[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 99 KB, 491x873, YOU WERE A DOG ONCE.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030217 No.7030217 [Reply] [Original]

So my girlfriend attempted to make chocolate chip cookies for Halloween, and this was the result.
I wasn't watching her do it, so I'm not exactly sure how this happened. The only things I do know is that she substituted baking soda for baking powder, and that she mixed it by hand instead of using some kind of beater.
There's a lot of batter left, and I'd like to be able to salvage it if it's just a matter of a missing ingredient or not being the right temperature or some shit.

Any ideas on what could cause this?

>> No.7030221
File: 212 KB, 600x1684, cookies.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030221

It looks like she put a shitload of sugar and fat in a bowl and forget to add any flour

>> No.7030228

>>7030221
So if we just dump like half a measurement of flour in and try it again, is it plausible they will resemble cookies?

>> No.7030235

>>7030228
Literally who knows? It can't be any worse if you try, though. At best you save it, at worst you waste the dough you were wasting anyway.

>> No.7030249

>>7030228
Can't you just find the ingredients for a single cookie and just scale up?

>> No.7030261

>>7030217
>So my girlfriend attempted
Quit reading right there.

>> No.7030265

muh trypophobia

>> No.7030273
File: 95 KB, 500x548, 1415841518084.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030273

I enjoyed the reference

>> No.7030277

>>7030217
Pan too small, too much liquid in the batter.

>> No.7030281

>>7030249
I mean, just fucking google it. There are like a literal million recipes for chocolate chip cookies. This shit isn't rocket science.

>> No.7030285

>>7030217
because it's supposed to make a dough and not a fucking batter

>> No.7030299

>>7030235
Worth a shot.

>>7030249
>>7030281
She used a recipe, I think she just missed a step.

>>7030277
What does the pan size do? I'm curious.

>>7030285
>implying I know enough about cooking to know they aren't synonyms

>> No.7030508

>she mixed it by hand instead of using some kind of beater

literally completely irrelevant

>> No.7030547

>>7030508
This, you're not supposed to use beaters to make a dough. Are you sure you're not the retard who made fucked up cookies?

>> No.7030557
File: 10 KB, 238x351, 1435801489999.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030557

>So my girlfriend attempted

No, you attempted. You just don't want to be called out for being such a braindead fool that you can't cook fucking cookies.

>> No.7030578
File: 965 KB, 1079x1806, 1433034323640.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030578

>>7030217

Too much sugar.

She's a woman, you expect her to do anything the way someone tells her she's supposed to?

Here's how it went:

>exact increments of butter?
>nahhhhhh just eye it, looks about right teehee I'm cooking look at me
>2 handfuls of flour is the same as 2 cups right?
>2 cups of brown sugar? Well, we don't have that but maple syrup is brown so I'll add that to the sugar to make it brown...same thing right!? Right!
>add a few of these bad boys: :^)
>now we're cooking
>why are my cookies flat
>ANON DID U OPEN THR OVEN MY MOTHER SAID NEVER TO DO THAT WHILE.SOMETHING IS BAKING OR IT WILL FALLLLLL
>THIS...IS...YOUR...FAULT
>*stomp stomp stomp* **SLAM**
>*knock knock knock, honey are you ok???*
>IT'S YOUR FAULT I'M TELLING MY MOM ABOUT IT RIGHT NOW!!! *SNIFF* *SNIFF*
>pls tuch pp my love

^true story

>> No.7030582
File: 126 KB, 320x263, unsheathes fedora.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030582

>>7030578

>> No.7030593

>>7030578
>"why don't girls date nice guys such as le self?"
Sorry you got turned down for the junior prom.

>> No.7030595

>>7030578
Looks about right to me.

>> No.7030596
File: 179 KB, 375x375, laughing-like-a-king-homer-simpson.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030596

>>7030578

Topkek

>> No.7030608
File: 2.99 MB, 4128x3096, 14463283397011411245183.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7030608

>>7030593

I wish I was still dating, being married with kids is rough I tellz ya.

>> No.7030611

>>7030578

Lol'd.

>> No.7030623

>>7030508
I have no idea what is and isn't relevant, which is why I posted it.

>>7030557
>>7030547
If it were me I would have known what I did wrong. But make no mistake, I can't cook at all either.

>> No.7031005

>>7030217
Poorly mixed is the main problem
You can use baking soda in place of powder, they're both sodium bicarbonate but powder has cream of tartar added. That's their only difference however it's a different amount for soda. Like if you use soda you only need 1/3rd of what it calls for for powder, I forget exactly but it's something like that.
Just mix it better next time, all ingredients should be room temp, and added properly at the proper time. Not all at once

>> No.7031014
File: 120 KB, 500x333, wjANVCD.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031014

>>7030578

LOL
O
L

>> No.7031018

>>7030217

The fuck is wrong with her. There is no possible way to fuck up cookies THAT badly.

>> No.7031025

>>7030578
ah you're just a faggot

>> No.7031026

>>7031025
See
>>7030608

Apparently not.

>> No.7031030

>>7030608
4chan is a 18+ website

>> No.7031031

>>7031005
Don't listen to this guy. You can't replace powder with soda. Powder has another ingredient that neutralizes soda so it ends up neutral on the ph scale. Soda will make your cookies spread, while powder will make them puff up like cakes.

>>7030547
So much misinformation in this thread. Mixing by hand definitely changes the cookie since most people won't cream butter and sugar by hand. However, it won't do what you have shown.

The baking soda is definitely the problem. The structure on the holes of your..."cookies" are what happens when you put too much soda in. I wouldn't recommend attempting to fix your dough, but if you do, I would recommend making something like the tollhouse cookie recipe and leaving out the baking soda, and even maybe a little bit of butter, then mixing the two doughs together.

>> No.7031330
File: 156 KB, 1280x722, http%3A%2F%2F40.media.tumblr.com%2F749d03770aec9a39f90128759e84684f%2Ftumblr_nf7mimO3mz1rxq8guo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031330

Omg dude just dump her

I've fucked up cookies before but this is on a whole new level

>> No.7031340

>>7030299
you need enough space for the cookies to expand as needed. also having cold dough makes them not expand too much

>> No.7031344
File: 419 KB, 500x667, 1439870475152.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031344

>>7031030

You're cute.

:^)

>> No.7031351

Baking and some of cooking is just chemistry you can eat.

No wonder most of us women are terrible at it.

>> No.7031352
File: 107 KB, 450x443, 1444510245258.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031352

>>7030578
Somewhere in the deepest recesses of my brain I know this is probably what happened.

>> No.7031353
File: 496 KB, 500x455, 1441496341598.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031353

>>7030608
Thank you, based cooking Dad.

>> No.7031364

>>7031351
Btw I'm a grill

>> No.7031375
File: 379 KB, 480x521, 1416745710276.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031375

>>7030608
your baby has a sick shirt!

>> No.7031769
File: 1.02 MB, 585x585, Capture.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031769

>>7030217
I've had a similar story. Except it was an (ex) boyfriend. Dude had a massive inferiority complex, so when I suggested he needed more flour, he got defensive and blamed me that my oven temp was wrong.

Just add more flour OP, maybe an egg too. And dump the wench. Don't date people who cant follow simple instructions. You'll thank me later.

>> No.7031777

>>7031769
>And dump the wench. Don't date people who cant follow simple instructions. You'll thank me later.
this. i could never make it work with any of my incompetent exes. if they do everything half assed, then you got a half assed girlfriend

>> No.7031783
File: 16 KB, 360x240, 1443492968656.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031783

>>7030221
These kind of comparison pictures that don't include ingredient ratios are so dumb, baking is applied chemistry.

Fuck these useless food bloggers and the dumbfucks they cater to

>> No.7031788

>>7031783
the "standard" chocolate chip cookie recipe is the one that is printed on the back of tollhouse chocolate chip bags
this picture probably goes off of that
calm down bud

>> No.7031805
File: 142 KB, 610x439, 1443492716997.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031805

>>7031788
Checked out that website and at least she's using weights for flour and tells people to buy scales, on the other hand her focaccia dough has sugar in it and everything else is measured in barbaric burger tsps

>> No.7031848
File: 4 KB, 450x450, 3.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031848

>>7030578
>Have two sisters who can't cook
>Read this

My rage and laughter has coalesced into a gestalt of emotions.

>> No.7031849

>>7030217
>>7031769
>I know how to keep my man

>> No.7031859 [DELETED] 

>>7031031
>So much misinformation in this thread. Mixing by hand definitely changes the cookie since most people won't cream butter and sugar by hand. However, it won't do what you have shown.

What is the point of saying this? It was all probably thrown together in the bowl to begin with, the butter was probably melted. You come off like some faggot who sells desserts out of a food truck.

>> No.7031861
File: 552 KB, 1280x528, vlcsnap-2015-08-07-23h08m52s9.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031861

>>7031783
>>7031805

>> No.7031897

>>7030578
women are so fucking stupid jesus christ

>> No.7031900

Tell her to just follow the nesltè toll house recipe, it's womanproof.
https://www.verybestbaking.com/recipes/18476/original-nestle-toll-house-chocolate-chip-cookies/

The baking powder is ok when you don't use brown sugar (white sugar is not so acid so it dowsn't react that good with soda). Also I think the oven was lower than 375 and the dough spread too much while cooking.

>> No.7031909
File: 33 KB, 736x441, 4a26de495ae7fefad395fcf73db2e79a.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7031909

>>7030578
> : :^)
Why are you dating a Spookfish anon?

>> No.7031920

>>7030217
That shit is fucking horrifying OP. I mean that in the literal sense. It's triggering my Trypophobia pretty hard. Got any more abominations?

>> No.7031924

>>7030578
implying I would care if that woman could cook or not instead of just fucking the shit out of her and making my own food or letting her burn our meals and just deal with it with a smile

>> No.7031926

>>7031924
B E T A
E
T
A

>> No.7032667

>>7030217
Make sure the butter is softened, not melted.

Use a little more flour, make the cookies smaller and more evenly spaced.

>> No.7032700

>>7031861
>vlc

>> No.7032777

>>7030217
This is a cooking thread, not a baking thread. Go back to /mlp/

>> No.7032783
File: 104 KB, 533x813, runner-throwing-up.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7032783

Needs more beef lellington