/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL

no, but i'm inspired now and going to make some.

wow, the girl on the right is super pretty, even if the picture is likely photoshopped.

jesus, if that had any more shoop, it would be a figment of digital artwork.

>>6471113
Dem ears though!

Also her nose IRL is the size of Russia.

Superior Zelda


>even if she is a nigger

Mami Tomoe

>>6471126
would be a good image for proudtobeasian

Vriska Serket

Hit up ProudAsian.

Miku Hatsune

>>6471136
The 'good' one here is super mediocre.

>ITT: fat vs fit cosplay

>>6471136
i can't tell which one is supposed to be "good"

>>6471136
i nose

>>6471144
i mostly liked what she did with the extra detail on the skirt and the clean look of it,sorry

>>6471132
the left looks more like a closet cosplay, so I wouldn't be so serious with the comparison. Maybe it was taken out of context? The right is adorable tho.

>>6471145
lmao i was exaggerating because it's really mediocre for a "good" comparison. the detailing is definitely a nice touch, but she's not wearing an ounce of makeup, and her bangs are the wrong style which is my #1 pet peeve with miku cosplayers because WOW IT'S NOT THAT HARD....

>>6471126
That one on the left is actually the worst cosplay I've seen in the last 3 or so months, period. o_o

Latula Pyrope

>>6471175
please stop using such subpar emotes and upgrade to much more kawaii ones, such as
(○゜ε＾○)

no but seriously stop

>>6471187
girl on the left isn't too bad

>>6471187

Vendetta fag or Asian guy trying to convince everyone westerners can't cosplay? I can't tell.

>>6471187
I always lol every time PL attempts to be feminine.

>>6471189
Good lord, what happened to that poor wig?

>>6471203
no clue.
i'm not even sure how a wig could get so greasy and janky looking.

>>6471193
>>6471195
That cosplay is shit.

>Stay butthurt PL fans.

>>6471187
what? Both are fine, left one lacks make up and photoshop unlike the right one. I don't really see a 'good vs bad' here.

>>6471210

Who the hell is PL? I didn't even know the cosplayer til now.

>>6471187
>'bad' Yuna cosplay
>not using PT as example

>>6471261
My guess is you're new?

She's a 30-year-old sinfully ugly woman who makes decent costumes at best, has been hired by Nintendo to model as their Link for events, and is generally used as an object for trolling on this board.

Not to mention she has thousands of retarded fangirls who think she is God's gift to cosplaying, and will whine and scream any time somebody criticizes anything she does.

>>6471273
At least PL looks like a woman.

>>6471136
>magnet vs venomania outfits
>magnet outfit is good
no

>>6471274

Not new, but terrible memory. I don't care for or remember people. I'm just here for pretty pictures.

In any case, my opinion still stands it's not terrible.

>>6471274
different anon never heard of her and i've been lurking for a year

>>6471312
>a year
>not new

>>6471321
lawl i know rite ur not a kool person unless uve been a Seagull for at least 10+ years XD

(Seagull btw is our code word. Outsiders wouldnt understand.)

US SEAGULLS MAN. PT AMIRITE? XD XD

>>6471312

>>6471323
>cries and goes to bed

>>6471324
I didn't say there was anything wrong with being new. But denying being a newfag when you've only been here a year makes you look more retarded than you realize.

>>6471187
neither are bad?

>>6471331
Sure smells like samefag in here.

If you're that desperate to defend her try to make your samefagging less obvious.

>>6471328
I...didn't deny it? Just said I haven't ever heard of her in around year, I usually stick to the lolita/PT/cosplay threads, so maybe I just missed it

>>6471331
I always love when pikminlink gets posted and fangirls try to leap on grenades for her.

>ITS NOT THAT BAD! UR JUST JELLY! I SEE NO PROBLEM NOTHING TO SEE HERE FOLKS MOVE ALONG.

>>6471336
It's the same person defending her over and over, you can tell by the way they type. Must be >>6471312.

>>6471343
The left doesn't seem that bad. Sure, she's a big girl, but her wig isn't tangled and everything seems to be in order.

>>6471359
Wig could do with a little work, but I agree, it's by no means "bad." As an earlier anon stated, this is really turning into a fat vs. fit thread.

>>6471385
did someone say /fit/?

>>6471359
>>6471385
Her weight isn't the reason I posted it, the bangs on the wig just look so awkward to me as to ruin for me completely.

Didn't mean to make it a fit vs. fat thing, sorry!

>>6471359
the bangs are styled retardedly though

>>6471425
i'm not sure which i'm laughing more at, the epic fail of a cosplay or the file name. i'm so sorry anon.

>>6471425
>posting people you know
You're cold hearted and I like it.

>>6471425
a-all of that work.
AND SHE COULDN'T JUST BIND HER FUCKING CHEST?
I was enjoying and then BOOBS.

>>6471455
My monthly validation via 4chan has been achieved. Thank you, anon.

sage for no contribution

>>6471480
Why are all the "good" Mikus so average?

>>6471483
Because most of the (readily available) god-tier ones are Asian, and we seem to be trying to steer away from asianmasterrace stuff.

>>6471098
>>6471126
>>6471136
>>6471480
>the bad ones
OP, please stop....

>>6471487
>>6471483
Challenge accepted. The hunt for an amazing non-Asian Miku is on.

Ignoring the shit Photoshopping on the "good" one, this really was the best I could find. I just have a folder of monstrosities, and doing my best to Google for the good ones, so choices are limited.

>>6471483
now shuddup

>>6471493
hide the thread faget

>>6471508
Oh come the fuck on, that's no where near "bad" and you know it. yes i mad

>>6471508
I don't think the bad one here is terrible. It's an unfortunate pose and expression, but she's average, not horrendous.

>>6471512
Protip: The bad is vendetta.

The only thing I personally dislike is the fabric choice for the gloves.
But it might just be the lighting since the right doesn't look as bad as the left.

>>6471519
And if anyone else didn't notice, one of the black parts of the flower thingy's fallen down, which is unfortunate.

>>6471343
what game/show/manga is this from??

>>6471538
el psy kongroo

>>6471538
Steins;Gate

>>6471508
That's what constitutes bad now huh? Everything else in this thread must be god awful abominations then.

>>6471343
well this is awkward

>>6471619
Eyeshadow abs have always pissed me off.

>>6471619
another of his cosplays

>>6471500
>beard on left
ew y gross ew
If you have the money to buy/make a fucking cosplay then take the time and effort to look decent, shit.
THE "BRING SANDALS" RULE WILL NEVER APPLY TO YOU.

>>6471698
What's his name? I wanna see more of his stuff.

>>6471619
>dat filename

>>6471713
Devin, He used to be Devin J. Kaiba Sixx on facebook but now it's just devin jackson

>>6471669

Oh look, It's Katie.

>>6471679
It's it's not strange to put makeup on your face for cosplay, why is it considered strange to put it on your body? It's about looking like the character, and if something helps, why not?

>>6471727
Because make up is MADE for your face.

>>6471731
I should stop replying, because your level of stupid is starting to hurt my brain.

>>6471724
fb.com/devinj.kaibasixx

This him?

>>6471733
>eyeshadow
>not made for face
lel

>>6471727
Because drawing messy lines of black eyeshadow on your pasty skinnyfat stomach looks like absolute shit.

>>6471737
>makeup
>restricted to face
lel

>>6471738
I'm speaking generally, not this one in particular. I'm sure everyone's seen at least one good example where they did it properly.

>>6471734
>fb.com/devinj.kaibasixx
Yep that's him alright. I guess he has two facebooks now

>>6471743
I don't know, doesn't really look like the guy.

>>6471508
>>6471517
>>6471512
>>6471519

Personally, I don't actually like Miyuko's Inori very much, because the outfit just seems very rubber-y to me. I have really high standards for Inori cosplayers though.
The things that stood out to me on the left was;
-Flower is peeling
-Fabric is awkward
-The felt on the bottom looks really cheap.

Pic related, my favorite Inori.

>>6471740
That's why it's called eyeshadow. Because it's for your eyes, not your skin creases.

>>6471123

I watch her DA, She has to be my favorite Zelda cosplayer ever. I love the one in OPs pic too though :)

>>6471698
Does anyone know the name of the good Kaiba!? I am a huge Kaiba fangirl and I cant find enough good kaibas! If someone can find his name or a page of his (or more than likely hers) i will love you forever! .... i just hope this isn't like the only decent pic they have of this cosplay

>>6471618
'bad' is a relative term
one is better than the other
>learning English on /cgl/

>>6471698
Jesus fucking god

>>6471508
Still feel bad for her she's got such tiny boobs, nice but tiny.

>>6471914

MY EYES! I wanted a good Kaiba not this!

>>6471336
Hmm, I won't deny I really like PL's Link cosplay but I'm terrible at recognizing people so I did not see it was her at the Yuna comparison pic.
I still thought it was a little too much putting her in that pic on the same wagon as >>6471189, >>6471136, >>6471132 etc. She's not THAT bad. It's not as good as the one on the right, the blue belt-like thingies are strange and cut poorly but it's still a decent cosplay.

>>6471760
You are oficially potato.

>>6471927
If she were fat there would be ground to feel bad
but she isn't even chunky
her tits fit her size and body shape well imo

>>6471189
That is one of the most disgusting looking wigs I've ever seen but the actual outfit looks nicer than most I've seen, what a shame.

>>6472451
It seriously looks like a Halloween store quality wig.

Where the hell is OP's picture from the left from? I swear I know her.

>>6471760
When you're painting skin, one tone looks too fake, not everyone can afford to buy a million different colours, eyeshadow palettes are a great alternative for cosplayers, fuck you.

>>6471508

Rufflebutt!

>>6471738
>>6471679
You do realize the one on the left is a girl....

Generally speaking:

fat people and cosplay doesn't go in pair.

>>6472594
Obviously she's a girl (which drops the cosplay from a 7/10 to a 3/10), I wasn't suggesting that she was male. This is why girls that aren't fit should stick to cosplaying female characters, or at least ones that don't have their abs exposed.

>>6472594
Where in those two posts did it say she was a guy?

>>6472487
>fuck you
No need to get upset.

This thread is shit. Out of all the comparisons, only two are actually shit vs. good. The rest is either vendetta fag or fat people lol.

>>6472626
Just because they're fat doesn't mean their cosplay can't be shit.

>>6472663

You should take basic English literature again, because I never implied that.

>>6472680
>only two are actually shit vs. good
>rest is fat people
>implying some of the fat people's cosplays weren't shit

>>6472672

Again, your reading comprehension. Refer back to >>6472626 then come back to me and I'll give you another test, okay darling?

>>6472686
But there are plenty here that are shit.

>>6472682

Again, your reading comprehension. Refer back to >>6472626 then come back to me and I'll give you another test, okay darling?

>>6472690

I was expecting eye bleeding. I was disappointed, what can I say.

>>6471972
It's mostly her hideous face that makes it so bad (she's from Europe and she looks like Alabama trailer trash here), and that she decided not to wear makeup AND use her famous wooden stare that she uses for all her lame photoshoots.

>>6471508
Come on. The one on the left is pretty good and not shooped to high hell with plastic surgery. Those are two different levels you can't compete with.

Both in the same picture!

>>6472760
The "good" one isn't that great either. Certainly an improvement from the one on the right, but I wouldn't call it amazing.

>>6472784
Can things be good without being amazing?

Damn /cgl/, you were not like this before...

>>6471201
this. I do this too every single time, especially looking at her sailor moon and aurora.

>>6471337
she's not an active lolcow. even adella is more ctive as one than her.

I still laugh about PL's husbando though.

>>6472784
Pretty sure that's an old photo too. You have to take that into account. Satin wasn't reviled as it is today back in the day.

>>6471972
I have a suspicion that this may be Sana-chan's borrowed cosplay.

>>6472791
Still, nearly every time she is mentioned or posted the entire thread derails into a war between her haters and fangirls.

This mostly occurs because someone will casually point out that they don't like her costume, or that they think it's bad, and then her fans will fly in and defend her like she is Jesus or something.

The funny thing about it is that this does not happen with other cosplayers. I remember somebody said they disliked Volpin's Big Daddy and maybe got one or two replies, but when PL's worst costume is picked on then suddenly that person gets ambushed.

>>6472795
Yeah true. I was thinking about that after I posted that reply.

>>6471337
http://dramu-dramu.livejournal.com/

No moar PT threads allowed in /cgl/ sooo we've taken our dramu shit somewhere else.

http://dramu-dramu.livejournal.com/

>>6471126
> implying fat nose Asian is good cosplay

that dress isnt even that great either

You guys do realize that the Yuna Costume doesn't even belong to PL. she didn't even make it. It was made by Jen. Stop giving PL credit for it. Which is also why she doesn't have it listed anywhere because it is not her costume.

>>6471123
Fuck no, way too brown.

>>6472992
The craftsmanship is God-Tier though. And she's still hot and looks hot in the costume, even if she is black.

>>6472939
Stop spamming your stupid LJ account everywhere. Nobody cares about PT.

>>6471754
doesn't matter, guilty crown is shit-tier

>>6472984
Okay so can we make fun of her other bad cosplays?

Somebody give me a superior Toon Link pls.

>>6473234
Best I could find.

>>6471698
That chick sure knows how to bind!

>>6473252
Malinda-chan has a good face for OoT Link but always cosplays other versions.

>>6471480
Left is a butterface. She has a really good body for Miku.....her face, not so much

pose and photography/shoop skillz have somewhat to do with how well the cosplay looks.

>>6473252
malinda always looks so incredibly tired. i kind of feel bad for her cause maybe she doesnt get enough sleep

>>6473271
>>6473346
She's kind of an ugly girl, no offense to her. But some of her costumes are pretty good.

I do hate how she's insisting on spiking all of her wigs like the way she did the Cloud one though.

>>6472760
I was expecting to see this classic here. Thanks for not disappointing me /cgl/.

>>6473359
>hate how she's insisting on spiking all of her wigs like the way she did the Cloud one though.
>implying that technique doesn't look fucking awesome

>>6473234
Akuriko is the best fucking Zelda godammit. Its like she walked right out of the game. I didn't like her SS Zelda as much though (her face didn't really suit it, she is more of a TP Zelda). I want her to cosplay OoT Zelda, young and adult.

>>6473423
Akuriko looks fine. PL looks like a 35-year-old man attempting to cosplay a 12-year-old.

>>6473221
>Nobody cares about PT.
Do you really believe that?

>>6473423
Akuriko is gorgeous, but her face looks like photoshopped mud in this picture.

>>6473534
I agree, but I've seen her IRL and she's just as gorgeous as her pictures, it is just bleedingly obvious which photogs photoshop her photos...

>>6473542
Yeah, I can tell there is pretty under there.. but God, they did a awful job with that photoshopping. Really bad.

>>6473252
I'm cosplaying as Shadow Link at an upcoming convention.

This is motivation

>>6471132
It isn't that hard to do a Homestuck cosplay. The left is just mentally retarded/lazy.

>>6471343
That's unfortunate...but she really tried.

>>6471461
she's a giiiiiiiirl gamer and she wants people to know it!

>>6471425
....
I'm gonna go cry now.

>>6471717
i didnt even see that

>>6473252
I love how link seems to be thinking "Ohgodwhy."

>>6473234

>>6471126
DUUUUUUUUUURIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIILLLLLSS!

>>6476754
yay!

>>6476771
>BRASIL

>>6476771
>>6476802
HUEHUEHUEHUEHUEHUEHUE.

Is buying something like this worth it since it's so heavy? It's very cheap but how much would something like this weigh?

More toon link?

>>6471197
Does it matter? Let's be butthurt about something as irrelevant as emoticons, guys.

>>6476966
>didn't bind

NEXT

>>6477005
>>6476966

Looks pretty binded to me

>>6476966
I hate how Toon Link cosplayers insist on wearing Uggs. And how they always get his tunic color so painfully wrong.

>>6477018
It kind of looks like she tried but her method looks pretty weak.

It seems like the main difference in most of these pictures is the one on the right is photoshopped and on the one on the left isn't.

>>6472992
So was the rest of Twilight Princess...

>>6477032
This. A lot of the "bad" comparisons really aren't all that bad. They might need a bit of polishing, sure, but to be quite honest, I think a lot of what makes them look mediocre is the fact that they aren't shooped, and the photo quality/lighting/poses/whathaveyou are sub-par compared to the "good" comparison.

>>6473252
uggs tho

>>6477024
>It kind of looks like she tried but her method looks pretty weak.

She could have big boobs. I have G's and I use a proper binding shirt as well as loose-fitting fabrics when I crossplay, but I still have a bit of boob lump simply because my boobs are just too big to ever be truly flat.

>>6477680
which bad comparison are you, anon?

There's a big difference between needing a bit of polishing vs. obvious lack of attention to detail.

>>6471343
I honestly don't think this is bad. she is just unfortunately too big :( if she lost weight it would be average/good

>>6471187
What everyone hates to admit about PL is that she doesn't have the face for the feminine characters.
It's akin to how people in this thread say a cosplay would be okay if the person wasn't fat.

Her cosplay would be okay if she frankly didn't look like a trap. Sorry.
>inb4 rabid PL fans give me a verbal pummeling for insulting their king of cosplay

>>6478316
or she (and everyone else) can cosplay whatever the fuck they want and have fun.

>>6478320
>cosplay is for fun only!
Okay, then why is this thread here? Or does that rule only exist for people you like?

>>6478322
cosplay being fun doesn't mean everyone's costumes are on the same level. Some costumes are terrible, but I'm sure they're enjoying themselves, so more power to them.

>>6478333
That doesn't answer the question. At all. I like how you completely circled around the fact that if cosplay is just for fun and it shouldn't matter what one looks like, then nobody should get picked on for their costumes if they're just having fun.

>>6478322
Not who you're replying to but why is it seen as a terrible thing to view cosplay as something that is strictly for fun?

If YOU want to take it seriously then obviously you're welcome to it but why shit on those who don't?


It's an honest question, so try to pull in your claws a little and answer with a level head, I really am curious as to why some women (and it's ALWAYS women) look down on anyone who refuses to take an admittedly silly hobby seriously.

ITT ugly people vs hot people

>>6474217
Well it's hard to get cuter than that--but I love Hee-Hee's little brother as Toon Link.

I just wish I could find more pictures of him.

>>6478989
I've met the one on the right! The wig is even more impressive in person.

>>6479120
Now I want to put my little brother in a Toon Link cosplay... this seems like a cute idea

>>6478989
The "bad" isn't really bad. He even has a fitting location.
It's just that the right is fucking perfect in pretty much every way.

>>6477816
>Asian
>Big boobs
lel

>>6478533
I don't have a problem with cosplay for fun.

I just think it's shitty that people pick on cosplays when they're bad even though those people are having fun too, but oh, suddenly that's "not for fun." Those are just shitty cosplays. But if it's their friends or someone they know and like? Hey, who cares if they suddenly have an objectively not good cosplay? They're just having fun, guise.

It seems people are selective when it comes to their ethics.
How's that for catty little claws, hunny?

>>6477816
This is true. There is only so much you can do when your boobs are that big. Saying that it's always possible to flatten big boobs with binding is the same thing as saying that it's ALWAYS possible to flatten fat rolls on a big girl with binding. After a certain size, you can't hide stuff like that.
The only people I've ever seen completely flatten their chests were smaller-end C-cups and below to begin with.

>>6478989
If the one on the left used a better fabric, it wouldn't look too... strange.

>>6479201
>Black person
>Anything but a big dick
lel

See I can be racist too.