[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking

View post   
File: 178 KB, 2560x2560, shutterstock_1733638781-sq-scaled.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19327908 No.19327908 [Reply] [Original]

Scotch > Irish Whiskey > B*urbon
Simple as.

>> No.19327911 [DELETED] 

>>19327908
Get on your knees and prepare yourself to suck my rubber duck.

>> No.19327944

>>19327908
Canadian rye masterrace

>> No.19328046 [DELETED] 

>>19327908
I prefer isopropyl alcohol and bath salts.

>> No.19328257

>>19327908
there's no reason to buy Irish whiskey. If you're broke buy bourbon, if you're rich buy scotch. Irish whiskey is the middle ground of mediocrity

>> No.19328395

>>19327908
I'm a bourbon guy but yeah, good scotch is better than good bourbon. Scotch just needs to be aged for a long time to taste good, like 8 years minimum.
Why did you censor bourbon?

>> No.19328402

Beer is the best though. No gas.

>> No.19328482

>>19327908
Scotch>bourbon>>>>Irish whiskey.

>> No.19328642

>>19327908
How could you say something so bold yet so controversial?

Scotch is indeed the king of brown liquors

>> No.19329066

>>19328482
>>>>>
This shit needs to stop.

>> No.19329070

>>19327908
>Bourbon >>>> everything else
fixed.

>> No.19329072

>no mention of rye
Retard alert

>> No.19329080

>>19327944
>is mixed with vodka 8%-20%

>> No.19329100
File: 80 KB, 501x771, 1682096403433401.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19329100

>>19327908

What is Glenfidditch considered? I like that shit

>> No.19329116

>>19329100
Glenfiddich is a mid-tier Scotch.

>> No.19329485

>>19327908
Irish whiskey sucks for the most part. It exists only so tryhards can grimmace and go "mmm that sure is strong"
Scotch>Bourbon>Irish Whiskey>Canadian Whiskey

>> No.19329693

>>19329485
lmao wut? Who the fuck is calling Irish whiskey strong? Most normies who prefer Irish whiskey go for it because it's "smooth" and they can drink their Jameson without coughing every 5 seconds

>> No.19329743

Kahlua > All

>> No.19329771

>>19328257
Bourbon isn't cheaper than scotch anymore. The hype culture made everything much more expensive.

>> No.19329789

>>19329771
to me, i assume because of history, bourbon is supposed to be a cheap drink. Scotch however is expensive. I assume its cause when UK was superpower, they created a culture with actual culture. meanwhile, usa hasnt created any culture, too young a country.

>> No.19329810

>>19327908
They're all overhyped but bourbon is the best because I can buy a pretty tasty bottle for fifteen dollars but to I have to shell out at least twenty-five before scotch or irish start getting good

>> No.19329815

>>19329789
This was true until 2015 or so, where it rapidly developed a hype culture and turned into a millennial status symbol that made the prices skyrocket for most of the well regarded bottles.

>> No.19329861

>>19329815
thanks goodness i was right with my gut instinct. Bourbon isnt shitty, but it just doenst come off as a pricey drink. Im thinking about cowboys and saloons.

>> No.19329871

>>19329789
>>19329815
i guess bourbon is american culture and thats fine. but its not like "high" culture, know what i mean? not saying brits are especially classy nowadays, but they were a legit and classy super power and had an appreciation for finer things.

>> No.19329882

>>19329815
>where it rapidly developed a hype culture and turned into a millennial status symbol that made the prices skyrocket for most of the well regarded bottles.
didnt know about this. i just recently learned about bourbon being expensive. like what? how did a drink that cowboys drink become something expensive?

>> No.19330426

>>19329789
>>19329871
O
B
S
E
S
S
E
D

>> No.19330522
File: 2.94 MB, 846x640, high proof likker.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19330522

>>19329882
The quality of the whiskey they drank would probably not be legal to sell today

>> No.19330655

>>19330426
lmfao. its true though. but like no, american whiskey is a good part of american culture. so your comment doenst make sense.

>> No.19330686

>>19327908
>forgot to rate rye
opinion discarded
>>19327944
Only if you're going for good shit like Alberta Premium, otherwise its garbage.
>>19329771
>>19329789
>>19329871
>bourbon went up in price because of hype culture!
>it was cheap because it didn't have a high culture around it!
It was cheap because it's the most common whiskey to mix in a cocktail, which brought down its perception as being shit since you only use shit product as a mixer. Its rising in value because people have begun realizing that you can actually have bourbon so good that you shouldn't mix it at all. The other part of it is rarity, comparatively aged bottles simply don't exist except for a few. Tons of scotch brands have 15, 18, 21 year old bottles for sale, very few bourbon brands have something like that at decent prices (see Buffalo Trace OFC). It doesn't hurt that shit like Pappy Van Winkle is also high priced but complete garbage, hurting the perception of the spirit. If you do manage to find exceptional bourbon, you can see it compete with really good scotch. OFC 94 practically tastes like scotch despite being a bourbon, it's tremendously good.

The true rating is:
Islay Scotch > Highland Scotch > American Rye > Bourbon > Scotch (rest of it) > Canadian Rye > Irish Whisky

>> No.19331486

>word for whiskey literally comes from Ireland
>they're shit at it
what gives?

>> No.19331953

>>19329693
^^this. i love Irish whisky now. Prefer it to the heavy smoked Scottish stuff.
Its weird how I went from one to the other but I have

>> No.19331969

>>19330686
incorrect, speyside > highland > japanese > taiwanese > indian > power gap > irish > canadian >>>>>> amerishart "whiskey" (sic)

also bourbon is for children, I don't know what you think it has to do with whisky

>> No.19332129
File: 129 KB, 900x1200, 6C885606-B852-4424-90E0-25D8982CBC26.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19332129

For me and my sugar momma it’s Irish whiskey

>> No.19332141

>>19329116
what about glenlivet 15

>> No.19332182

Wasnt there some whiplash about "scotch" being a top meme nowadays?
sourced grain
sourced peat
sourced barrels (standard)
the only thing being local being their water source and methods?

>> No.19332187

>>19331969
>japanese that high
opinion discarded

>> No.19332197
File: 34 KB, 600x600, 1629547246559.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19332197

>>19327908
>>19329072
>>19330686
I knew something was a rye here!

>> No.19332200

>>19332129
Anon living the dream

>> No.19332213

>>19327908
I'm approaching 28 and still can't stand the taste of alcohol

>> No.19332653

>>19332182
if by methods you mean "distilled, blended, aged in Scotland" then yes, because the climate.

also there are plenty of Distillers that are offering some limited edition Local Barley fairly regularly. Although it's hardly worth a comparison because something in that price range is already going to be coming from a tier or two above in cask quality that the distillate difference is too slight to make it worth.

and nowadays the market is lead by brand puppets that push "a leak" to some new super limited edition, committee only, online only, EU ONLY, 50CL bottle of ancient barrels some Asian bought and wants flip for bookoo bucks and the peon shill group push it through social media and they dont even have to have a good pitch they literally just say "BRO TRUST ME, JUST BUY IT. SUPER CEREAL."

>> No.19332657

>>19332129
got moar?

>> No.19332670

>>19332213
dont worry, you will hit puberty one day

>> No.19332860

Jack Daniels is the only whiskey endorsed by Frank Sinatra and is therefore the best.

>> No.19332896

>>19327908
It all tastes bad. The best one is what you're most used to.

>> No.19332912

>>19330522
They used well water and inferior grains compared to today

>> No.19332947

>>19332213
That's because you're drinking it wrong, you have to drink it with ice and let it dilute it a bit, then it will be much less harsh and enjoyable, that or you're just drinking absolute garbage bottom of the shelf crap

>> No.19333034

>>19332141
Solid choice too. Glenmorangie is right there with them. Any of the single malt scotches i've tried in that 50 dollar range are usually pretty nice.

>> No.19334941
File: 28 KB, 594x508, 1579363495389.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19334941

drinking Jack Daniel's Old No.7 ama

>> No.19335129

The bourbon """"shortage"""" is an absolute meme. Mass produced swill made out of corn is suddenly the rarest shit on the planet? It's a bigger manufactured shortage than nvidia GPUs.

>> No.19336565

>>19332947
Dilluting whiskey is for homosexuals, anon.

>> No.19336729

>>19335129
If everyone starts drinking a bunch of it and it takes a cycle of 4+ years to produce, more for rare bottles that aren't made at the same scale in the first place, it's understandable

>> No.19338167

I prefer bourbon over irish whiskey but yeah scotch is king by far

>> No.19338190

>>19327944
fahnny joak!

>> No.19338191

>>19328395
Because he's a self-loathing American

>> No.19338540

>>19328257
This is exactly what I've been told but then the guy went into Nipponaise whiskeys and I stopped paying attention.
idk shit about the stuff but of the ones I've had, and that admittedly isn't many, I quite liked Basil Hayden's.

>> No.19338554

>>19327944
Can I get a QRD on this? Is it an American meme that Canadian whisky is good?

>> No.19338674

>>19338554
It's a Canadian meme and also retards who get their opinions from watching Mad Men

>> No.19339452
File: 123 KB, 366x513, file.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19339452

cheap $25 J&B or top shelf $60 Macallan?

>> No.19339465

Scotch is the IPA of whisky. It is one note, two at best, and nothing else. BRO ITS SO SMOKEY ITS SO GOOD BRO I CANT TASTE ANYTHING BUT SMOKE, IF I WAS CAUGHT IN A HOUSE FIRE MY MOUTH WOULD HAVE RHE SAME TASTE IN IT BRO. Or if youre lucky DUDE YOU CAN TASTE SO MUCH PEAT AND GRASS BEHIND THE SMOKE BRO OHMY GOD

>> No.19339516

>>19339465
>drink Islay whisky
>get Islay profile
wow is you

alternatively
>drink Speyside whisky
>get Speyside profile
I think some people legit have a mentality towards Scotch and will hype it up instead of giving it a fair shake.

>>19339452
J&B is a decent enough, jobbing pour you can basically do what you want with. I wont buy Macallan again unless it's in a blend like Naked Grouse. The 12 Sherry Oak I had in the purple box was more sulphur notes than whisky/sherry. I would absolutely buy Glenmorangie, Glen Grant, Glengoyne over Macallan.

>> No.19339527

>>19327908

Yeah, I sure love the taste of a campfire in my mouth you stupid fucking idiots

>> No.19340265

>>19328482
I prefer some Scotches to Irish, but there are many Scotches that are worse in my eyes than a nice Bushmills or Jameson. (There are decent whiskeys from elsewhere too.)
I don't like bourbon at all. I can taste a good quality one when I have it, but I just don't like it. I'm happy to leave those to others.

>> No.19340280

>>19329100
She has a nice pumpable ass

>> No.19340282

>>19330522
WTF are they drinking there, battery acid?

>> No.19340287

Having some Pikesville Rye rn. May switch over to Maker's cask strength for some sweetness to go along with the high proof

>> No.19340292

>>19340280
I would tongue punch the fart box

>> No.19340874

>>19327908
Silence European

>> No.19340966

>>19327908
Irish whiksey > bourbon > Japanese whiskey > scotch >>>>> whatever the fuck Canada calls whiskey

>> No.19340971
File: 127 KB, 1806x1806, Studio_Project-2022-05-30T074718.170_1806x.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19340971

>>19327908
This is good

>> No.19340989

Bourbon > Whiskey > Everclear > juice from the bottom of the garbage bag > Sc*tch