[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL


View post   

File: 249 KB, 740x490, free_cosplay_by_susanart19-d6ntg82.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8280398 No.8280398 [Reply] [Original]

What do you think about non-muscular guys cosplaying muscular/ottermode characters? Should being buff be as important as good wigs/costumes/props/makeup? And do you think cosplaying shirtless characters is too attention seeking?

Beyond that general topic, I really want to cosplay Souske from Free! because I like the character and enjoyed the second season immensely, but am worried about not matching the build well enough and appearing attention whore-y because I've never done a shirtless cosplay. However, from what I've seen from a cursory Google search, I'd be better than most any I've seen. Would it be bad for me to try?

>> No.8280406

>>8280398
The fuck is wrong with MC's face?

>> No.8280409

>>8280406
The fuck is wrong with all their faces*

>> No.8280413

>>8280406
There's a lot of things wrong with OP's image. Mostly the shooped abs, Jesus.

>> No.8280433

>>8280413
I'm aware of the hilarious faces lol, this was just the first image on Google where the 5 mains were shown, and the one where they all had the "best" bodies.

>> No.8280441
File: 5 KB, 124x144, killme.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8280441

>>8280406
>>8280413

>> No.8280453
File: 52 KB, 1024x684, free__makoto_by_lilaeroplane-d6x7hht.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8280453

>>8280413
The weirdly shooped pec lines look like surgical scars...

>>8280398
As long as you aren't too skinny/fat/otherwise gross to look at you're fine OP. Most Free! cosplayers are girls anyways and fuck what people think about attention-seekers, do it if you want to. Unless you're actively seeking for attention, in which case you better be damn good. Pic related body-wise at least

>captcha
>farta

>> No.8280455

>>8280453
Oops I probably should've picked a better picture

>> No.8280493

>>8280453
Alright, fair enough. I'm in decent shape, and I plan on cutting 3-4% bf before I do Souske. I'm just super autistic and want it to be accurate as possible more than anything. Also was just curious about the general consensus on male bodies not being accurate since I see female bodies not being accurate discussed fairly often. I personally think an accurate body, especially for a character known for being muscular/one in revealing clothing is just as important as the costume itself.

>> No.8280570 [DELETED] 

>>8280398
>Only Haru has bulge
Did they shoop out their penises? I'm confused.

>>8280493
That's way too low for a Free! cosplay.

>> No.8280572 [DELETED] 

>>8280398 (OP)
>Only Haru has bulge
Did they shoop out their penises? I'm confused.

>>8280493
That's way too low for a Free! cosplay (and really anything other than competing). You're probably better off going for 6-7%.

>> No.8280574

>>8280398
>Only Haru has bulge
Did they shoop out their penises? I'm confused.

>>8280493
That's way too low for a Free! cosplay (and really anything other than competing). You're probably better off going for 6-7%.

>> No.8280581

>>8280574
>cutting 3-4%
I'm pretty sure he means he's going down by that much and not actually going that low...
The others could be girls with shooped chests or tucking?

>> No.8280586

>>8280581
Don't mind me, I'm just being illiterate.

They might be girls. I can't stop looking at OP's picture. There's just so much wrong.

>> No.8280593

>>8280398
The less clothing a cosplay has, the more the smaller details matter, this goes especially for sexy cosplay.

No harm in trying the cosplay though as long as you're not superfat or something.

>> No.8280599

>>8280574
Meant cutting down 3-4% to 11% or so lol. 3-4% bf would only be possible with cutting agents and show prep.

>> No.8280631

>>8280586
They're all guys, just shooped to hell and back.

>> No.8280636
File: 105 KB, 636x960, 1090964_709741619040960_279632300_o.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8280636

>>8280631
dropped pic

>> No.8280718
File: 35 KB, 480x480, so-happy.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8280718

>>8280631
I laughed so hard my parents though I was the girl from the exorcist movie.

>> No.8281155

>>8280636
FUCK MAKOTO'S FACE

What were they thinking?

>> No.8281329

>>8281155
DO NOT FUCK MAKOTO'S FACE
And, really, I'm more concerned about Haru's pose...

>> No.8281339

I mean, at least Rei looks good

>> No.8281345

>>8281329
It's the There'sNoSpaceForHimToSitButIfHeStoodHeWouldn'tFitEitherSoLetsJustHaveHimLookLikeHe'sTryingToTakeAShitWhileHidingTheFlabAndYesThatAngleIsGood pose

>>8281339
Nagisa's pretty cute too

>> No.8281349
File: 565 KB, 778x582, reika-phelps yaoicon.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8281349

Please come back once you are Phelps-tier.

>> No.8281381

>>8281345
His face is 2D

>>8281349
I remember him from Yaoi-con, he doesn't have the face for this. Maybe better makeup would help.

>> No.8281726

I think being in shape is important if you are cosplaying a character that shows a lot of skin. It would be weird to see say, a noodle man cosplaying Ace.

Also girls get shit on enough for not being completely perfect and in shape so I'm glad that guys have to put forth effort too.

>> No.8282122

>>8280441
>don't laugh
>send help

>> No.8282142

>>8281349
Well, if that's all it takes then I'll be more than good after a cut.

>> No.8282197

>>8282142
Post pics. And let me touch your biceps.

>> No.8282291

>>8282197
I posted a pic In the cosplay suggestion thread, but in mobile so can't link. Sh-should I post another?

>> No.8282398

Needs more muscular girls....

>> No.8282433

Yes, being the bodytype of the person is important.

>> No.8282445

>>8282291
I tried stalking the suggestion thread but I have no idea which one you are. Y-yes pls. Or wait until you can link.

>> No.8282598
File: 461 KB, 1900x2688, IMG_20150426.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282598

>>8282445
Like I said, plan on cutting down 4% bf, or about 10lbs, before the con, which is in early September, so I have plenty of time.

>> No.8282603

>>8282598
Honestly, you body isn't suited for Free! cosplay. :(

I would go for a larger character.

>> No.8282635

>>8282598
I'm going to agree with this anon too >>8282603
You are however buff enough to cosplay some good looking 2D hunks. Set your sights higher than Free, we believe in you!

>> No.8282653

>>8282598
You're more stocky. You'd make a good Graves or possible Berserk.

>> No.8282659

>>8282603
Even if I cut? I'm going to do Gouda from Ore Monogatati at some point because I'm just over 6'5, but I kinda wanted to do a Free guy because I like the characters quite a bit. though I'm 4 inches taller and will still weigh 60lbs more even after the cut, Free characters are like JoJo one's; they look significantly heavier than they are actually listed as. >>8282635
Thanks, I want to do other stuff too, but right now I'm pretty inexperienced so wanted to do something "easy" to get a hang of cosplaying. All my previous ones have been made by friends.

>> No.8282660
File: 325 KB, 1200x869, Berserk-Page.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282660

>>8282598
Agreeing with the others, rather then Free! cosplay you should try a more bara character. God knows we need more baras in this world. Pic related.

>> No.8282669

>>8282660
I'd love to do Guts some day, but right now I have no way to make props or armour, and even of I did, I'd want to start on something far simpler to get practice. Something that complex is definitely my end goal though.

>> No.8282672
File: 302 KB, 1503x1100, berserk_v04_186.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282672

>>8282653
You read my mind anon...

>>8282659
>>8282660
Y-younger Guts?

>> No.8282680

>>8282672
Meant to reply to >>8282669

>> No.8282685

>>8282659
You have too much muscle and your bone structure looks wide. Even if you signed a contract with a gains goblin, it probably wouldn't be enough.

>Mfw no cute skinny twink genetics

>> No.8282691

>>8282685
p.s. what I meant by this is don't attempt to sacrifice your gains.

>> No.8282694
File: 164 KB, 322x342, IMG_20150220_191846.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282694

>>8282685
>I'll never be a qt trap

>> No.8282701

>>8282691
I won't lol, need them for sports. I'll think of some other "easy" big guys I guess.

>> No.8282709
File: 398 KB, 1831x2000, TDKR_Bane.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282709

>>8282701

>> No.8282729
File: 750 KB, 495x1641, SigmaOfficialArt.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282729

>>8282701
>big guys
>easy cosplay
>those aesthetics

You play any vidya, OP?

>> No.8282746
File: 203 KB, 1484x1264, IMAG0578_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8282746

>>8282729
I do indeed, this was sitting right by my bed. That might be fun actually.

>> No.8283052
File: 34 KB, 426x341, 1424489356237.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8283052

>>8282598
sweet jesus

>> No.8283083
File: 27 KB, 105x100, k gasp.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8283083

>>8282746
Nice! Selfpost here in the progress thread or something if you go through with it. There's a criminal lack of ZE cosplay and I think you'd be a great fit.

>> No.8283109

>>8282672
>fucking Griffith man

>> No.8283199

>>8280398

To me a cosplay has to do justice to the original character, even if it means being fit/fat/whatever the character requires.

People surely have different standards and a lot of them do their cosplays just for fun but to me there's nothing less appealing than a skinny boy trying to portrait a buff and big muscular character.

>> No.8283200

>>8282660

Berserker/ Time-skip Guts in the beginning of the anime is my dream cosplay but I think my hands are not big enough to cosplay him yet.

>> No.8283671

>>8280398
I think being the right height and build is more important the larger/buffer a character becomes. If it's someone in a lot of clothing or not known for being big, crafting of the outfit becomes far more important (within reason, if you're cosplaying a slim character and are extremely fat, it just won't look good).

Girls tend to get more shit for this simply because characters that show more skin are usually female, and male characters that do typically have bodies that take a lot of training to emulate. If more guys were willing to cosplay shirtless/scantily clad males while not being physically ready, I'd think you'd see just as much bashing of them, especially on /cgl/.

I think you'd be able to do lots of buffer characters OP, and if you did cut 4% to like 8% bf, you'd be pretty popular, since to my knowledge there aren't any male cosplayers that are both buff and 6'4+

>> No.8283696

>>8280636

They're trying to make Mako's eyes look like the anime, where they're downturned. Just no.

>>8281349

Dem back muscles. But I'm seconding >>8281381. Love the muscles, not the face. However, Reika fawning over Phelps was THE best part of that con.

>>8282598

You could probably pull off Sousuke, since he's the beefiest. But that con could definitely benefit from a more bara physique. Hell, more muscles in general. Some of those bishies were not toned at all and I saw way too many man boobies.

>> No.8283874

Are there any cosplay options for an ottermode-ish male other than free?
I want to avoid the batshit-crazy fujoshis.

>> No.8284663

>>8283874
There's really a ton of options, lots of JRPG characters are Otter. As far as anime goes, lots of shonen characters are Otter as well.

>> No.8286129
File: 104 KB, 1200x900, FB_IMG_1430238996985.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8286129

>>8283696
Yeah, the biggest cosplayer I know of is Drefan, but he's "only" 5'10, so a bigger dude that's also very tall would fill a hugely empty niche.

>> No.8286164

>>8282598

You could pull off most Jojo characters.

>> No.8286191

>>8282598

lol i'm bigger than you and i have less bf

>> No.8286203

>>8286129
Those thighs... oh good lord

>> No.8286231
File: 31 KB, 632x196, probirdrights.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8286231

>>8286191

>> No.8286322

>>8286191
Very nice, Height/weight? Pics?

>> No.8286334

>>8286191
I dont know about you but i think the rest of the world knows that Big =/= fat

>> No.8287260

>>8282598
Lifts?

>> No.8288674
File: 18 KB, 400x321, pepesad.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8288674

>>8286129
>tfw 6'1 220lbs
>mfw 14% bf

>> No.8291919

>>8287260
Best gym lifts are like 485x2/352x1/638x2

>> No.8293162

>>8280593
This.
I'd come across so many other Free cosplayers who'd do things like wear tennis shoes, or a really off-color wig, if a wig at all.
Also, buying jammers from Tyr or leggings from emFraa with stripes that just happen to match the colors of their characters is surprisingly common.
Goggles around the neck is a nice touch, especially if you get one with lenses that match their color, too.

>>8281349
That really was my favorite part of the con.
But so far 2015's the year of terrible work schedules and stalled gains.

>>8281381
I know that my makeup game is next to zero, besides some concealer or powder.
Really do need to learn more if I ever hope to do more serious costumes, though.

>>8282598
As other anons said, you're more built than the lean ottermodes in Free.
If you're into JoJo's, your height / build would be great for a stand like Star Platinum.
+1 rep if you find a Jotaro to cosplay with.

>> No.8293186
File: 338 KB, 450x413, o0oBlush.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8293186

>>8293162
P-Phelps, you visited us again!

[spoiler]please be my waifu[/therearenospoilersoncgl]

>> No.8293203

>>8282598
I think you're too bulky for any Free! characters who are all ottermode but you could pull off most of the characters in Jojo, Kenshiro from Fist of the North Star or Gamagori from Kill la Kill very well. Perhaps Armstrong from FMA but he's pretty pale.

>> No.8294523

>>8293162
Yeah, I plan on cosplaying a Pillar Man someday, or someone from Part III. But I'm too shit at cosplay currently and have no where to work now, so I have to postpone those plans. >>8293203
>tfw not white enough

/int/ was right.

>> No.8295326

I think people need to realize that calling people out on cosplaying widely outside of their bodytype isn't fat-shaming or shinny-shaming or whatever, just reaction to a bad cosplay.

I guess the quality of a cosplay hinges on how close you resemble the character you're trying to mimic, and that your appearance and build are part of this.

>> No.8295386

>>8280574
The others didn't stuff their pants

>> No.8295439

>>8280398
Rin looks like a thai lady boy.

Also if the only thing you goin wear is pants for a costume you think you could at least make them right?
The only one with proper swimmers is haru and his wig and face look retarded.

>> No.8295498

>>8282598
Dragonball z.
I don't know why you'd want to do free, you don't look like the type to like such a gay anime..
Don't get me wrong i like free too, just seems like it's to get girls.

When white people do free cosplays it often looks shit i can't think of one good free cosplayer that isn't japanese or chinese to be honest... I seen acouple good rei's that were white girls...

>> No.8295575
File: 383 KB, 792x1080, 3714092-3992840596-Endle.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295575

>>8282598
Don't be a faggot you fucking piece of shit and cosplay Destruction of the Endlesss or Ares from Marvel, you slut. I love you, please cum inside me.

>> No.8295686

; ~ ;
I'd love to do a cosplay that shows off my gains but I feel thats way too tryhard
Instead I'm going as a Haikyuu member

>> No.8295707

>>8295686
Which haikyuu? You can still show off your thighs if you do it right.

>> No.8295744

>>8295707
Asahi Azumane
No wig required

>> No.8295790

>>8295498
I actually enjoyed the second season a lot. First season was okay, but I liked the character development quite a bit in Endless Summer. I also related to Souske because I had to quit sports in college due to an injury. If I wanted to cosplay to get girls I'd probably do a generic shonen or a DC/Marvel character.

>> No.8295920

>>8295790
I like the second season much better, because the first season was fun, but it had the shittiest melodramatic drama.
"I wanna beat you"
"ok"
*beats him*
"no now for REEL"
*beats him again*
*starts crying because he didn't get into the relay*
for fucks sake.

>> No.8295939
File: 438 KB, 960x1280, tumblr_n66sfu8hwX1s25teco2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295939

I love these fuckers. There's another shot I thought I had of them as Simon and Kamina doing the same pose at AX.

>> No.8295943
File: 99 KB, 427x640, 14752113998_80e8c70a21_z.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295943

God bless Kill La Kill. There was a NB Gama last Fanime I'm searching for a pic of that had a perfect Gama shape.

>> No.8295949
File: 160 KB, 1024x765, rider___afa_2012_by_drefano-d5l1s6i.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295949

I want to see more ripped Iskanders. It's nice that bigger guys have him as an option but he's still supposed to be ripped to bara shreds.

>> No.8295982
File: 65 KB, 960x622, 1896735_575091365920562_680473541_n.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295982

>> No.8295996
File: 179 KB, 538x601, 1430424978504.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8295996

>>8295982
He's so bara

>> No.8299420

>>8293186
I like to drop by and skim threads every few weeks. Usually don't post, though.
[spoiler]As long as you're okay with the fridge being stuffed with yogurt, eggs, and milk.[/cglneedsspoilers]

>>8295790
It's nice to see other guys cosplay Free for reasons other than to pick up chicks or show off.
Personally, I was a swimmer, and my personality matched closest to Makoto, so went with him.
2013-2015's had a ton of sports anime recently to chose from.

>> No.8299494

>>8280398
I think you're taking this way too seriously

>> No.8301672

>>8299494
> too seriously
Do you know where you are.

>> No.8301748

Getting fit, toned and sculpted takes a lot of time and work like any other part of a costume. However I'd prefer to see a more complicated outfit than a wig and bathing suit. But if you're costume is simple and mostly there to show off your body don't fuck those few pieces up.

>uncut unstyled wig
>bathing suit with lines badly painted on
>Jersey with duct tape details

>> No.8303463

>>8295949
ripskander

>> No.8303749
File: 378 KB, 540x402, doubashi.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8303749

>>8282598
>>8282659
I have a suggestion if you want an easy big bara cosplay while cosplaying from a popular sports series.

http://yowamushipedal.wikia.com/wiki/Doubashi_Masakiyo

This character hasn't been introduced in the anime yet but die hard fans of the series should recognize you. Sports animes are pretty easy to cosplay because they're usually team uniforms and I'd suggest finding a Hakone biking uniform online that can tailor one to your size.

>> No.8304093

>>8303749
I don't want to do anything from media I'm not a fan of, and haven't gotten into Pedal. Is it good?

>> No.8305208

>>8304093

Not that person but I personally think it's great, and the author being a big cycling enthusiast is a big bonus.

I'm working on a 3rd year Teshima cosplay and would love to see more of the new characters instead of the same old characters with bad make up.

>> No.8305661

>>8304093
I'd highly recommend it. This is just my opinion and a pretty strong one but I'd say its one of the best sports anime to come out recently.

>> No.8308269
File: 70 KB, 480x720, 10317795_10154296635620347_2695686675461250045_o[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8308269

>>8295943
There ya go. Bryan's a beast!

>> No.8312513

>>8308269
ew

>> No.8312560

>>8281726
no dif from fat skinny nerds goin to comic con since the 80s

>> No.8312588

>>8280398
same thing when landwhales cosplay as hot characters

>> No.8317870

>>8280398
sexy

>> No.8317908

>>8305661
>>8305208
I keep hearing about yowapeda but am hesitant to start. I loved tenipuri back in its heyday and I went into Free thinking it'd be a sports anime just like that. I watched the first season of free hoping for epic swim meets but instead it was just boys crying and being incredibly gay, and i'm saying this as a rotten fujoshit.

>> No.8317995
File: 36 KB, 256x265, (wake me up) wake me up inside.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8317995

>>8280636

>> No.8318052

>>8317908
Free is a sports anime as much as K-On was a musical anime. Its literally KyoAni moe drama with a side theme shoved in. I thought everyone was aware of this? I wouldn't consider it a serious sports anime like Diamond no Ace, Haikyuu or Yowamushi Pedal.

>> No.8319854

>>8317908
There's three types of sports anime / mange:
1 - Realistic. IE: Slam Dunk.
2 - Unrealistically Exaggerated. IE: Kuroko no Basket.
3 - Drama with sports on the side. IE: Free.

>> No.8321949

5' 6"
130lbs
8% Bodyfat

I'm never gonna cosplay anyone muscular...I don't really like muscles.

>> No.8321987

>>8286129
What glorious thighs~