/ck/ - Food & Cooking

>>12932192
cold, wtf?

>>12932192
i usually pop it in the microwave before eating, so warm-hot

Hot any other is retarded

more important question, do eggs belong in potato salad?

>>12932192
Just a bit below room temp.

>>12932205
otherwise known as "cold"

>>12932192
I like to leave my pot salad on the counter so I sneak a nice room-temperature bite any time of day

Nigga, you aint eating real potato salad unless it's sat out under the warm sun all day long.

>>12932218
definitely not cold. maybe cool, i'll give that to ya

2 hours in the danger zone, use it wisely

>>12932223
Mmmh I love dying from cereulide poisoning

Who eats it cold except people from Reddit

>>12932245
Oh no.
Look out, I hear there might be some yellow jackets outside too that might buzz around your weak ass.

>>12932192
That's screaming out for some mustard and horseradish. Use Colman's and Gold's for that extra kick.

>>12932204
yes

Thread should be:
>Is potato salad a salad?
And the answer: No

>>12932192
Depends on the potato salad. Mayo based like pic related, cold. German style, warm

>>12932551
Webster's dictionary disagrees
Definition of salad
1: any of various usually cold dishes: such as
a: raw greens (such as lettuce) often combined with other vegetables and toppings and served especially with dressing
b: small pieces of food (such as pasta, meat, fruit, or vegetables) usually mixed with a dressing (such as mayonnaise) or set in gelatin
2: a green vegetable or herb grown for salad
especially : LETTUCE
3: a usually incongruous mixture : HODGEPODGE

>>12932192
>Is potato salad eaten warm or cold? Please help, this is ruining my marriage.
>Not accepting that dishes can be enjoyed in many forms.
Pasta salad, egg salad, tuna salad, potato salad, etc. are all enjoyable both warm and cold. However, the temperature can mask and accentuate certain flavours.

>>12932192
Cold obviously, are you retarded?

>>12932556
>or set in gelatin
>eggs in aspic is now a salad
I'm out.

>>12932563
Good, get out and stay out

>>12932566
What if you set potato salad in aspic? That would make it a salad salad. Mind blown.

There's nothing I love to eat more than some steaming-hot potato salad. I microwave it right out of the pot so it can get extra-hot.

>>12932360
Great, I hope you create a whole business fermenting your own potato salad in the sun for five straight days and then feed it to your whole family and friends, all for that magnificent test boost of course

>>12932579
>There's nothing I love to eat more than some steaming-hot potato salad. I microwave it right out of the pot so it can get extra-hot.

potato salid is a sin and shouldant exist

Mayonaise is ilegall

>>12932570
Serve it on a frisbee for extra points like you'd get in grade school.

>>12932662
Based tardposter

>>12932710
tard baseposter

Isn’t southern style “German” potatoes salad served hot?

>>12932192
not even white and i know its supposed to be a cold dish

>>12932555
no German eats warm potato salad, u burger.

Arent potatoes au gratin basically hot "potato salad"? There is nothing wrong with potatoes au gratin

Cold to contribute to the growing consensus. Please for the love of god don't consume your potato salad warmer than room temp.

>>12932192
This looks like shit. I have a godlike recipe for a german + EE mixed style potato salad which is mindblowing. And cold is the answer

>>12932192
i can say ive eaten warm and cold. doesnt really matter: if you like warm, eat warm, if you like cold, eat cold
its not ruining marriage:
>>your making mountain out of molehill

>>12932721
Only after they goostestep to work up a thirst.

I eat mine cold. Only eat it made with mustard. I've never made my own I just buy the stuff from Schnucks Deli.
I'm more of a cole slaw type. Vinegar based

>>12932192
It's pretty good with some macaroni noodles in there

>>12932732
They literally do. It might not be fashionable now, but the original German recipe for potato salad can be served warm or cool. It's not at all like American potato salad (OP pic)
Your obsession is causing you literal retardation.

>>12932192
Cool-ish? Not directly-out-of-the-fridge cold though, it needs to be warm enough for you to be able to taste the flavors.

>>12932843
Well that wouldn't be called potato salad, would it? It would be called something with German words,

Cold obviously

>eat it hot!
>hot mayo tends to just dissolve back into oil
Cold, always.

>>12932865
Yes. Kartoffelsalat. Which translates to "Potato Salad". Because that what it is. You do know German potato salad doesn't have mayo in it, right? It's vinegar based.

>>12932192
If the taters & eggs are right out of the pot then warm is fine. If not, then put in the fridge straight away to cool.

I'd say probably around like 60 degrees Fahrenheit.

Nobody eats mayo based dishes hot

It's meant to be eaten chilled

>>12933256
This one knows the ways.

If you make it fresh from the potatoes and eggs right out of the pan....that is where angels smile.

>>12932192
Cold, wtf. There are actually subhumans that eat it hot? You people disgust me...

>>12932588
Show me on this doll where the room-temp potato salad touched you.

>>12933561
I eat it right out of the pot. Warm potatoes and bacon.

>>12932192
The shit kind with mayo is eaten cold.
The good kind with vinegar and bacon is eaten warm.

>>12933567
I use them all, though? Eat it warm and cold.

>>12933572
>I use them all
What kind of potato salad do you fucking make?
Anyway, as long as you use mayo it should be eaten cold as mayo will just turn into oil when warm.

>>12933566
3rd worlder spotted.

>>12932204
No, cold eggs are disgusting.

>>12932555
>>12932732
Go for broke, how about room temp?

> whole thread
> nobody says ‘slightly chilled’

This is why everybody laughs at us, guys.

>>12933248
So it's not potato salad. It's kartoffelsalat. OP asked about potato salad.

>>12932192
freshly made so warm.

Deviled Egg potato salad is the best

>>12933248
No wonder you krauts all smell like vinegar and goosestep.

Here's a deviled eggs recipe from my mom, it's really good imo.
-----
I don't follow an exact recipe. Adjust for your taste.

Eggs - 1 dozen hard boiled, cut in half lengthwise
Onion - 1/4 cup finely minced
Coleman's Mustard - either dry powder 1/4 tsp. or wet 1/4 tsp.
Indian Hot Curry Powder - 3/4 tsp.
Hot Sauce - 1/4 tsp.
Salt - 1/4 tsp.
Pepper - Freshly ground - 1/4 tsp.
Mayonnaise - 1 cup +/-

Remove cooked egg yolks from eggs and finely crumble in a bowl with a fork
Place cooked egg whites in a covered container and refrigerate
Add dry ingredients i.e. curry powder, salt, pepper, and dry mustard (if using) to crumbled egg yolks and mix together
Add onion to egg yolks and mix together
Add wet ingredients i.e mayonnaise, hot sauce and wet mustard (if using), and mix together. Almost whip it.

Place plastic wrap on surface of egg mixture and refrigerate over night.

The next day, check the egg mixture and add additional mayonnaise so the consistency is semi-firm yet moist.

Using two teaspoons, scoop enough egg mixture into a spoon and use the other spoon to push from the spoon into the egg white. Make a nice size mound.

Sprinkle filled eggs with a little curry powder for decoration.

Enjoy and adjust the next batch to your taste.

>>12932192

How the fuck is that a salad? Where's the lettuce, the tomato, the onion etc. etc.?

>>12934432
That's why german potato salad was differentiated in the original reply.

>>12934571
Screen capped. Have always wanted a genuine recipe for these. Tell your mom I owe her a big one.

>>12932192
The proper temperature for potato salad is reached after a bowl of it has sat in the summer sun on picnic table for however long it takes to finish cooking hotdogs and burgers.

Seriously, why do so many of you leave food in the sun when having a barbecue? How fucking hard is it, really, to set up a sun umbrella in your gardens near the outside table? Do you not have big sun umbrellas in the US? Should we start a crowdfunder and mass ship some over to you faggots from the U.K.?

>>12933591
American, so literally the first world by definition.
>>12933581
Deviled egg w/ bacon potato salad.

>>12932192
I eat it shortly after making it which includes boiling the potatoes so it’s always warm or hot but it tastes good after being refrigerated too.

>>12932811
Based St. Louis poster

>>12934704
bong, please

>>12935006
Everywhere in America is basically the desert? Ok.

I personally eat it cold. I buy it storemade so heating it would be like eating heated mayo

>>12932192
You put it out cold then it warms up during the picnic

>>12932192
Just like that Pink Floyd song
Any way you like

>>12932192
that looks like throw up. dude never touch a potato again. and this isn't a salad.
>12932201
its supposed to be cold you fucking mong

>>12932192
>mayo and potato salad
>eaten warm
Oh god I might be sick

>>12932192
>warm potato salad

>>12932732
Chef John from foodwishes.com did a German potato salad recipe. It had some bacon fat in it IIRC. He said it should be served warm so the fat isn't solidified.

>>12932192
I've only ever been given it cold but it's fucking disgusting so who cares.

>>12932192
It's a little warm when I first make it and eat it, but I love it cold from the refrigerator the next day, too!

>>12932192
>warm potato salad
I've never heard of this shit in my entire life, this sounds like something they would do in the bible belt

>>12932570
What if you set reddit reddit in reddit? That would make it a reddit reddit reddit. Mind blown.

>>12932192
the one food that always made me puke

i think we can all agree that pickled beets do not belong in a potato salad, it just ruins it.

>>12932192
>whiteoids eat this