/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL

>>9136507
You have really shit tastes.

Here's mine! My tastes are a bit all over the place

wew

>>9136523
salty/9
>>9136534
7/9 all that Innocent World, nice
>>9136550
6/9 I've always loved that chiffon MM dress

>>9136507
that selection seems kinda all over the place....

As for me, I'm just...kind of basic goth with a vampire theme...sort of.

Oh I totally skipped over the rating part.

>>9136507
2/9 I'm wondering what you're style is.

>>9136534
5/9 good stuff.

>>9136583
6/9 Pretty basic as you said. Kind of looks like goth lolita starter pack, some undeniably good prints though.

>>9136583
6/9 yeah I don't stick to one substyle, never have t b h

Are the top 9 the ones we own, or the ones we want?

>>9136630
shut the fuck up???!!!?

>>9136507
I love happy bell! Such a cute Meta print.

My taste is unbalanced/10. I like gothic too but not enough for any gothic to be in my top 9...

>>9136652
>SWP

shit/10

>>9136639
What? It's a valid question.

muh velveteen

>>9136663
>SWP instead of SPW

shit spelling/10

Here's mine.

>>9136630
It's your top 9 fav dresses, whether owned or not

>>9136677
7/9 velveteen is my weakness. And this classic OP detailing is lovely (though I personally can't pull it off any longer)

>all this shit taste

not surprised, just disappointed

>>9136652
Incredibly tacky/9. I love it.
>>9136677
Marry me. 9/9

>>9136652
Gaudy/9. I find the consistency of your taste charming though.

>>9136732
8/9 GOOD SHIT

OPs are my soft spot.

>>9136550
7/10, would be great without the middle section.

>>9136677
11/10, are you me?
>tfw I didn't include my dream dresses because I'm already spamming DD threads with it

>>9136732
9/10, very elegant

My wardrobe/wishlist is a mess and always will be

>>9136677
8/9. I've been coming to appreciate velveteen and old school a lot more lately.

>>9136732
9/9. I'm not that into florals anymore but I remember pining for Mary Magdalene floral prints when I first discovered the fashion.

>>9136741
THANKS ANON

>>9136746
8/9 That top right boz is especially beautiful, the IW preserved dolls are always watching' kills it though.

>>9136798
7/9
That top middle moitie OP is amazing (if it's the one I think it is), very gorgeous fabric. I have it in black and it's so comfy.

Picking only 9 is hard, there are so many more I love equally, and this is why I have way too many dresses

>>9136741
>>9136737
I am pretty consistently into tacky and gaudy OTT. Thank you, anons.

>>9136732
Looks very wearable, the florals are lovely. 7/9, only because Cadre du Lapin isn't at all my taste.

>>9136798
Not bad, not bad. 8/9.

I'm only slightly ashamed of how much Baby I want.

So I really like blue, apparently

Yeah, I have shit taste.

>>9136507
Mine

>>9136874
I'd agree, but then I'm secretly in love with Meta's hakama cuts

>>9136875
Guess you have shit taste too.

>>9136871
I love your taste with Krad Lanrete's Versailles, Baby's Marie Antoinette, and AATP's The Grace.

I couldn't get the link / app to work on my phone so excuse my shittier collage. Still pretty new to lolita so am interested in what others think of my taste. I couldn't decide on colour combos in the first row, hence why they are joined. I currently own AP Elizabeth Unicorn OP in navy and KL Venice Carnival JSK l in black

I tend to like brown, or floral, or both.

>>9136677 9/9 and >>9136746 6/9, because velveteen and old school are the best.

>>9136843
also 9/9 for frills and florals

>>9136843
7/9 those colours are all amazing, very elegant

>>9136871
9/9 great taste anon!

>>9136876
Fantastic taste, anon! Those are all gorgeous.

>muh classic

>>9136899
You get a 7/9 from me! I joined the reservation for the JSK version of the Yolanda OP you have in the bottom row and I can't wait for it to arrive.

>>9136902
8/9 Sauce on top right corner?

>>9136770
What is that middle left dress?
7/9 the dolly cross is throwing me off.

>>9136823
6/9 how do you guys with mainly classic/gothic also like pastel sweet?

>>9136876
Top tier tacky.

>>9136899
I mean these all look decent but I would recommend looking at more brand/non taobao dresses for the sake of having better quality stuff. Like I know that R series take the crown is unnecessarily expensive for a taobao dress so it probably makes more sense to get a brand regimental stripe or crown jsk.
I really like that yolanda dress on the far right though.

>>9136902
4/9 so much full shirring.

>>9136914
9/9 bury me in these.

>>9136876
good shit/9

Decided to hop in with select wardrobe pieces; stuff I'm really feeling at the moment. Phasing out colors feels so good.

>>9136534
6/10, good stuff, but not my taste. Your Anniversary Rose and VM OP are very worth it, though.

>>9136583
7/10, I can dig it; your Moitie selection is great and even though you're hoping styles, you're not too terribly all over the place

>>9136677
10/10 pls be mine and we can velvet together until the end

>>9136732
9/10, great JetJ taste

>>9136746
I have 3 of these dresses, but have had 4, so I'll go ahead and give you a 9 for being on the same wavelength as me

>>9136970
8/9 feerie is one of my favourites

>>9136904
8/9 best boz and JetJ

>>9136843
7/9 no shame, just beauty

>>9136874
I really like your shit taste. But I also have shit taste, I guess.

>>9136960
I wear every substyle, I've sold most of my normalfag clothes on consignment to make room. I was getting bored of lolita just wearing classic, branching out made me fall in love with lolita again. It keeps things fresh to be goth one day and sugary sweet the next

This is completely fantasy since I'd never be able to find most of these, let alone fit in them

>>9136914
8/9 You have two things from my grid but in sax and now I want something from yours.

>>9136997
I can tell you that that velveteen Meta OP runs quite large, anon. I'm taking mine in for cleaning this week and just measured it; it's 48cm laying flat at the bust, so it could fit a 96cm bust pretty well. The sleeves are nice and long, too.

>>9137006
Thanks for that info! The meta I'm not too worried about fitting but the other stuff, yes. Thanks meta for being a bro. Also hospitality doll is basically a sex costume and I probably couldn't wear it out even it I owned it, so I will be content to admire it aesthetically.

>>9137021
Probably not the worst choice on Hospitality Doll. I have that one as well and can say that the blouse does run quite small. The sleeve and bodice lengths are stupid short and it's about 87cm comfortable max for the bust. The skirt is oddly accommodating, though.

The VM coffin, tho.. Best thing to ever put on a wishlist. A+

>>9136954
http://lolibrary.org/apparel/fleur-rose-jsk

>>9137047
Thanks anon!

A couple of these I would never even try to hunt down because I know I'd never wear them, but I love them all the same.

I don't think I'd try to find some of these; I wouldn't know how to coord them, honestly. But all of these dresses made my heart skip a beat when I first saw them.

These threads make me feel so good because I usually own at least 1 dress from each collage and it feels the best when I own over half

>>9137130

Considering one of them is all velvet, another is random OTT, one is mostly less popular taobao, and some anons are going full sweet, full classic or full gothic, while accusations of "shit taste" are flying about, this seems to imply more that you have a jumbled-up wardrobe of whatever you can find, more than anything else, so......

>>9137148
Anon probably owns the ~*most covered*~ dress in each collage. Also I don't really understand deriving joy from owning a closet full of stuff that other people want.

>>9137115
I have such conflicted feelings about yours, because half your pieces I love, but the other half I hate with equal amounts of passion.

>>9137130
I'm an anon that used to own a lot of coveted items, and have since sold most of it off and only kept what I actually like and wear. You'll grow anon.

>>9137159

I have a handful of dresses that seem to show up in the wishlist thread every now and again, mostly whenever that happens I just feel grateful I already own the dress and won't be fighting some other anon in a bidwar for it, so there's that?

>>9136685
9/10, you've got a bunch of my favorites on your list

>>9137148
Most of them anon, not all of them, did you fail your reading comprehension tests?

>>9137159
>>9137164
Basically what >>9137169 said. It's not like I buy dresses specifically because other people want them, it just so happens that a lot of what I do like and own is also wanted by other people. Looking at this thread, there are a few dresses which are on multiple collages, it doesn't really mean anything other than that it's popular.

I own all except the last row, but I want too much and I own too much.

>>9136843
7/9, nice taste. I waver between wanting fleur antoinette in green and deciding that's one too many fleur antoinettes.

>>9136871

I reserved that series but in a different cut. KL for life.

>>9136904

7/9, such nice but varied taste

>>9136914
8/9, muh classic indeed.

>>9137185

Dropped pic oops.

>>9137181

I can read, anon. I also said "seem to imply". Basically, just reading your comment and quickly skimming the thread gives me the impression your wardrobe is a mess because the photos are all 9-dress collages representing very different tastes, regardless of what impression you actually intended to convey when you typed it out.

I mean, I'm not the one getting mostly negative responses to my comments, so maybe you want to rethink your wording next time. For the record, I'm both >>9137148 and >>9137169.

>>9136997
>>9136904
>>9136732
>>9136677
I like you guys let's be friends

This was really hard. Only own 5 out of the 9, sadly.

The bottom row Meta dresses didn't have stock photos from the colorways I wanted so imagine the polka dot one as red and the other in tartan.

>>9137200
The skirt from the same series, top left, is on LM right now.

My favourites change a lot but right now I'm really into OPs.

>>9136583
7/9
>>9136677
9/9 perfect
>>9136732
6/9
>>9136746
6/9
>>9136876
Haha, I love the consistency! Keep going, anon.
>>9136904
7/9, really nice
>>9136970
7/9 as well
>>9137210
9/9 marry me

lot of good taste in here

>one of these gulls is not like the others
>one of these gulls likes sweet

>>9136960
Middle left is by Cloudberry Lady. I found out about it after it sold out and it's been on my wishlist since.

>>9137253
8/9 makes me nostalgic for when I wore more sweet.

>>9136583
7/10. The bottom row lowered your score with some weird colorway choices and I'm not a fan of bottom far right. Great picks otherwise!

>>9137198
9/10 would wear all your Moities + I like your bottom row choices. Good luck in finding some of them, anon!

I sadly only own two of these dresses. Not pictured is forest harvest.

>>9137283
dropped ppic

Only made it with the dresses I own.

>>9137210
9/9 mouth watering mode

>>9137190
8/9 bottom right florals are beautiful

>>9137198
8/9 love your taste anon, top right OP especially

>>9136997
6/8 (1/1 coffin is a wardrobe staple) don't give up anon, \jetJ sizing can be odd and MM can be unforgiving though.

>>9137195
>tfw lone lolita and this is nice

All dresses i dont own.
I think ill try to use this as a guide as what to buy next. So thanks OP. Though the new AatP halloween print ill buy when it comes out.

Already one the telephone JSK and Fantastic Dolly in other colorways but haven't been able to find these.

>>9137185
There is no such thing as too many Fleur Antoinettes. I have it in green and ivory right now and I'm regretting not getting it in apricot during the rerelease.

>>9137370
My wardrobe is 100% black and 85% gothic but even I have come real close to getting Fleur Antoinette a couple of times. It's a gorgeous dress.

>>9137383

It came in black one particular year (2009), if that piques your interest. Though it seems really rare and hard to find by now.

>>9136677
8/9 Velveteen is the best!

>>9136843
7/9 Beautiful florals!

>>9136904
7/9 Lovely MM and JetJ choices.

>>9136997
9/9 Everything is amazing.

>>9137190
8/9 MM love!

>>9137370
>There is no such thing as too many Fleur Antoinettes.

Agreed. Fleur Antoinette is the only dress where I want it in multiple colorways.

i really like food and blue apparently

>>9136843
>>9136871
>>9136914
10/10, so elegant i love it

>>9136902
10/10 for grandma's couch kei

>>9137299
8/10 why holy lantern this is so good otherwise

I'm stuck in 2010

Lavender and black (plus the occasional crazy JetJ print).

>>9136732
>>9136871
>>9136997
>>9137210
>>9137404
love all of these

>>9137766
9/9 gorgeous. I've always loved copellia and am hunting for robe de chapelle

I have trash taste desu

>>9137323
do you want holy theater in navy? cause i have that same cut that im trying to give to a loving home.

>>9136550
noice/10
i especially like the first row and the last dress because fawns

>>9136583
fucking cool/10
Gothic doesn't suit me because babyface,pale as a ghost,and i love pastels. But i find it so beautiful on other girls.

>>9136677
8/10
old school is the coolest

>>9136746
6/10?
you have special taste but i kinda like it,you look like an interesting person.

>>9136843
lovely/10 you have the taste of a real modern day princess

>>9136871
It's so elegant! Not a fan of classic lolita on myself but holy crap it looks awesome. And blue is my favourite color as well so i tend to want too much stuff in blue colorway. Woops

>>9136876
tacky but a good kind of tacky. You probably look like some badass JRPG character with these and i like it

>>9137198
Mana-tier taste/10
I love Vampire Requiem in lilac in this cut so much, aw mang

>>9137200
Cute and quirky!/10
I picture you as a cute and fun person to be around

>>9137210
Absolute elegant badass/10

>>9137253
Aw man, makes me nostalgic of 2010 and such, I have the JJ and Milky Berry. Love them.
Super cute taste!

>>9137286
Super nice/10
I like the innocent world dresses you choosed, it's a nice collage.

>>9137452
I like half of it, chocolaaaaate, also Magical Etoile in navy and that last dress look really cool

>>9137519
same anon, same. but it's so fucking cute especially when worn in a "simple" way

Here's mine!
>muh sweet loliduh

>>9137452
Well, Holy Lantern was on my wishlist since the original release, I actually tried to win two $700 auctions before the rerelease. I'm really sad that it's such a bandwagon dress now, because it's still very dear to me.

>>9137917
I was actively trying to buy it but i think I missed the sale. At this very moment I'm on vacation for two weeks so I'm not really looking to buy in case an emergency happens but I'll put my email up here anyway.

If you're asking close to retail (~$300) though I'm not really interested as it was on sale and it's not my top priorities

>>9137210
The only 10/10 tastes I see here t b h. I'm with you on the black.

>All these rates out of ten when the max is 9

>>9137973
Not any of the anons you posted here, but this post is really cute. I like the thought you put into each comment.
So, I'll say for yours double-natured/10. I like the navys and blacks mixed with the soft sweet prints.
I like how the first row are sweet, but some of AP's softer sweet prints.
Second row is my personal fav and all something I own outside except the mint one. What is the furthest left print?
Bottom row feels older but has that classic AP vibe.

>>9137831
7/9 I like ya, anon. Chocolate and donut top row is a win with me, but I love your messy and cluttered love of weird violet and navy prints. The bottom row is hideous honestly, but it's that special Baby/AatP hideous.

>>9136732
Oh God, what is that top center lavender dress?
9/9 for new dream dress awakening.

>>9137253
GOOD SHIT

Idgaf holy lantern is my one true love

>>9138141
8/9 non grandma dresses have no place in my classic haven

>>9137831
I like it, 7/9
>>9137519
The golden age, 10/10
>>9137344
Cinema doll is so overrated and dolly dot or whatever is just ugly. 6/9

I like red, velveteen, oldschool, and pastel vomit...my tastes aren't very cohesive.

>>9136652
tacky/9 I love it

>>9136677
9/9 so good

>>9136997
love/9

>>9137253
7/9 golden age ap

>>9137286
8/9 I hope you get that chess story piece one day, anon!

>>9137519
9/9 perfect

some of these dresses I don't own and never will, but I really like them. I do admit I have some really mismatchy tastes but I enjoy both sweet and gothic styles.

>>9137766
Very pretty, feminine, and classy. 9/10, only one I personally don't like is the green dress because that shade in particular reminds me of my edgy weeb days for some reason.

>>9137452
9/10 I like these too although I don't like the Lief(?) one in the middle in the bottom row!

>>9137238
10/10 amazing taste

>>9137210
another 10/10 for amazing taste

>>9137519
9/10. That's the best color way for Marine Kingdom too. Nice taste

Queen of shit taste reporting in.

>>9138233
>>9138334
Ayyyyy my fellow shit tasters, 9/9

>>9137253
>>9137519
>>9137299
My favorites of the thread so far, sweet lolita owns my life

Here's mine. Honorable mentions who did not make the cut: BTSSB Paris Windows, AP Cinema Doll, and Meta Swan Lake - all in ivory. RIP

It's an odd mixture of florals and jewel tones

>>9136732 my perfume anon

>>9136550
>>9136871
>>9136902
>>9136914
>>9137210
>>9137404
>>9137766

good taste anons

i'm a mess

>>9136534
>>9136732
>>9137253
8/9, really liked it

>>9137452
are u me anon? 9/9

>>9136904
>>9137519
9/9 too

This was difficult. Mostly pulled from my wishlist.
>idk what I am doing

>>9138477
8/9 that first one!

>>9137766
>>9137404
>>9137190
9/9!

>>9137210
with the other anon, be my wife/10

Mushrooms everywhere

>>9138101
It's Arabesque Rose by MM, gorgeous fabric and the only lavender piece I have.

I like classic, gothic and strawberries haha, dont see myself ever finding the first few but I can dream.

>inb4 another michael-in-navyfag
I'm kicking myself for not buying it new

>>9136732
anon, do you already have the koitsukihime op? If not it's up on y!a (btssb version) http://page9.auctions.yahoo.co.jp/jp/auction/k224008277

>>9136550
7/9, middle row kinda brings it down but otherwise impeccable taste anon.

>>9138557

I have bottom right in brown and am about to sell it. Are you interested at all?

>>9138638

*bottom left rather.

Sorry, that was an embarrassing spatial unawareness.

what the filename says

>>9138615
>>9136746
What is it about the middle row that you guys aren't liking? Is.. is it the meta

>>9138477
8/9 classy

>>9138484
5/9 at least you are self aware.

>>9138518
7/9 velveteen gobelin master race.

>>9136970
8/9, very spoopy
>>9137103
first row is 9/9 for retro meta, but overall 5/9
>>9137200
7/9, Most of the dresses in your collage I've either owned or have on my wishlist. Good taste.
>>9138245
9/9 beautiful
>>9137299
8/9 A+ tastes, but your poor wallet!
>>9137831
6/9, lavender's beautiful and chocolates's delicious
>>9137973
cute dresses and cuter personality/9, let's be friends
>>9138233
6/9 p good
>>9138427
7/9, you've got a really nice cohesive style, it's sweet but still very elegant
>>9138484
top left is 4/4 , everything else is 5/9
>>9138518
7/9, beth a qt

>>9138526
It's from Jane marple, no idea of name or release date

>>9138590
I do have it anon, but thanks for being so thoughtful

Taste is all over the place, but I really like berries

>>9138878
5/9 , I'm just no big fan of the busy AP prints

>>9138670
5/9 the gold and ivory is neat

>>9138590
7/9 like it

>>9138557
8/9 love the theme

>>9138518
4/9 too simple for me

>>9138484
7/9 , they are all very different but all very nice

>>9138477
9/9 all gorgeous

I think anyone calling shit taste, but not posting their own 3x3 needs to be disregarded. There's a girl in my comm who considers Claudia shit taste, but her dream dress is that purple organdy abomination by AatP.

Pretty sure I have average tier taste, but at least I know what I like? The JetJ and IW dresses are not yet in my wardrobe but on the list of things to purchase once finances permit and I can find them

>>9139061
7/9 I like berries too

>>9138878
7/9 I saw the witch set and castle skirt worn in person and they were very underwhelming

>>9138670
5/9 not really my thing sorry

>>9138590
6/9 you have set yourself a difficult task finding those...

>>9138557
7/9 mushrooms!

This is mine, unfortunately I only own 3 of them.

>>9138233
Chess story anon here. I've checked LM and there's a bunch that are unsold so I'll wade through the listings. Didn't know the dress was /that/ nice until I started reading reviews on it, since it was released around the time I became interested in the fashion. That detailing in the lace though... it's beautiful.

>>9139061

I absolutely adore that apron IW piece. Its so adorable.

Not gonna rate others because I'm not a great judge, but I'm curious what people think of mine.

>>9139160
Fuck, I just realized Cathedral isn't properly centered and you can barely see it.

Mix of owned and wishlist, I feel like my style is pretty cookie-cutter but I'm comfortable that way.

>>9139128
8/9, Cosmic throws it off

>>9139103
7/9, love the purple theme

>>9139061
6/9, I like the berry ones but the rest are meh

>>9138878
8/9, totally not my style, I just like the palette and cohesiveness

>>9138590
7/9, not into the floral ones

>>9138141
8/9, goddammit Holy Lantern

>>9138898
I'm in love. Thank for sharing anon.
>this will haunt my dreams

>>9138898
Found it on lolibrary anon!
http://lolibrary.org/apparel/crown-lily-gobelin-jsk

>>9137323
Are you the anon I said I'd fight for träumerei?
Either way, good taste on the navy btssb!

>>9139295
8/9 AatP whores unite

>>9138334
That sure is some top tier shit taste, anon 9/9

>>9139160
It's a bit all over the place but the majority seem to be nice pieces, 6/9

>>9139295
7/9 I can see the cookie cutter but it's still cohesive overall, and the music themed dresses are adorable.

>>9139370
Sadly I don't think it was me. Which means there is at least three of us...
I'm getting to a point where I'd definitely settle for red and maybe pink.

mix of stuff i already own, and things on my wishlist

>>9139351
That neckline. Comes in black too.
Shit sonnnn.

>>9137210
Not into gothic but this is good.

>>9137344
7/9, lovely retro vibes.

>>9137973
Nice, the bottom row is 3/3.

>>9138233
Kinda meh, 3/9 but good old school pieces.

>>9138557
7/9 nearly perfect.

>>9139061
7/9 super nice.

Fairly representative of color distribution of my wardrobe. Lots of sweet prints but I have a soft spot for nonprints in burgundy.

I'm basic goth trash that shops with the motto "If it isn't black, put it back".

>>9138557
We have very similar tastes in mushroom prints.
I have bottom left in the skirt and I'm finding it impossible to match the white and the wine color to anything. The only reason I didn't buy the OP was because of the ribbon and belt. It looks incredibly cheap like Milano tier irl at least in my option

>>9140552
I used to be this way. Honestly, it makes your wardrobe so fucking annoying when your tastes are all over the place, I miss the days when I was pure goth trash.

Great taste over all, BTW.

>>9139639
Did you mean to reply to >>9139295? Just asking because they have more music pieces than I do, so I thought maybe you meant to reply to them?

>>9137198
Are you me, anon? 8/9

>>9136970
7/9

>>9137210
9/9 perfect

Apparently I like nuns, wine and chocolate

I'm a terrible lief fag and I know it, but I want nearly all their dresses!

>>9139295
7/9 Loving those reds and teals anon!

>>9139857
4/9 That's quite a mix colour wise, like the classic pieces though.

>>9140417
7/9 This is so lovely anon, the pastels are very pretty, not sure about the burgundy.

>>9140552
9/9 Love it all!

>>9141034
7/9 So elegant, not sure about the top left and bottom right but otherwise beautiful.

eternally searching for the triple tiered velveteen op, i won't give up yet!

>>9136677
9/9 velveteen is love, velveteen is life.

>>9137238
9/9 such beautiful taste!

>>9137973
cutest taste/9 you must be really fun to be around!

>>9138233
6/9 karami deserves a spot in my collage too, i wear that comfy sucker all the time.

>>9138878
7/9 while i wouldn't wear most of these, i love all the detailing and textures.

>>9139061
3/3 for berries, i've also recently developed a love for innocent world's berry items.

>>9139103
8/9 it's not my style but love the palette.

>>9141195
7/9 for tartan and big bows, i love these old school elements with a modern look.

>>9141195
Lol, that birdcage dress sold on LM for 6 bucks.

>>9139160
You have bad taste, 2/9

The moitie and the green baby (what is that?) are nice, but meme circus is overrated and not that cute. the skirt and the rest of the middle row is tacky trash

>>9141811
>Masquerade Theatre
>trashy

Lol

>>9141811
>love air mail, puppet circus, and masquerade theater are trash
Oh honey, the one with the shit taste here is you.

And that green dress is AatP, not Baby.

>>9139160
I'd give you a 7 or 8, don't listen to that other anon, they're confirmed for shit taste.

>>9141811
>love air mail, puppet circus, castle of nightmare and masquerade theater are trash
Oh honey, the one with the bad taste here is you.

And that green dress is AatP, not Baby.

>>9139160
I'd give you a 7 or 8, don't listen to that other anon, they're confirmed for not knowing what they're talking about. The only thing that made me raise an eyebrow is that you have a lot of bloodbath dresses, like Puppet Circus and Love Air Mail, which I'm a bit salty about and find kinda basic.

>>9139370
Traumerei is getting a rerelease, no need to fight! Rejoice anons!

>>9141959
I'm so happy right now that I'm not computing this post
>>9141811
Could you identify which collage you are, or post yours if you haven't already? If you think that anon of all people has 2 level taste and are calling shit like Masquerade Theater and Love Air Mail tacky trash, I'm assuming your 3x3 must have been put together by the lolita gods themselves.

>>9141948
The only bloodbath dress I see besides the ones you listed is Twinkle Mermaid.

>>9141967
Seconding this request. I can't tell if they're trolling or just an extreme example of one of those people that can't differentiate between not-their-taste and shit taste.

>>9139160
I don't necessarily like every single one of these dresses, but none of them are bad. 8/9

>>9141762
I don't really like old school sweet, but the pieces you picked out are super cute for the most part. 7/9

>>9141811
>>9141981
>>9141967
>>9141948
>>9141814
Troll or not, I am prepared to take a boxcutter to a bitch's face over calling Masquerade Theater tacky and/or trashy

>>9141967
Yeah, I have the feeling they're the exact kind of person that >>9139069 is talking about.

>>9141811

>>9141959
Where did you hear about that? Can't find any info.

>tfw this thread is a bunch of lolitas on the internet threatening to fight each other over their different tastes in frilly dresses

I love you guys never change.

>picture
>The Greatest Lolita Dresses Ever Made
>i.m.o.

I own 6/9 so I'm pretty happy. I'll wait for the remainder to find their way, no hurry.

>>9138898
The black one came up on Wunderwelt a couple of months ago. I was surprised that it was Jane Marple, since it looks like old JetJ or something to me. It was up for a few hours, but didn't last a day.

>>9141762
There is one in BST!

Here I was thinking I always went for navy

>>9141811
bitch you dumb
>>9139160
bany you flawless

>>9142073
*baby

I don't have a wishlist, so I decided to include only dresses that I already own amongst the ones that I currently love the most.
Green/brown/powder pink + flowers = love.

>>9142216
7/9 love the classic, but a couple of them aren't my thing

>>9142081
7/9 liking the red x gold but not sure about the bottom right...

>>9142046
Your left hand column isn't really my thing and I haven't seen a good jellyfish coord ever, 6/9

>>9142031
Why top right when AP has made many better card suit themed dresses? Also not a fan of the high waisted cuts on cross themed dresses 6/9

>>9141762
Old school 7/9

>>9141195
I wouldn't wear any of this myself but it's not bad overall, 7/9

>>9141034
I love moitie but they have some much nicer plain dresses, 6/9

>>9140626
I don't like them for myself, but 7/9 I think Mercator is ugly in that colour, and the lief sailor dress would have been improved without the brand name being so obvious.

>>9140552
Some great stuff but also some not so great. 6/9

>>9140417
Really not sure about some of those 6/9

>>9139857
I have no idea what's going on here and I'm not sure I like it 5/9

Mine. Love sleeves and princess styled dresses are perfect for me.

>>9142081
>>9141034
>>9140552
>>9139295
>>9139160
>>9138590
>all dat premo moitie and aatp
A minimum of 7/9 for all of you

>>9142286
Hime/9

Here's mine. I'm a tacky bitch with a monotone wardrobe. I think I own three of these here dresses, but my wardrobe is mostly ouji and skirts, so that's not saying much.

>>9142331
I really love yours for some reason, even though it's not my thing personally. I don't see many wardrobes like this and it's refreshing. I think it's because I see a lot of people tend to sell off a majority of quirky older pieces or really old prints like this. Your love of the oldschool looking music notes prints is really charming,
Adorably oldschool tacky/9.

I'll contribute too
I have no idea why I want Holy Night story exactly in red colorway, also I don't know how it's going to match with the rest of my black-blue-violet wardrobe either

>>9142029
It hasn't been announced but it is confirmed. There were rumors so some big chinese shopping service called baby and they confirmed, it's happening!

>>9142331
9/9, oldschool monochrome is great! (Especially when music gets involved.)
>>9142471
Holiday Goth/9

I went through my Pinterest wishlist, and I guess my overall theme would be Sugar Plum Fairy?

All cats all the time

>>9142669
9/9 lives

>>9142669
I'm a bit disappointed there's no CTP, but eellent taste with that JetJ pussy.

>>9142686
CTP is too pricey for me to even dream about, plus it's not really my style. It does make me feel like a bit of a failure as a cat obsessed lolita to not want it, though.

>>9142286
What's the bottom left dress? I'm in love.

>>9142590
8/9, I love the very sweet-classic feel
>>9142669
7/9, the top row is A+ taste

Generally, I prefer classic/non-print sweet. I have some dream dresses that are far outside that realm (Sugar Dream Dome, Daydreaming Goldfish) but I try to ignore those impulses for cohesion's sake.

>>9142749
8/9, this reminds me of what I fell in love with when first getting into the fashion

Ta da

>>9136507
4/9
>>9136534
7/9
>>9136550
8/9 love it!
>>9136583
4/9
>>9136677
velveteen/10 great taste
>>9136732
7/9
>>9136770
6/9
Also what's the sauce on that moth dress? Print is 10/10
>>9136871
8/9 cutes blues
>>9136904
8/9
>>9136914
9/9 solid taste
>>9137190
8/9
>>9142286
8/9 bottom left corner is amazing

>>9138334
Glad to see i'm not the only one into celestial prints anon

>>9138670
T-the space cats... I love that anon!
>>9138233
The one in the top right... damn. I love that 17th century feeling.

>>9137265
I have the skirt in this colorway and it's amazing. I wish they'd do a rerelease so I could buy the JSK too.

>>9142704
>>9142875
Thanks. The bottom left one is the "Swan's Song" from Yolanda.

>>9142996
>Yolanda
Muh girl

I love red, all shades of brown and navy

>>9144171
And all shades of blue.* I went too fast..

>>9138670
What's the name of the dress with the cats in the clouds? I can't find it anywhere

I noticed a lot of people itt posting 3x3s of nearly identical dresses. Maybe I just have more random taste.
Too many favorites to fit into 9 spots so I tried to not include ones too similar, if that makes sense

>>9142590
love this

>>9142471
I love all your dark choices

>>9142286
are you an actual IRL princess

I can't give good ratings of other people's choices because I just have different taste than a lot of you but mine is >>9144238 and I wonder what people will think about it

>>9142286
Love ya for picking top middle

>>9137404
>>9136677
>>9136843
>>9136970
Also digging these

>>9141762
>>9138233
>>9137238
>>9137210
Shout out to fellow Elizabeth lovers

All around 8-9/9

>>9144238
9/9 for the Barbie collaboration!

>>9144171
Something about this is very Heidi-esque to me, and I have no idea why. Great taste in berry prints!

>>9142286
Perfect taste

>>9144244
Some interesting choices there and a wide range of styles - particularly unsure about top left. 7/9

>>9144238
8/9 love it. I'm one of those with cohesive tastes for a 9x9, my wardrobe has several distinct themes so for this I just chose a couple.

>>9144171
Not my thing, but 7/9 nice taste.

>>9142875
5/9 for awkward cuts and some dresses I just find plain fugly/not to my taste. More power to you if you can pull some of these off.

>>9142749
7/9 classic is love

>>9142669
7/9 some of the choices are dubious but CATS

>>9142590
So not my thing, sorry. 6/9

>>9142471
Really like this overall, but really hate dolly cross/whatever that top middle is called. 7/9

>>9142331
Bitch please where are your IW music prints? Can't have a wardrobe like this without them. 7/9

My shit taste, but I did mine only with what is in my wardrobe because it made it more challenging.

>>9137286
Two of these are in my wardrobe in two different colors. 6/9

>>9139103
bless this cohesiveness.

>>9142286
5/9

>>9142590
9/9

>>9147512
Dropped my pic in an internet outage. Poor timing.

>>9142031
7/9 some solid picks, most of these are dresses I was into at some point

It was hard to pick just 9 dresses. Partly because I've seen lolita change so much over the years and I wanted my selection to reflect what typifies lolita for me, dresses I like as art in their own right that I might not wear, dresses I do wear and showing multiple styles.

I got into lolita through western/victorian/romantic goth, but have always loved dresses that walk the line between gothic and sweet, before the whole Tumblr creepycute thing. Yes, I do want Bittersweet to be a legit substyle but it's more because I loved pastel fashion etc as a 90s kid but also never left my emo phase. I'm short and young-looking, so hard-edged straight up goth looks stupid on me. I get the feeling gothic and sweet was less polarised back in the day as a kuro or shiro coord could lean either way depending on details and styling. Current gothic reminds me more of EGA.

I've always been kind of particular about classic even though I barely wear it in reality, but I always adored MM solids, perhaps with a contrasting shade.

The pintucks, ruffles, plenty of lace trim, bows (particularly waist/chest bows) and emphasis on solids with contrasting lace (often ladder lace) in earlier lolita kind of exemplifies the look for me. It is *absolutely,unmistakably, distinctly lolita*, not just any bell shaped sun dress that is expensive, happens to have a print slapped on it and a vaguely historical theme.

Some of my wardrobe is like that now, but I just look at those dresses as just nice dresses even if I can't fathom how they're supposed to be the same fashion as your typical black and white oldschool fare. You can tell I feel alienated these days. It's cool and everything but not what I remember. Fabrics, cuts and styles are drastically different. The world revolves around prints. Trim is disappearing! I'm not totally blinded by nostalgia though. Lolita was pretty questionable looking in the very early days. I think the 2005-2009 styles are a compromise between old and new.

>>9147923
Sorry I can't help but add I've noticed sweet has gone the furthest from historical influences. It goes from being something arguably victorian or edwardian inspired like the centre dress to something where it just being as cute as possible is the priority. Synthetic fabrics, plastic, lots of makeup, glitter and non-lolita footwear aplenty because of decora influences etc. Well, gothic uses non lolia shoes but it's more about them looking generally good quality (read; expensive) and mature than tying in with a strong theme,lolita feel or otherwise looking historical.

>>9147514
Love this but not into pastel sweet, 7/9
Also what is that dress in the middle of the bottom row?

>>9147939
Atelier Pierrot Rose de Plume

>>9147923
I agree with you about bittersweet, anon. I'd like to see a good combination of sweet/gothic. There's a lot of "cute" gothic-themed stuff out there and I feel like there'd be a lot of potential for a cute/gothic mash-up but bittersweet futzed it up since it seemed to pretty much just be "sweet print dresses with dark colorways!!!!!!"

>>9147927
I'm a bit confused since sweet uses most shoes made for lolita of all three styles. You can get away with non-lolita shoes in classic and gothic (oxfird, mary janes, stripper heels) but less likely in sweet. I don't really know what you think sweet lolitas aim should be instead of being sweet. Not all gothic or classic dresses are more inspired from the historical costumes either and RD made a pretty comparison between some sweet dresses and Edwardian and Victorian cuts and motifs which you should see.

I've been trying to be more cohesive with my wardrobe choices.
The ones I don't own on this are Elizabeth Bride of Death, Iron Gate, Katrina & Funeral Procession of Rose.

>>9152299
6/9 because it's mostly not my thing, but holy shit your top row is awesome

>>9147923
5/9, really not my thing at all. I find all the prints you've chosen really fugly.

I tend to like plainer stuff without prints, or simpler prints if there is one. (I like dresses with stained glass patterns a lot too but I couldn't find an example of one I really liked.)

>>9153090
oh Toy Drops, I love that OP so much but there no way that it looks flattering on anyone.

>>9153176
I do agree it looks a bit weird on people. AP dresses have this weird way of looking much shorter than they are when worn in the product image, and I kinda feel Toy Drops especially would look nicer as a slightly shorter dress.

Mine! It was so hard to choose out of my 30 dresses wishlist, since I like a lot of different styles and I don't play favourites.

Shout out to >>9138245 for sharing my unending love for military lolita and to >>9138557 for all the quirky forest prints.

>>9137519
name of 1st print on 3rd row???

bump

>>9153500
Your taste is not my taste but it is still good taste. 7/9

>>9153090
Really love your bottom row. Really meh about the rest. 6/9

On mobile so ratings are hard.

>>9136523
seconded

>>9137210
>muh dick

I'm new here. Where do y'all find these pictures of dresses?

>>9137115
>Tfw you can't have shadow garden in cream

>>9159131
Usually Lolibrary. While you're at it, read this:
http://thelolitaguidebook.tumblr.com/

>>9148341
who is RD? I want to see this.

Relatively new to lolita, still trying to figure out my tastes.

>>9160170
this is nice, a good mix but still cohesive
7.5/9 for me, good luck getting some pieces!

I'm just rating the ones I really like

>>9137190
9/9 gorgeous

>>9137210
9/9 wonderful gothic!

>>9139103
9/9 loving those purples!

>>9139128
9/9 can't go wrong with any of these

>>9139295
7/9 I love the top part of this especially.

>>9140552
8/9 Love all of these, except I'm not too fond of the nun op bottom left.

>>9140626
7/9 Minus the nun op on the top middle and the bottom left.

>>9141034
9/9 yes, gothic!

I really love polkadots I'm so sorry cgl

>>9136874
5/9 i like all the theater/gillet ones. Right middle is the only true miss for me
>>9136876
3/9 ruffles master race
>>9136914
5/9 i love MM so much but i don't fit 99% of their pieces, makes me so sad

Btw I'm just rating by how many of the dresses in the collage i really like, not saying the rest are shit or anything.