[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking

View post   
File: 19 KB, 480x360, hqdefault.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930689 No.16930689 [Reply] [Original]

New York vs Chicago Pizza thread

>> No.16930710
File: 12 KB, 288x175, download (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930710

they're both dumb extremes?

>> No.16930721

>>16930710
New york style is not even close to extreme, it's the perfect ratio

>> No.16930735
File: 38 KB, 399x600, DSC09660-399x600[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930735

>>16930689
Chicago saw NY pizza enjoying world fame so they decided to invent a "pizza" because they're the "other" big east coast city but their cuisine is shit. So they made this monstrosity.
>uhhh new york pizza is thin and has a nice firm crust... so let's make our crust a mush and make the whole pizza disgustingly thick
>uhhhhh new york pizza puts the cheese on top.... so let's put the tomato sauce on top instead
you can't even buy a "slice" of it because everything flows out of it like a disgusting sludge.
It's same reason they use this retarded neon-green relish on their hot dogs. Just desperation to have SOMETHING for people to remember about their god-awful shithole of a "city". But instead of inventing something good, they invent retarded garbage.

>> No.16930740
File: 46 KB, 851x639, pizzapaplis.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930740

>>16930689
I live in Downriver Detroit. This is what we have for Chicago style pizza.

>> No.16930755

>>16930735
I grew up in a suburb of Chicago and I agree with all you posted. But. I once went to a nice place actually in Chicago and the deep dish completely defied physics and it's own nature. It tasted amazing. Nothing was at all overwhelming like you'd think. It even tasted fucking "light" somehow, even lighter than normal thin pizza. And it was very tasty.

>> No.16930757

>>16930740
Haven’t had it since I was a kid, but my dad is like autistic or tourettes or something so literally every time I see him he shouts out “pizzapopolis!” like fifty times. He says he just thinks it’s a really fun word to say. He’s been doing it for like 30 years now

>> No.16930765

>>16930755
I’ve had Chicago style pizza like that too. Idk how they do it, and I don’t even think I could remember off the top of my head an example of a place that’s done it. Somehow there’s a way to make great Chicago style, but most people don’t know it

>> No.16930776

>>16930757
Your dad is top tier awesome. Can I meet him at Pizza Papalis?

>> No.16930800
File: 1.00 MB, 350x191, 1614338744778.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930800

>> No.16930819

>>16930689
Pan>detroit>american>italian>>new York>chicago

>> No.16930855
File: 82 KB, 810x1080, White man from Detroit.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16930855

>>16930819
You need to be my friend.

>> No.16931109

>>16930689
If i cant eat it without using untensils, its not pizza
I don't care if that's the norm in Italy

>> No.16931137

>>16930710
fpbp, fuck amerilards

>> No.16931309

>>16930689
id love to try chicago but it looks like a this is all i should eat today meal.

>> No.16931320

>>16931309
step yo fat game up boi

>> No.16931488

>>16930735
the reason the tomato sauce is on top is otherwise the cheese would burn given the longer cooking times

>> No.16931494

>>16931320
As someone who used to be fat I will never eat like that again.

>> No.16931503

>>16930689
Chicago style is an interesting novelty and New York style is for children.

>> No.16931517

' '

>> No.16931573

I am an actual italian and I learnt to cook chicago style pizza, it is wonderful and I love it.
I ate nyc pizza in little Italt and didnt like it, in brooklyn found a sicilian pizzaiolo and his american style pizza was decent

>> No.16931607

This argument about pizza seems very much like arguing about what size tits are the best.

>> No.16931610

>>16930689
Both unfathomably foul

>> No.16931613

>>16930735
Chicago is considered east coast?

>> No.16931624

>>16931613
Yeah it's right on the coastline with New York and need jersey, dumbass

>> No.16931628

>>16930689
I'm more of a New York style guy myself, but I can see the appeal of Chicago style, even if it's not necessarily something I'm into.

>> No.16931640

>>16931607
Pizza 'tism is an American tradition.

>> No.16931743

>>16930710
Lol it’s a giant toasted lunchables pizza.
It’s like you gave an oven to a 2nd grader

>> No.16931876
File: 2.59 MB, 640x360, Guaranteed Replies.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16931876

>> No.16931878

>>16931624
It's in the mid-west on the great lakes

>> No.16931892

Chicago style pizza is designed to feed a family and be carried home while retaining its heat and the cheese melt. New York style is designed to sit under a heat lamp and be sold to walkers going by. I prefer Chicago. If I was getting a single serving for only myself, I’d be better off getting a Neapolitan pizza. And eating while walking doesn’t appeal to me.

>> No.16931907

>>16930689
One is an actual pizza, the other is FIB population control via coronary failure

>> No.16931910

>>16931876
>sighs in Korean

>> No.16931918

>>16930735
>god-awful shithole of a "city"

To be fair NYC is a shithole of a city as well, there's trash, bums,and rats everywhere and rent is through the roof

>> No.16931939

>>16931137
Shut the fuck up you don't know shit about pizza

>> No.16931981

love me some 'go 'za

>> No.16932364

>>16931918
There was a period from around the 90s to a few years after 9/11 where it was quite nice. But it's gone to shit again, yeah.

>> No.16932398

>>16932364
This. It was historically shit, then Giuliani-era NYC saw a lot of improvements, then it went to shit again.

>> No.16932416

>>16930710
euro pizza is poverty food shit

>> No.16932427

>>16932416
pizza IS poverty food

>> No.16933046

>>16930689
I don't acknowledge the one on the right as a pizza.

>> No.16933116

>>16930689
Whichever one isn't kosher.

>> No.16933195

>>16932416
And american pizza is proudly continuing that tradition.

>> No.16933198

Both styles are good but if think ny isn't the best then you don't know shit

>> No.16933222

>>16930689
What does Chicago style pizza taste like?

>> No.16933252

>>16931876
>be lactose intolerant
>eat pizza
>??
>profit

>> No.16933255

>>16930689
>actual pizza
>shitty tomato sauce pie
New York hands down

>> No.16933263

>>16930689
>deepdish
that's our special occasion shit, our standard pizza is typically does a flat cracker crust cut into squares

>> No.16933268

Fuck you

>> No.16933276

>>16933222
chicken parmesan without the chicken

>> No.16933324

>>16930689
What is that American abomination on the right? It's definitely not pizza.

>> No.16933337

I've never had a Chicago deep dish pizza. I refuse to believe it wouldn't be absolutely delicious though. It seems like something I wouldn't want every time I had pizza, but would absolutely love a few times a year.

>> No.16933445

>>16930689

I prefer the californian Hot Carl

>> No.16933937
File: 179 KB, 1200x1200, apple-pie-1200-square-592-2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16933937

>>16930721
It's not a pie.

>> No.16933943

>>16931309
That's the idea.

>> No.16933948

>>16931624
Ever heard of maps?

>> No.16933959

>>16933222
Checked. It tastes like any other pizza. It's just thicker. It's a texture change.

>> No.16933972

>>16933337
You have the correct idea about it.

>> No.16933996

>>16930689
So you mean NY pizza vs Chicago pizza flavored cake?

>> No.16934007
File: 342 KB, 500x295, can8.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16934007

Chicago pizza is not a pizza and NY is just a subpar pizza.
Neapolitan pizza is the only pizza worth eating desu

>> No.16934057
File: 126 KB, 960x720, joe mamama's.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16934057

I like what they serve in downstate Illinois. It's not deep dish, and it's not what is considered thin crust as thin crust is even thinner than this here. Plus it is cut into optimal pizza eating squares.

>> No.16935547
File: 36 KB, 348x348, 348s.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16935547

>>16934057
Square cut pizza is the best pizza

>> No.16935550

>>16930689
Apples to oranges. Apples are good. Oranges are good. /thread

>> No.16935557

>>16934057
Tavern style pizza is eaten all over the midwest, but it too originated in Chicago. It's Chicago's other pizza, and honestly, this variety should be the official pizza of Chicago.

>> No.16935603

>>16931613
It is here in California, even though “Illinois” doesn’t seem particularly East-coast.

>> No.16935731

>>16930710
I have to go with this pretentious euro pizza with some prosciutto on top. Love it

>> No.16935737

>>16930721
There is hardly any sauce or cheese on it. The ratio they have at all the pizza chains is a fine ratio.

>> No.16935774
File: 469 KB, 1080x1350, 5B0B437F-90DF-492D-BA72-4D7CF772960A.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16935774

I’ve always preferred the euro pizza, but one day I came across a slice in NY that was pepperoni and peppers. I didn’t realize they were picked and when I took a bite it rocked my world.

I don’t know what the place was called but it was downtown and I would kill to have it again.

>> No.16935785

>>16930740
I actually think they’re pretty good. I liked that I could get A deep dish pizza singleserve for not too much money

>> No.16936339

>>16930689
Detroit Deep Dish is objectively the best form of pizza

>> No.16936354

>>16930689
I like both :)

>> No.16936688

american greek pizza is superior to both,

>> No.16936776

>>16930689
new york retards call pizzas PIEs like what the fuck it's not a pie, a pie is a fucking pie, learn to say pizza

this infuriates me so much because they just use that word incorrectly as a signal they from NY like theyre better than everyone else