[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking

View post   
File: 28 KB, 452x678, IMG_3557.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19378574 No.19378574 [Reply] [Original]

Stop calling cottage pie shepherds pie.

>> No.19378622

>>19378574
Ok then I'll call it what it actually is, a casserole.

>> No.19378623

>>19378574
that's just a meat blingism

>> No.19378633
File: 99 KB, 754x754, FD0CB328-8F0F-4500-B329-BA80BBAAB096.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19378633

>>19378574
It’s cottage pie if there’s beef.
It’s shepherd’s pie if there’s lamb.
It’s your choice.

>> No.19379106

>>19378574
Drop the price of lamb, and I will

>> No.19379138

>>19378574
make me, chump

>> No.19379141

seriously though, if I made the recipe with kangaroo meat, what would the final name for the pie be?

>> No.19379144

>>19379141
bogan's pie

>> No.19379167

>>19379141
Skippy pie

>> No.19379200

>>19379141
Koala Fucker Pie

>> No.19379265

I used mashed squash instead of potatoes once, it worked pretty well

>> No.19379318

>>19378574
It's the same damned thing.
>Shepherds pie has lamb!
No. They are the same damned thing. Ground meat pie with potato (not even always mashed) crust.

>> No.19379839

>>19379141
Prisoner colony pie

>> No.19379875

>>19379141
Kangerole

>> No.19379889

>>19378633
What if there’s fish?
Your mom’s pie?

>> No.19380134

>>19379141

dingo's dinner

>> No.19380138

>>19378574
Make me kike.

>> No.19380150
File: 129 KB, 1200x800, toad-in-hole.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19380150

>>19378574
i do what i want.

>> No.19381429

>peas
>carrots
>corn
nice job ruining the pie

>> No.19381492

>>19379875
You sir have won the internet, I tip my hat to you

>> No.19381521

>>19379141
Cottage turnover

>> No.19381528

the claim that shepherd's pie must contain specifically lamb is pedantic nonsense with no connection to actual culinary tradition.

>Shepherd's Pie
>Take cold dressed meat of any kind...
from an 1849 cookbook. You're a stooge who's incapable of independent thought

>> No.19381531

>>19381492
If it's not a fedora I'm not interested

>> No.19382152

>>19379141
Ned slop

>> No.19382165

>>19378574
Queer Cakes it is then.

>> No.19382174

>>19379875
genuine kek

>> No.19382205

>>19379889
stargazy pie

>> No.19382207

>>19378574
ok but i fuck your wife in a cottage when you go on your weekly bovril jaunt

>> No.19382542
File: 425 KB, 873x797, BC767555-60B5-4F9C-9CAE-A74E23C59E83.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19382542

>>19379889
It’s just fish pie. Some call it a fisherman’s pie. But you can call it what you want. It’s your choice.

>>19382205
Only with a crust and fish heads.

>> No.19382678

>>19381528
I am going to use this naming convention just to annoy you.

>> No.19382695

>>19378574
if you've never had a shepherd's pie made with scalloped potatoes, you've never lived.

>> No.19382706

>>19378574
No, I won't. The only reason cottage pie means beef and shepherd's pie means lamb is because of the vast numbers of boring prescriptivist brits brute forcing your own definition without any etymological basis, simply your own smugness. If I can be strictly correct while pissing off people with nothing better to do with your dull lives than to behave live geriatric women upset about what their lounge room seating gets called then I will do so.