/ck/ - Food & Cooking

Consult the chart

They are hotdogs.

this is such a non-debate like the Die Hard thing that I'm convinced Big Dog must be behind it all

Is cereal soup?

>>17118729
we've been over this

it is an open faced sandwich

>pick your poison

>>17118729
The purpose of language and dividing things into categories is for people to be able to communicate to the other person what you mean or want and for him to understand you.
If you ask a person to bring you a sandwich they sure as hell won't give you a hot dog.

>>17118747
Based germany and chicago, argentina looks really good as well

>>17118742
Empirically I guess it would be

>>17118744
wrong, it's on a split roll, not a single slice of bread.

A hot dog is as much of a sandwich as a meatball sub (the closest comparison to a hotdog).

>>17118738
>Big Dogs literally pre-dates 4chan

>>17118747
For me, it’s chicago, denmark, or vietnam

Technically yes it is a sandwich even though normally it’s not what you’d think of when you think sandwich.

>>17118747

>>17118804
Legally hot dog is a sandwhich

>The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) describes a sandwich as “a meat or poultry filling between two slices of bread, a bun, or a biscuit."

>>17118866
So a PB and J isn’t a sandwich. Got it.

>>17118729
no and neither are hamburgers

Is a sedan a home?

>>17119233
But why are chicken burgers called sandwiches by Americans then?

>>17118729
no hotdogs are not a sandwich they are a skinless sausage.

when placed in a bun some idiots might consider them one, but they would be wrong.

>>17118729 >>17118732 >>17118736 >>17118738 >>17118742 >>17118744 >>17118747 >>17118755 >>17118759 >>17118792 >>17118804 >>17118811 >>17118819 >>17118829 >>17118844 >>17118866 >>17118880 >>17119233 >>17119234 >>17119261 >>17120236
Yes.

>>17120254

>>17118747
Do you eat the Idaho dog like a hot dog or a baked potato?

>>17118729
no, its a tube of meat.

>>17120310
Kek Jesus Christ that pic

>>17118729
Yeah they are part of a broad category of sandwiches

But if you opened a hot dog place in a food court and the owner of a place that sells subs sued the court owner wanting you shut down because the contract said one sandwich shop, you’d probably be allowed to stay because there’s a narrower category of sandwiches that excludes certain types of “atypical” sandwiches.

Burritos and döners and gyros and shawarmas and hot dogs and hamburgers are all sandwiches but they are atypical sandwiches. When we say “I’m getting a sandwich” from a restaurant we mean usually a place that sells a food item on bread rolls (sometimes sliced bread) with sliced luncheon meat and vegetables in between. The luncheon meat is cooked and usually stored cold (exception: nice delis keep pastrami and smoked meat and corned beef brisket steaming).

So my answer is that while a hot dog is a sandwich, you would not call a place that sells only hot dogs a sandwich shop. People generally specific the category of sandwich with atypical sandwiches like hot dogs.
>>17118744
Why? Because it’s only one continuous piece of bread? Subway cuts open a large roll but it doesn’t cut the bread in two. Many sandwich shops do this. A hot dog only has like sixty degrees of exposure, not 180° like an open faced sandwich.
>>17118736
Yeah basically this. Atypical sandwiches are not usually referred to as sandwiches but as the specific type.
>>17118742
No, it’s porridge which is a stew.
>>17118747
The Michigan dog is missing onions

And new york no onions light mustard
>>17118755
Bingo
>>17118804
I see someone already made the point I was going to
>>17118866
What does it mean to be “between a bun”?
>>17118880
Not according to the United States department of agriculture, no
>>17119233
I believe that hamburger is an abbreviation of hamburger sandwich actually. But again, as an atypical sandwich, people usually specify the type of sandwich instead of referring to it as a sandwich.

>>17118732
upvoted and bought 4chan gold for

>>17118747
Korea, China, Amsterdam.

Not all.

<- sandwich type hot-dog

<- non-sandwich type hot-dog.

>>17118729
No, they're buns.

>>17118729
A hot dog is a hot dog.
>>17118742
Cereal is cereal.

>>17122702
Is McD wrong calling the patty in a bun "sandwich"?

>>17118747
I will eat any of the ones without ketchup, ketchup is for subhumans.

>>17118747
seattle; tijuana; dodger;doyer; korea; germany; carolina; coney; bagel; kansas; chile; guatemala; china; argentina; vietnam.

>>17122673
this is superior, no dog slippage
wwhat is called, where do i get one

>>17118747
I'm Norwegian... have only had the Norwegian and the French. Love the French type. It's a whole meal.. The Chicago one looks great.

>>17123682
instead you get sauce fucking everywhere

>>17118747
seattle
germany
baltimore
argentina
don't @ me

hot dog is hot dog
sandwich is sandwich
fuck you

>>17118729
Are subs sandwiches? Are po boys?

>>17124758
>are sub sandwiches, sandwiches?

>>17118729
Yes, also pizza, nachos, and arguably sushi.

>>17118729
No, they are dumplings

>>17124781
fuck it ill bite. explain nachos.
Pizza and sushi I can see but nachos, na...cho.

>>17118732
Christ, that ice cream waffle things sounds so fucking good right now.

>>17118811
Kek, nice digits

>>17118747
Denmark is where it’s at. I’d kill for a Danish hot dog right now

>>17125078
Each individual chip is like an open face sandwich, therefore a plate of nachos is like a plate of tea sammies.

>>17124769
The bread isn't cut in half all the way just like a hot dog bun, which people have used as a point to argue hotdogs aren't sandwiches. So what does OP think qualifies as a sandwich?

>>17118729
>are hot dogs sandwiches
no, they are clearly subs

>>17118729
Hey now you come to mention it, I think they're

Do we have to have this thread every single day?

>>17122673
non-burger here. for my entire childhood this is what hotdogs were for me.
>hotdog "baguette"
>filled with ketchup and mustard
>frankfurter/wiener