[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 448 KB, 1600x1034, 1634162533973.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17131286 No.17131286 [Reply] [Original]

Have you tried anything new recently?
Whisk(e)y General

>> No.17131293

I used Dr Pepper cream soda in lieu of Coke in a whiskey & coke. It was pretty good.

>> No.17131322

>>17131286
>muh barrels
>muh angels share
>muh wood magic

fuck you pretentious faggot, we aready have a based whisky thread
>>17129290

>> No.17131328

>>17131322
it kinda gay in that thread

>> No.17131344
File: 122 KB, 750x563, 1630566056151.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17131344

I recently bought a bottle of Barrell Seagrass, it tastes really good, I can taste the apricot brandy finish, can't really taste the seagrass note people are saying it has.

>> No.17131409

>>17131344
talkin bout gay

>> No.17131613
File: 1.48 MB, 1440x2361, 20211216_020947.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17131613

i've got blue lable yesterday first time. taste like heaven. feels good man

>> No.17131631

>>17131613
The bottle itself is so damn based.

>> No.17131638

>>17131613
Nice, I've never been able to tell if it's worth it.

>> No.17131645
File: 137 KB, 600x600, Widow-Jane-10-Year-Old-Bourbon.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17131645

yeah, it was good.

>> No.17131652

>>17131638
As in you haven’t tried it? Or you have but aren’t convinced it’s worth the price?

>> No.17131655

>>17131652
I've never tried it.

>> No.17131779

drinking peated new make right now, much better than any aged stuff i've had so far.

>> No.17131787

>>17131779
Where did you get it

>> No.17131815
File: 39 KB, 301x461, 27CEA821-46A0-4EA5-BEA5-295F36848E87.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17131815

>>17131655
You could always grab a miniature “airplane bottle” to try.
My local liquor store has them for $20 or so.
Even comes in a nifty little box.

>> No.17131992

>>17131286
>Have you tried anything new recently?
I recently opened the new Cairdeas and a Big Peat Prohibition Edition

>> No.17132248
File: 133 KB, 474x650, bt.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17132248

sazeracbros...
it's over...

>> No.17133150
File: 44 KB, 540x720, gfdob.12yo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17133150

>Imagine paying good money for blended

>> No.17133174

>>17133150
>imagine dismissing blended out of hand because faux-snobbery

>> No.17133184
File: 45 KB, 486x409, 1505263661817.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17133184

>>17133174
Name ONE blended whisky that is more than adequate at best in comparison with Scottish single malt

>> No.17133368

>>17131613
Good taste. Not worth the $200 price tag. It’s very easy to drink and very forgettable. I would pay $60 for it. The extra $140 is just marketing telling you “this is the best whisky!”

>> No.17133383

>>17133184
Single malt is definitely better by far. But there are some terrible single malt scotches out there. I remember I had a Deanston 20 year old fully matured in a first fill sherry cask and it was a sulpher bomb. Terrible whisky. Black Label is unironically better than that. But I do agree, single malts out perform blends consistently.

>> No.17133414

Is Scotch a meme bros? Or should I go down the rabbit hole?

>> No.17133477

>>17133414
Go down the rabbit hole. Islay is best though.

>> No.17133515
File: 123 KB, 1005x753, 69AB1DAE-6B11-4192-B6D7-C716AD267E0D.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17133515

I have a Scotch question. Does the fact that bourbon was held in the ex bourbon american oak barrels matter much in the taste of scotch? Like if it was the same barrel and same char level but held brandy instead of bourbon, would there be a significant difference to the Scotch when it’s finally aged in it? Are there any Scotch autists that can help me out?

>> No.17133831
File: 249 KB, 712x1052, 7867621D-FEFA-4190-91C9-35D456B49641.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17133831

>local store has this
>it’s $1999.99
Fuck I hate being poor

>> No.17133864

>>17133831
even if you were rich, why would you burn money like that

>> No.17133966

>>17133864
Are you saying you wouldn’t?
Even if you were rich enough to spend that on a bottle without even blinking an eye?
I’d personally love to taste 41+yo single malt from a distillery that hasn’t existed for 46.
Something which will literally never exist again, and inevitably go from rare to unobtainable at any price when what’s left is gone.
It would be fascinating to try.

>> No.17133988

>>17133966
there's plenty of dead distilleries and this is just one of them. it's literally just a product from a now defunct business and you're basically just paying for the lore and backstory of it.
you can buy 40 year old ben bracken at aldi if you want to drink old whisky at an affordable price.

>> No.17134021

>>17133988
>you're basically just paying for the lore and backstory of it
Yes. And a fucking sweet box.
>40yo Ben Bracken
>”from an undisclosed Scottish distillery”
I’d rather pay more for some sweet lore than buying a bottle of “dude trust me”.

>> No.17134085
File: 961 KB, 1125x4513, 69C29837-0AEC-47F6-8F89-D6CBF07AE5BF.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17134085

>>17133515
Can scotch autists confirm this?

>> No.17134092

>>17133383
>sulfur bomb
This is, unfortunately, a risk with any wine cask-aged whisky. It's because some wine barrels are sterilized with sulfur candles before being used for whisky.
This is why I wouldn't ever spend big money on a whisky aged in any kind of wine cask.

>> No.17134112

>>17134085
I’m not a scotch autist. But I am a former Jack Daniels employee (can’t speak for other distilleries), and their 2nd biggest source of profit aside from the whiskey itself is selling the only-once-used barrels to other distilleries; primarily to the UK and Japan.

During aging, the whiskey pulls a lot more from the barrel than the barell pulls from the whiskey.
And perhaps more importantly, the whiskey is the product. They don’t let a drop go to waste, and use a process to extract as much as physically possible from the barrel itself.
Afterward, all that’s really left in the barrel is some lingering aroma, which really isn’t going to do much when it’s filled with a spirit that has an entirely different grain bill.

>> No.17134138

>>17134112
That’s actually really interesting. I had no idea. Thanks anon.

>> No.17134149
File: 663 KB, 1125x1387, 23287D09-8680-4EDF-B918-4650F9DB4A6D.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17134149

>>17134085
Or is this true?

>> No.17134165

>>17134138
No prob.
The barrel-extraction is used by a lot of bourbon distilleries also; it’s what Jim Beam markets as their “devils cut” product by blending it into bourbon in a higher concentration.
Jack just blends it in to the rest of the No. 7 though.

>> No.17134174

>>17134149
This seems more likely to me considering the vast difference in flavor between ex sherry matured scotch and ex bourbon matured

>> No.17134177

>>17134085
This wouldn’t explain port casks which are used for long periods of time to age port. 40+ years. Older casks are sought after because they don’t want a strong oak influence on their port. Yet when scotch distilleries use these old casks to finish their whisky, casks that should be completely spent of all the oak flavor, they still give scotch a dark color because of the port soaked in the cask.

>> No.17134206
File: 128 KB, 800x700, ff7.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17134206

>>17134149
lmao, whisky officially confirmed to be literally nothing but wood infused vodka with a drop of wine added to it for taste

>> No.17134422

>>17133515
There wouldn’t be a “significant” difference because they’re both spirits, so I would imagine they would interact with the oak similarly.

>> No.17134479

>>17134206
Do you even know what the fuck actually constitutes a whiskey or a vod..
>literal collector of soyjacks
Nevermind. Keep sucking those cocks and reaching for your dreams.

>> No.17134491

whats a good 50 dollar whisjey i can get wherever

>> No.17134519

>>17134491
4 roses single barrel. Best $50 bourbon the market

>> No.17134539

I've recently come to appreciate Elijah Craig. It's expensive, but I'm not 25 anymore and Old Crow damn near kills me.

>> No.17134569

>>17134174
I think he’s arguing it’s the oak and level of toasting and previous maturation length that matters more than the “sherry”. It could be anything with a similar abv going in, like say a japanese sake, and the results would be similar. It’s interesting that a person from Macallan is saying the Sherry doesn’t matter, when they invest so much in it.

>> No.17134577

>>17134491
Glenfiddich 12

>> No.17134609

What's the whiskey you buy most often?

For me, it's Laphroaig 10 because it's under $40 at my local Costco and they always have it.

>> No.17134613

>>17134519
I think Old Forester 1920 is better for around $50.
For high-rye bourbons I actually prefer Old Grand-Dad 114 at like $27 to FRSB.

>> No.17134630

>>17134569
Learn your barrels, bro.
The entire point of a sherry barrel is that it’s a “high mileage” barrel and won’t impart barrel flavor like a new or just-a-few-years-used barrel will, beyond a bit of sherry flavor.
That’s why it’s specifically a sherry barrel, and not a new barrel or single-use bourbon barrel or even a wine barrel.
Of course Macallen or anyone else has to invest a lot on said barrels; look up the situation on purchasing “new” sherry casks.

>> No.17134676

>>17134630
>point of a sherry barrel is that it’s a “high mileage” barrel
Yea that’s correct for the sherry industry. I thought for the Scotch industry it was different. Aren’t almost all sherry casks new american oak toasted and seasoned with sherry for approximately 2 years? The sherry industry doesn’t sell it’s really old casks to Macallan. I would think they wouldn’t actually want them because they would be exhausted casks?

>> No.17134682

>>17134422
Is this true? Would most people in the industry agree with this?

>> No.17134720

>>17134676
>The sherry industry doesn’t sell it’s really old casks to Macallan.
That’s precisely why their sherry casks are such a massive investment.
They have to do what they can to repair said casks, even if it means cobbling together new casks from staves of old ones, or adding “newish” staves to existing old casks for repair.
But again, the point of a traditional sherry cask is that it’s “exhausted”, in the sense that it isn’t giving a ton of flavor to the whiskey.
If you taste a bourbon, the barrel flavor is super pronounced. It’s meant to be. That’s why it can only be a virgin charred barrel.
With Scotch it’s different, which is why the most prized aging casks are the oldest sherry casks whatever distillery has.

>> No.17134732

>>17134676
The scotch industry's demand for sherry casks cant be sustained by the sherry industry so sherry "seasoned" casks are used. Macallan Sherry Oak uses seasoned oak from Spain. The Macallan Double Cask is a combination of American and European seasoned casks. It seems like they're really pushing the double cask stuff lately and I would assume that's because the american oak is more accessible. Regardless, seasoning is commonplace and anons talking about 40 year old port casks aren't talking about whisky that is representative of the vast majority of what people are actually drinking

>> No.17134748

>>17134720
>the point of a traditional sherry cask is that it’s “exhausted”, in the sense that it isn’t giving a ton of flavor to the whiskey.
That’s incorrect for Scotch. Sherry casks that are exhausted on 4th, 5th fill etc will give virtually no color/flavor to the whisky. “Exhausted” sherry casks are good for aging sherry. Sherry producers do not want a heavy oak influence on their sherry.

>> No.17134771

>>17134732
>It seems like they're really pushing the double cask stuff lately and I would assume that's because the american oak is more accessible
Yea this is true today. It’s true for the sherry industry as well. It’s a common misconception that the sherry industry uses mainly european oak, when in reality, most of the oak used in the sherry industry today is actually american oak.

>> No.17134780

>>17134748
>That’s incorrect for Scotch. Sherry casks that are exhausted on 4th, 5th fill etc will give virtually no color/flavor to the whisky.
Is that not precisely the point? Is that not why you can see 12/18/21yo Scotches with a golden color rather than brown?

>> No.17134812

>>17134780
>Is that not precisely the point?
No. That's why you don't see marketing language touting whiskies as "fourth fill" but you often see "first fill" noted right on the bottle

>> No.17134823

>>17134812
If it were “first fill”, it wouldn’t be a sherry barrel or bourbon barrel or any other sort. It would be a virgin barrel.

>> No.17134828

>>17134780
Well I think we’re just misunderstanding each other. An exhausted cask is NOT good for scotch. It will not have a golden color. It will look straw in color. So having a really really used cask is not good. It’s dead. But for sherry producers it’s actually prized.

>> No.17134830

>>17134823
That’s not what first fill means in the scotch industry.

>> No.17134847

I wonder what the seasoning is exactly. Like what is the difference between the sherry seasoning that macallan does vs glendronach vs aberlour etc. Is this "sherry" seasoning sourced from Spain or is it formulated by the scotch distilleries themselves? And what happens to the inevitable sherry seasoning byproduct? I read somewhere awhile ago that some is turned into sherry vinegar but who really knows

>> No.17134848

>>17133515
I need more opinions on this!

>> No.17134892

>>17134177
https://youtu.be/-Eg3yvLHuTo
Yea it doesn’t explain this. Master of wood at macallan BTFO.

>> No.17134979

>>17133515
Idk

>> No.17135174

Why is scotch so fucking confusing?

>> No.17135270

>>17131992
I've been interested in trying a peated blended malt from Douglas Laing's. how is it?

>> No.17135281

>>17133831
>distillery lasted 9 years during a boom
>40%
never gonna be worth it. if I were to blow money like that on scotch I'd probably go Brora if it were one bottle or a handful of limited editions.

>> No.17135347

>>17131286
imagine how satisfying it would be to smash all those barrels like a big gorilla

>> No.17135371

So I need to get my father a Christmas present and I know he likes drinking Buffalo Trace. I can't find any liquor store near me that has it atm. Does anyone know a whiskey that's pretty similar? If it's a bit more expensive that's not a problem, i just want it to taste similar if not better.

>> No.17135374
File: 202 KB, 1240x696, A6648979-AB4B-40D4-A61D-5320CEC8C163.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17135374

What is the most traditional cask for scotch? Not something exotic or used for finishing. But the cask that’s used as a benchmark to compare to others?

>> No.17135382

>>17135371
Eagle Rare or Colonel EH Taylor

>> No.17135448

>>17135382
Much appreciated.

>> No.17135483

>>17135374
Ex bourbon barrel.

>> No.17135495

>>17135270
It's young tasting but if you like heavy peat it's well worth it

>> No.17135596

>>17134479
awww, don't be mad at me because YOU fell for marketing like the easily impressed bugman you are.

>> No.17135600

>>17134720
Sherry houses don't sell their old Solera casks, retard. What they're using in whisky is standard barrels seasoned with young Sherry wine, it's not even the aged stuff.

>> No.17135614

>>17135495
the prohibition one turned me off as that whole thing was such a Jewish trick it is still echoing through to today so I'd probably be getting the Christmas Edition or the normal Big Peat. does it stand out as being more heavily leaning towards the Caol Ila or Ardbeg side of things?

>> No.17135631

>>17133150
Is Glenfiddich 12 YO a good entry level Scotch? It's currently on sale at my local grocery store for 30€

>> No.17135640

>>17135631
probably better to most compared to Glenmorangie 10 at the same price. it won't scare anyone off Scotch to be sure.

>> No.17135796
File: 1.22 MB, 3264x2448, 34699474-7672-4B7B-852B-CE4494964922.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17135796

Drank a few shots of these 2. Both delicious in their own way. The glenlivet was sweeter and would probably mix well, the Glendronach was more of a traditional whiskey taste. I only got into whiskey 2ish months ago but my taste buds are definitely beginning to acclimate to the taste and I’m beginning to pick up differences and certain flavors.

>> No.17135877
File: 24 KB, 470x470, regionsofscotch_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17135877

>>17135631
Great way to start. Go for it brother, you won't regret it. Perhaps look into the different "regions" of scotch eventually if you get into it

>> No.17136199
File: 12 KB, 300x240, 1535479362055.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17136199

>>17135640
>>17135877
Thanks to both of you. I got one bottle, now I just need proper glasses to start my journey off into Scotch (I only have Tumblers).
I'm quite experienced with Rum and Bourbon but I don't think I ever tasted Scotch, so I'm glad I found a decent starting point. If I enjoy it I will definitely go by region and try out the more unique flavors Scotch has to offer.

>> No.17136221
File: 15 KB, 144x350, FD78CEE2-1329-4259-A2ED-D52F55847366.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17136221

>>17131286
Am I doin it right?

>> No.17136232
File: 1.94 MB, 1567x3771, flintlock-88-proof-straight-bourbon-whiskey_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17136232

Very smooth for such a high proof whiskey.
Definitely recommend.

>> No.17136467

>>17135631
I'd say it's the de facto starter scotch.

>> No.17136652

>>17134828
Some whiskeys are coloured, Jura is coloured with caramel, probably for this reason.

>> No.17136746
File: 747 KB, 1920x659, hakushu-distillery.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17136746

has anyone been on distillery tours, or anything like that? I've wanted to make it more of a point to travel to some in Scotland or Japan, since they seem to be in beautiful areas for some of them

>> No.17137068
File: 31 KB, 660x574, 07a4da3f313f.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17137068

>>17131787
at the liquor store

>> No.17137504
File: 17 KB, 532x582, 1505531755562.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17137504

>>17136199
Glad to help another anon out!

>> No.17137507

>>17136746
My grandpa went to Scotland for a distillery tour. He had a blast and came home with two used barrels (empty)

>> No.17137529

>>17136232
>high proof

>> No.17137645

>>17134812
Is “first fill” considered better than “second fill”?

>> No.17137658

>>17131613
Johnnie walker green is based, this is really good but too pricey for what it is

>> No.17137694

>>17135483
Why would ex bourbon barrels be considered standard?

>> No.17137719

>>17137694
because only the best is good enough

>> No.17137726
File: 193 KB, 1200x997, Topshelf.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17137726

>>17133477
BASED
>>17131286
There's a distillery in Perth that started doing whisky not too long ago. Their gin is excellent, so I picked up a bottle of their single malt sherry cask aged whisky. It's very young, obviously, but I've got high hopes

>> No.17137731

>>17137726
"world whisky" is the true patrician's choice

>> No.17137750

>>17137731
Yeah, but Topshelf has nowhere near the rep needed to be considered there. It's their first whisky, give them a couple of decades and we'll see where they end up

>> No.17137885

>>17137719
??

>> No.17138427

>jameson
very good

>> No.17138492

>>17137885
bourbon is the king of spirits
so much so that its leftovers are being lapped up by scotcucks and other europoids

>> No.17138516

>>17138492
t. american with dead tastebuds

>> No.17138610

>>17137694
It’s considered standard because it has previously held whisky, so it’s not exotic and very similar to the new make spirit they are going to put in them. It’s not something vastly different like a wine cask.

>> No.17138646

>>17138492
Why are Americans in love with overtly sweet things. Bourbon is ridiculously sweet and for women.

>> No.17138675

>>17138646
why are you in love with cock?

>> No.17139269

>>17133966
taste is a sense, not an experience. if you had the money to blow, and you did this, alone, in your cage, would it improve your life. would you still wake up in the morning and long for things out of reach. like a real man's haircut. like a gaze that doesn't repel any creature with half a soul left. would that local store's expensive discontinued whiskey really fix anything you already have. you're a used band aid on a broken leg.

>>17134021
good god 1,000 usd for a 'fucking sweet box' and 'some sweet lore.' if this isn't bait, you've fully chummed yourself.

>> No.17139299

>>17134085
Interesting. The master of wood for edrington says the previous contents of the casks is just marketing. Was he fired for saying this?

>> No.17139302

>>17139269
>tl;dr
Be honest, how much have you had to drink tonight?

>> No.17139375

>>17139269
>taste is a sense, not an experience
And senses are experienced

>> No.17139417

>>17138492
Bourbon is good but dont go down the rabbit hole looking for the allocated shit

>> No.17139425

>>17131613
Green Label does the trick but at a quarter of the price. Still, I had a pour of the Blue months ago and it did feel fantastic before I bit into a biggie soft pretzel

>> No.17139434

Liked the Old Forester 120 I got at Costco last week so much I went back and got two more today since I'm sure they won't have it after the holidays and it was $47. It's such a flavor bomb.

>> No.17139595 [DELETED] 

>>17139375
>>17139302
you couldn't just cope for your failings in a single post? making the assumption two pathetic men aren't logging on tonight
once again, just driving this home,
drinking something won't make you a person worth basic human eye contact

>> No.17139596

What does a scotch taste like?
What does a bourbon taste like?

>> No.17139599
File: 982 KB, 2448x3264, IMG_5377.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17139599

got this for secret santa at work. its a glass for tasting spirits apparently. does this actually do anything? I've never really bought into this but I guess it'll be nice to have something besides a plastic cup to drink my whiskey with.

>> No.17139634

>>17139596
>scotch
woody grain with varying amounts of smoked anus
>bourbon
corn syrup

>> No.17139640

>>17139634
The scotch sounds interesting.

>> No.17139672

>>17139599
Makes it easier to sniff nice smelling whisky and feels fancy to drink from while at it. If you don't care to the point of using plastic cups you won't have much use for it other than as a shelf decoration.

>> No.17139775

>>17134085
So it’s all marketing?!?!?
Scotch bros….did we get memed?

>> No.17140195

What's the general consensus on balvenie? Is it respectable?
I'm an 18 year old babby who doesn't know shit but this is my first scotch and damn is it good. I was worried I wasn't gonna like whiskey after vomiting and blacking out last time but I'm all good. Damn whiskey is good.

>> No.17140355

>>17140195
respectable enough for a seriously entry level bottle. you get the 12 Doublewood?

>> No.17140567
File: 40 KB, 362x362, 1503449658887.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17140567

>>17131293
dr pepper cream soda is kino. Good with cigars
>>17131344
Try Dovetail if you like seagrass. Thomas Moore and Old Elk make mostly finished booze, haven't had them but heard they are good.
>>17131645
Tried it once and didn't like it at all
>>17136221
Good bottle for party rocking
>>17140195
If you do not know what you like yet you ought to just try new bottles instead of getting memed into bottles by the power of suggestion. If you want to try Scotch any 12 year from one of the bigger distilleries is worth trying, try to make note of the region and the kind of barrels used.

>> No.17140586
File: 134 KB, 457x1200, 9565501-1[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17140586

picked this up because it was affordable. I like the islay smokey flavor but the smell is a bit too astringent. overall pretty nice but i dont have a huge frame of reference. Ardbeg was better to me but in a different price class.

>> No.17140597
File: 24 KB, 476x255, WAAAAAH.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17140597

Is there any beginning scotch whiskey you would recommend or should I just stick to irish because I enjoy it

>> No.17140600

>>17140597
literally just ctrl - f and type in beginner scotch

>> No.17140606

>>17140597
why do you need entry level scotch? I dont understand how a drink can be for beginners. talk to the owner of the liquor store for something affordable and popular. if you dont like it, regift it to some scrub friend.

>> No.17140808

>>17140606
Don't ask the liquor janny unless you can tell if he's just trying to move bottles that sit on the shelf.

>> No.17141021

>>17140597
there's no "beginner's scotch", that's literally just a cope that consoomer soyjaks came up with in order to give their preferred form of alcohol consumption an air of sophistication and elitism
>oh no m'lady, you might hurt yourself with that bottle of lagavulin, might wanna ease into the experience with glenfiddich first
if you already made up your mind about whether you like smoke or not, you can pick what you want.

>> No.17141503

>>17131645
doubt

>> No.17141528

Picked up oban 14 in England. And glendronaxh 10 at the duty free on sale. Oban is great but definitely glad I got it got 55 pounds as opposed to 140 CAD as it's not a 140 dollar bottle of whiskey. Glendronach is worse of course, but complex enough and a good price at 47 pounds for a 1L. I am thinking of picking up either another bottle of Alberta premium cask strength or larceny bourbon next (is 52 cad too much for that?)

>> No.17141538

>>17141528
i intended picking up the alberta but since it's 140 bucks in my country, i opted against it. if you can get it for a civilized price, you should go for it.

>> No.17141552

>>17141538
I was referring to the larceny for 52. AP cask strength is about 65 here, still a great price though, really feels substantial to drink.

>> No.17142177

>>17135374
Sherry casks actually, that is what they used to use until Spain made it hard for them to export them, so they switched to ex bourbon barrels in like the 50s if I remember correctly.

>> No.17142338

>>17142177
I agree that it’s the most “traditional” cask. But not the best example of a “benchmark” cask. Sherry notes can overwhelm a scotch. A bourbon cask won’t really overwhelm a scotch because it previously held something very similar (whiskey).

>> No.17142503

Scotchchads, can you explain why you enjoy scotch more than other world whiskies?

>> No.17142586

>>17135174
It just has more variety. There are strict US laws that determine what makes a whiskey legally able to be called "bourbon". The fact that one of the requirements for being called "bourbon" is that the mash bill must be at least 51% corn grain, means that almost all bourbons taste very similar.

There are no such restrictions on Scottish whiskys, so there is a larger variety of Scotches.

>> No.17142600

>>17142586
This is misleading. Scotches main flavor comes from single malts. Other grain alcohol is essentially neutral grain spirit. So scotch tastes like malted barley. You actually can get more variety from the grain flavor used in bourbon, like a high rye bourbon.

>> No.17142601
File: 329 KB, 1920x1440, high-proofs.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17142601

>>17135371
See my post here (>>17142586). Almost all bourbons taste similar. So, just get a more expensive bourbon.

I recommend Old Forester 1920 Prohibition style. That will cost you about $55USD. If that's too steep, Old Grand Dad 114 is almost as good as OF1920 for about half the price. Both are in my pic.

>> No.17142609

>>17142600
Interesting. What about blended Scotches, and single pot still whiskys like some of the Irish whiskys?

>> No.17142684

Is it just me or is Jap whiskey shit

>> No.17142766

>>17142601
>old forester
by the roughness of the taste, it would be more appropriate to call it young forester

>> No.17142830

>>17142609
Blended scotches use aged neutral grain spirit to help stretch their whisky. You won’t taste rye or corn in your johnnie walker because they distill it to near vodka levels. Then they blend that with single malts which don’t distill to neutral spirit levels and use 100% malted barley. I think irish whiskey is the same but they can use unmalted and malted barley.

>> No.17142873

Fireball whiskey 375ml from the bottle. Fight me. And yes I do live in ny

>> No.17142884

>>17133831
Steal it

>> No.17142900

>>17139375
the taste is the experience

>> No.17142977

>>17134085
Uhhh Scotch bros.. I don’t feel too good.

>> No.17142997

>>17142586
The mashbill isn't why bourbons taste similar. The usage of new oak barrels is where the similarity comes from

>> No.17143044

>>17134149
seems far more plausible

i've tried a whole array of exotic finishes and they sometimes go overboard with it, so it definitely does impact a flavor. however, they might as well just add flavoring to the cask at this point.

>> No.17143070

Think of all the highs and lows that will come from the whiskey in all those barrels. Whiskey really is a magical potion.

>> No.17143076

>>17143070
>Whiskey really is a magical potion.
not really

>> No.17143131

>>17143070
Hamilton had the same conclusion with Shulgin and phenethylamines (MDMA being the most known)
"The decades of laughter, the gallons of tears..."
Rip Alexander, Hamilton is a nice guy.

>> No.17143326

>>17143070
>highs and lows
>bourbon
All gonna taste pretty much the same

>> No.17143558

What are you guys drinking tonight?

>> No.17143561

>>17143558
Trump Rye

>> No.17143563

>>17143558
A Single Barrel Barrel proof Bone Snapper rye, it's MGP 95 5 rye recipe

>> No.17143805

>>17142766
Not him. The 1920 is clearly aged a pretty long time because it's oaky as fuck.

>> No.17143982

I'll be drinking whiskey tomorrow, straight and with ginger ale. Getting some good ginger ale when I go shopping tomorrow with whenever whiskey I end up getting. Probably Buffalo Trace if it's there.

>> No.17143986

>>17143805
>t. brown-forman

>> No.17143994
File: 46 KB, 541x506, 1633138298419.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17143994

For me, it's Wild Turkey 101. Simple as.

>> No.17144429
File: 227 KB, 1920x1080, Wild-Turkey-Bourbon-Bottle-Held-by-Jason-Alexander-as-George-Costanza-in-Seinfeld-Season-5-Episode-13-1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17144429

>>17143994
baste