[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking


View post   

File: 52 KB, 909x552, carrageenan-and-5-other-gum-additives-you-should-avoid-if-you-have-ibs-sibo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11179158 No.11179158 [Reply] [Original]

Is carrageenan safe?

>> No.11179162

It might be, but it also might not be.

>> No.11179165

>>11179158
>gives you information
>doesn’t explain it
Kek
Never listen to shit like that

>> No.11179172

>>11179165
Even in my own research on carrageenan I can't find anything conclusive.

>> No.11179294

It's safe. Here's how to spot dumb Facebook bullshit meme health crap posted by dumb people with respect to acids.

All acids are just protons being shuttled by water molecules in a complex know as hydronium. ALL acids. All of them.

The only difference between, for example, vinegar (acetic acid) and concentrated nitric acid is the molecule's ability to readily give up/let go of it's acidic proton.

Coming to my point, any substance carragenan is added to will have a pH. There's nothing special about stomach acid that would cause to become cancerous. Adding it to sour cream? It's got some acid, by their claim it would automatically cancerous. Which it's not.

Carragenan is a polysaccharide made by algea I believe. It's a type of long chain sugar. All it does is increase viscosity and improve mouthfeel. In the case of coffee beverage from the store for example, carragenan and other gums are added to low-fat beverage formulations to provide the same Timon and mouth feel of full-fat drink.

>> No.11179301

>>11179294
Your explanation about acids and their reactions is pretty bad.

>> No.11179418

>>11179158
>"DR"HAGMEYER
>chiropractor
>licensed to practice voodoo alternative medicine
>not licensed to practice real medicine
>not even an actual doctor, or nurse, nothing
every time

>> No.11179523

>>11179301
Care to elaborate?

>> No.11179580

>>11179523
Figure it out yourself, retard

>> No.11180002

>>11179301
No it's not

>> No.11180119

carrageenan will give make you femenine

>> No.11180128
File: 84 KB, 764x454, Web-Dr-Hagmeyer[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11180128

>>11179418
Shh, just let Dr. Hagmeyer's helpful chart explain how to be healthy. He spent all night making this in CorelDraw.

>> No.11180292

Half of the shit that makes up junk food is not safe, There's really not much you can do about it.

>> No.11180893

>>11179301
>>11179580
OK thanks for your contribution

>> No.11180912

Neat, not a single source on that picture.

>> No.11182013

>>11179158
>(natural)
>soy milk
>nutritional shakes
>infant formula

>> No.11182056

>>11179158
>>11179172
>>11179294
>>11180912
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=carrageenan+cancer

>> No.11182376

>>11179158
http://raypeat.com/articles/nutrition/carrageenan.shtml

I can't say this is proof, but here is some food for thought. Sources at the bottom.

>> No.11182382

>>11182056
That’s not a source

>> No.11182397

>>11182013
the thickening agent is natural, the products it is used for may not be

>> No.11183460

>>11179158
Well, my quick google has just lessened "becomes" to "may"

Fuck I hate the social medias combined with individualism, everyones wants to be that special snowflake

>> No.11183464

>>11180128
>Hollistic and Functional medicine for chronic disease
Oh boy

>> No.11183553
File: 160 KB, 1365x768, d241.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11183553

>>11179294
>Here's how to spot dumb Facebook bullshit meme health crap posted by dumb people
>How to spot gay buttfucker bullshit meme health crap posted by a fag on 4chan with no sources
>>11182382
>That’s not a source
It's better than the source you posted you buttblasted bitch, i.e. none
I swear to god vegan fuckboys are thick as thieves tonight

>> No.11184982

>>11179158
It's currently generally recognised as safe (GRAS), yes.

There was one study from Joanne Tobacman that linked poligeenan to inflammation, but repeated attempts to replicate her study with carrageenan completely failed. Unless you are eating boric acid (and, you are not), the only thing that would cause one to transform into the other would be raising it to a near-boil at ≈87°C (which would itself kill you if it happened in your stomach).

She went on the defensive and starting pushing her bullshit to "natural science" snake-oil pushers, which is a good indication that the study was probably fabricated, Wakefield-style, from the beginning.

>>11179294
It's from a seaweed.

>> No.11185064

>>11179158
Yes
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.3109/10408444.2013.861798?journalCode=itxc20

>> No.11185309

>>11180128
The glaciers are trying to kill us?

>> No.11185418
File: 32 KB, 638x633, 1533372508595.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11185418

>>11179158
>Dr Hagmeyer is a licensed Chiropractic physician who holds advanced certifications in Functional Medicine.

>> No.11185496
File: 35 KB, 662x960, 1534732921606.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
11185496

>>11180119
>Will give make

>> No.11185515

>>11185309
ice(((berg)))