[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug ] [ 4plebs / archived.moe / rbt ]

2022-05-12: Ghost posting is now globally disabled. 2022: Due to resource constraints, /g/ and /tg/ will no longer be archived or available. Other archivers continue to archive these boards.Become a Patron!

/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL


View post   
View page     

[ Toggle deleted replies ]
File: 1.85 MB, 500x289, tumblr_ne6nzqw9Eq1shrx9ko1_r2_500.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7986557 No.7986557 [Reply] [Original] [rbt]

Previously: >>7971138

> Cosplay Masterpost:
http://pastebin.com/Lu6AxkYk
A pastebin full of tutorials, links, and general helpful info for Homestuck cosplays. As always, more input of any kind will always welcomed Tutorials, wig suggestions, any suggestion or contribution is great and will be added.

Regardless, we can always discuss:
> 2014 is almost over, what HS cosplays have you done this year? Do you plan to do more HS cosplays in 2015?
> What's your favorite HS cosplay that anyone has done?
> Have you ever been to any Homestuck panels? What were they like?

>> No.7986677
File: 50 KB, 319x480, 050_FRONT_47d486c4-d298-4da8-b23a-6dbee2af8332_large.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7986677

>>7986557
Does anyone have experience with lace front wigs? The one i bought from Arda was extremely tight on my head, and i also looked like shit, maybe i'm just uggo?

The wig i got was a Dany during the Black friday sale, i plan to fix the hairline so it's good for fef.

The wig is going to be for Feferi, also is there any Feferi's that used goggles and didn't look like weenies?

>> No.7986695

>>7986677
Pure black wigs look like shit without makeup and especially lace fronts in my experience. With that said, I do think the final result is great. Just make sure your hair/wig cap doesn't show through the lace. Also, cutting the hairline to look more natural really helps. Lace tight to the hair and whatnot.

Also, ardas LFWs have much tighter lace than what the first one I bought, so that may be part of it, that it just looks unnaturally thick.

>> No.7986717

>>7986695
Okay, thank you so much, when i tried it on i wasn't wearing any make-up, and i just looked like a haggard witch (and not the good kind haha).

>> No.7986721

>>7986717
Try filling in your eyebrows if they're light, just that usually gives a much better representation of how it'll look in the end. Seriously, when I fill in my brows it bumps the 100% black lace fronts from "what te actual fuck" to "ah okay".

>> No.7986736

>>7986721
That might help, my eyebrow hairs are dark, but they're sparse. Also thinking back to it, i might've looked weird because i'm not used to having so much hair/such long hair.

>> No.7986741

>>7986677
where do you trim the lace to on these? I bought some lace fronts from arda as well but I've never used any before so I'm not too sure where to cut them to

>> No.7986774

>>7986741
I'm not really the best person to ask about that, sorry.

But Arda has a video about lace fronts that may be of help to you.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrNcVbdGqgA

>> No.7986783
File: 360 KB, 900x600, tumblr_ndd2uuyY2z1r35os0o2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7986783

>>7986741
About 1/4th inch or less from the hairline.

>> No.7986801
File: 904 KB, 320x240, tumblr_ng8ja3XEQk1sjxr6po1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7986801

>>7986677
Did you cut the lace off yet? Arda's lace fronts fit terribly at first because they leave too much extra lace on.

>> No.7986816

>>7986801
I cut the bulk of it off, there's about and inch to a half inch left.

Do other lacefront wigs have such hard, scratchy "lace"? Or is it just arda?

>> No.7986826

>>7986816
I know they've been hunting for softer lace but I don't think they've switched over to a new type yet. At least they know it's a problem.

>> No.7986855

>>7986816
Previous lace anon.
I have two short lace fronts, one from the sale Arda had in november because they were disstatisfied with the lace quality of that batch (wrong colour or something) so they sold them all for like 30 bucks. I also have one I bought off of ebay. Arda's lace is definitely finer and softer, but that might just be that batch. Even then, with the ebay wig which is clearly plastic, I can't say it's particularly scratchy at all. At least not when the wig is fit snugly and the lace glued.

On that topic, best way to glue lace fronts without bunch of grey getting stuck on the back of the lace?

>> No.7987328

>>7986855
I really wanted to buy a wig during that sale/ bad batch thing, if i remember the lace was too soft. The lace on the one i have is very plastic-y, but i don't really have any other lace fronts to compare to.

Also to answer your other question, in the Arda video posted up-thread they show that there is double-sided wig tape, so instead of great getting on the lace it would get on the tape.

But i've never tried it so i can't be sure. Either way i hope you find a solution to your problem.

>> No.7987350
File: 840 KB, 1278x1920, tumblr_ngdtmnqOce1tb8lyyo2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987350

There was a lot of not-good posts in the tag, so it was hard to get things for the dump. Still anyway, here is the tag dump

>> No.7987354
File: 348 KB, 682x1024, tumblr_ngdpgi1DCV1qirsnro1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987354

>>7987350

>> No.7987356
File: 253 KB, 1280x851, tumblr_ngdodcDVOf1qj2jduo2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987356

>>7987354
I really like this Karkat, but damn, i hate their horns, also their lips could use a bit of colour.

>> No.7987358

>>7987328
I have the tape for lace front wigs from sally's and I can say that it works pretty well. It hold the wig in place and it's easy to remove from the wig. I usually cut the width of the tape in half but that's just my personal preference.

>> No.7987359
File: 158 KB, 1280x824, tumblr_ngd02zM9Jz1smctvro1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987359

>>7987356

>> No.7987364
File: 63 KB, 640x960, tumblr_ngche2BmV11qcltrio4_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987364

>>7987359
It seems that Miwafwakes (sp?) is selling pic related, GT Rose dress and dreamer Rose.

>> No.7987368
File: 286 KB, 1280x889, tumblr_ngc36yx7wr1rhey4wo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987368

>>7987364

>> No.7987373
File: 604 KB, 1280x1048, tumblr_ngc0acO3Q71rq0y31o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987373

>>7987368
Last one for now, unless people want a separate dump of the worst that i can currently find in the tag.

>> No.7987376

>>7987364
How is her selling them even relevant

>> No.7987390

>>7987376
It's relevant because it's Homestuck cosplay, and others usually make posts when other well-known Homestuck cosplayers are selling off their costumes.

>> No.7987399

>>7987356
>horrible horns
>bad freckles
>poorly styled wig
what is there to like???

>> No.7987440

>>7987399
I agree with the other anon, they have a nice faceshape and tbh I think the wig has potential.

>>7987373
Yes, give is the worst of the worst. Bring it on.

>> No.7987475

>>7987390
>well-known homestuck cosplayers
Yea, but miwafwakes hasn't been into homestuck for at least a year, and she was never even on the bnf list

>> No.7987476

>>7987440
nice face shape doesn't redeem a less than mediocre cosplay

>> No.7987480
File: 241 KB, 469x348, 100 homestuck cosplay Tumblr.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987480

>>7987475
I hadn't known that, sorry.

>>7987476
Yeah i saw their other cosplays when i checked out their blog, those double sickles tho.

>>7987440
Rest in piece anon, here comes the storm.

>> No.7987484
File: 83 KB, 960x639, tumblr_ng6n0kj7Pe1s0fr5ao1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987484

>>7987480

>> No.7987485
File: 910 KB, 320x240, tumblr_ng6wyb7sNh1sl6yoqo1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987485

>>7987484

>> No.7987487
File: 153 KB, 1000x750, tumblr_ng8b2qU17a1tvc47go1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987487

>>7987485

>> No.7987490

>>7987485
These kinds of gifs make be physically uncomfortable and there's no short supply of them. It really makes me wonder what kind of person actually finds this attractive?

>> No.7987492
File: 1.06 MB, 260x173, tumblr_ng76lwNlkZ1u0s6dgo1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987492

>>7987487
>>7987490
No clue, some one must since there are so many like it. Or maybe they all just think it will get them popular? I don't know, it's best not to think too much on it.

>> No.7987494
File: 1.01 MB, 320x240, tumblr_ngaz5gIplk1rsg7uto1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987494

>>7987492

>> No.7987498
File: 1.13 MB, 320x240, tumblr_ngcchoRlhz1rrad4ho1_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987498

>>7987494

>> No.7987503

>>7987484
I... like this a surprising amount for how lazy it is.
>>7987494
>can't tell if shitty Kurloz or shitty Gamzee

>> No.7987522
File: 719 KB, 320x240, tumblr_ngd885E0Fy1r66cbpo3_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987522

>>7987498
Last one

>>7987503
Its the Grand Highblood

>> No.7987524

>>7987522
Drat my lack of Makara-related knowledge...
>>7987498
Link, what are you doing with those sick shades?

>> No.7987549

>>7987490
I always imagine they're only watched by people strapped down with their eyes forced open ala Clockwork Orange.

Because otherwise it's like watching your niece's awkward piano recital, the most excruciating poetry-slam/white rap-off, a 2 bit masquerade sketch, and someone LARPing out "My Immortal" level bad fanfic all rolled into one.

>> No.7987554

>>7987498
did you accidentally get the zelda tag or is that....human karkat or something? dave with too much ears?

>> No.7987595
File: 1.10 MB, 320x240, tumblr_ngcchoRlhz1rrad4ho4_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987595

>>7987554
Its human Sollux

>> No.7987604

>>7987595
i tried

>> No.7987611

>>7987595

i

ok

>> No.7987617

>>7987604
>>7987611
Look at that smug ass face >>7987595 look at it and admit defeat

>> No.7987629

my jimmies are so rustled that everyone in op's gif took the time to do makeup and put on contants but none of them filled in their eyebrows.

it's ok on rose, maybe. that's it.

>> No.7987631

>>7987629

*contacts. jimmies so rustled i can't type.

>> No.7987730

whats a good toothblack?

>> No.7987914
File: 93 KB, 635x954, Fanfare_Raquel_Welch_close_up.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7987914

>>7986677
A have friends that wear lacefronts and have both the bad batch and the regular Arda lacefronts.

Lacefronts in general tend to be a bit scratchy. Especially ethnic ones, it makes them easier to add spirit gum to and glue into place for a long period of time.

Softer lacefronts tend to not last as long because when they are cleaned they rip.

Arda' bad batch was made with a super soft lace, but its very peach and the mesh is farther apart, which makes it easier to see if you are up close and try to cover it. It also makes hair knots (which is how the hair is put onto the wefts more noticeable)

The regular Arda Wigs lace that is scratchy is pretty much what a high quality ethnic wig would be made of. Again because its easier to clean spirit gum off of.

As for how to apply them:
http://youtu.be/xrNcVbdGqgA?list=UU2GHrm3pUEi8iWAe41UWRzA

I've been considering doing one of those article things on the subject with comparisons of lacefronts. Including ones from FashionIsWig

>> No.7988052

>>7987595
did NOT see that coming

>> No.7988055
File: 229 KB, 667x1000, tumblr_nekowdhf5U1qbjtjgo1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7988055

Guess what time it is.
That's right, time for the ~Crunchy year review 2k14~

So a few notes before I begin, first off, the year isn't quite over yet, so I reserve myself for the fact that new statements or cosplays may show up.

Due to the reoccuring discussions about quantity I also want to point out how few cosplayers reach the output that CBC&;co has. The average is around four or five cosplays from what I can see so far, and asking more than a finished cosplay every twice months is actually asking a lot. This also ties in with the appearance of people on the list appearing in the tags. Please remember that there are people behind these names, with real life stuff to do and real feelings and whatnot.

I'm going from the top and headed down.

>Yaexrae

Finished Cosplays
>Kimono Rose
>Rainbow Drinker Kanaya

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Frequently posting WIP-shots of HIC
>Has reworn other Homestuck cosplays
>New walkthroughs and tutorials pertraining to Homestuck cosplay

Notes:
Quality is still high and gratious WIP-shots are many. Fun to follow and post Homestuck material even outside of cosplay. Criticisms are generally nitpicky. Only downside is that there’s not a huge amount of final pictures output, but IMO following the progress and the use of interesting techniques makes up for that.

>> No.7988071
File: 303 KB, 1280x853, tumblr_ndxiym32jG1rjg7dto2_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7988071

>Cowbuttcrunchies

Finished Cosplays Gothichamlet
>Sufferer
>Punkstuck Vriska
>Signless
>God Tier Kankri
>Derbystuck Vriska
>Samuraistuck Sollux
>Jedistuck Sollux
>Humanstuck (Mori Girl) Aradia
>Viking Signless
>Sollux
>God Tier Sollux
>Christmas Vriska

Finished Cosplays Hhhhammy
>Disciple
>Punkstuck Meenah
>Book Of Signless Disciple
>Derbystuck Nepeta
>Potterstuck Karkat
>Jedistuck Karkat
>Samuraistuck Karkat
>Humanstuck Nepeta
>Viking Disciple
>Karkat
>God Tier Karkat
>Christmas Karkat

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Have a Handmaid planned
>They were guests of honour (IIRC) at Alternicon and hosted two panels there
>Parttaking in Arda's iron wig competition

Notes:
Their cosplay blog is a joy to follow, the only thing people seem to frequently complain about is low variety, or rather the high presence of alternate universe cosplays. I’m personally of the opinion that this is a matter of personal taste and preference rather than something which should be taken into account regarding whether they’re worth following or not for someone interested in Homestuck Cosplay.
Please note I didn’t go through their personal blogs, seeing as all their tutorials et cetera are found on Cowbuttcruncheis and their personal blogs aren’t very well organized.

>> No.7988079
File: 267 KB, 768x1024, tumblr_ndnrzia21o1qhc1x7o1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7988079

>Pyropi

Finished Cosplays
>Star Trek Terezi
>Jedistuck Terezi
>Punkstuck Terezi
>Terezi
>Potterstuck Terezi
>Samuraistuck Terezi
>Humanstuck Terezi
>God Tier Terezi
>Christmas Terezi

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Still posting JJ logs
>Still reblogging Homestuck
>Still making fun of cosplay kickstarters and similar

Notes:
Complaints are mostly the same as those geared towards CBC (not enough variation etc.). Cosplays are all around clean and finished photos are generally good.

>> No.7988260

How does anon feel about these, specifically the Roxy wig?

http://www.cosplaybuzz.com/search?q=Homestuck

>> No.7988274

>>7988260
Hate that they can't use official artwork, also that curly ass Vriska wig, no thank you.

>>7987914
Thank you much for telling me this, and it does make sense that the lace would be harder/ more sturdy to allow longer wear etc. Also i believe that video was already posted >>7986774

>> No.7988390

>>7988071
>the only thing people seem to frequently complain about is low variety
I've never understood this. Sure Pyropi only cosplays Terezi now, but CBC has a huge number of characters (I count 9 in that list).

>>7988260
Is it bad that I like the John wig?

>> No.7988459

>>7988390
I seriously doubt the wig comes pre-styled, but if it does, I think the spikes are too thin and oddly placed.

>> No.7989074

http://yourmatesprit.tumblr.com/post/104630345105/i-almost-died-in-homestuck-cosplay-ft-my-bathtub

>I was casually taking "selfies" with the video function on and SOMETHING SURPRISING HAPPENED

It never ends

>> No.7989302

>>7989074
I don't know, it looked like (he? according to their about section) slipped while standing on the end of the tub. But its honestly hard to tell since this isn't one of those "OH GOD A SPIDER" webcam gifs.

One thing is certain, OTT make-up is OTT

>> No.7989316

>>7989302
>Selfie
>Video

There's no way this isn't fake.

>> No.7989364
File: 158 KB, 393x400, who want lasagna.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7989364

>>7989316
Yeah you're probably right.

I have to say, one day i hope someone does something like this, but so over the top that it should be in an infomercial. The super late night infomercials, none of that baby shit.

>> No.7989474

>>7989316
Well, it's possible. I mean, my shitty phone camera switches from pic to video if I poke it wrong. Agree with >>7989364 that it's way too exaggerated though.

>> No.7989518

>>7989364
That is actually a great idea.

>> No.7989523

>>7989474
It's possible that you take half a dozen photos, switching kawaii positions with each button click and somehow don't realize the entire time you're in video mode...?

>> No.7989623

>>7989523
Late to the party but, it can happen, sometimes when i have long nails i'll think i hit (when i hear my nail tap the screen) the button but didn't.

Also fuck touch screens.

>> No.7989639

>>7989316
It can totally happen tho.
I once tried to take a photo of my eye (had an infection) and send to my mom but instead took a video and creeped the ever living shit out of her because it was 30 seconds of a bloody eye staring and blinking. On the iPhone you have to swipe right to change modes so you can accidentally do that, or if you forget to switch back to photo mode after a video (happened to me then). So.

>> No.7989646

>>7989639
but just to clarify >>7989074 is fake as shit, mostly because of her awful acting.

>> No.7990598

Waiting for the flood of Vriska braids to come in. What's the best way to do a wig like that? Other than inserting one million wefts.

>> No.7990741

>>7990598
Well the first problem with making that into a wig is that it looks fucking awful.

>> No.7990752

>>7988055
>>7988071
>>7988079
Praise be to Crunchy Anon.

I won't update the graphic until all the updates are done, but should I add the new notes to the existing ones or just start from scratch?

>> No.7991063

>>7990752
Remake it, probably. After we've made decisions and list updates. I won't post the rest until monday due to con activities.

>> No.7991453

>>7990741
Yeah, with you on that one, Hussie doesn't know how hair works.

>> No.7991461
File: 28 KB, 500x375, c994677f37a7621d2427cbafd7158eec.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7991461

>>7991453
Her hair makes sense if you see it as ratty ass scene girl dreads

>> No.7991474

>>7991461
The ugliest shit out there. Thinking about dirty ass white girl dreads makes me want to gag.

>> No.7992126
File: 268 KB, 1280x720, tumblr_ngitbl1lvE1s5kz4eo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992126

Tag dump, starting off with some braided Vriska's

>> No.7992128
File: 268 KB, 510x333, tumblr_ngi8x3wZBP1qew3yzo1_r1_1280.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992128

>>7992126

>> No.7992129
File: 705 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_nfop0kxGm91qj8sx1o2_r1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992129

>>7992128

>> No.7992133
File: 296 KB, 682x1024, tumblr_ngfp56B3m51rl33guo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992133

>>7992129

>> No.7992134

>>7992129

she's so cute

>> No.7992137
File: 479 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_ngfpydBlJn1rjx7a5o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992137

>>7992133

>> No.7992138
File: 726 KB, 561x800, tumblr_ngfvd7EEAx1qfq0vlo1_1280.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992138

>>7992137

>> No.7992143
File: 410 KB, 960x1280, tumblr_ngfydejEVK1rpfubho3_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992143

>>7992138

>> No.7992144
File: 340 KB, 600x900, tumblr_nggan7o8mv1r35os0o6_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992144

>>7992143

>> No.7992148
File: 38 KB, 960x640, tumblr_nggh9fRR8G1rg175do1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992148

>>7992144

>> No.7992153
File: 343 KB, 1067x1600, tumblr_nggjmtcvnG1rhey4wo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992153

>>7992148
Okay, last one for now.

To start a conversation, what is everyone's favourite homestuck cosplay(s) that you have done yourself? Any HS cosplays being worked on atm?

I really enjoy being Meenah, Roxy and Terezi, i'm working on Dead Aradia, and remaking Meenah accessories

>> No.7992353

>>7992126
Are those horns made of fucking tape my god.

>> No.7992415

>>7992153
Shit, I like this. My main nitpick is that the splatters on her shirt aren't explosive enough and seem more like random daubs of paint, but gore makeup is weird to apply without experience. The photography and editing are great on this (excepting the blurry edge on the lopped-off arm). Wig and horns also look really good.

>> No.7992429

>>7992415
I think there is another picture of her in the tag, she's kinda shoopy from what i remember but i'f you want, i can try and find her.

>> No.7992457

>>7992153
all those fraying edges on the coat jesus CHRIST

>> No.7992490
File: 199 KB, 1280x889, tumblr_ngc36yx7wr1rhey4wo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992490

>>7992457
Yeah you can see them better here

>> No.7992496

>>7992490
how could anyone do that and think that looks good
sure the jacket is supposed to be ripped but ripped=/=fraying edges

>> No.7992503
File: 69 KB, 768x917, tumblr_ngj94gnOPo1sv94pxo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7992503

>>7992496
Yeah, but the thing is, i don't understand why its her good arm that has the fraying edges

Also another braided Vriska from the tag.

>> No.7992710

>>7992129
i wonder how she made her ears

>> No.7992785

>>7992153
I'm having a lot of fun being Cronus. I feel attractive and I enjoy having the mindset of "I deserve the love of everyone" every once in a while. Also, good excuse for shameless flirting haha.

Kanaya is also nice, mostly because she gives me an opportunity to be feminine every once in a while.

>> No.7993779

Thinking of cosplaying a Homestuck, but not sure which one. How do you guys decide?

>> No.7993801

>>7992785
I can't believe how much the HS community varies from place to place. Where I live, you basically can't do Cronus, like at all. And you can only do Mindfang with permission. And either one with any kind of "deserve" or flirting would probably get you physically attacked.

>> No.7993807

>>7993779
In general, you should only do a troll who's symbol matches your birth sign. Any of the humans or other non-hemotyped characters are fine though.

>> No.7993809

>>7993779
Usually i choose a character i'm really interested currently, then i decide if i would fit them and how much skill it would take to make the cosplay itself (luckily with homestuck cosplay there aren't too many characters that need a lot of skill to do).

>>7993801
I think i remember someone saying something like that some threads ago, are you that same person. Also do you have any stories/ care to elaborate?

>> No.7993826

>>7993779

The one you like the most

And you can still pull off, physically (don't do Bro if you're a hamplanet lady, don't do Nepeta if you're a beefy hairy hulkman, etc)

>> No.7993831

>>7993807
>Cancer
Too much responsibility.

>> No.7993832

>>7993826
>not deliberately doing a cosplay you don't fit at all for the humor factor
no wonder you never get any con-pussy

>> No.7993834

>>7993807
I'm usually not this kind of person but, no that's dumb.

>> No.7993842

>>7993832

yeah as I was typing it I was already thinking about how much I want to see the tallest, hairiest, most bara nepeta of all time, but if the OP wants to cosplay *well*, I think it still works for advice.

>> No.7993865

>>7993801
If you're going to ban Cronus you should just as well ban Rufioh too.
>I betrayed my gf, causing her to go bonkers and screwing our session entirely and got away with it because I'm kind of attractive and like to pretend I've bad confidence and I still don't feel guilty about it

Is it an active ban or is it just a community consensus?

>> No.7993896

>>7993865
If you're gonna ban all them you might as well ban Vriska. Just for starters, she's not a "safe" character to cosplay since she invites aggressive flirting and can also provide a cover to be aggressive under the excuse of being in-character. She's acted non-consensually in the comic and it's inevitable people will try to replicate that, not to mention some of her outfits are revealing and promote low self esteem-driven attempts to look hot.

>> No.7993945

>>7993807
I remember this from a few threads back. I still cant believe this is actually real. What the actual fuck? Cosplay whoever the fuck you want.

>> No.7994042

>>7993807
This is stupid. Cosplay whatever troll you want.

I may be too old to care or just not involved in my local comm to get a feel for it, but the idea of not being "allowed" to cosplay certain characters is mind boggling to me. Do people have equivalence problems in thinking cosplayer = character or what?

>> No.7994049

>>7993807
hahaaha wtf? do people really think like this? then again a big part of the fandom is retarded so. Imagine this "rule" combined with the sj-forbiddan characters rule.

we should just ban all aquariuses from all homestuck cons ever.

>> No.7994142

>>7993807
I have never heard this in the three years I've been a Homestuck. I've heard rumors, but, what.

>> No.7994143

>>7993842
I need this now. Like Man-Toph.

>> No.7994144

>>7993801
I really question the capability of these types of people to lead normal function lives within society with such a devotion to a fandom and its characters that an affront by a character is an insult to them personally.

>> No.7994312

>>7993807
definitely trolling. iv never heard anything this dumb in my life.

>> No.7994359

>>7994312
it may be trolling here, but I'm pretty willing to bet that is actually a thing that happens

>> No.7994369

>>7994312
As soon as troll symbols were introduced and associated with their caste system and blood type it became a thing to treat cross-hemotype cosplay as at least mildly appropriative. It's been a thing on Tumblr and to different degrees all over the place. With the introduction of Calliope's and then Jade's trollsona, it got sort of renergized. Since, in the setting, a trollsona is easily something compareable to blackface.

>> No.7994379
File: 55 KB, 625x626, c70.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994379

>>7994369

>> No.7994389

>>7994369
Do you seriously think anybody here is going to fall for this shit tier bait? You should've stopped while you were ahead.

>> No.7994404

>ctrl f carapace
>not found
Why u do this 2 me cigl

>> No.7994411

>>7994404
Do you want me to find&post you some carapace cosplays, anon?

I'm very bored.

>> No.7994421

>>7994411
Hell yas

>> No.7994441
File: 30 KB, 393x382, 1378942944406.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994441

>>7994369

>> No.7994443
File: 1.99 MB, 1280x932, 131217788990.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994443

>>7994421
Dumping now

>> No.7994449
File: 764 KB, 900x1350, aimless_renegade_by_froggykisaki-d5k4v0p.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994449

>>7994443

>> No.7994463
File: 246 KB, 1024x1371, jack_noir__and_snowman_by_angelcloud0090-d5ht7ov.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994463

>>7994449

>> No.7994466
File: 223 KB, 746x1071, the_black_queen_by_wuzabow22-d5l0q9c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994466

>>7994463

Sorry in advance if i double post the same cosplayer.

>> No.7994473
File: 119 KB, 500x750, tumblr_lwxdi7lfs91qba7l9o1_500.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994473

>>7994466

>> No.7994479
File: 409 KB, 748x516, tumblr_m81fdkGC8z1r22j8ho1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994479

>>7994473

>> No.7994489
File: 98 KB, 1000x667, tumblr_m5qnm50GP11qba7l9o3_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994489

>>7994479

>> No.7994499
File: 227 KB, 450x338, tumblr_m6lw4yiAYj1r0w2l3o1_500.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994499

>>7994489

>> No.7994507
File: 443 KB, 342x876, tumblr_m39nrvXRvX1r22j8ho1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994507

>>7994499

>> No.7994508
File: 669 KB, 1280x1707, tumblr_m78hkzxOj21ql9r4ao10_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994508

>>7994507

>> No.7994509
File: 167 KB, 500x750, tumblr_malfr1ZeOF1qiu1ojo1_500.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994509

>>7994508

>> No.7994511
File: 181 KB, 500x725, tumblr_mgj2pqpJkr1r2yl4xo1_500.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994511

>>7994509

>> No.7994513
File: 105 KB, 960x720, tumblr_mgzz6oeIVz1qmzikoo5_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994513

>>7994511

>> No.7994516
File: 330 KB, 1080x1920, tumblr_migb5pvnxc1qd9cn1o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994516

>>7994513

>> No.7994519
File: 299 KB, 500x398, tumblr_mn2v19ctj01qctlh8o1_500.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994519

>>7994516

>> No.7994524
File: 78 KB, 500x333, tumblr_mpb8fopEa91r5hnnmo1_500.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994524

>>7994519

>> No.7994528
File: 216 KB, 900x1370, wayward_vagabond_by_truealaso-d4wi17d.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7994528

>>7994524
Last one that i got, cheers.

>> No.7994558

>>7994528
i was hoping 4 a mayor

>> No.7995196

Really new to the threads and was always wondering, how do people end up on the bnf list? Do people vote or something?

>> No.7995219

>>7995196
It's consensus. When the list was first started two years ago or so it was actually really easy to fill out. Well known cosplayers who produce good work don't leave much to argue about. It's demotion or removal that brings out drama.

>> No.7995273

>>7995196
Originally it was a combination of quality, quantity, and community involvement. Cosplayers are added/removed every few months but Crunchy Anon is doing a big review and overhaul at the end of the year. My guess is more active people will be added then.

>> No.7995335
File: 535 KB, 700x1129, tumblr_n892zdZTEU1qe1lg6o3_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995335

Finished Cosplays
>Helmsman
>Promstuck Cronus
>Blind/Fancy God Tier Sollux
>Erisolsprite

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>They’ve posted a few walkthroughs and answers asks
>I’m not sure if this is something they’ve been doing since before
>They and Dei-Sandvich got a costume commission blog which is interesting but not updated a lot

Notes:
I want to note that including their GT Sollux might have been a bit of a stretch as it wasn’t actually MADE in 2014 AFAIK. Their cosplays hold a high quality, they’re well though through with interesting details. In my opinion, a candidate for God Tier, depending a bit on what they do in 2k15 and any WIP-shots they post.

>> No.7995348
File: 203 KB, 500x750, 1395291118642.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995348

>>7995335
That's Kisbe, for the record lol.

Dei-Sandvich

Finished Cosplays
>Promstuck Mituna
>Casual Eridan
>Eridan
>Fancy God Tier Eridan

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Their blog got easier to naivgate
>They’ve an unfinished Aradiasprite laying around somewhere

Notes:
As with Kisbe, including their GT Eridan might be a stretch. They’ve yet to wear Aradiasprite, so hopefully we’ll see that in time for Katsucon or somesuch. The quality of their work is very high, and they do answer questions though not a whole lot as they’re not hugely active in general. They've sold off their Eridan since.

>> No.7995385
File: 469 KB, 675x900, tumblr_mv00cxMxrv1qhvh8so3_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995385

>Snowchildhero

Snowchildhero contacted me and asked to be removed from the list, if there’s still interest in keeping them on it I will post information about finished cosplays etc. but as we’ve respected the tiernames’ wishes regarding this in the past (Silencedrowns), I’m going to assume that Snowchildhero will not be part of the updated list.

>> No.7995403

>>7995385
People have wanted her off the list for a long time. I don't think anyone will complain about kicking her now that she's asked for it.

>> No.7995431
File: 26 KB, 798x521, seadweller thinsgs.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995431

>>7995335
Praise be to Crunchy Anon.

I have a question for HSG, what is everyone's opinions on extra seadweller appendages? Things like webbed fingers, arm fins and gills. (Pic related, i suck i know)

Is it too much or only if its done well?

>> No.7995445
File: 705 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_n7yv263JmN1rothkko2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995445

>Periodicallypapaya (previously Rosining)

Finished Cosplays
>Kanaya
>Vriska (pre incident)
>God Tier Vriska
>Trickster Jane

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>There’s a Prospit Dreamer Kanaya, but there’s no finished shots of it
>They also have an unfinished Porrim and Aranea in their tag

Notes:
Periodicallypapaya is still the youngest person and the list, and very good at that. Hits a nice middle ground between toony and realistic and has nice and clean craftmanship as well as interesting photos, most of the time. They do cosplay help, but not all of it is tagged.

>> No.7995524
File: 190 KB, 1024x1024, tumblr_ngld5ebRcp1s7sam0o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7995524

>>7995431
Which seadweller are you making? I think it could look good on a simple outfit like Feferi's default, but it'd be overkill on anything more complicated.

Webbed fingers are nice though.

>> No.7996310
File: 667 KB, 936x1368, 11517_b2f352020c27f25f4382bc9f969f7472.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7996310

>>7995431
I think little touches like that are cool if done well, but a lot of people in the Homestuck fandom probably don't have the skill in making prosthetics to pull it off. Gills are cool (pic related is a PETA ad but is nice for inspiration), but webbed fingers may be incompatible with some characters. I don't think Eridan would be able to get on all of his rings if he had webs, unless they were really short and vestigial or something.

>> No.7996333

>>7996310
>Gils on the neck and not over the chest where they should be
Definitely please don't use that for inspiration

>> No.7996357

>>7994558
like with the cans n everything

>> No.7996359
File: 27 KB, 468x335, article-1374056-0B81EA2E00000578-622_468x335.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7996359

>>7995524
I thought my reply was posted hours ago, but i plan on Meenah and Feferi

>>7996310
Yeah, when i think about Eridan with webbed fingers his rings would get in the way, unless, like HIC's fins they could be piercings. But that's a little much.

>>7996333
The thing that sparked my interest again was actually pic related. And yeah, it would make more sense for the gills to be on the chest, but they would be covered up by my shirt and not be seen.

>> No.7996365
File: 17 KB, 194x298, embryo_jpg_18049.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7996365

>>7996333
For 100% biological accuracy, just put them right on your fucking face

>> No.7996382
File: 272 KB, 402x494, 1418700315539.jpg 194×298 .png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7996382

>>7996365

mmmm guuuurl

>> No.7996395
File: 15 KB, 300x400, perfection.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7996395

>>7996382
>The one time I forgot to save that Kanaya nudestuck image

>> No.7997239
File: 65 KB, 211x212, 0 cgl MSPA Generally Lovely.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997239

>>7996395

>> No.7997297
File: 201 KB, 676x289, 90593160a158855c1ea813c37f90f0d637ac596e.png 750×1125 .png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997297

Expatri8?? Also this comic is 25 pages, maybe it will actually be good? Even though the art style is weird. The backgrounds are pretty though

>> No.7997330

>>7997297
Equius's ancestor used both names.

http://mspaintadventures.wikia.com/wiki/Ancestors

>> No.7997355

>>7997239
That still looks like something that came out of the Sims or something.

>> No.7997365
File: 103 KB, 798x521, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997365

>>7997355
Say that to my face fucker

>> No.7997369
File: 23 KB, 110x126, butts.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997369

>>7997365

>> No.7997429
File: 159 KB, 1518x910, IMAG3523_1_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997429

I posted a few threads back asking if this length was too big for Terezi horns but didnt post pic. Posting again just to get a better opinion because you cant really tell without seeing them. Also I was in the middle of painting them during the photo, hence the crappy paint job.

>> No.7997444

>>7997429
They're kind of a little big tbh. They're also spaced really far apart. They'd work for Latula but for Terezi you probably want to shave an inch off and more them more toward the center of your head.

>> No.7997449

>>7992138
>>7994513
Who are they??
>>7995431
I mean they look cool and all but as
>>7996310 said
You might not be able to put the rings on correctly if youre attaching something. But even if you make them really short theyll still be noticeable.

>> No.7997455

>>7997444
Wow thanks, I was thinking of putting them closer too. The base is tin foil and I dont think Ill be able to cut through them without buthering it so I guess Ill have to start again unless you have any tips for that.

>> No.7997545

>>7997429
>>7997455
To add on to what the other anon said, they seem to be a bit curvy.

>>7997449
Yeah, luckily Meenah and Feferi don't seem to be wearing any rings.

>> No.7997560

>>7997545
Webbed fingers are something i associate more with Aradiasprite than the seadwellers, since she's drawn with them. As an embellishment I think it could either look alright or like someone accidentally fucked up the fingers on their armsocks.

>> No.7997691
File: 214 KB, 720x1280, tumblr_ngp20d56Ib1rdlrzmo3_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997691

>>7997560
So i was in the tag, looking for good/ not-so-shitty pictures for a tag dump, and i saw this

and i

I just don't

>> No.7997715

>>7996357
And a sash

>> No.7997855

>>7994558
>>7996357
>>7997715
Be the change you want to see.

>> No.7997859

>>7997691
Holy shit. And the award for most unflattering angle goes to.....

>>7997715
What is google search

>> No.7997866

>>7997691
she's a good likeness of jade though

>> No.7997885

>>7997866
If Jade were an ugly autist maybe.

>> No.7997902

>>7997885
autism doesnt affect how someone looks

>> No.7997904

>>7997902
i mean fashion sense maybe but their face nah

>> No.7997905
File: 10 KB, 161x243, Jade_5_computers.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7997905

>>7997885
>>7997902
>>7997904
jade is kind of an autist though (not actual autism.. "weird" autism)

>velcro shoes
>fursuits
>obsessed with a childrens cartoon

>> No.7997907

>>7997885
She actually, really looks like a dorky 13 year-old

>> No.7998156
File: 103 KB, 960x960, 10411844_563210453809118_4124103419665189198_n[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998156

this bro could do whatever he wanted to me aaaahh <3 <3 <3

>> No.7998163

>>7998156

"he"

>> No.7998175

>>7998156
>that filename
>23 notes on tumblr, posted 5 days ago
Smells like a wizened vendetta chan stirring up negative attention by being way too flattering.

>> No.7998292
File: 389 KB, 1280x850, tumblr_ngp9t2Mseo1soosq6o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998292

What is going on with that Terezi/Karkat/whatever in the middle

>>7998175
That's my guess too

>> No.7998306
File: 135 KB, 500x410, 1418115283141.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998306

>>7998292
No clue, probably laziness

that Jake in front of her reminds me of pic related

>> No.7998610

>>7998306
what even happened to that dude

>> No.7998612
File: 332 KB, 480x640, tumblr_ngplok1akO1ste50wo1_500.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998612

>> No.7998615
File: 536 KB, 498x702, tumblr_ngpllyFSAn1s605mho2_500.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998615

>>7998612

>> No.7998616
File: 141 KB, 250x334, tumblr_ngpelsWWxZ1s65v24o2_250.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998616

>>7998615

>> No.7998630

>>7998163
HAS NO STYLE

>> No.7998643

>>7998630
HE HAS NO GRACE

>> No.7998644

>>7998610
last i saw he was cosplaying that red haired girl from nardo who stalks sasuke everywhere.
>>7998612
i will never understand the desire to add fake freckles to everything.

>> No.7998647
File: 70 KB, 480x640, tumblr_ngph4e06Hw1spyjvbo1_500.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
7998647

>>7998643
THIS JADE HAS A FUNNY FACE

>> No.7998883

>>7998156
Are they sucking in their lips?
>>7997905
Nah she is just a tacky kid still living in the 90s, but I could see it. John too.

>> No.7999980

>>7998647
Those eyebrows though.

>> No.8000040

>>7998615
oh my god it's acne dave

>> No.8000983
File: 371 KB, 1280x853, tumblr_ng1d5lSsJC1r33yrpo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8000983

Jesus, it's dead in here.

>> No.8000984
File: 735 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_ng1xichBCX1rqpo6po1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8000984

>> No.8000986
File: 87 KB, 600x900, tumblr_nfvz5rFQVr1sag7ouo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8000986

>> No.8001042

>>7998612
>thumbnail looked like a Justin Bieber reaction image
>opens pic
why.jpg

>> No.8001074

>>8001042
Oh my god now I opened it.

Why.

Why.

>> No.8001102
File: 38 KB, 145x151, tumblr_nc2n7dAQ3Z1r0iwb8o2_250.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001102

>>8001074
>mfw opened it too

>> No.8001114

>>8001042
iirc it's supposed to be "gamer rose"

>> No.8001140
File: 1.30 MB, 1280x1920, tumblr_n3zupgqIWW1ro93t6o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001140

Virulentmalapropisms

Finished Cosplays
>Feferi
>Drunk Rose
>Trickster Roxy

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Not really

Notes:
If you like anime cosplay too they are definitely worth following. They answer cosplay questions but it took me a moment to find the right tag (hint, it’s not in their general cosplay tag). I can’t find anything new they’ve planned, but their cosplay quality is high. I think we should keep an eye on them and if they show no interest in new Homestuck cosplay in the next few months I say it might be time to remove them.

>> No.8001145
File: 337 KB, 1280x850, tumblr_n345m2BCas1qbh83no1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001145

Vantasticmess

Finished Cosplays
>Code Geass/Homestuck Crossover

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>“There are still 2 Homestuck cosplays that I really want to do!
>Derse dreamer Dave (not fancy!stuck, just plain derse pjs). I’ve been promised to do this with my beta kids for the longest time, but it’s been a matter of getting up the energy and time to do them!
>Scourge Sister Terezi with knightarcana. We even have cool blood-colored jackets for it! But same problem - it’s a matter of having the time and energy to finish putting together the cosplays to our satisfaction and wear them.”

Notes:
>“When was the last time you cosplayed Karkat?”
>“In gray make up? Katsucon 2013:”
>“I will never stop being a Homestuck fan, and I may yet someday put Karkat back on as well! I hate saying ‘yes, I’m definitely done with this’ about anything, because it inevitably isn’t true. So—!
>Long story short: if you’re watching my tumblr specifically in hopes of seeing more Homestuck cosplay, I have a number of older photosets lined up in my drafts to post to this tumblr over the next several months, but no new cosplays with definite expected photoshoot dates. It’s up to you if that’s worth sticking around for.”
They have reblogged older photosets, and are one of the reasons as to why I think a “honourary mention” category could be useful. I wouldn’t say their presence is very relevant on the list anymore. Def. worth following if you’re into anime cosplay, though.

>> No.8001147
File: 208 KB, 1280x854, tumblr_n4tmuuPa0B1qhju1eo1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001147

Cancerously

Finished cosplays
>Black Dress Rose (outfit was borrowed/bought/gifted)
>Supposedly did Feferi and a personal god tier for Katsucon. No shots.
>God Tier Jade
>Supposedly did a punk Terezi for New York Comic Con. No shots, aside from a WIP-shot.

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>They’ve sold off a lot of their Homestuck cosplays

Notes:
I would not put them on the list if they were brought up today. No real WIP-shots, low shoot output and not particularly interesting costumes to make up for it. I say it’s time to remove them.

>> No.8001162
File: 443 KB, 1280x1280, tumblr_nec81oPAmT1r33yrpo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001162

Okay this is a break just because I was going through Crowmunist's blog and I am SO IMPRESSED by these HORNS.

>> No.8001170

>>8001162

Hot damn!

I also agree a "greatest hits" catagory could be useful, but I'd like to see the list be a current and useful resource for who to follow for content. That's what it was originally purposed for.

>> No.8001179

>>8001162
Wow, do they have a tutorial?

>> No.8001180

>>8001147
Hey Crunchy anon, can I recommend bonniviwii for the bnf list? She has a lot of cosplays with over 5k notes, and still has a lot of homestuck cosplays planned for next year. She's probably pretty tier though imo.

>> No.8001182
File: 265 KB, 667x1000, tumblr_nc6eye3ZwS1qzmpk6o7_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001182

>>8001170
Essentially that's why I think it should be a thing, that way we don't have people crying about cosplayers who don't do Homestuck any more being removed from the list (such as Ceriene). But that's all up to you guys.

>>8001179
They were 3D-printed, apparently.

Moving on to pretty tier.

Mostflogged

Finished Cosplays
>Mindfang
>Knit Dress Roxy
>Mom Lalonde
>Demon Roxy
>Trickster Roxy
>I believe there was a B/W dress Kanaya but I can’t find it
>Ballgown Dreamer Roxy

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>“if the marketing team is making it a fucking nightmare for cosplayers to sell their used hand made items that aren’t offered in the what pumpkin store that’s enough of a reason for me to stop wanting to invest time/money into homestuck. “

Notes:
Craftmanship is good as ever and they’ve clean shots of everything. Helpful. Were moved down due to drama, but honestly I’m not sure if that’s a thing any more.
Should be removed if they are serious about not making Homestuck cosplays in the future.

>> No.8001191

>>8001180
I think there was an incident/drama with her and /cgl/ a while ago, i forget what exactly happened though.

>> No.8001192

>>8001191
lol it's probably a self post

>> No.8001194

>>8001162
God these are gorgeous. Might be the best Megido horns I've ever seen.

>>8001180
Isn't that the Australian Roxy who had a bunch of friendfags come in here to fawn over them and then "took a break" from cosplaying because we said we didn't like their scarf or something? Yeah, gonna say no.

Seconding the removal of vantasticmess and cancerously though.

>> No.8001195
File: 485 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_nfgv35uB0R1r33yrpo1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001195

>>8001180
Recommend as much as you like! I've them, Striderian and Hammasratas on my list and fresh blood is always nice.

Crowmunist

Finished Cosplays
>Dirk Strider
>Meulin Leijon
>God Tier Dave
>Davesprite
>Suit!Dave
>Dave Strider
>Jade Harley
>Jake English

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Aradia Megido Wips
>God Tier Jade Wips
>Rose in a Suit Wip?

Notes:
Remember when I first did this and complained that they had very few shots of their work?
Yeah, no longer. Very clean cosplays and shoots which show them off well, they do cosplay help but it took me a moment to find the tag.

>> No.8001196

>>8001192
Maybe, is that was the old drama about? Her selfposting. Damn i forget, it was good drama though.

>>8001195
Hey crunchy, do you cosplay? I'm just curious.

>> No.8001200
File: 517 KB, 1079x1920, tumblr_n60f2sB9Yg1qj8sx1o1_r2_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001200

>>8001196
I do, as a matter of fact.
The day I'm suggested for the list is the day I quit reviewing it, lmao.

Seclusionsalad (Pearlgirl710)

Finished Cosplays
>Blue Coat Aranea
>Jadesprite
>God Tier Rose
>Disciple
>God Tier Jade

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>They’re working on a God Tier Aranea

Notes:
Another cosplayer on which my main complaint was low shoot output, also some people whining about cosplay amounts which I do not agree with but I digress. Clearly knows what they’re doing, have also posted some tutorials and better cosplay help since. Definitely bump-material.

>> No.8001212

>>8001196
No I'm pretty sure she was posted and then got all her friends to defend her all while pretending she has never read /CGL/ before. Then she had a hissy fit about how she'll never post photos of herself online again if they'll get posted on /CGL/ and be ripped to shreds, even though no one even insulted her. So, sorry anon who recommended her, it's a no from me.

>> No.8001214

>>8001200
Ooo, I'm really curious now. Have you even been posted here? What's your favorite cosplay to wear?

>>8001212
Ah okay, thank you for reminding me.

Also i'm a no as well.

>> No.8001221
File: 553 KB, 1000x667, tumblr_n3untlODCd1qfu6zso1_r1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001221

>>8001214
I have been posted here a few times, but haven't most of us? (Selfpost, if nothing else) But I'm not going to tell you any more than that, sorry!

>>8001212
I'll probably still look through their blog, we'll see.

Violetprince

Finished Cosplays
>God Tier Dave

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>They do have a few Homestuck characters in their cosplay plans

Notes:
I say remove them, if they get back into it then that’s one thing but apparently they won’t be cosplaying for a while anyway according to their cosplay schedule.

>> No.8001225
File: 731 KB, 500x750, tumblr_n1s37tG7LZ1r0dmxco2_r1_500[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001225

Harshwhimsical

Finished Cosplays
Cod Tier Gamzee

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
Nah

Notes:
They were on the edge when I did this last time, I say it’s time to remove them.

>> No.8001227
File: 182 KB, 1280x854, tumblr_nf5sg1xlCs1qjz2q5o4_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001227

Kitty-Maru

Finished Cosplays
>Derse Dreamer Dirk
>Dragonmom
>Roxy Lalonde
>Samuraistuck Dirk
>Robo Arm Vriska
>Fancy Dreamer Roxy
>Swimstuck Roxy
>Fancy Dreamer Dirk
>50’s stuck Roxy
>Magicastuck Dave

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>Can’t really tell, their blog isn’t very well organized

Notes:
They’re good, not amazing but good. Their output is a bit uneven, ballgown Roxy for example is awesome while their fancy dreamer Dirk is more on the not-overly-impressive side of the scale. I really don’t like their Dirk wig, for the record, and I do think sewing is more their forte. Seated pretty well where they are, in my opinion

>> No.8001229

>>8001221
No, i understand wanting to stay as anonymous as possible. Especially doing /cgl/ list stuff.

>> No.8001231

>>8001221
Wow, that is...a really sloppy Dave. There's no way I ever would have thought this was a BNF.

>> No.8001240

>>8001231

A lot of these bnfs were picked back in 2012 when there was less to choose from.

>>8001221

Crunchy are you east or west coast? I want to buy you a drink at a con sometime for putting up with so many whiners over this lol

>> No.8001241
File: 697 KB, 533x800, tumblr_n3hcr79NU81qjnfuho1_1280[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001241

>>8001229
Thanks, anon! When you figure me out I'll be sure to let you know haha.

>>8001231
They've a pretty nice Eridan, which got them on the list. Of course, the standards were lower at that point I am fairly sure.

Fromgilbowithaweseome

Finished Cosplays
>Humanstuck Eridan
>Humanstuck Karkat
>God Tier Karkat
>Humanstuck Eridan
>Jake English
>This Gamzee fashion disaster
>Cronus (no shots)
>Humanstuck Swimstuck Eridan
>Karkat
>Kankri
>Eridan (no shots)
>Gamzee

Other Homestuck Cosplay news
>nah

Notes:
A lot of the complaints were about their big amount of Humanstuck cosplays, and I stand by my statement that they still do it much better than most. Still has a high shot output and a lot of fun and interesting gifs (something I’d love to see more of among cosplayers in general, making usage of tumblr’s photoset function) and in that sense and with the cosplays they put together they’re pretty creative. I would love to see some proper shots of their Eridan and Cronus, though.


I'm going to head off to eat something and review suggestions when I get back. Don't be afraid to ask me to go through blogs, but do so today because after Friday I won't have computer access.

>> No.8001244

>>8001240
And I'm European, but if I ever go to an american con I'll let you know!

>> No.8001272

>>8001244

Oh God, I'm European too. Now I'll be forever paranoid thinking that the Crunchy Anon might be from the same country as me.

Keep up the great work, CA!

>> No.8001390

>>8001241
One day crunchy

ONE DAY.

>> No.8001393

>>8001180
nice self post

>> No.8001394

>>8001393
You're late

>> No.8001403
File: 1.69 MB, 1000x1500, tumblr_nbsg42SToW1qgotqjo1_1280[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001403

>>8001272
I have an official chum handle.
crunchyAnon [CA] began pestering HSG.

>>8001390
Welp. Good luck!
(Think about this: regardless, I'm the winner in the situation!)

>>8001180

Going through this one anyway.

Finished Cosplays
>God Tier Rose
>Jade Harley
>Aradia

Notes:
Quality wise, they're pretty average quality. Their Roxy is cute but the rest isn't really note worthy and they're very much recycling the same three cosplays over and over again without any alterations.
Also, apparently drama?
They're a cute Roxy, but not much else.

>> No.8001439
File: 8 KB, 650x450, 00475_2.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001439

>>8001403
> regardless, I'm the winner in the situation!

Damn Crunchy, you sly.

>> No.8001509

Do we have any good current/new homestuck cosplayers? All I've seen posted are cosplays from a few years back or a year back..
I mean, of course the shitty ones are posted constantly but it's a little disheartening seeing nothing new that's decent.

>> No.8001512
File: 543 KB, 500x713, tumblr_ngfvd7EEAx1qfq0vlo1_500[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001512

>>8001439
B)

Striderian

Finished Cosplays
>Trickster Roxy
>God Tier Roxy
>God Tier Vriska (borrowed)
>God Tier Feferi
>Spades Slick
>Terezi
>Derse Dreamer Nepeta
>Swimstuck Jade
>Trickter Roxy
>Damara

Notes:
Their cosplay holds high quality, especially for their high output. There are even a few cosplays I suspect they've done but which I haven't seen in their tag, such as red dress Kanaya. They do cosplay help and a smaller amount of WIPs, I say they fit on the list. They also have a fair amount of cosplays from earlier years.

>> No.8001513

>>8001244
Oh nooooo crunchy, I wanted to buy you a drink too! Oh well!

>> No.8001516

>>8001403
I'd say leave her out simply because any time she hears she's been posted on cgl she loses her shit and starts attacking people she knows goes on cgl.

>> No.8001524
File: 1.82 MB, 1280x853, tumblr_nf8f4cfpR51qjzt0oo1_1280.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001524

>>8001513
Actually, I don't really drink anyway. I'm sorry! I'd love to meet you guys. You can buy me a milkshake instead haha.

Hammasratas

Finished Cosplays
>Dirk Strider
>Derse Dreamer Sollux
>Humanstuck Sollux
>Feferi's glasses Sollux
>Sollux
>Psiioniic
>Kurloz

Notes:
They've been on and off the list, and while I do think their cosplay is generally quality, I also can understand why HSG isn't too fond of their personal taste. They've posted a bit of fanservice as of late, but in general their shoots aren't super exciting.


ALSO there was a anon who had a few European names as suggestion but never posted them, what happened to that?

Please don't be afraid to post suggestions, you guys, like, don't call self post unless the suggestion REALLY doesn't make any sense. I'm fairly sure a lot of names will be swiped so it'd be nice to add in new ones.

>> No.8001525

>>8001516
do you have any good drama, it sounds like you know her?

>> No.8001535

>>8001525
I don't know her that well honestly, but she's pretty drama clean if you don't take her burning hatred of cgl in to account. The only drama I really know about her is based on in-groupy stuff I've heard through the grapevine, sorry!

>> No.8001569

>>8001525
Different anon but she borrowed the Princess Bubblegum costume she always wears off a friend of mine over 6 months ago, hasn't returned it when asked, and it is claiming it as her own work.

>> No.8001589

>>8001569
definitely not going on the bnf list

>> No.8001605

>>8001516
Seconding (thirding?). That kind of behavior is auto-shit tier demotion IMO.

>> No.8001623

>>8001605
That's Heaven-tier, yeah. Doesn't Rikala do the same thing? There's nothing I hate more than cosplayers who claim credit for costumes that aren't theirs.

>> No.8001663

>>7986557
Lol why are we discussing a bunch of cosplayers who haven't been relevant since 2012.

BNFs don't exist in the current Homestuck fandom, as opposed to two years ago when everyone was jumping to post everything people like ceriene and cancerously were even planning and talking about. The Homestuck BNF era is over, this is beating a dead horse.

>> No.8001671

>>8001663
The list is out of date yeah which is why we're fixing it. But I disagree, some of the BNFs like the ones in God Tier have managed to stay relevant... I'd say most people in the HS cosplay community can recognize Yaexrae and CBC's work. Besides, this has always been more of a who's with watching list than a BNF one anyway.

>> No.8001672

>>8001671
*worth. Thanks, auto correct.

>> No.8001676

>>8001663
>not relevant since 2012
>most of the list names are still cosplaying HS and doing a good job of it
All of my what.

>> No.8001688

Is it okay if i do a dump?

>> No.8001691

>>8001663
A lot of the BNFs on the list just kind of laugh about people following them expecting to see new Homestuck cosplay

>> No.8001696

>>8001663
>>8001671

As somebody who remembers putting this shit together in the first place it was literally because every thread somebody would come in and flail around and ask who on tumblr was worth following, and HSG was sick of it and wanted a graphic. Y'all blew this up into something that's a way bigger deal than it was originally.

>> No.8001697

>>8001688
Go ahead anon!

>> No.8001710
File: 1.29 MB, 480x360, tumblr_inline_ngr0eqDWAR1qkceqi.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001710

>>8001697
Okay, thank. I want to make sure, since my dumps take up a lot of space.

>> No.8001711
File: 304 KB, 1280x802, tumblr_ne2qf6unTK1tux5mfo1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001711

>>8001710
Should've used better word choice, but w/e.

>> No.8001715
File: 1.16 MB, 320x240, tumblr_nglkm0SjeP1rl9io3o2_400.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001715

>>8001711

>> No.8001719
File: 693 KB, 1280x1917, tumblr_nglygqNcBc1r0hzpdo10_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001719

>>8001715

>> No.8001722

>>8001688

As long as you're not getting stuff from the /search ... lately it's only been showing shitty askblogs. You're better off going though the /tagged

>> No.8001727

>>8001524
Hey, Crunchy, I have a few nominations:

Striderian (looks like she's already been reviewed so consider this a vote for her)
Caledbuttscratch
Mitsuki-aizawa
Neokalugovaya

>> No.8001729

>>8001719
Who is this?

Also, we're coming to the end of this thread so I'll just sum up my opinions in the next thread, please also use this thread to leave suggestions for names.

>> No.8001731
File: 422 KB, 1280x1280, tumblr_ngmqcwsnkt1sr5c3fo2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001731

>>8001722
Yeah i always go /tagged

>> No.8001734

>>8001731
this is a cute idea but it just looks really off?

>> No.8001736

>>8001719
why dont john cosplayers ever fucking style their wigs

>> No.8001740
File: 613 KB, 1280x1707, tumblr_ngn1m7Ljvv1sbfseno1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001740

>>8001731

>>8001729
I'm sorry, i was trying to find him in the tag but i can't seem to find it.

>>8001734
Probably the black skirt that makes it look weird.

>> No.8001743
File: 118 KB, 960x1280, tumblr_ngn893uAlE1qf5atpo2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001743

>>8001740

Pic related is Dynasty-stuck Fefeta

>> No.8001746
File: 916 KB, 816x1061, tumblr_ngnqeyyhGf1s7o2spo1_1280.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001746

>>8001743

>> No.8001747
File: 476 KB, 1280x1920, tumblr_ngnv45Vj2W1r14erio1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001747

>>8001746

>> No.8001750
File: 324 KB, 596x900, tumblr_ngssz4flkV1qj67q9o1_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001750

>>8001727
Caledbuttscratch

Finished Cosplays
>Potterstuck Dave
>Aradia
>God Tier Aradia
>Christmas Dave
>Samuraistuck Dave
>Aradiasprite

Notes:
Cosplays with CBC&;Co so if you’ve seen them before that’s why. They’ve a nice feeling for cosplay composition (looking at their Aradiasprite). They post wips and as far as I’m concerned they’re on the level where they belong on the list.

>> No.8001753
File: 1.63 MB, 1280x1325, tumblr_ngp2iaGhw01qm2dwdo1_1280.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001753

>>8001747

>> No.8001756

>>8001743

who's this?

>> No.8001757
File: 111 KB, 640x960, tumblr_ngphf8jAy51sd1wk7o4_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001757

>>8001753

>> No.8001758
File: 56 KB, 960x640, tumblr_ngqwjhhBDP1s3fcv1o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001758

>>8001757

>>8001756
You can find them in the tag ( /tagged/homestuck-cosplay )

>> No.8001764
File: 312 KB, 981x1280, tumblr_ngr4zcMNyy1ra6bb8o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001764

>>8001758

Only really posting pic related because they have cool contacts. Also really obviously shooped in horns.

>> No.8001765
File: 942 KB, 850x1280, tumblr_ngsgztttTr1qfgf2co1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001765

>>8001764

>> No.8001770
File: 275 KB, 900x596, tumblr_ngssz4flkV1qj67q9o4_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001770

>>8001765
Okay last one for now. I may hold off on dumping until Christmas or something. Kind of like a Christmas present no one really wants, like shitty socks from your uncle.

>> No.8001772

>>8001764
Know this person, they haven't cosplayed Homestuck for a long time and those lenses were custom ordered for another cosplay, which I can't remember the name of?
They were really big on Amporas and Captors back in the day, though.

>> No.8001773

>>8001145
>>8001162
as bnf's start to drop off a honorary mention or greatest hits list could be nice
could put in cosplayers who are good/helpful with certain aspects of hs cosplay, like sewing, makeup or propwork.

>> No.8001778

>>8001773
*>>8001170

>> No.8001780
File: 757 KB, 900x600, tumblr_nfm0ivDvqr1rmf578o2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001780

Mitsuki-Aizawa

Finished Cosplays
>Jane Crocker
>Winterstuck Jade
>Winterstuck Rose
>Meulin
>Nepeta
>Terezi
>Aranea
>God Tier Rose
>God Tier Aranea

Notes:
High output with a few outstanding gems (their God Tier Aranea in particular). Craftmanship wise they’re on about the same level as Kitty-Maru I’d say, so definitely tier-worthy. They’ve a cosplay FAQ as well but I can’t find a WIP-tag.

>> No.8001806
File: 101 KB, 682x1024, tumblr_ndjz8fNxiT1smctvro2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001806

Neokalugovaya

Finished Cosplays
>God Tier Jade
>Pre-Incident Vriska Except She Still Has The >Eyepatch On Her Glasses Or Is That Canon?
>Damara
>Knit Dress Roxy
>Handmaid
>God Tier Roxy
>Dead Roxy
>Trickster Roxy

Notes:
Their blog is 100% Homestuck pictures. No coshelp, no tutorials or asks. No WIPs. Their cosplays are… Nice, and if nothing else they’ve a good output, but they’re not really top notch either. Think Kitty-Maru but you even out the highs and the lows to a pretty okay middle ground.

>> No.8001807

>>8001773

That stuff should all go in the pastebin

>> No.8001818

i need help. i cannot shade and highlight without looking ridiculous and dirty. i have a round face, and when i try to contour, it doesnt look natural. and if i add too much it looks dirty. any tips about contouring for round cheeky faces? also any brushes that someone can recommend?

>> No.8001831

>>8001818

Some Qs:

Contouring for kids or for gray?
If not gray, what's your natural complexion look like?
What kind of makeup are you using under the contouring?
What are you using to contour? (Powder? What kind?)
What brushes are you using?
Are you blending well?
How much makeup are you applying and where?

Pics would be helpful, anon. If you're asking for help you're not going to get shit on too badly.

>> No.8001855

>>8001831
its for gray.
i use ben nye under.
i use this opaque eye shadow pallete and use the dark grey colors, cant remember the brand lol.
i used several brushes... tbh im pretty sure they werent for contouring. ive used a kabuki brush, and this other smaller brush.
i try to blend as much as i can.
i just rub the brush on some of the powder, blow on it gently, and shade the eyes, jawline, and the temples, im really only having trouble with my cheeks.
i dont have any pictures of me at the moment.
(also thanks anon)

>> No.8001876

>>8001855

Might be from the eyeshadow, sometimes the pigments in those are mixed and can look splotty when you're trying to get a sheer coverage out of it

Cheeks need a lot less powder than you'd think they do. If your face is really round, try experimenting with how far towards the center of your face the dark part comes.

Kabukis are for blending and large application, aren't they? try a blush brush.

>> No.8001878
File: 281 KB, 593x507, jkhk.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8001878

>>8001855

>> No.8001895

>>8001855
Take a picture of the eyeshadow palette, i might know what it is.

>> No.8001953

>>8001895
i dont have access to it right now. i think its e.l.f.

>> No.8002008

>>8001953
Elf is a really hit or miss brand, i have some of their brushes and they're pretty solid for the price but i stay away from their eyeshadows.

A good cheap brand i like is BH Cosmetics.

Another thing is if your contouring is coming out to be too dark try going over it with translucent powder (Ben nye neutral set is pretty good)

>> No.8002015

>>8002008
its not too dark but my cheeks make it look really obviously fake instead of realistic. it seems to work well, its just my god damn cheek. i usually left them unshaded because it would never look good.

>> No.8002042

>>8001753
I laughed, nice subtitle. Who are these cosplayers?

>> No.8002046

>>8001753

is that supposed to be betas or cronkri? the makeup/wig looks like cronus but the subtitle seems more eridanish

>> No.8002048

>>8001729
the god tier john is faygo-fuckyourself, i dont remember if they changed their URL to take out the hyphen or not

>> No.8002066
File: 12 KB, 236x236, ddabdcc2ab808227ed7cc32a1d7baa5d.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002066

>>8002015
One thing that helps me find where to contour for my cheekbones is to suck my cheeks in and make a fishy face. Apply shadow in the depression going from your ear to the corner of your mouth, or a little bit higher if you want a stronger illusion of cheekbones.

Also, are you contouring for a male or female character? If it's for a girl, you can draw attention away from the contouring on your cheeks by having dramatic eye makeup.

>> No.8002134

>>8002015

To go off of what this anon >>8002066 said/ the image they posted, have you tried using a darker cream shade as a contour? It may be easier to blend and look more natural than powder.

Btw what shade of ben nye are you using? I use cadaver grey

>> No.8002246

>>8001525

i was actually the one who unintentionally started that drama mentioned up thread if we're thinking of the same situation.

all i had had said was that i didn't get why she was being posted every thread because she's pretty mediocre. someone (possibly her) replied that her work is clean and she adds so many unique touches. i'd pointed out she adds the same touches most roxys add (i actually found less sticking to canon while googling), and her faq lists where to buy every piece of it, and another anon pointed out her wig is barely styled.

that's when she freaked out on tumblr. as far as i know she was never "ripped to shred", another anon and i had pointed out she's very average and not worth reposting every single thread. someone might have suggested that it was selfpost, but i don't remember for sure.

>> No.8002248

>>8001509
seconding this

>> No.8002263

>>8002248
>"Any good current homestuck cosplayers?"
>Asked in a thread full of BNF evaluations and new list suggestions

>> No.8002624

>>8002246
always gotta take it to tumblr. whenever my cosplay happens to get "ripped to shreds" here its just motivation/constructive crit i need to improve.

>> No.8002755

So, my suggested changes to the list:

>removal of Snowchilhero on their own request
>removal of Vantasticmess due to inactivity
>removal of Cancerously due to inactivity
>removal of Mostflogged who has outright stated they have no interest in future Homestuck cosplays, provided this is correct
>removal of Violetprince due to inactivity
>removal of Harshwhimsical due to inactivity

>promotion of Seclusionsalad to Mid Tier due to increased amount of finished shoots, high quality craftmanship and varied cosplays

>adding Striderian to Pretty Tier
>adding Caledbuttscratch to Pretty Tier
>adding Mitsuki-Aizawa to Pretty Tier
>adding Neokalugova to Pretty Tier

If HSG is interested in adding Hammasratas to Pretty Tier you also have my passive support.

Feel free to suggest more names.

>> No.8002765

>>8002755

Until when will you be available, Crunchy? Just so we know until when we can suggest names.

>Time to go on my following list

>> No.8002782

>>8002765
Until tonight, I'll still have internet access but not my computer, probably.

>> No.8002805

>>8002755

I agree with all of these changes. Much more useful as a resource.

>> No.8002819

>>8002755
I agree with all of this too. Were we considering Ceres as an addition this round too?

>> No.8002842

>>8002755
Only thing I don't agree with is neokalugova. the construction on her gt roxy is pretty atrocious imo.

>> No.8002843

>>8002842
I agree, she's at a slightly lower level than the other pretty tiers, but she (and Hammasratas) aren't from the USA if we wanted more Europeans to follow.

>> No.8002845

Does anyone have any male cosplayer suggestions just to shut the inevitable butthurt anons up? Birdtype and that Eridan who was posted last thread come to mind but their quality might not be up to snuff.

>> No.8002847
File: 753 KB, 1000x750, tumblr_n14l3nKKPE1r1yfkgo4_1280[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002847

>>8002819
Ceres

Finished Cosplays
>Diamonds Droog
>Dangan Ronpa Crossover Prince of Hope

Notes:
They've a lot of good cosplays in the past, but the last cosplay in their tag they actually made would be Diamonds Droog. There's a Derse Dreamer Equius from november, but that was from an old shoot. I vote nay, it's one thing to keep old cosplayers on who haven't been super active, another to add on cosplayers who might just not return to the fandom.

>> No.8002848

>>8002847
Oh that's a shame.... I didn't realize she was so inactive.

>> No.8002849

>>8002843
Different anon but I don't think it matters that we get non-American on the list just because. She's out of place there compared to everyone else already tiered. Frankly, so is that mitsuki chick.

Striderian has always been meh to me but at least they have better variety and better construction. Caledbuttscratch I'm not sold on. Their Aradia is cute but their Dave is really not; they don't stand out imo beyond the fact that they hang out with CBC.

>> No.8002852
File: 122 KB, 476x514, bruh.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002852

>>8002845
Birdtype haven't done any Homestuck this year.
See things like this make my job so much easier.

>> No.8002854

Can someone dump the most recent version of the list for reference?

>> No.8002857

>>8002849
>voting for zero new additions

I think everyone except maybe neokalugova compares to other pretty tiers like kitty-maru or fromglibo. It doesn't make sense to hold everyone to a higher standard, otherwise we'll keep running into the same problem we've had all year where old people aren't removed and new people aren't added.

If we want to make special exceptions and add a few people with one hit wonder showstoppers that's one thing but the whole point of crunchy'a review is to find new, good cosplayers.

>> No.8002862

>>8002857
I put a vote in for Striderian. Maybe that wasn't clear by the way I phrased it.

If we're going to include lower quality cosplayers on pretty tier, then we should bump up other pretty tiers into mid tier to make room.

>> No.8002864
File: 81 KB, 500x750, tumblr_moputvG7IP1rwz9xxo4_500[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002864

>>8002854
That's what we're trying to make, for the time there is no most recent version of the list. Everyone on it is in this thread anyway.

As for Caledbuttscratch and similar:
It seems like a lot of anons has incredibly high expectations. We can't hold everyone to the same standards as we do tiernames which has been on the list for long and we all already know, nor can we compare potential pretty tiers to people on mid tier.
Have another shot of Caledbuttscratch.

>>8002862
I would say that Crowmunist could very well be bumped to mid tier. As for "making room"... The list doesn't exactly have finite spots. It's literally a list of suggestions of Homestuck Cosplayers to follow.

>> No.8002874
File: 1.21 MB, 1000x721, tumblr_neshzeh1Bc1qf5atpo1_1280[1].png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002874

>>8001743

fraubeilschmidt

Finished Cosplays
>Lolitastuck Feferi
>Promstuck? Roxy
>Feferi
>Militarystuck Feferi
>God Tier Rose
>Ballgown Dreamer Roxy
>Damara Megido
>Dynastystuck Fefetasprite

Notes:
A Spanish cosplayer.
HSG may question their taste (militarystuck, lolita in cosplay), but I have to say I think they're pretty good. Apparently they also have a lot of Homestuck planned for the future.

>> No.8002912

>>8002874
Another vote for her. I am always of the opinion that the more active people on, the better. This isn't an exclusive club, just a list of people who are keeping the fandom going. I don't have much opinion on bumping the current pretty tiers up to mid but I do question putting people like kitty-maru on the same level as kisbe.

>> No.8002923
File: 562 KB, 1280x853, tumblr_nep2tykVpG1r35os0o2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002923

>>8002864
Caledbuttscratch has enough output to warrant being added imo.

>> No.8002929

>>8002864
I didn't mean "making room" in the literal sense so much as keeping tiers grouped with like peers so to speak. If pretty becomes a more introductory category, then we should bump the more established cosplayers already on pretty tier up to the next level. SS should be promoted no question. I could support crowmunist being promoted too. If kitty-maru has future HS cosplay plans I'd bump them as well. Since cancerously made it there's no reason to keep them off.

I guess I thought we had a lot more pretty tiers than we do. I didn't realize how many names had dwindled off. It's hard to mentally separate from the glory days of old but beggars can't be choosers. Might as well add everyone.

>>8002912
Why aren't Dei and Kisbe god tier yet? They're easily on CBC's level in skill if not in output.

>> No.8002934

I think its time for a new thread

>> No.8002940

>>8002929
>Why aren't Dei and Kisbe god tier yet?
They're up there in terms of craftsmanship, but nowhere near Yaexrae or CBC's level of helpfulness.

>> No.8002947
File: 380 KB, 700x1430, tumblr_mlem7sNNXa1qj67q9o1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8002947

>>8002849
Caledbuttscratch's Dave is pretty decent in the sea of shitty Daves, but they seem to be doing a lot of Aradia lately. I really like how clean their dreamer looks, though.

>> No.8002948

>>8002929
Like I said, I would not put Cancerously on mid tier today. The cosplay quality of the fandom has increased, the standards are higher.

As for Kisbe and Dei-Sandvich, it has previously been a matter of lack of tutorials. I do think thir craftmanship warrant a position on God Tier, but I'm afraid they're not the types to stick in the same fandom for very long and am worried that they might not cosplay Homestuck for much longer. Of course, that alone isn't a very good reason to hold them back, but that is my personal bias and thus I haven't really said anything about them.

>>8002934
I sy we wait a little or at least make sure the conversation isn't just dropped in a new thread.

>> No.8002949

>>8002929
I wish Dei and Kisbe had more output and posts in general because otherwise they'd be a no brainer for promotion. When's the last time they actually wore Homestuck? If they have any upcoming plans I wouldn't mind seeing them bumped.

>> No.8002955

Also, it is great that people post more pictures of suggested cosplayers!

Let's keep this up until we hit image limit haha.

>> No.8003124

Sorry I'm late. ...And lazy. But here's the new thread:

>>8003123

>> No.8003154

>>8002874
>>8002912

I'd say yes for her as well. I'm all in for active people.

>> No.8003159

>>8003154

Whoops shit, I didn't see there was a new thread.

>> No.8003179

>>8002874
Ugh...can you post more pics? She's just so...lackluster. Even when compared to the other new additions.

>> No.8006327

>>8002134
i actually custom mix ben nye clown white with ben nye black. it saves me money.

>>
Delete posts
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.
Captcha
Action