[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 654 KB, 2048x2048, 1566116789394(2).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13631930 No.13631930 [Reply] [Original]

Is it universally true that a good cuisine historically always comes from the economically poor lower classes in every country? If you look at places like Italy, France, Japan it seems to be true. They're regarded as some of the best cuisines at the moment, but ingredient wise it's poor people food

>> No.13631934

>>13631930
Pic, not related. I WILL rape you. Goodnight, babygirl.

>> No.13631965

Great thread you got here OP

>> No.13631973

>>13631930
yeah poor people eat caviar...

>> No.13632036

Poverty necessitates creativity when it comes to food

>> No.13632047

>>13631930

no

>> No.13632149

IS

>> No.13632170

>>13631930

yes.

>> No.13632174

>>13631973
>caviar
>cuisine

>> No.13632206
File: 1.42 MB, 1276x836, serb.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13632206

>>13631930
Yes.

Same way that most western cuisine is just meat + veggies, because it's pretty easy to make anything taste good with just meat and some extremely basic seasonings

>> No.13632312

>>13632206
Why is she cute but also ugly

>> No.13632387

>>13632206

Yeah you assholes need to dive into this topic in depth if you want to understand global cuisine. Thailand, Malaysia can grow anything in a day. Their food is fresh and distinctive. The more North you go, the more clever people had to be with food and preserving food, all the way up the the Arctic circle where they'd rot birds in a bag over months and eat it. What do you think about swedish cuisine other than smarmy meathballs? Surströmming. A food that makes normal people puke. So France is right in the sweet zone where they need to learn to preserve shit with confit and that nonsense but also have cows and bread and cheese. Then there's shitty British food for the longest time until modern globalism and colonial India fixed them.

>> No.13632453

>>13631930
The perception that this is the case is mostly just because the kind of people who immigrated to America and opened restaurants tended to be poor, and they brought their poverty recipes with them, so it became what we associate with those countries.

>> No.13632513

>>13632387
>Indian food
>an improvement over English food
Post hand right now nigger, a shitload of curry, fish sauce and turmeric does not suddenly metamorphose bad food into good food

>> No.13632543

>>13632513
I'm just going by what the dull pricks in London keep saying and how they want to occupy Indian food as "their own". Chicken Tikka Masala is ENGLISH. Not mentioning the Dickensian gruel based diets that the peasants lived off of. Or the tin and copper miners eating goat penis.

>> No.13632565

>>13631930
>Italy, France, Japan it seems to be true
the eff you talking about, all 3 of those places had high society culture and imperial ambitions

>> No.13633891

the truth is that poor cuisines are more accessible to the palette and we perceive them to be higher quality.

Haute cuisine is as popular to the elite today as it was when peasant food was only for peasants

>> No.13633905

>>13632513
>Indian food
>fish sauce
You couldn't be more wrong.

>> No.13633908

>>13632543
>Chicken Tikka Masala is ENGLISH
It was invented in Scotland.

>> No.13633991
File: 445 KB, 1366x1080, 1555470306167.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13633991

>>13632565
France yes this is partially true but most of the cuisine was originally food of the poor, as most people were

Cassoulet

>> No.13634006
File: 216 KB, 1439x1080, 1562790528361.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634006

>>13632565
>>13633991
Andouillette

>> No.13634009
File: 318 KB, 1440x1080, 1568795340992.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634009

>>13633991
>>13634006
Tarte flambée

>> No.13634020

>>13631930
No... good food comes from innovative ideas of simple ingredients.

Classic French fine dining is the ultimate expression of using farm to table ingredients to make amazing dishes.

Lyon style cooking would blow the minds of any chef, and whip any apprentice into shape. Modern 'gastronomy' is a fucking meme, to see who can use the most technology to basically remake old dishes into new ones.
Kind of like using the same business model that Henry Ford used and recognizing Elon Musk is using the same model to build cars just with different methods.

>> No.13634028

>>13633991
>>13634009

>>13634020
Agreed

Grattons lyonnais sur saucisse

>> No.13634030
File: 198 KB, 1080x720, 1574338494309.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634030

>>13634028

>> No.13634036
File: 371 KB, 1440x1080, 1569645728782.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634036

>>13633991
>>13634030
Bœuf bourguignon

>> No.13634040
File: 919 KB, 2048x1536, 1579710669075.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634040

>>13633991
>>13634036
Bouillabaisse

That is sea urchin on the bread, expensive now but historically much more cheap and common

>> No.13634619

>>13631930
taste tested by the masses
whereas rich people get retarded ideas like 'exotic' or 'rare' or 'expensive' even if it tastes like shit.
later on rich people come in and take poor/common people food and try to make it more expensive

>> No.13634660

>>13632312
Turkish women in general

>> No.13634691

>>13631930
the thing about poor food is they have to eat the same thing over and over so they find a way to make it as good as possible, wheras rich people can afford to eat whatever is in season, they have chefs who experiment with expensive meats and ingredients so there is less cooking involved if you just sear a steak or cook a lobster and eat it with vegetables

also coffee is bad for you in excess, 1 cup is fine if you drink it black

>> No.13634729
File: 236 KB, 500x500, 1542628025612.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13634729

>>13634036
jesus christ put a spoiler on that, i almost coomed

>> No.13635983

>>13634020
>innovative ideas of simple ingredients.
So, smart poor people food?

>> No.13635994

>>13631930
she has nice boobies but i dont like her face

>> No.13636016

>>13631930
its absolutely not true in France

>> No.13636021

>>13631930
reminder that before capitalism basically everyone in the entire world was extremely poor, even the elites lived lives worse than lower middle class people today. So yeah all cuisines came from poor people because everyone was poor not that long ago

>> No.13636111

>>13634006
Sausage casing stuffed with worms? Yummy!

>> No.13636131

>>13631930
These disgusting brown naples have been up for 2 days. wuddafug jannies

>> No.13636137

>>13631973
>caviar
>salted fish eggs
Yes, I suspect poor people were catching fish and wishing to use everything edible preserved the eggs by heavily salting them. So yes, the poor have been eating caviar from time out of mind.

>> No.13636197

>>13632513
You are just as retarded as the whore in op's post.

>> No.13636226

>>13636021
/thread

>> No.13636236

>>13631930
Poor FARMERS and FISHERMAN. They’re technically poor but they have tons of meat, dairy and vegetables.

>> No.13636243

>>13636021
i think it's hilariously sad that people who advocate for socialism have never experienced food lines and rationing but just so they don't have to pay for college because they want to get a genders studies degree so they can bitch and complain why they couldn't get into a STEM field.

>> No.13636314

>>13636236
yeah but you can't live just on that shit. most poor countries have backwards ass socialist governments that take that directly from them and pay them pennies on the dollar for their goods.

leading up to the fall of the soviet union, the concept of the farmer growing food crops for personal use was a new concept.

>> No.13636329

>>13636243
>the food line meme
You understand that eastern europe was poor literally forever and was actually at its richest point and closest to parity with the West under socialism right? I mean, A LINE, for fucks sake starvation and famine itself have been part and parcel of that part of the world literally forever. A line was a huge step up and the assumption that we'd have the same experience in the West is fucking retarded.

>> No.13636333

>>13636329
denile aint' just a river in Egypt comrade.

>> No.13636340

>>13636329
Stalin killed a fucking lot of people by starving them, it wasn't just lines

>> No.13636344

>>13636329
>T. Retard without grandparents in East Europe

>> No.13636346
File: 1.22 MB, 2047x3482, economic freedom.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636346

>>13636329
>the assumption that we'd have the same experience in the West is fucking retarded.
Capitalism and economic freedom more broadly very strongly correlates with increased prosperity whenever it occurs, its not an assumption, its a logic conclusion based on real world evidence

>> No.13636348

>>13636329
<one meat ration coupon for defending socialism>

>> No.13636350

>>13636131
Fuck off, it is good bating material.

>> No.13636360

>>13636344
>grandparents in East Europe
you mean a jew?
>>13636340
that was political and deliberate, not an economic criticism
>>13636346
Select sectors need to be run by the state to prevent abuse like the power grid and healthcare

THIRD. POSITION.

>> No.13636363

>>13636348
i think i heard this on a podcast but some california chick went to Cuba and they were explaining the coupon system of getting your food and the Cali girl asked "what if the person is a vegetarian?" and the person explaining to her laughed at her because that's not even a thing there. People think socialism is some co-op you buy into and you get your "loot box" every month.

>> No.13636365
File: 90 KB, 576x638, based currybros.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636365

>>13632513
>>13632543
>>13633908
>Chicken Tikka Masala is ENGLISH
BULLSHIT. Chicken tikka masala was / is and will always be Indian food only. Just because you make it milder to suit your taste, it doesn't take away from the fact that it's Indian. As the chef in my pic related says, claiming it and copyrighting our inventions is crazy. You guys should stop doing that. Just because you add yogurt since you can't the handle spice of the original dish doeS NOT make it "your invention". Again, will you guys stop claiming our things for once. From language words to food to culture. You guys have done enough damage. Now stop. No one is saying not to eat it. Keep eating it, But claiming it's YOUR invention is the problem. Colonization is not something to be proud of and also culture exchange due to colonization will never be valid. It's an Indian dish. Just because you eat it a lot doesn't make it yours.

>> No.13636369

>>13636360
MAXIMUM DAMAGE CONTROL

>> No.13636370

>>13631930
hahahaha! no.

>> No.13636378
File: 224 KB, 500x334, geezus.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636378

>>13634006
>>13634030
>>13634036
>>13634040

>> No.13636408

>>13636360
>that was political and deliberate, not an economic criticism
it was both a failure of an economic system and a political system

>> No.13636415

>>13636360
yeah, because governments are so good at not abusing their power

>> No.13636421

>>13631930
No - tends to be a mix.
Technique comes from wealthy people demanding opulent meals and from poor people trying to make the most out of lesser or harder to prepare ingredients.

Spices pretty much only were imported to europe for wealthy people but were commonly used by regular people in the far east. in the middle east, primarily wealthy people used spices there too.

>> No.13636444

>>13636408
but the food and infrastructure existed to feed those people. The same abuse can happen in a capitalist system and in fact did, e.g. the irish potato famine.
>>13636415
I think you're not understanding that the enormous corporate conglomerates that run our countries abuse their power too.

>> No.13636452

>>13636444
>potato famine happened in 1845
>Ireland was a capitalist country back then
that's a yikes from me.

>> No.13636453

>>13636444
>The same abuse can happen in a capitalist system and in fact did, e.g. the irish potato famine.
the irish potato famine had nothing to do with capitalism, it was a government exploiting its peasants to enrich the party, straight up lefitsm

>> No.13636457

>>13636444
>I think you're not understanding that the enormous corporate conglomerates that run our countries abuse their power too.
Thats why capitalism is good, leftism has a mandatory monopoly on everything which always leads to corruption and poor quality and lack of innovation, capitalism drives innovation and prosperity by encouraging competition

>> No.13636463

>>13636452
>19th century UK
>not capitalist
okay...
>>13636453
That's literally my point, it was the fault of the political system much the same way Stalin's holodomor was. The food and infrastructure to feed the people existed in both scenarios but politics got in the way, so the economic system was not at fault.

>> No.13636468

>>13636457
>enormous monopolistic corporate conglomerates run the vast majority of the economy
>"competition"
you're just defending huge industrial cartels which themselves run the government

>> No.13636472
File: 39 KB, 644x500, literally.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636472

>>13636463
>literally

>> No.13636478

>>13636365
you need to go back

>> No.13636490

>>13631930
popular =/= good

>> No.13636492
File: 53 KB, 1280x720, maxresdefault[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636492

>>13636472

>> No.13636495
File: 125 KB, 1200x800, mud-cookies-haiti-1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636495

>>13631930
i can't believe OP forgot about mud cookies.

>> No.13636500

>>13636492
>maxresdefault[1].jpg
phone posters need to be gassed

>> No.13636506

>>13636452
It was a colony of England which meant they felt the full pain of the kick from the brutal boot of their capitalist overlords. Capitalism ultimately robs man of dignity and oftentimes life itself.

>> No.13636507

>>13636329
>r. A line was a huge step up and the assumption that we'd have the same experience in the West is fucking retarded.
no it wasn't you fucking retard, famines and starvation became significantly rare in europe and most countries that eventually fell to soviets has increasing qualities of life
guess what happened AFTER the soviets took over
incompetent, retarded, corrupt fucks and their idiots defending them till this day I swear

>> No.13636512
File: 229 KB, 2048x1152, rYab19z.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636512

>>13636506
>confusing capitalism with mercantilism
.

>> No.13636520

>>13636468
still better than the alternative, and history shows that natural monopolies are very hard to maintain in a free market, they basically only happen for significant periods of time with government interference

>> No.13636523

>>13632565
Many (maybe most?) modern Italian dishes are recent creations, and much of the country was insanely poor in the 1800's with people eating acorns and shit to survive leading to one of the major Italian diasporas to America in the late 1800's. Things like polenta and gnocchi stretched with whatever they could get their hands on were considered poverty foods for poors until more recently. It wouldn't have been something you'd serve to the upper class or that they'd consider eating in the past.

>> No.13636526

>>13636463
UK was a mercantilism country you dumb newfag. go back and tell your uni socialist professor you need new buzzwords to misunderstand.

>> No.13636541

>>13636495
are they any good?

>> No.13636555

>>13636506
this is what socialist actually believe. Also like that other anon pointed out. Wealth of Nations was written long after the golden days of English colonies so the idea of Capitalism wasn't a thing until Adam Smith wrote that book.

>> No.13636575

>>13636520
so everyone should just the fuck up and let the jewish cartels rob the country blind and leave us out to dry like a knocked up whore once it's all gone, at least you know where you stand, guy.
>natural monopolies are very hard to maintain in a free market
you just do the same goalpost moving as left wing socialists and communists, you're doing a >THAT'S NOT REAL CAPITALISM
Yes, it is, because the 'totally unnatural monopolies that wouldn't exist in real capitalism!' gain political and cultural power which they wield to alter the conditions of the marketplace. That's what has happened.

>> No.13636576

>>13636506
mercantile colonies have literally nothing to do with capitalism, and in practice look a fucking lot more like Soviet Russia's colonization of eastern Europe and Central Asia

>> No.13636584

>>13636575
>so everyone should just the fuck up and let the jewish cartels rob the country blind
Go back to fucking /pol/ man, what the fuck are you even talking about?
>gain political and cultural power which they wield to alter the conditions of the marketplace
Only possibly in an overly strong government

>> No.13636655

>>13636584
>1% of the population
>50% of billionaires
Is that the free market at work too?

>> No.13636661

>>13636555
>capitalism didn't exist until Adam Smith defined it
/lit/fags need to /out/

>> No.13636684
File: 431 KB, 5343x3663, 1552841744439.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636684

>>13636655
literally everything is better than ever before, stop focusing on shit that doesn't even matter, rich people being rich doesn't stop you from also having a better life than 99.99% of all people born more than 100 years ago

>> No.13636703

>>13636684
wow you're a fucking faggot.

>> No.13636757
File: 17 KB, 280x280, 1573674394015.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13636757

>>13636703
seething socialistard

>> No.13636806

>>13636021
>>13636226
>>13636243
retarded
>>13636757
>>13636684
It's time for you to realize that the growth in living standards was the cheap energy transition. Oil and its various byproducts are what boosted agriculture, industry, international trade, etc. Human will can't transcend physics.
Though all this cheap energy has been a miracle for mankind, it's not unlimited nor consequence-free. So yes you're a fucking faggot if you're fine with a tiny elite claiming most of the growth as long as you get to the tiny drops they let behind.

>> No.13636812

>>13636703
dilate

>> No.13637150
File: 220 KB, 500x543, 1500425736161.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13637150

>>13636806
>posting this unironically

>> No.13638069

>>13636541
best dirt you'd ever taste I wager
emmy made and ate them at one point https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J76fun8m5no

>> No.13638299

>Is coffee good for you?

>> No.13638420

Same with music

>> No.13638503

>>13631930
The only reason France, Italy and Japan have tasty peasant food is because those countries have mild climates that are well suited to growing a broad variety of vegetables, herbs and spices, plus they have access to the sea for cheap, plentiful seafood, everywhere else peasants ate shitty food like boiled turnips, potatoes and wholemeal bread for pretty much every meal

>> No.13638511
File: 172 KB, 331x384, 1577144032589.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13638511

>>13638420
>folk music is better than nobleman music like Bach and Vivaldi

>> No.13638551

>>13638511
It is though

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZxml8SJOjg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDtWM6L75l4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hALhJM8xuIA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubIGp0BTikw

Nobleman music isn't even about anything, it's just an excessive amount of instruments.

>> No.13638566
File: 73 KB, 764x512, crainomilkies.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13638566

>>13631930
those tits look so suckable

>> No.13638583 [DELETED] 

Also, did you all entirely forget this mini-series
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwkRWIwZ43A

>> No.13638589

>>13638583
ah fuck wrong thread

>> No.13638630

>>13631930
A culture of historical opulence and success leads to people eating wonky bullshit like peacock liver soaked in mercury or watery tiger penis soup purely for the “medicinal” magical value rather than any enjoyment of taste.

Case in point, expensive chinese high class cuisine is garbage but Vietnamese povo commie cuisine (with a bit of french influence) is infinitely better

And chinese food from historically poorer/backwater areas is generally good as well

>> No.13638652

>>13631930
False. Good food comes from two things:
>access to ingredients
>a royal class that demands good food

This is why all good food types start off as food for nobility. For example:
>Dim Sum
Breakfast of the Chinese emperors

>Sandwich
Made for the Earl of Sandwich

And so on. If you were a dirty medieval peasant, you rarely had access to meats, let alone high quality spices and whatnot. All haute cuisines started off as food you served to royalty because they were picky eaters with access to all the ingredients available to the country. Peasants primarily subsisted on grains and whatever scraps of meat they could find (like snails and whatnot).

>> No.13638674

>>13632387
>britland
>cuisine
>fixed
get real

>> No.13638689

>>13631930
my cosine is pretty, but yours is very pretty.

>> No.13638707

>>13636500
Does anyone actually use a pc anymore?

>> No.13638730

>>13634036
that is not beef burgundy

>> No.13638849

>>13632387
the information here is worse than that of schizophrenic on crack

>> No.13638947

>>13636684
Most of this is in reference to China and African countries. Why should I care?

>> No.13639283

>>13631973
It was poor people food in a small region of France before Russians made it into a delicacy

>> No.13639290

>>13638707
only nerds that don't belong on 4channel

>> No.13639434

>>13638511
He ain't wrong though

>> No.13639480

>>13636526
yes the united kingdom in the 19th century, during the industrial revolution was actually "a mercantilism country" no capital and private ownership at all.

>> No.13640456

>>13631930
sauce?

>> No.13640457

>>13631973
Uhmm. yes? In Iran, Russia and all the other regions bordering the Caspian sea, poor people ate that shit, it wasnt before the 20th century that it became a "delicacy"

>> No.13640469

>>13632513
>english food
Mate, everybody on this entire earth hates english food, the only remotely good thing that came from your islands was brekkie. Nobody likes jellied eel or fucking pasties filled with digusting root veg and trash meat. Why do you think kebab stores are all over the UK? Because your food sucks

>> No.13641065

>>13631930
it's almost like for the majority of all human history, there have been more poor people than rich people. Yeah I wonder why we have more recipes from poor people, ya tard.

>> No.13641660

>>13636329
Eastern european here from the happiest barracks. Go fuck yourself and your enabling family with a rake. Hope you will get to realize your dream and live in a communist country for the rest of your life.

What a fucking idiot.

>> No.13641754
File: 36 KB, 607x405, diet plate(1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13641754

>>13638511
Most classical music was just formula music in the same vein as our pop songs

Classical music is literally pop music from the past

And I like classical music

>> No.13641816

>>13631973
Lobster used to be poor people food. Things change.

>> No.13641819

>>13639283
>It was poor people food in a small region of France before Russians made it into a delicacy
keked i'm french and no, it's from iran and yes it's was the poor who eat it and the fish is for the rich

>> No.13642039
File: 456 KB, 546x767, IMG_0232.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13642039

>>13636243
You mean I no get a gender study degree for free? I change world with study of gender..it is mystery to all. You must pay me engineer salary to know gender so I can pay taxes for heroin people and The Bernie Sandman. I am woman so hear me roor

>> No.13642208
File: 45 KB, 720x696, IMG_0248.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13642208

>>13642039
White man is devil. No good. They do no thing good. First person on moon, mikroposssear, cumbustyun engine, all the internets, Lezbo naughty films, nucalur power... no non-homo whyte man does any good. Wymon are us future... in 100 years men will be dead and we will be a wymon only planet

>> No.13642348

The lower classes do the cooking