/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL

Hi /cgl/, inquiry!

Shy guy for halloween, because it is simple and warm and I don't want to freeze my keester off.

Except I didn't want to do the paper plate mask. So this is what I've got so far--plaster because no one could give me much advice about fiberglass.

SO THE QUESTION:

Any ideas on how to smooth this? Elmers glue and water layer? Or wood glue? Can you sand elmers?

Also the eyes are ever so slightly different sizes (they will have mesh or nylons to make them black when it is done)...is it fine or does anyone have any good ideas on how to make them even? Layer by later plaster isn't working...its like trying to get even eyeliner wings. :/