/biz/ - Business & Finance

>>22160205
Nope just benefits me, that's enough.

>>22160205
Do job programs like the tsa provide any value?

>>22160205
yes, traders provide liquidity and therefore improve price stability.

>>22160205
who the fuck cares nigger

>>22160205
>Does trading provide any actual value to society?
Yes, it provides liquidity in the markets. Plus the traders take on a lot of risk for that which might pay off nicely, but usually does not for most of them.

theoretically yes

>>22160205
liquidity

Well, all of this is "middle-manning" in one way or another, just in increasingly abstract ways. If you try to imagine a primitive society with people trying to buy/sell shit from each other but running into problems due to amounts required, physical transport, seasonal variations, etc etc etc then you can start to imagine how {{{middle men}}} lubricated the process and allowed trade to grow, and then banking and everything became more important that the trading itself.

A book about the economic history of Europe, ideally going back to very early Egyptian times or as far as possible, and ideally written 100+ years ago so it's got some actual content, would be good for you.

It takes some real mental gymnastics to understand how today's high-finance is necessary and important, but I do believe it is:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2f2kGHcdJYU

What we are doing, here, with crypto? No, basically nothing at all. We're garbage.

No, but we're more meme consultants than traders.

>>22160278
basically this

>>22160205
retards will say no, but the true answer is yes

>>22160205
No you stupid fuck. It's entirely a ponzi scheme to keep capitalism alive.

>>22160205
>Does trading provide any actual value to society?
>Does fractional reserve banking provide any actual value to society?
>Does fiat currency provide any actual value to society?
>Does modern academia provide any actual value to society?
>Does the pharmaceutical industry provide any actual value to society?
If an industry is dominated by Jewish people, the answer is definitively "no"

>>22160205

Trading is the very essence of supply and demand. As a trader you decide what things have value and which don't.
If you don't know why something is valuable you shouldn't trade, because you're only giving fake value to stuff that has no value which results in fake value getting crashed when reality catches up

>>22160205
> He doesn't know exchange is the cornerstone of civilization
Grug have bitrock
Grug want trade berry
Grug see long nose tribe
Grug make deal
Grug unhappy long nose tribe
Long nose tribe short Grug

Yes, it separates retards from their money, and potentially their lives as well

>>22160205
Stock traders? perhaps
Crypto traders? Nope, crypto speculation is a zero-sum game.

>>22160233
fpbp

>>22160205
YOURE INVESTING YOU RETARD

>>22160205
>>22160268
This. They allow for capitalist evaluation of a company .
>Inb4 tsla.
Yes, tulip mania ended as well.

>>22160205
Yes, traders are risking their shit to establish conversion rates between [valuables].

No, and I'm glad. Normal fags that promote violent riots and seethe at each other all day in silence at work can suck my dick. They don't contribute shit and if they do it's out of selfishness anyways.

>>22160268
>traders provide liquidity and therefore improve price stability.

>>22160205
Yes, it transfers money from brainlets to high IQs, and high IQs will use it to kill the jews.

>>22160205
"yes" - some kike

>>22160205
You are facilitating price discovery, thereby serving as a function of the emergent order algorithm which efficiently allocates resources that we call "Capitalism".

Just be sure not to confuse it with that Marxist's mean when they say "Capitalism", which is what everyone else means when they say "Corporate socialism" or "crony capitalism". Marxist's are too dumb to understand economic functions even if they had the self-efficacy and emotional fortitude to read outside their cucked bubble.

>>22160205
>that ID
Do you provide any value, DICK?

>>22161373
kek

>>22160205
Depends on what type of trading. Currency and stock trading is purely parasitical and will eventually lead to ruin as demonstrated by history over and over.

>>22160913
But the kikes issue the currency so they benefit more than any, you fag.

Crypto is more like gambling but with better odds if you know whats up.
Equities are what the mutts put their money into so that when they're old they can retire, so from that perspective they're beneficial.
Commodities are very much beneficial.
Forex appears to be beneficial but isn't it just a way for the banking cartel to keep their power as it's them who control this market?