cunts

>> No.6413045
File: 132 KB, 400x235, 153.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413045

>>6413037
Fuuuuuuck yeeeeees. Chese kransky sausage on the middle wrapped in pastry for those who don't know.

>> No.6413047

>>6413037

Breddy good. Did you post the AB yesterday? Or is /ck/ just infested with Adelaide cunts?

>> No.6413048

>>6413012
There's definitely a cost efficient, healthy, and delicious way to be poor, and certainly plenty of muh fellow Americans do it. I try to just because thrifty, and less money on food is more money to other things. But you'll see people pulling shapes like buying bottled water with food stamps and it's like nigga what are you doing?

>> No.6413053
File: 51 KB, 400x300, ab3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413053

>>6413047
no, fuck i forgot about AB's

>> No.6413076

Murrica here, so pie will always be linked with sweet in my mind. I think the only savory pies we have here are pot pies... and I guess pizza too, technically.

Those meat pies you guys always post here look so damn good, especially the ones you can just pick up and eat, no fork required. Thinking of making some of my own this coming weekend, but there are so many variations I'm not sure where to start.

>> No.6413079

>>6413076
where do you live? jamaican meat pies are fucking delicious and very common in some parts of the states

>> No.6413100

>>6413079
California, but not near any of the melting-pot areas like San Francisco.

>> No.6413144

Savoury. I grew up in a village in Lancashire, and Wigan was the nearest large town to shop in. For some reason, people in Wigan really fucking love pies- pretty much every other shop on the high street is a pie shop, it's like the Starbucks of that town. So I think of chicken and mushroom, meat and potato, Scotch pies, steak and kidney, butter pies, minted lamb, etc.

The only common sweet pies in the UK that I can think of are apple, rhubarb and cherry, though I'd actually like it if we had more of a sweet pie culture, some of the pies common in the US sound really good.

>> No.6413333

sweet

sweet

>> No.6413339

Pie makes me think of sweet, or tart pies. A pot pie immediately brings to mind a savory meal.

>> No.6413342

>>6412659
pizza is not pie

>> No.6413346

>>6413342
>what is deep dish

Deep dish pizza is most definitely a pie.

>> No.6413347

Dutchfag here, I think of sweet pie. Especially apple and cherry. Apple pie can be ordered pretty much in any venue that servers coffee.

>> No.6413352
File: 163 KB, 1600x900, 1391952765506.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413352

>> No.6413706

>>6412786

are making pies from scratch economical and convenient? I currently cook for the house but mostly make stir fry because we don't have much money for food. I make it for my roommate as well, but he works a swing shift, so he takes my stir fry from the fridge and brings it to work with him the next day.

stir fry reheated in a microwave isn't too great so I have been searching for an alternative meal.

>> No.6413718

Sweet, unless you specify that it is a potpie or pizza. The first time I heard "pie" used to mean meat-filled whatsit was in a Charles Dickens novel.

>> No.6413729

Any Ausfags here, is this a good, legitimate recipe for Aussie meat pies?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKfhcQet-6M

Gonna try making it this weekend. Never had any sort of meat pie before, this seemed basic but tasty, not sure if I should add anything else like potatoes or cheese or whatever, or go for a different recipe?

>> No.6413730

>>6413352
wut

>> No.6413732

>>6413045
So it's a sausage roll?

>> No.6413740

>>6413346
No it isn't. A pizza is made with bread, a pie is made with pastry.

By your logic a sandwich is a pie.

>> No.6413743
File: 32 KB, 310x471, mclobster-3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6413743

>>6413730

>> No.6413746

>>6413346
its a pie but not a pizza right niggaz?

>> No.6413747

>>6413729
>meat pies
>Australian

You're a special kind of stupid.

>> No.6413751

>>6413746
No, it isn't.

>> No.6413760

>>6413747
>implying there are no meat pies in australia

>> No.6413766

>>6413760
Well no shit Australia eats meat pies, you are just south brits.

>> No.6413917

>>6413747
I just said I'd never had a meat pie before, and I also clearly just looked up the pie referenced in the OP. Hence why I asked about them. Thanks for the helpful suggestions, ya cunt.

>> No.6413953

>>6413917
No, you posted that pies are Australian, like a complete fuckwit American.

>> No.6413972

We don't really do pies much in my country and when we do, they're split 50/50 sweet/salty.
There are no pie shops or anything like that.

We do have shops that sell pasty-like foods, if pasties count as pies, though. Our pasties are always salty.

>> No.6413979

>>6413953

He didn't say that all meat pies were Australian.
He did ask for a recipe for an Australian-style meat pie.

Get it now?

>> No.6413989

>>6413953
>what is reading comprehension

>> No.6413997

>>6413979
And there's no such fucking thing as "an Australian meat pie" you dumb shit burgers.

>Hey guys is this a good recipe for Zimbabwean burgers

>> No.6414004

>>6413972
When you say salty, do you mean savoury? I can't imagine salty being a filling I would ever go for, but then the Scandis do like that salted liquorice.

>> No.6414009

>>6413989
Something you clearly lack.

>Any Ausfags here, is this a good, legitimate recipe for Aussie meat pies?

>Hey guys, is this a good recipe for Russian fried chicken?

>> No.6414028

>>6413997
>And there's no such fucking thing as "an Australian meat pie"

There isn't?

>>Hey guys is this a good recipe for Zimbabwean burgers

Uhm, you know that burgers generally have different recipes depending on where they are made, right? For example, American burgers are generally made with 100% beef patty, whereas the recipes I see in English cookbooks tend to be more of a meat-loaf style with lots of breadcrumbs and whatnot.

>> No.6414034

>>6413997
>And there's no such fucking thing as "an Australian meat pie" you dumb shit burgers

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meat_pie_%28Australia_and_New_Zealand%29

>> No.6414048
File: 25 KB, 400x407, U stencil m8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414048

>>6414028
>whereas the recipes I see in English cookbooks tend to be more of a meat-loaf style with lots of breadcrumbs and whatnot.

>> No.6414055

>>6414034
YA BURNT

>> No.6414056

>>6414048

Google Jamie Oliver's burger recipe. He, like many others, seem to think that you need to add crackers/breadcrumbs, eggs, and such in the patty. Come to think of it, even fucking Ramsay had a cook put breadcrumbs, etc, in the hamburger patties on one of the episodes of Kitchen Nightmares.

anyway, point is that regional variations of foods exist.

>> No.6414057

>>6414034
Yes anon, you linked an article from wikipedia, you deserve a banana sticker.

Just because someone adopts something from another country, it does not make it belong to the adoptive country.

There is no such thing as an Australian meat pie because it existed long before they were colonised, you stupid, stupid fuck.

>> No.6414063

>>6414056
That sounds like bullshit, I haven't ever seen that in my life.

>> No.6414066

>>6414057
>There is no such thing as American English because the language existed before North America was colonized

>> No.6414071

>>6414056
>regional variations of foods exist.
No shit.

What does that have to do with a carbon copy of something and Ameriblobs thinking the copy is the only one in existence because you are beyond ignorant?

>> No.6414072

>>6414057
>There is no such thing as an Australian meat pie because it existed long before they were colonise

Christ bro, we're not talking about the history of the dish or who invented it. Dial back the Autism knob a bit.

Anon simply asked for a recipe for a meat pie the way they are typically made in Australia. That is perfectly reasonable as I would expect meat pies to have different ingredients depending on where they are made.

>> No.6414077

>>6414066
That's correct, there is no such thing as "American English".

There is English and then there is incorrect English, like a child would use before being corrected by someone who knows better.

What does this have to do with your stupid claim that pies are Australian? Is this your retard attempt at saying Austria, as in Europe, the home of pies?

>> No.6414083

>>6414072
>Dial back the Autism knob a bit.
he doesnt know how anon

>> No.6414089

>>6414077
That wasnt me, but you sound like a faggot Man City fan.

I'm just saying that if you get your dick and balls all stuck up you ass because someone asked for a recipe for an Australian meat pie, instead of referring to LE EPIC ENGLISH PIE, then you have a special and severe brand of autism.

>> No.6414090

>>6414072
>Gets shown to be talking shit
>C-calm t-that a..autism

No, he asked for a recipe to make "Australian pies" and considering no such thing exists, you get this train crash of a thread. Americans truly are the most ignorant people on this Earth.

>> No.6414092

>>6414071
>What does that have to do with a carbon copy of something

It's not a carbon copy. That's the point. For example, if you asked the average American for a "meat pie", they'd expect what we call a "chicken pot pie": unbrowned chicken, a white sauce, and veggies like carrots and peas. I've never been to Australia but according to the wiki article (and what I see on Google) the Aussie ones tend to be a brown gravy, red meat, and are often served with ketchup. I don't claim to be an expert on the latter but that sure is a different recipe than what one would get in the states.

>>copy is the only one in existence

Nobody ever said that. Someone simply asked for the recipe for that version. They didn't say it was the only one or the best one.

>> No.6414097

>>6414089
Can I get a recipe for Iranian Tennessee barbecue?

>> No.6414101

>>6414090
>considering no such thing exists

But that's not true. It's clear from a basic google search that the recipe for a "meat pie" is different depending on where that pie is made.

>> No.6414104

>>6414092
Do you live in some sort of bubble which shields you from the world?

How many times does it have to be repeated to you that there is no such thing as an Australian pie?

>> No.6414110

>>6412659

since your image is bias, I think of apple pie.

>> No.6414115

>>6414101
No shit it's different depending where it's made, pie is an unbelievable umbrella term.

This has no bearing on someone claiming that particular pie, or even all pies, are Australian when they were all eaten long before Australia and burgerland were even discovered.

>> No.6414119

>>6414104
>there is no such thing as an Australian pie?

I reject your autism, anon.

Would it make you any less buttmad if anon had asked for "a recipe for a meat pie the way they are usually made in Australia"?

>> No.6414123

>>6414110
Why did Americans stop eating meat pies? You held out for years until the apple trees grew to make apple pies, yet the perfect food for frontiersmen was simply dropped from use.

>> No.6414132

>>6414119
Now I suspect you are just shitposting, nobody is this retarded.

Why the fuck did you even bring Australia up in the first place?

>> No.6414137

>>6414123
>the perfect food for frontiersmen

you mean chili?

>> No.6414142

>>6414132
>being this mad about losing the empire

>> No.6414149

>>6414137
>Pie
>Any filling you have at hand
>Perfect for bulking out ingredients during hard times
>Filled with calories
>The pastry keeps it warm for hours
>The pastry allows easy transportation
>The pastry is made from some of the most basic food staples
>Tastes great

Pies are literally the best outdoors food and there is a reason they were used as such.

>> No.6414155

>>6414142
So you are just a shitposter, I should have known, but with Americans it's always hard to tell, the line between retard and shitposter has considerable overlap.

>> No.6414161

>>6414155
>implying I'm American
>implying that wasn't my first post in this thread
stay mad

>> No.6414166

>>6414004
Yes, savoury. We don't have a word for 'savoury.' Things are categorised as 'sweet' or 'salty/salted.'
Even if you try to google translate the word 'savoury' it just comes back as 'salty.' It's kinda weird, because our cognate word for 'savoury' just means 'flavoursome.'

>> No.6414167

>>6414137
Why not just have the best of both worlds and have a chilli pie? They are great.

>> No.6414171

>>6414166
After spending time on /int/, I thought it was something like that.

Tell us about the few pies that you do and the pasties you get where ever you are. While pasties aren't pies, they do belong in the same category "pasties, pies and sausage rolls".

>> No.6414176

>>6414063
I see it all the time on Brit tv shows. I don't personally know any Brits who don't put binders in their burgers. It drives me absolutely batty.

>> No.6414178

>>6412664
i always assumed people do that because of how fun it is to say "EY-A-PIZZA-PIE" in a shitty italian accent

im stoned though so idk

>> No.6414180
File: 81 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414180

>>6414123

American meat pies are basically 'pot pies' usually filled with chicken or turkey, sometimes beef, and carrots, peas, celery, onions. They are kind of synonymous with really low-income households, because here in 'Merrica the supermarkets stock them in mass, for like .60c~$1.00

Thus, meat pies, for the most part are very tiny portioned, low quality, and equated to rednecks, abusive fathers, struggling families etc. The only kind of savory pie I've had that was decent was a quiche, which is basically a pie crust filled with eggs, potatoes, veggies, and of course cheese, being american. My mom used to make those sometimes and they were quite good, especially with chillis and peppers, a sort of southwest influence.

Pic related: they are aforementioned shitty pot-pies.

>> No.6414185

>>6414176
Britfag here. This annoys me to no end aswell. There is no reason to add breadcrumbs and/or egg as a binder in a burger when you have decent fatty meat

>> No.6414188

>>6414180
I know that your only savoury pie is that weird chicken soup thing, but my question was why did you stop eating them? The pilgrims were British after all and like I said, they waited for years to grow apples just to make apple pies and out of nowhere you just stopped having pies other than sweet ones.

>> No.6414206
File: 287 KB, 1200x900, 1419803655493.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414206

Nout better than going to the bakery and getting something hot/

>> No.6414215

>>6414188

My guess is that making a filling and making a pie-crust seems like and awful lot of work, just to combine them into a single presentation.

Actually, if you walk about pioneer food, americans, even today in the south make cornbread, which was basically a 'dutch oven' (large cast-iron skillet) filled with corn and baked after being covered in coals, or just hung from fireplace. I guess it seems easier to portion foods out on a plate rather than combine them, but that's where a sandwich comes in.

The origin of sweet pies is kind of a mystery, i don't really know why all pie crusts are filled with sweet stuff, I would guess its a german thing? I would guess lots of struddels have an influence, and maybe a pie is a family sized portion of that.

btw, pumpkin pie was probably the first real american pie, not apple or cheery or meat pie: pumpkins could be taken into a sweet or a savory direction, and pumpkins saved the lives of colonists because of how often they grew around new-england.

>> No.6414221

>>6414215

*er, cornmeal, as well as other spices

>> No.6414235

>>6414215
>The origin of sweet pies is kind of a mystery
What? They came from Britain along with your pilgrims, who ate both and my question was why when they ate both, did they drop one and keep making the other.

Not only that, they had to plant the apple trees, which aren't native to America, and wait years for them to bear fruit before making an apple pie.

You had the patience to wait all that time for fruit pies, yet savoury pies are too much effort? Seems unlikely.

>> No.6414236

>>6414171
The pasty-like foods are generally just stuffed with cured meats and cheeses. Sometimes with a sauce or gravy depending on the type of cheese used. Other times, they're just cheese.
They're nothing special. Vegetarian Punjabi immigrants have introduced curried ones stuffed with mixed veg and those are pretty delicious, too.

As for the pies, those are a bit difficult to even google for because we don't have a word for 'pie.' The word for 'pie' is the same word as for cake, bread, tarts and, in some retarded dialects, sandwiches.
But here are some of the undeniably pie-like pies we make:
Salty/salted/savoury ones include spinach and cheese, ham and potato, artichoke/cardoon, zucchini and curds (similar to quiche, but more creamy), caramelised onion and saltfish with eggs (also similar, if not identical, to quiche).

Sweet ones include various versions of cheese cake, various fruit pies (plum and apple seem to be the most common fruits we use for sweet pies), our version of pumpkin pie (doesn't have all the spices the American one does, just a spice that's cousin to cardamom and sometimes vanilla essence), various cream/custard pies and one of the stranger ones, blood and chocolate with almond essence (yes; blood pie is sweet).

>> No.6414244

>>6414236
>Vegetarian Punjabi immigrants have introduced curried ones stuffed with mixed veg
Are you by any chance Dutch?

Yeah, most of those pies are eaten in Britain too, except for pumpkin pies which are seen as an American thing and pumpkins aren't really eaten here. and blood pies, we prefer our blood in the form of black pudding.

>> No.6414252

>>6414235

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Appleseed

little bit of american history/folklore

You should keep in mind that the modern version of pies is probably a matter of preference as to why pies in the USA are mostly sweet 'desert' pies, instead of savory ones. I've always refered to 'pie' as sweet, maybe because it's part of a 3-course meal, or appetizer, main dish, and desert where pies fit the strudel definition.

Honestly, I can't recall a time when I wanted too or even had the option of eating a savory meat pie, in the UK/English sense, because there are so many more options to eat out there. Even traditional american meals are pasta, roasts, sandwiches, burgers, chicken dishes, etc...

But think of this; Pizza is referred to as a pie sometimes here, which kinda fits the definition of a pie: a crust and a filling, that happens to be savory. Something like pasties and stuffed breads are still a thing, especially in the Midwest.

>> No.6414266

>>6414252
Don't bring up the Michigan insults. May the UP forever burn for what it did to Cornwall.

>> No.6414269

>>6414266
>implying cornwall makes good cornish pasties
Everyone knows the best "Cornish" pasties come from Devon.

>> No.6414270

>>6414252
You have to use a very loose definition to call a pizza a pie. A pizza is bread with toppings, a pie is made using pastry and has a filling.

>> No.6414272

>>6414266

I don't know what UP is other than a direction

>> No.6414277
File: 51 KB, 616x462, American abortion.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414277

>>6414269
Don't start this now, we have a common enemy.

Have you seen the jokes that Michigan calls an "authentic pasty"?

>> No.6414286

>>6414272
The Upper Peninsula or UP for short is a region of Michigan. They call themselves Yoopers.

The region had Cornish miners who brought the pasty with them. In time the yokel locals started ripping them off and making fucking god awful copies.

In this day they are for some reason proud of what they make and either claim it as a local creation or give credit to fucking Finland of all places.

May god destroy that disgusting region.

>> No.6414293

>>6414270

I see what you're trying to do: you're arguing with semantics and that's dumb. Pie has always been a crust and filling, and defining it as a pastry-dough is a modern definition for a sweet, not a savory pie.

>> No.6414295

Meheeco, i think about feet

>> No.6414297

>>6414277
>common enemy
Leave the Welsh out of this. They can gogogofuck themselves.

>> No.6414298

>>6412659

I think of a nice meat pie first. Then, a mince pie.

England here.

>> No.6414310

>>6414293
You're a fucking idiot.

>> No.6414316

>>6414286

huh.

I'd say a coup lakes and climate. The result is some lack luster food, when it comes to the starch department; meats and stews however are another story.

>>6414310

thanks, thank you.

>> No.6414319
File: 2.36 MB, 260x260, Welshman pulls.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414319

>>6414297
I wouldn't call the Welsh our enemy, that denotes that they are human beings.

>> No.6414326

>>6414316

*I'd say a couple things, USA has some really shitty bread nationwide, and a lot of that part of the country, near the great lakes, has a lot of Scandinavian influence, because of the lakes and climate.

my laptop derped.

>> No.6414331

>>6414326
I know the entire history of that shitty region. May they forever suffer for their insult.

>> No.6414408

>pie

Sweet

>pot pie, Shepards pie, etc

Savory

>> No.6414423

>>6414178
Yeah that's probably close

>> No.6414481
File: 79 KB, 560x415, deliciouspie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414481

>>6413740

>> No.6414492

>>6412670
Don't lump us all in with the sauce eaters. I hate sauce on my pie. Completely ruins the flavour. Best pie is a homemade Lamb and rosemary pie with a nice gravy and a good pastry. Beef and mushroom, Pepper steak. Australia has the best pie culture, but I will admit, the sweet pies you yanks have make my mouth water. Banana cream, key lime, Pumpkin. That shit rocks.

>> No.6414504
File: 44 KB, 486x480, Laughing Dee-Dee.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6414504

>>6414492
>Australia has the best pie culture

>> No.6414507

>>6413732
It's more than just a sausage roll, mate. It's a commitment.

>> No.6414546

>>6412858
>VB
How anyone can drink that shit is beyond me.

>> No.6415238
File: 210 KB, 419x610, AUS_03_0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415238

>> No.6415242

>>6412659
sweet.

>> No.6415268

>>6412659
Savoury.

I like to take the top of the pie off, like opening a can, and eat that before pouring some sauce into the meat/gravy eating that mixture with a spoon before devouring the remaining pastry bowl. It's the only way.

>> No.6415456

Southern US, basically the only meat pie you'll find is "Chicken pot pie".

>> No.6415488

>>6412659
savory
maybe because we have a great sekrit chicken pie recipe in the family we/I do every christmas/parent's birthday/relevant party
takes a whole evening to make a couple with everything from scratch but it's good

>> No.6415508

>>6414546
yea, i prefer emu bitter but any beet is pretty good

>>6415238
farmers union is shit, go buy Brown's or masters

>> No.6415518

>>6412659
>When you hear the word 'Pie' do you think sweet or savory?
An American pizza.

>> No.6415538

>>6415268
I'm not the only one!
Wait till I show my entire family this post! My honour will be restored.
Then I will have to explain 4chan to them, my honour will be lost again.

>> No.6415548

>>6412664
A meat pie with ham, cheese tomato sauce melted on top

>> No.6415582

>>6412659
I think sweet.
Sweet is more prominent in the US.
I'd like to try more savory pies, but other than making them myself, I'd be SOL.

>> No.6415688
File: 108 KB, 500x375, pasti-barm.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415688

>>6413144
I live in wigan lad, nothing but pie shops as far as the eye can see. People from wigan are also known as pie-eaters and it is also known for its various pie eating comps.

>not having a pie bap
>greggs a shit
>galloways 4 lyfe

>> No.6415689

>>6414481
Underrated post.

>> No.6415709
File: 458 KB, 1024x768, 1417959103683.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415709

>>6412659

>> No.6415715

>>6415689
Your post made it overrated.

>> No.6415719

>>6415688
It's a pie barm, lad.

>> No.6415720

>>6413012
>not knowing that shit soul food scraps are no longer dirt ass cheap because white people found them
Exception being chittlins. Not even niggers really like intestines that much though.

>> No.6415722

>>6415720
I don't know what chitlins is, but without intestines, how do you make sausages?

>> No.6415724
File: 163 KB, 330x369, ZIMBABWE.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415724

>>6414481
>American "comedy"

>> No.6415727

>>6412997
No, and we're not ashamed of it

>> No.6415753

UK

Savoury, no questions.

>> No.6415763

>>6412666
>Savory

Triggered

t. actually English

>> No.6415766

>>6415763
Brit on vacation tbh.

>> No.6415780

>>6412659
Definitly a meat pie, frozen mrs mac's pies.

>> No.6415789

>>6412659
Mexico, sweet. People cringe when I mention meat pies and I think it is silly.
A Canadian lady gave me a veal and pork pie around Christmas time and it was fantastic.

>> No.6415800

savory

OZ

>> No.6415816

>>6415800
>savory

You're no m8 of mine, cunt.

>> No.6415822

>>6412670
Shitty mass produced pies need to be drowned in ketchup to be edible. Similar thing with americans with their bright yellow mustard.

>> No.6415834
File: 199 KB, 1600x957, sweerpotato.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415834

>>6413352

>> No.6415838
File: 108 KB, 640x480, 1402571679902.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415838

>> No.6415842
File: 785 KB, 1920x1280, gamepies.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415842

>> No.6415859
File: 212 KB, 2048x1362, pie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415859

Red Door Bakery. Godly, just make sure you get it in a bag. Pies don't need a plate unless there are chips and gravy involved.

>> No.6415946

>>6412659
Probably /ck/'s only resident kiwifag here, we stand with the aussies on this one, steak and cheese all the way m8

>> No.6415950

>>6415946
Are you a Gaysian? If not, you're not the only kiwi who posts here.

>> No.6415986

>>6415688
>putting a pie in a sandwich
but why anon
why

>> No.6415990
File: 533 KB, 2048x1360, pie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6415990

>>6415986

>> No.6416248

>>6415838
>stew with a bit of pastry on top

That's no pie m8, I'd have complained (I wouldn't).

>> No.6416250

>>6415990

Is this the Brit equivalent of posting your 9mm and money roll?

>> No.6416264
File: 46 KB, 451x392, 1376830834563.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6416264

>>6415990
>Barclays cheque

>> No.6416274

>>6412664
A pizza pie is an entire pizza. When you order a pizza, you ask for a pie and specify what size. I don't know about deep dish cause fuck that it's not pizza.

>> No.6416285

>>6416274
pizza is not pie.

>> No.6416340

>>6414123
You need a fair amount of infrastructure to make pie though. Flour which means a mill, butter which means farms, and ovens. None of which would be uncommon in small towns/farming communities but maybe not on the "frontier." You also need very cold ingredients, which before refrigeration technology is fine in northern Europe where you can leave everything outside for an hour, but not so much in most of 'Murrica for most of the year.

The temperature question makes me think, what's Canadian pie culture like? Any canu/ck/s here?

>> No.6416349

>>6416340
And like I said to the other guy, as soon as you were able to, you started making apple pies.

>> No.6416366
File: 298 KB, 705x300, justintimewgs3.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6416366

>>6416349
It's the dutch. Most of our pastries and pies come out of dutch settled areas. Hell our normal apple pie is "Dutch" apple pie.

>> No.6416377

>>6416366
This is unbelievably wrong.

>> No.6416622

>>6415838
What the fuck is up with that mash, it's far to well rounded its meant to be slopped on. And where the fuck is the gravy, what are you meant to shove in your pie when you have eaten the top off of it and try to eat the filling with a spoon.

>> No.6417155

>>6412665
Had my first pork pie last week. It was delicious and so much better than the scrapped chicken, frozen vegetables and gloop they called "chicken pot pie" here.

>> No.6417208

>>6413706
You can make american-style pot pies in casserole dishes easily enough. Just find a recipe you like and put all the ingredients into a dish. You can cook the filo pastry (which you can find in the frozen section of most super markets) separately and place it on top after, so it doesn't get soggy. Then scoop it out like any kind of casserole.

They're basically as expensive as you want to make them. Whatever veg you want, whatever meat you want, some seasoning, then you make the sauce using either cream or a pan-dripping gravy.

>> No.6417209

>>6412659
Pic made me think savory when first reading, but sweet would be the definite answer. 'Murica reporting in, for some sweet, apple-filled goodness.

>> No.6417220

>>6416366
It's more of a Northern European thing in total than it is a group of recipes specifically from the Netherlands. Even if we do get some of the big ones from the Dutch.

>> No.6417245
File: 220 KB, 1600x1173, pecan pie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6417245

American here: I think of sweet pies when people around here say "pie." But my boyfriend is from north Jersey and "pie" to him means pizza unless you specifically refer to it as like "pumpkin pie."

I'll be honest, I love savory pies. I've been to the UK a few times and basically lived on meat pies and curry while I was there. I'm not a big fan of sweet pies just because I prefer savory things generally.

That being said, the best sweet pie is pecan pie, without question. Full of flavor, able to be served in appealing slices, with a crunchy texture. You can't beat it. Also they remind me of my grandmother, who passed away last year.

>> No.6417388

>>6415842
Damn, those pies look tasty as fuck.

It's too bad the US doesn't have this savory pie culture. Meat pies sound awesome as fuck.

>> No.6417412

>>6415842
So you do you reheat those or are you just supposed to eat them at room temperature?

Also, how are they not dry?

>> No.6417418

>>6417388
>It's too bad the US doesn't have this savory pie culture.
Just because the electoral college system exists and people with no culture get to choose the president, doesn't meant the midwest and south have no sane food.

Pot pies and cornish pastries, as well as "pies" pretending to be casseroles, exist across the central states.

>> No.6417441

>>6415838
>Pastry just a hat

Fuck off back to your chain pub you cunt.

>> No.6417462

>>6417245
>btw im a girl XDD

>> No.6417476

>>6417462
Naw, just a gay dude who likes cooking.

>> No.6417487

>>6416622
In America mashed potatoes are usually thicker.
I definitely prefer it that way, when they're thin they just feel like a heavy slop.

>> No.6417488

>>6417476
S-sceak? Is that you?

>> No.6417489

>>6412659
Savoury probably pops into my head first. We have plenty of both though.

>> No.6417504

>>6417488
Saggynips is Canuckistani, not Burgerstani.

>> No.6417537

>>6417488
Nope. Sorry!

>> No.6417551

>>6417489
>We
At least state who 'we' are you cunt.

>> No.6417682

Savoury, Australian.

>> No.6417709
File: 71 KB, 1000x564, 1vOL8zp3afmdLVvvfB4gZwWjFfzA-FSLbDgdc_QvDyG.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6417709

>Norway
Sweet pie, usually either blueberry or rhubarb. Aside from premade frozen stuff, the only dinner pies I've seen have been with cheese, minced beef, onion and peppers.

Also, we tend not to cover our pies here, at least not completely.

>> No.6417895
File: 33 KB, 315x314, boompie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6417895

These aren't too bad. I had them when I was working in Waco.

>> No.6418690

>>6414180
>The only kind of savory pie I've had that was decent was a quiche
>and of course cheese, being american
Quiche clearly isn't fucking American. Cheese is key ingredient, so it's not "being american". It's like saying: "We have pizza here. It's basically bread, tomato sauce, and of course cheese- being American."

>> No.6418696
File: 84 KB, 500x375, 1375444300938.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6418696

>>6417155
By pork pie do you mean a pork pie or a pie that has pork in it?

>> No.6418697

>>6417245
>I've been to the UK a few times and basically lived on meat pies

Good lad.

>> No.6418699

>>6417412
>So you do you reheat those or are you just supposed to eat them at room temperature?
Personal choice, pies are eaten hot or cold.

>Also, how are they not dry?
Excuse me? For starters it's you know, a pie, so all moisture is kept inside and secondly, how is a steak not dry?

>> No.6418702
File: 203 KB, 525x712, Cornish Pepe.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6418702

>>6417418
>cornish pastries


REEEEEEEEEEE

Fuck you, fuck Michigan and fuck your insults.

>> No.6418901

>>6412828
God tier meal

>> No.6418924

>>6412828
God DAMN. I go visit relatives in London every few summers and our first stop is Arment's Eels and Pies. At first I was turned off my the fact that it looks like someone ate handfuls of parsley and puked on a pie and mash. But wow it is delicious.

>> No.6418938
File: 11 KB, 480x360, porkpiecharliemingus.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6418938

>>6412659

I think of Charlie Mingus

>> No.6418992
File: 188 KB, 1200x1600, dry.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6418992

>> No.6419051

>>6415842
>wild game pie
>4 kinds of meat in a single pie

Has science gone too far?

>> No.6419075

>>6419051
Britain is the country that invented the turducken, no meat is too much.

>> No.6419107
File: 202 KB, 1024x683, image.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6419107

>>6414167
i sure hope you mean frito chili pie, son. ain't nothing better under them friday night lights.

>> No.6419109

>>6419107
>Chilli on crisps

Nah lad, I mean a pie with chilli in it. Have you honestly never had one?

>> No.6419120

>>6412659
sweet

Southern and Mid-atlantic US.

I think in other places, it can mean 'pizza pie'

>> No.6419132

>>6419109
can't say I have, but it doesn't mean I'm not interested

>> No.6419252
File: 352 KB, 1800x1221, 1402930843258.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
6419252

>> No.6419295

Savory.

I can't tolerate sweet food.

>> No.6419297

Yes.

>> No.6419312

>>6418699
I mean, you can't put that much liquid in the pie if you're going to leave it sitting around. Otherwise it'll just ruin the bottom. And if it's just sitting out at room temperature, doesn't the meat inside dry out?

>> No.6419365

>>6419312
Aside from the fact that they are in a heated display. how in the fuck does room temperature "dry-out" a closed environment? Are you dried out being at room temperature? Are jars of sauce dried out at room temperature?

Take your shitposting to /b/.

>> No.6419369

>>6419365
>being this mad

>> No.6419373

>>6412659
I've never had a good pie in my whole life. I think about sweet and sweet pies are more prominent, although I personally favor savory.

>> No.6419386

>>6419369
Like I said, take your shitposting to /b/.

>> No.6419418

>>6419386
>i dont know what a shitpost is
this is not a shitpost >>6419312

>> No.6419916

USA
SWEET, I think of pumpkin pie specifically
the only savory pie that i've had is chicken pot pie