[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 182 KB, 1800x1080, Nmbc_055.jpg_595.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR] No.12772[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

Is the moral of this story about the dangers of cultural appropriation?

>> No.12773

>>12772
Im sure that wasnt the intention

>> No.12774

No, the message was about not to be a weaboo
Jack was the weeb
Christmas town was Nippon

>> No.12775

No, the moral was "If you get bored with your job, shut up and keep doing it anyway, stupid."

>> No.12776

>>12772
It's about not screwing around with the affairs and creations of others just because you think you know what is best.

Perhaps the same could be said of all the animation industry.

>> No.12777
File: 71 KB, 640x803, 17553852_1247635228617893_3424420985780231097_n.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>12772
Yes it was

>> No.12778

If youre a braindead tumblrfag who sees everything as some form of validation of their political beliefs, then yes. Otherwise probably not

>> No.12779

>>12772
Burton is a creative mind so it's more applicable to artists & creativity in general. He essentially was copying another artist and trying to make that artist's work his own without fully understanding the context and nuancies of that work. Instead, he should have been taking inspiration from that artist's work to enrich his own work and give himself a new perspective.

>> No.12780

>>12776
>Perhaps the same could be said of all the animation industry.
Deep bro

>> No.12781

>>12777
>implying anyone under the age of 12 would know what Nightmare Before Christmas is

>> No.12782

TNBC always confused me. Tim Burton loves morals about individuality and not giving a shit what others think...but this movie's moral is the complete opposite.

The moral of the film is literally DO NOT TRY NEW THINGS, YOU WILL FAIL. JUST STICK TO THE STATUS QUO. FALL IN LINE AND EVERYONE WILL PROSPER, COMRADE.

>> No.12783

>>12782
>taking it at face value and boiling it down to something so dumbed down instead of seeing the actual complexity of the moral
c'mon man

>> No.12784

>>12779
>He essentially was copying another artist and trying to make that artist's work his own without fully understanding the context and nuancies of that work. Instead, he should have been taking inspiration from that artist's work to enrich his own work and give himself a new perspective.
This.

>> No.12785

>>12772
I thought it was the usual "The grass is always greener" type thing?

>> No.12786
File: 209 KB, 1024x1252, The moral of Wreck It Ralph.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>12772

>> No.12787
File: 39 KB, 384x313, 1478219674717.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

>>12781
I don't interact with a lot of younger people, is Nightmare Before Christmas finally just a brand of Hot Topic clothing to a whole generation?

>> No.12788

I see it more as a message that if you're inspired to try something yourself, you should go for it. If you fuck it up, then at least you gave it your best. But you should also take responsibility for your mistakes and kill Oogie Boogie when he attempts to kill Santa Claus and your zombie waifu.

>> No.12789

>>12788
sage words

>> No.12790

Its /co/ so I can't tell if OP is trolling

>> No.12791

>>12788
Was Sally a zombie? I thought she was a rag doll

>> No.12792

>>12791
Zombie, rag doll, same difference.
Whatever she is, you can know for a fact that she wanted Jack to bone her.

>> No.12793

>>12772
This is my favorite kids movie
I don't know why I have a strange fascination with the idea of a character who is a king above everyone with control over everything who worked through hell to obtained it all and now that he has it he is bored and bitter and sits in the throne looking down at everyone with nothing but disdain, I had it all my lofe
There is this old musician I loved as a kid who is pretty much among the top three musicians ever in my country and he used to have this perfect voice but now it's old and raspy and destroyed by all the drugs he did and I went once to watch him play Wich he did once a year and he sat and yelled I was the king of this land Wich is part of the lyrics of a song but with his old voice not even singing looking at the audience and you could tell he was the fucking king and we are the servants going there to pay tribute

>> No.12794

>>12791
she was a frankenstein

>> No.12795

>>12793
One, you're high.
Two, was it Dylan? Because I know that all he does nowadays is mumble his songs.

>> No.12796

>>12777
Well, she's kind of right, isn't she? In this particular instance, anyway. That might not have been the intended message of the movie, but you can't deny that Jack took what wasn't his and nearly ruined it completely because he didn't understand it.

If Jack wants to dress as Santa, more power to him, but the problem is he tried to BE Santa.

>> No.12797

>>12777
Technically the whole world is culturally appropriating the American version of Christmas
SantClaus alone was designed for cocacola ads

>> No.12798

>>12791
>>12792
>>12794
rag doll stuffed with autumn leaves
holy fuck please go to a doctor and get your memory checked, these kinds of movies are specifically setup so you'll remember them even past childhood

>> No.12799

>>12772
I thought it was about how stores shouldn't start putting the Christmas stuff out when Halloween isn't even over yet.

>> No.12800

>>12779
This. Also, midlifecrisis.

>> No.12801

>>12797
It's gotten to the point where Saint Nicholas and the American version (translated into "christmas man" or "father christmas" are now two distinct figures in Europe, one giving presents on Dec 6 and the other on Dec 25.

>> No.12802

>>12796
He kidnapped santa claus, not allowing him to do what he does and doing it for him instead, wrong.
"cultural appopriation" is bullshit as a concept because it's not stopping people from doing what they do, it's just copying them. Imagine if instead of trying to take-over christmas they would have turned halloween into a holiday of scary gifts and surprises. There'd been no problem at all.

>> No.12803

>>12777
>Tried to take what is unique about Christmas Town away
He literally stole Santa, it's not the same thing

>> No.12804

>>12775
that's a good point
april fools, filtered

>> No.12805

>>12801
Nah, in most places in Europe it's still Baby Jesus/etc. that brings presents on the 25th.
And I think the dec6 thing is mostly a thing in ex-communist countries because Christmas was discouraged back then.

>> No.12806

>>12777
Since she provided no context on who the children she so often talks to are, I'm going to assume she just kidnaps them and teaches them about this stuff, then tosses them back on the street to start a new run.

>> No.12807
File: 458 KB, 1920x1080, Random Art (35).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
[ERROR]

It's about not forcing your views on another

It's just Plato's Cave all over again

>Get out of ordinary place
>See wonders and unexplainable things
>Try to tell the average folk about the said things
>Instead of trying to reach for paradise they make the ideas commonplace, misunderstanding every single aspect of it
>Finally forces everyone to behold what he saw
>In fear people attack him ending in death and the others going back to status quo

Of course the downplayed the death part, but it's pretty much that

Trying to make other people see something only themselves can do always ends in disaster.

>> No.12808

>>12772
no, the moral is Burton is a fucking hack when it comes to animation and Henry Selick is the true source of this films brilliance.

>> No.12809

>>12803
And convinced the other citizens of Halloween Town to emulate Christmas with a drastically incomplete understanding of what it's actually about or what the point of everything they're doing is, thereby spoiling it for the people who were expecting an actual Christmas and instead got Halloween Town's flawed interpretation thereof.

>> No.12810

>>12772
the moral was "dont copy something superficially without understanding it"

>> No.12811

>>12807
they aint gonna kill me, they chained to a chair. ill go get some clorophorm and knock those cock suckers out before i haul their dumb asses into the light

>> No.12812

>>12805
Low countries and environs it's Dec 6 for Saint Nicholas (with some areas instead opting for Saint Martin on November 11 because ti's their patron saint), and Dec 25 is the commercialized American version.

>> No.22027

>>12810

Sorry. I can't think of a reference.